Zillow and the National Association of Realtors are locked in a legal fight with a Texas startup, which accuses them of anti-competitive practices

Asia's Tech News Daily

© Joe Raedle/Getty Images A Zillow employee in Florida. Joe Raedle/Getty Images

  • Zillow and the National Association of Realtors were accused of anti-competitive practices by REX.
  • REX filed a federal lawsuit saying the two hid property listings that weren’t from Realtors.
  • The Texas startup said Zillow and NAR provided “virtually no visibility” into those listings.

REX, a real-estate startup, has accused Zillow and the National Association of Realtors (NAR) of anticompetitive practices, saying in a lawsuit that the two work together to suppress listings from real estate agents who aren’t Realtors.

“Through horizontal agreements, three of the most highly visited hubs – Zillow, NAR-licensed Realtor.com, and Trulia – now provide virtually no visibility to homes listed by brokers outside the market dominant cartel,” the startup’s lawyers wrote in an amended complaint filed in late September. (Trulia is owned by Zillow.)

REX filed its original complaint in US District Court in Washington in March, a move that amounts to another attack on NAR’s practices and rules. The Department of Justice last year opened a separate investigation into what it said were anticompetitive practices at NAR.

On Friday, NAR filed a motion seeking to dismiss REX’s lawsuit, saying the company’s amended complaint failed to connect NAR with the changes made to Zillow’s app.

REX’s new complaint fell “well short of establishing a plausible agency relationship between NAR and Zillow – or NAR and any MLS – with respect to the design of Zillow’s website. REX’s amended allegations therefore show that REX’s claimed injuries were not caused by NAR,” the filing said.

About 70% of US real estate agents are Realtors, meaning they’re members of NAR. That organization’s Multiple Listings Service (MLS), has long been the standard for Realtor listings. And many of those MLS listings are now posted on Zillow’s family of apps.

While NAR is a trade organization with extensive reach, real estate agents don’t have to join it. REX – its name is an acronym for Real Estate Exchange – isn’t part of NAR. As such, REX’s listings on Zillow are put in a different category, non-MLS listings.

There’s a toggle in Zillow’s search results to switch between MLS and non-MLS listings. In the app they’re called either “Agent Listings” and “Other Listings.”

“The new web display creates a separate page, concealed behind the primary results, where REX homes are now funneled,” REX said in its complaint. It added: “The label is incorrect: the tab is not all agent listings, but exclusively MLS agent listings.” (The lawyers added the emphasis.)

REX says they’re able to sell homes with lower commission by not being NAR members. The details are laid out in the lawsuit: Realtors charge about 2.5% to 3% commission on sales, plus other non-negotiable Realtor fees that bump the total up to about 5.5%, according to REX’s lawsuit. REX’s total commission is more than 2 points lower, averaging about 3.3%, the company said.

Zillow said the claims made in REX’s lawsuit are “without merit.” The company’s hands are tied, a spokesperson said, because NAR rules require MLS listings to be separate from non-MLS listings.

“REX voluntarily chooses to use Zillow’s services to advertise their for-sale properties on Zillow for free,” Viet Shelton, a spokesperson, said via email on Friday. “We encourage REX to join Zillow in advocating for industry rule changes that would allow their for-sale listings displayed on Zillow to appear the way they were last year.”

Both Zillow and NAR sought to dismiss the case earlier this year. NAR and REX didn’t immediately respond to requests for comment.

Read the original article on Business Insider

Internet Explorer Channel Network
Asia's Tech News Daily
News Related

OTHER NEWS

The Classic Little Mermaid Songs Lin-Manuel Miranda Thought Were Too Sacred To Touch For Halle Bailey's Movie

© Provided by CinemaBlend Lin-Manuel Miranda appears on The Kelly Clarkson Show. If there’s anything that could make the live-action adaptation of Disney’s classic The Little Mermaid more exciting, it ... Read more »

Kim Kardashian West to receive Fashion Icon gong at People's Choice Awards

© Bang Showbiz Kim Kardashian West will receive a Fashion Icon gong Kim Kardashian West is to be honoured with a Fashion Icon gong at the People’s Choice Awards. The ... Read more »

First photo: Actor Vineet Kumar Singh marries long-time girlfriend Ruchiraa Gormaray

© Provided by Zee News Actor Vineet Kumar Singh, known for his work in films such as gangs of Wasseypur and Mukkabaaz, has tied the knot with long-time girlfriend Ruchiraa ... Read more »

Carrick kemudi United berdepan Arsenal

© Provided by Sinar Harian BEKAS pemain Manchester United, Michael Carrick akan terus mengemudi skuad The Red Devils itu bagi mengharungi aksi berdepan Arsenal di Stamford Bridge pada Jumaat, berikutan ... Read more »

