Zahid's lawyer says political donations not illegal, ‘strange' that star witnesses didn't say they gave bribes for contracts

© Provided by Malay Mail Datuk Seri Ahmad Zahid Hamidi is pictured at the Kuala Lumpur High Court September 21, 2021. — Picture by Shafwan Zaidon

KUALA LUMPUR, Sept 21 — Datuk Seri Ahmad Zahid Hamidi’s lawyer today told the court that charitable and political donations were legal in Malaysia, and claimed his client was “unnecessarily” charged because the prosecution’s star witnesses did not say the millions of ringgit given were for bribes.

Ahmad Zahid’s lead defence lawyer Hisyam Teh Poh Teik today sought to clarify questions raised by the trial judge in relation to the term “political donations”. 

In this trial, Ahmad Zahid is facing eight corruption charges, involving a total RM21.25 million in cheques that he was alleged to have corruptly received as a reward in his role as the home minister then in relation to alleged contract awards or proposed aid in receiving contracts. 

The cheques were banked into law firm Lewis & Co, which Ahmad Zahid’s lawyers have insisted is a trustee that held money on trust for charitable foundation Yayasan Akalbudi, a foundation registered with the Companies Commission of Malaysia and where Ahmad Zahid is a trustee.

High Court judge Datuk Collin Lawrence Sequerah today highlighted that “political donation” is included under the definition of “gratification” under the law. Gratification is a key element of corruption or bribery charges.

Under Section 3 of the Malaysian Anti-Corruption Commission Act, “gratification” is defined as “money, donation, gift, loan, fee, reward, valuable security, property or interest in property being property of any description whether movable or immovable, financial benefit, or any other similar advantage”.

Teh responded by showing past court judgments in Malaysia that support Ahmad Zahid’s lawyers’ view that “political donations” are not illegal.

Citing the 2013 Court of Appeal judgment in a corruption case (PP v Zul Hassan & Others) involving an older version of Malaysia’s anti-corruption law which also included “donation” under the definition of “gratification”, he argued that it was not enough to show there was solicitation or receiving of gratification and that the prosecution must also prove that the asking or receiving of such funds were done corruptly in exchange for project awards. 

He said the Court of Appeal had in that 2013 case said that the prosecution must show the purpose of the gratification to be unlawful, and that it had said the asking or receiving of funds for the purpose of donations to political parties alone is not against the law.

He said the Court of Appeal had also referred to a research paper from Vanderbilt University which had listed several examples where political donation may amount to corruption and bribery, including when donation is given on the condition that an election candidate or the receiver promises to perform a future act, or when the receiver promises a particular action on the condition that the contribution is given.

“My Lord will recall, as far as all these charges are concerned, none of the donors fall into the categories of examples given by the author. They came and said these donations are either political in nature or charity. 

“As per the authority, the court recognises political donations are lawful, are permissible in law,” Teh told the High Court today.

Teh further cited the High Court’s 2018 decision (Md Zailani Md Zain v PP), arguing that the prosecution must prove that the purpose of the gratification or contribution was unlawful before the corruption charges can be established against Ahmad Zahid.

“The eight charges brought against the accused (Ahmad Zahid), they are not proven by the prosecution that there’s corrupt element — this is a bribe,” he said.

© Provided by Malay Mail Lawyer Hisyam Teh Poh Teik is pictured at the Kuala Lumpur Court Complex August 18, 2020. ― Picture by Hari Anggara

Throughout the trial, Ahmad Zahid’s lawyers had repeatedly highlighted that the businessmen who had given millions of ringgit through cheques — with some cheques physically handed over to Ahmad Zahid — had either said these were for charitable donations or political donations.

At one point, the judge noted that the prosecution’s view is that it does not really matter what the witness states regarding the money given, as corruption could be inferred from the facts.

Teh however replied that the witnesses’ views were important: “It’s very important that the witnesses must be clear as regards to the purpose of donation. All witnesses called by the prosecution on all these eight charges, very clear in their minds these are donations — either charity or political. These donations are not illegal under the law.”

We find it very strange, My Lord, there are four important witnesses, 36th prosecution witness Junaith Asharab Md Shariff, 32nd prosecution witness Datuk Abu Hanifah Noordin, 34th prosecution witness Chew Ben Ben, 38th prosecution witness Azlan Shah Jeffril. 

“These are main witnesses for the prosecution. They came before Your Lord, not a single one of them said this is corruption, this is bribery, this is corrupt gratification in exchange for contracts. None whatsoever.

“We find it very strange, unless and until they can bring authorities, we say this is a case of over-prosecution, accused person unnecessarily prosecuted for these charges,” he told the judge.

