Banff's historic backyard cabins have renewed relevance amid housing crunch

Travel back in time, and Banff residents were making housing work for them by building backyard cabins — even if they weren’t legal — for workers and tourists.

Today, Ottawa is looking for such creative solutions and more as it challenges municipalities to come up with ways to tackle the country’s housing crisis — and Banff’s plans might bring back that now lost gentle density as part of the fix.

The municipality sits on a fixed land base, with no space for suburbs to sprawl, and the development of new housing has plateaued.

Almost all residential land, 98.5 per cent, is already developed. But officials say the town has a 700- to 1,000-unit housing shortage it wants to make up.

“It’s really about trying to incentivize people to make the most of their properties,” Dave Michaels said.

There’s money on the table from the federal government, thanks to the housing accelerator fund. Banff has a proposal in the works.

The town is looking at a whole suite of options. Michaels said they have proposed financial incentives and tactics to tax vacant or underdeveloped land and want to ease some planning requirements.

“All options are on the table,” Michaels said. “There’s a lot of changes that we really think will incentivize a lot of development that’s kind of waiting in the wings that hasn’t been possible with the increases to construction costs.”

Among the ideas under consideration are eliminating parking minimums, bumping up building height maximums, and allowing accessory dwellings, such as secondary and backyard suites.

banff's historic backyard cabins have renewed relevance amid housing crunch

Banff’s manager of Planning Services, Dave Michaels said to spur new housing development officials want to create incentives and ease some development rules. (Helen Pike/CBC)

Accessory dwellings are a fitting call to the past.

In the 1930s, Banff was a town of so-called gentle density — officials did a survey and found 400 cabins and tent houses in backyards.

Today, that would make up about 10 per cent of the town’s housing, estimated Kathleen Gallagher, a development planner with the town.

The number is even more interesting in today’s context because, if all of the town’s measures are approved by council, and Parks Canada next year, Gallagher said they hope to spur the development of 400 to 500 new units three years after the new policy and incentives come into effect.

“I think it’s neat that we’re seeing this same story play out and the same type of solutions,” Gallagher said.

banff's historic backyard cabins have renewed relevance amid housing crunch

Kathleen Gallagher is a development planner with the Town of Banff. (Helen Pike/CBC)

That same story: workers need a place to live in the tourist town and the housing currently available just isn’t enough.

A shack in Banff may sound romantic, even cute — but after years without much regulation or oversight, the town became littered with them. An Order in Council from 1932 described the homes as unsanitary, dilapidated, and a blemish on the townsite.

It wasn’t the vibe Ottawa wanted for its first national park. Canvas didn’t evoke “Crown Jewel.”

“They wanted to look good for the highbrow tourists,” Gallagher said. “Just not wanting the backyard cabins to be a blight on the town.”

Letters back and forth, between Ottawa and Banff officials outline the struggle between the federal government’s rules and wishes, and the reality for some tenants.

In one correspondence, then-superintendent P.J. Jennings writes about a man living in a cabin illegally through winter who couldn’t afford a house, or even a room — he had nowhere to go and refused to move.

“Housing was expensive and limited, and people needed to come here and work,” Gallagher said.

Of course, those little cabins aren’t as plentiful today. In 2017 the town survey found only 45 of the relics. Many didn’t meet standards when the time came to comply with development rules in the 1930s.

Many more fell victim to much-needed density. A bigger project with more units had more value to land owners in many cases.

banff's historic backyard cabins have renewed relevance amid housing crunch

Housing has always been an issue in the Bow Valley, but pandemic impacts have chagned the landscape. (Helen Pike/CBC)

But the idea and spirit of a backyard cabin is again relevant today.

There are secondary suites and accessory dwellings in town, but Michaels thinks the town could benefit from more.

“We have a large number of properties that don’t have accessory suites or secondary dwellings that really could benefit both the property, the individual property owners,” Michaels said. “Provide them extra income, as well as allow that incremental housing through our community.”

These discussions will continue into 2024, with public consultation and any land-use bylaw changes coming to the town council floor for consideration.