Biontech-Chef: Haben noch harte Monate vor uns

© Keystone/dpa-Pool/Bernd von Jutrczenka Den Menschen in Deutschland stehen nach Ansicht von Biontech-Chef Ugur Sahin wegen der vierten Pandemie-Welle noch “harte vier, fünf Monate” bevor. Aufgrund der kalten Jahreszeit und ... Read more »

Khloe Kardashian: I'm a strict parent

© Bang Showbiz Khloe Kardashian is a strict parent Khloe Kardashian is a “very militant” parent. The 37-year-old star has True, three, with basketball player Tristan Thompson, and Khloe admits ... Read more »

No separate norm but I-T rules cover crypto income: FM

© Provided by The Financial Express However, eight cases of cryptocurrency-related fraud are under investigation by the enforcement directorate, she added. Finance minister Nirmala Sitharaman on Tuesday said no separate ... Read more »

HPSC cash-for-job scam Probe: Director of firm has no role in OMR sheet tampering

© Provided by The Indian Express Jasbir Singh, one of the directors of the software agency that was named in the Vigilance Bureau’s FIR in Haryana Public Service Commission’s (HPSC) ... Read more »

Milan Luthria: Both of us had to leave Suniel Shetty behind

© Provided by Mid-Day Launching a star kid can be a big responsibility. Director Milan Luthria, however, is not feeling any pressure as he is days away from introducing Ahan ... Read more »

Priyanka Chopra admits long-distance romance has been 'hard'

© Bang Showbiz Priyanka Chopra admits the last year has been tough Priyanka Chopra has found it “hard” to spend so much time away from home over the last year. ... Read more »

Dia Mirza has THIS special wish for her 40th birthday instead of throwing a big party

© Provided by Pinkvilla Dia Mirza is one of the most loved actresses of Bollywood. We might not see her that often on the silver screen but that has not ... Read more »

Murder probe launched after Amber Gibson's body is recovered

© Provided by Daily Mail MailOnline logo Police have launched a murder probe after the body of a missing 16-year-old girl was recovered from a beauty spot outside Glasgow.  Amber ... Read more »

'The Voice' Instant Save: Vote for Holly Forbes, Jeremy Rosado and Jershika Maple

© Trae Patton/NBC/NBCU Photo Bank via Getty Images The Voice season 21 live shows are here and it’s time for fans to vote! Following the Top 10 performances on Monday night, ... Read more »

UK's Johnson increases push for EU migrant return deal to solve Channel crisis

© BEN STANSALL Migrants are helped ashore from a lifeboat at a beach in Dungeness, on the south-east coast of England, on November 24 after being rescued on the English ... Read more »

US health panel backs Merck COVID pill

© Provided by dw.com Molnupiravir has been shown to reduce the rate of hospitalizations and deaths among people at high risk of developing severe COVID A panel of US health ... Read more »

CNN suspends anchor Chris Cuomo over help he gave his governor brother

© Angela WEISS CNN journalist Chris Cuomo has been suspended indefinitely CNN said Tuesday it had indefinitely suspended primetime anchor Chris Cuomo after the release of legal transcripts that revealed ... Read more »

Midland Showcases Latest Tech Gadgets At EICMA

© RideApart.com Midland Showcases Latest Tech Gadgets At EICMA Stay connected no matter where your adventure takes you. Those of us of enjoy venturing off the beaten path aboard our ... Read more »

Netflix's Squid Game comes 10th in list of most-watched shows

© Provided by Daily Mail MailOnline logo Streaming giants are failing to beat traditional broadcasters in the UK’s TV ratings charts. Despite their boom in popularity, only five shows from ... Read more »

NextPay partners with Ayannah for fund disbursements to unbanked recipients

NextPay logo Homegrown financial technology startup NextPay has partnered with local online-to-offline (O2O) digital payments provider Ayannah to allow its customers to disburse funds to unbanked recipients. In a statement ... Read more »

Mark Meadows cooperating with January 6 investigators

Donald Trump’s former chief of staff Mark Meadows is cooperating with the House select committee investigating the January 6 riot and is providing records and agreeing to appear for an ... Read more »

SLO police identify suspect in murder of 64-year-old homeless man

San Luis Obispo police have identified both the suspect and the victim in a murder that took place near San Luis Obispo Creek more than a week ago. According to ... Read more »

The Georgia election official who refused Trump's request to find him 'more votes' in the 2020 election was interviewed for 4 hours by the January 6 select committee

Getty Images (L), AP (R) Trump called Georgia Secretary of State Brad Raffensperger in January to help him win the state. Raffensperger was interviewed by the January 6 select committee ... Read more »

CDC says it is moving to tighten international COVID-19 testing rules

FILE PHOTO: A general view of Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) headquarters in Atlanta WASHINGTON (Reuters) – The Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) confirmed late Tuesday ... Read more »