The judge said the prosecution’s view is that it can be inferred from the facts —- such as where contract was awarded and money was given sometime later —- irrespective of what the witnesses say.

Teh replied that the court should decide based on “direct evidence” given by prosecution witnesses under oath in court, and that the law does not allow for inferences to be made when there are direct evidence available.

In the event there are inferences, Teh said the criminal law in the country requires for the inference favourable to the accused to be adopted.

“So, based on this point alone, (there is) no evidence of rewards. Charges 16, 17, 18 will fall flat to the ground. This is the most important element, not proven by the prosecution,” he said, referring to three charges involving a total of RM2 million given by Azlan Shah through three cheques from his company Profound Radiance Sdn Bhd that he handed over personally to Ahmad Zahid.

Profound Radiance was appointed as the one stop centre for visa processing matters in Nepal and Pakistan prior to the giving of the RM2 million cheques, but Teh had today argued that the evidence showed that the appointment process went through proper procedures and protocols and that it was not Ahmad Zahid who had made the appointment.

Teh highlighted that Azlan Shah had previously denied in court that the RM2 million cheques were corrupt money or were corruptly given by him or corruptly received by Ahmad Zahid, adding that this businessman had also denied that the RM2 million was not given as a reward for Profound Radiance’s appointment for the contracts.

Teh argued that it would have been very easy for the prosecution witness Azlan Shah to say that the money given are as a “reward”, and “nothing will happen” to this witness as he would be protected by law under Section 132 of the Evidence Act.

Under Section 132, a witness would not be arrested or prosecuted over an answer given in court if the answer was given truthfully, as the witness could still be prosecuted for giving false evidence through such an answer.

Teh said he had not come across a case before where an accused person is convicted when there is no evidence of corruption from star witnesses, and challenged the prosecution to show court cases where this had happened.

Today, Ahmad Zahid’s lawyers concluded their oral submissions for all 47 charges that their client is facing, but reserved their right to make a final reply to the prosecution on two legal points relating to corruption charges.

The trial resumes tomorrow, where the prosecution is expected to start presenting its oral submissions.

Ahmad Zahid’s trial is currently at the end of the prosecution’s case, as all 99 prosecution witnesses have already testified previously.

At the end of the prosecution’s case, both sides will present their final arguments verbally through oral submissions, before the court decides whether the prosecution has proven a prima facie case that would require Ahmad Zahid to enter defence or if he should be released from the charges.

In this trial, Zahid ― who is a former deputy prime minister and currently the Umno president ― is facing 47 charges, namely 12 counts of criminal breach of trust in relation to charitable foundation Yayasan Akalbudi’s funds, 27 counts of money laundering, and eight counts of bribery charges.

© Provided by Malay Mail

Related Articles Lawyer: Zahid unrelated to brother’s RM250,000 loan from businessman, so bribery charge is ‘faulty’ Zahid’s lawyer claims 27 money laundering charges politically motivated, wants full acquittal At Zahid’s trial, judge asks why foundation used ‘bag of cash’ instead of cheques to donate millions to Yayasan Akalbudi

Internet Explorer Channel Network
News Related

OTHER NEWS

Need Data on ‘Illegal Churches' in K'taka, Want to Bring in a Bill to Stop Forced Conversions: BJP MLA

© Provided by News18 Need Data on ‘Illegal Churches’ in K’taka, Want to Bring in a Bill to Stop Forced Conversions: BJP MLA Karnataka BJP MLA Goolihatti Shekhar, while clarifying ... Read more »

Judge denies request to block lethal injection in Alabama

FILE – This undated file photo provided by the Alabama Department of Corrections shows Willie B. Smith III. Federal judges heard arguments Wednesday, Oct. 13, 2021 about whether Willie B. ... Read more »

Covid live: UK reports close to 50,000 new cases as government warns of ‘challenging' months ahead

LIVE – Updated at 18:57 © Photograph: Maureen McLean/REX/Shutterstock The UK reported close to 50,000 new Covid cases on 18 OCtober. UK reports 49,156 new cases, highest since mid-July, and ... Read more »

Joe Biden leads tributes to ‘dear friend' and ‘patriot' Colin Powell

Photograph: David J Phillip/AP Tributes poured in for former Republican secretary of state Colin Powell after the announcement of his death on Monday morning at the age of 84. Leading ... Read more »

First ETF linked to Bitcoin is set to make its debut

FILE – In this Feb. 9, 2021, file photo, the Bitcoin logo appears on the display screen of a cryptocurrency ATM in Salem, N.H. ProShares said Monday, Oct. 18, 2021 ... Read more »