OTHER NEWS

11 minutes ago

Iordanescu hails Romania's 'generation of soul' after Ukraine win

11 minutes ago

Reaction to Romania's 3-0 win over Ukraine at Euro 2024

11 minutes ago

Analysis: Soccer-Romania's main Man has Midas touch in Euro win over Ukraine

11 minutes ago

Scotland's Porteous banned for two games

14 minutes ago

America's largest private bus company covering 500 cities across US files for bankruptcy

14 minutes ago

How to pick the trendy 'healthy' waters that really ARE worth paying for and avoid 'ridiculous' products: Nutrition experts deliver their verdict

14 minutes ago

Video: Inside the police fight to halt hooliganism: With England in town, Mail Sport spends three days with the German cops in Dusseldorf - and witnesses a concerning war-baiting trend

14 minutes ago

Video: 'Blockbuster discovery' at George Washington's Mount Vernon estate

14 minutes ago

Viral England fan spotted cheering the Three Lions on AGAIN as he reappears Gelsenkirchen ahead of their Euro 2024 opener vs Serbia... as fans claim he is 'living the dream' travelling the world watching the Three Lions play

14 minutes ago

Video: Stephen A. Smith defends Angel Reese after brutal foul on Caitlin Clark and accuses WNBA referees of 'looking for something' so they can punish Chicago Sky rookie

14 minutes ago

America's wine supply in serious danger after invasive species hitchhikes from New York to California

15 minutes ago

Crystal Palace to fight to keep Marc Guehi... as Premier League rivals monitor the England international after his impressive Euro 2024 bow

15 minutes ago

Inside the police fight to halt hooliganism: With England in town, Mail Sport spends three days with the German cops in Dusseldorf - and witnesses a concerning war-baiting trend

15 minutes ago

Stephen A. Smith defends Angel Reese after brutal foul on Caitlin Clark and accuses WNBA referees of 'looking for something' so they can punish Chicago Sky rookie

15 minutes ago

Feds sue Photoshop owner Adobe over subscription plans, hefty termination fees

15 minutes ago

Joe Biden let Rachel Morin killer suspect in — her blood is on his hands

16 minutes ago

We will never allow state resources to be used to target leaders, says Lungisa

16 minutes ago

"In five? I don't know about that" - Derek Fisher responds to Draymond saying the 2017 Warriors would destroy the 2001 Lakers

16 minutes ago

Eddie Jones interview: England are now benefitting from my selections

16 minutes ago

International review launched into Canadian Human Rights Commission

16 minutes ago

Map Shows Russia's Probing NATO Borders With Airspace Violations

16 minutes ago

Packers DE Rashan Gary thankful to have healthy offseason

16 minutes ago

DCE on cusp of joining greatest Maroons captains

17 minutes ago

Tesla sues ex-supplier Matthews over EV battery trade secrets

17 minutes ago

For the city, for Boston

17 minutes ago

Boats cruise across the Seine in Paris Olympics Opening Ceremony rehearsal

17 minutes ago

A recently elected mayor is shot and killed in southern Mexico

17 minutes ago

Romania were far too good but Ukraine have already won at Euro 2024

17 minutes ago

British number one Jack Draper finds early rewards from new aggressive style

17 minutes ago

‘Keir Starmer Needs You!’: Tories launches Facebook page targeting Reform voters

17 minutes ago

Prestigious Dulwich prep school drops Native American house names after cultural appropriation complaints

17 minutes ago

Inside election social media campaign costs as Labour outspends all other parties combined

17 minutes ago

Stuart Varney: Biden's 'Parole in Place' scheme is code for amnesty

17 minutes ago

NSW to receive $11.9 billion less from the GST over the next four years

17 minutes ago

Sir Paul McCartney adds FOUR new UK dates to his mammoth Got Back world tour as veteran star, 81, returns for his first British gigs since headlining Glastonbury in 2022

17 minutes ago

Vince Carter says Kobe Bryant would have won his sixth ring if the Chris Paul trade wasn't vetoed: "That would be a cheat code"

20 minutes ago

Illinois' unclaimed property auction begins with $2 bills, a Pickup truck and more

21 minutes ago

Edmonton-raised soccer star Alphonso Davies named captain of Canadian men’s national team

21 minutes ago

‘Terrifier 3’: Jason Patric Joins Cast Of Horror Pic, Filming Wraps & New Image Released

21 minutes ago

Half of U.S. military bases in the country are in 'health care deserts'