Greatest NFL Players Not in the Hall of Fame

When you think of the great quarterbacks of the 1970s, Terry Bradshaw is the first name to spring to mind. In leading the Pittsburgh Steelers to four Super Bowl championships in six seasons, he became one of the game’s great stars and was an obvious selection to the Pro Football Hall of Fame in 1989.

greatest nfl players not in the hall of fame

San Francisco 49ers RB Roger Craig

But a case can be made that Bradshaw was not even the best quarterback in his own division during his era. That distinction may belong to Ken Anderson, the Cincinnati Bengals great who threw for nearly 5,000 more yards than Bradshaw during their careers and had a passer rating 11 points higher.

Yet Anderson has not received his call to Canton — and likely never will. Anderson, the 1981 NFL MVP, tops our all-time NFL team of players not in the Hall of Fame. Here is the lineup.

Ken Anderson, Quarterback

Years: 1971-86

Team: Cincinnati Bengals

Overshadowed by Terry Bradshaw early in his career and Joe Montana later, Anderson put up stellar numbers worthy of the Hall: 32,838 career passing yards and 160 touchdowns playing during an era that was decidedly less passer-friendly than today’s game.

Before Bill Walsh made the West Coast offense famous in San Francisco, he invented the system as Anderson’s coach in Cincinnati.

Anderson led the league in completion percentage three times and in passing yards twice, and was the NFL MVP in 1981 as he led the Bengals to the Super Bowl, where Montana and the 49ers launched their dynasty.

Fred Taylor, Running Back

Years: 1998-2010

Teams: Jacksonville Jaguars, New England Patriots

While Ken Anderson was overshadowed by Terry Bradshaw and Joe Montana, Fred Taylor was eclipsed by the small market of Jacksonville. Taylor never won a Super Bowl and did not get the national exposure he should have. But he earned respect on the field.

Taylor rushed for 1,000-plus yards in seven seasons and 11,695 career yards over his 13-year career, averaging 4.6 yards per carry. His career rushing yardage total is good for 17th on NFL all-time list.

That’s more career rushing yards than Earl Campbell (9,407), Jim Taylor (8,597), Larry Csonka (8,081) and Terrell Davis (7,607). All of them are Hall of Famers. Taylor should be too.

Cliff Branch, Wide Receiver

greatest nfl players not in the hall of fame

Cliff Branch

Years: 1972-85

Team: Oakland/Los Angeles Raiders

Cliff Branch was a key weapon in the Raiders’ deep passing game and finished his career with three Super Bowl rings.

A three-time first-team All-Pro, Branch finished his career with 8,685 receiving yards and 67 touchdown catches — 16 more than Swann and four more than Swann’s Hall of Fame teammate, John Stallworth.

Like Harold Jackson, Branch excelled during an era where defenses typically had the advantage over passing games because of the rules of the time.

For more on the Greatest NFL Players Not in the Hall of Fame, go to Stadium Talk

OTHER NEWS

11 minutes ago

Stree 2 teaser: Tamannaah Bhatia joins Rajkummar Rao-Shraddha Kapoor horror comedy

11 minutes ago

Book Review: ‘The Singularity Is Nearer,’ by Ray Kurzweil

11 minutes ago

Charlton fixtures for League One 2024-25 season

11 minutes ago

New V12 Aston Martin Valiant is Fernando Alonso’s side project

11 minutes ago

Tbo Touch urges parents to be honest with their children

11 minutes ago

Avanti West Coast says fleet overhaul means ‘much-improved travel experience’

11 minutes ago

Squabbles could collapse KZN GPU

11 minutes ago

League Two 2024/25 fixtures in full: Title favourites Chesterfield Town raise curtain on Friday night

11 minutes ago

21m striker is open to signing for West Ham with Lopetegui keen on a move

11 minutes ago

Slovakia vs Romania lineups: Confirmed team news, predicted XIs, injury latest for Euro 2024 today

11 minutes ago

WATCH: MacG's wife Naledi Monamodi goes viral with TikTok video bragging about her body

11 minutes ago

AFC Wimbledon fixtures for League Two 2024-25 season

11 minutes ago

Millwall fixtures for Championship 2024-25 season

11 minutes ago

Hamdan bin Mohammed issues decision on appointment of Corporate Administrative Support Services CEO at RTA

11 minutes ago

History awaits Proteas in T20 World Cup

11 minutes ago

Tesla recalls Cybertrucks over wiper, trim issues in latest setback

14 minutes ago

U.S. journalist Gershkovich appears with shaved head as espionage trial begins in Russia

15 minutes ago

Fastest teenager in the country finishes fifth at Olympic trials before making relay pool cut

15 minutes ago

Ageing Croatia fail to shake European Championship hoodoo

15 minutes ago

Dozens of roads and lanes to be closed for NDP National Education shows

15 minutes ago

Aer Lingus pilots launch work-to-rule actions, tossing travel plans of passengers into disarray

15 minutes ago

Malibu mansion owned by Sally Field and Olivia Newton-John hits market for $25 million

15 minutes ago

Belarus Reports Record Trade Growth with Russia

15 minutes ago

Josh Hart's Four-Word Reply To Knicks' Mikal Bridges Trade

15 minutes ago

Is Bills' Roster Turnover An 'Overblown' Storyline?

15 minutes ago

EU signs Frontex cooperation agreement with Serbia

15 minutes ago

'Shaken to the core': Kenya shocked as protests turn deadly

15 minutes ago

NASA launches final SpaceX weather satellite into orbit

15 minutes ago

Are the big two coming clean about the state of our finances?

15 minutes ago

Chinese shoppers are so obsessed with LVMH that some people asked the CEO to bless their babies

15 minutes ago

Bear Grylls shares his daily diet, including eating one steak, six eggs and drinking electrolyte water - after he admitted he now cringes that he once promoted veganism

19 minutes ago

Gates open to Glastonbury Festival - as campers rush to find best spots

19 minutes ago

Carpet makers threaten to shut business

19 minutes ago

Victorian nurses, midwives score 'once in a generation' 28 per cent pay rise

20 minutes ago

Rovam Powell on West Indies T20 world cup exit to South Africa

20 minutes ago

PSX faces post-budget pressure

20 minutes ago

Is Emmerdale or Coronation Street on tonight? Full schedule from EastEnders to Love Island

20 minutes ago

Govt seeks Rs34.6tr borrowing

20 minutes ago

Sri Lanka Women vs West Indies Women Live Score: Sri Lanka Women score after 1 overs is 4/0

20 minutes ago

‘False pretenses’: Labor ‘in trouble’ over failed cost-of-living election promises