Raffensperger talks with Jan. 6 committee about call with Trump: AJC

Georgia Secretary of State Brad Raffensperger sat down with the House Committee investigating the Jan. 6 attack on the Capitol for more than four hours Tuesday, the official told The ... Read more »

Kyle Rittenhouse 'not enrolled in any ASU classes,' university officials say

As controversy continues to simmer at Arizona State University over any potential ties Kyle Rittenhouse may have with the Arizona’s public university system, ASU officials have issued a response. Read more »

Brad Raffensperger talks Trump pressure call with Jan. 6 committee

The House committee investigating the Jan. 6 attack on the Capitol interviewed Georgia Secretary of State Brad Raffensperger for several hours Tuesday in a meeting that included discussion of former ... Read more »

Arizona State University says Kyle Rittenhouse not enrolled in 'any' classes after student outrage

Kyle Rittenhouse is not currently enrolled in any Arizona State University classes, school officials said this week following demands from students that the administration “withdraw” Rittenhouse from the school. “Kyle ... Read more »

Twitter bashes New York Magazine's book of gushing essays on AOC

The new book has sent Twitter on a rampage, with one user calling it “beyond parody.” Getty Images / Ian Forsyth New York Magazine is getting slammed on social media ... Read more »

Ghislaine Maxwell trial LIVE – Epstein pilot alleges Trump flew on Lolita Express plane as ‘black book' claims emerge

THE sex trafficking trial of Jeffrey's Epstein's alleged “madam” Ghislaine Maxwell started on Monday, and Lawrence Visoski, Epstein's former pilot who is testifying for the prosecution, claimed former President Donald ... Read more »

Q2 GDP: Economy just about grows to pre-COVID size, but some sectors lag badly

© Provided by CNBCTV18 The key takeaway from the second-quarter GDP numbers is that the overall economy has grown back to the pre-COVID levels. Total output in constant prices was ... Read more »

First WhatsApp update for Universal Windows Platform App coming! Feedback wanted

One of the most prominent and widely used messaging applications, WhatsApp is releasing the first update for the Universal Windows Platform app, through the official beta channel on the Microsoft ... Read more »

Pradosh Vrat 2021: Date, Significance, Shubh Muhurat and Puja Vidhi in December

© Provided by News18 Pradosh Vrat 2021: Date, Significance, Shubh Muhurat and Puja Vidhi in December In Hinduism, Pradosh Vrat has great significance. This fast is mostly observed to appease Lord Shiva. Hindus place a ... Read more »

Horoscope Today, December 1, 2021: See daily astrology prediction for zodiac sign Aries, Leo, Capricorn

Leo, Capricorn and Aquarius ascendant sign people will remain in an enthusiastic and valorous form when it comes to their work. Read your daily predictions to know the possibilities for ... Read more »

Tega Industries IPO to open today. Check what grey market trends suggest

© Provided by CNBCTV18 Tega Industries’ public issue will open for subscription on Wednesday, December 1, and close on Friday, December 3. Ahead of the launch of IPO, its grey ... Read more »

Lecturers on strike today captured by 'hard left', uni chiefs say

© Provided by Daily Mail MailOnline logo Lecturers who begin strike action today have been captured by the union’s ‘hard left’ who undermined negotiations, university vice chancellors said last night. ... Read more »

Leni: We need true, radical solidarity

THE Covid-19 pandemic has taught the world to “build a future of true and radical solidarity,” Vice President Maria Leonor “Leni” Robredo said in her keynote address at the 63rd ... Read more »

Oxford High School shooting in Michigan leaves 3 dead, 8 injured

A 15-year-old boy is in custody after three students died and eight were injured in a shooting Tuesday afternoon at a high school in Oxford, Michigan, authorities said. © WDIV ... Read more »

January 6 committee uses recent deposition to justify plan to refer former top Trump DOJ official for criminal contempt

The House select committee investigating the January 6 attack on the US Capitol is using Jeffrey Clark‘s refusal to answer questions during a recent deposition and failure to hand over ... Read more »

Oil rises 1% ahead of OPEC meeting under Omicron cloud

By Sonali Paul © Reuters/Richard Carson FILE PHOTO: A maze of crude oil pipes and valves is pictured during a tour by the Department of Energy at the Strategic Petroleum ... Read more »

Hong Kong bans non-residents from three more countries over Omicron

People wearing face masks to prevent the spread of the coronavirus disease (COVID-19), walk on a street in Hong Kong HONG KONG (Reuters) – Hong Kong will ban non-residents from ... Read more »
On free-english-test.com you will find lots of free English exam practice materials to help you improve your English skills: grammar, listening, reading, writing, ielts, toeic