Republicans tear into Biden for violating D.C.'s indoor mask mandate

© Provided by Daily Mail MailOnline logo Republicans are hammering Joe Biden after he was caught violating Washington, D.C.’s mask mandate during his first date night with Jill since moving ... Read more »

Gupta's GFG files High Court claim against AIP amid French smelter row

© Provided by City AM Sanjeev Gupta’s GFG Alliance has filed a claim against American Industrial Partners (AIP) with the High Court amid a row over an aluminium smelter in ... Read more »

MacBook Pro: Apple launches totally redesigned new laptop that is ‘reimagined in every way'

© Apple Screenshot 2021-10-18 at 18.32.00.png Apple has launched a new MacBook Pro, which comes with a total redesign. The new computer comes in two sizes – 14- and 16-inch – and ... Read more »

Nightlife tsar warns security staff shortages are becoming ‘the biggest issue' for the sector

Security staff shortages are hammering venues across the UK and becoming the biggest issue for the nightlife sector, Greater Manchester’s night tsar has said. Sacha Lord has given the latest ... Read more »

Newcastle eye twin opportunity as Leeds join race for familiar Chelsea man

© PA Images Chelsea’s Ross Barkley and Ruben Loftus-Cheek swap places on the pitch during the Premier League clash against Brighton, September 2020 The race to sign Ross Barkley from ... Read more »

AirPods 3: release date, price, leaks, launch and all the news

Apple AirPods 3 are rumoured to be a mighty exciting pair of iPhone headphones, and they’re expected to be revealed at Apple’s ‘Unleashed’ event today, Monday 18th October.  © Provided ... Read more »

Apple M1 Pro and Max: Company releases new professional chip for its more powerful computers

© Apple Screenshot 2021-10-18 at 18.46.09.png Apple has announced the ‘M1 Pro’ and ‘M1 Max’, a pair of chips built for its more powerful computers. The processors are built on ... Read more »

Apple event – live: AirPods 3, new MacBook Pro, Apple Music voice discount and more products unveiled

LIVE – Updated at 19:03 © Getty Images apple.jpg Apple has unveiled a host of new products at its “Unleashed” virtual event on Monday. The star of the show is ... Read more »

Hudson's Bay sues Quebec retailer alleging trademark infringement of Zellers brand

TORONTO — Hudson’s Bay Co. ULC is suing a Quebec retail family over the use of the Zellers brand.  © Provided by The Canadian Press In a statement of claim ... Read more »

Bill Gates shares photo from daughter Jenn's wedding to Nayel Nassar

Bill Gates is a father-in-law. The Microsoft co-founder’s oldest daughter, Jennifer Gates, wed Nayel Nassar on Saturday, and on Monday, Bill Gates shared a photo of the happy couple. © ... Read more »

Police searching for suspects after shooting in Vaughan, 2 women injured

© Nick Westoll / File / Global News A York Regional Police officer and cruiser. York Regional Police say they are seeking suspects after a shooting in Vaughan early Monday ... Read more »

How to pay? Biden agenda at risk

While the Biden administration continues to push the narrative that the multitrillion-dollar reconciliation bill will cost “zero,” its simultaneous call for historically high tax increases suggests otherwise. The administration’s tax ... Read more »

Saskatchewan sending 6 intensive care patients to Ontario as ICU challenges continue

© File / Getty Images Doctor holding oxygen ambu bag over patient given oxygen to patient by intubation tube in ICU/Emergency room Premier Scott Moe has announced the transfer of ... Read more »

Everything you need to know about the Brawl Stars World Finals 2021

© Provided by Dot Esports The 2021 Brawl Stars World Finals are almost here. From Nov. 26 to 28, 16 teams from across the globe will be competing for the ... Read more »

Apple unveils new AirPods, Mac chips

Apple’s newest Airpods will sell for $179. EPA Apple on Monday introduced a third generation of its AirPod wireless earbuds with “spatial audio” features and a $5-per-month streaming music plan. ... Read more »

I was sick for months and thought it was IBS – I found out I was pregnant when I gave birth in the bathroom

A WOMAN'S nightmare became this TikTok star's reality – they found out they were pregnant WHILE giving birth. Chess, who goes by the pronouns they and them, shared their surprise ... Read more »

UK firms must disclose climate impact, says Sunak

Some large UK businesses will have to start disclosing their environmental impact, according to new requirements set out by Chancellor Rishi Sunak. © Getty Images The new rules will also ... Read more »

The most popular baby names in England and Wales revealed

© Provided by The Independent The most popular baby names for boys and girls in England and Wales in 2020 have been revealed, with Oliver and Olivia topping the list ... Read more »

Andy Ngô keeps reporting people on Twitter who post this very real photo of him standing by far-right graffiti

© Provided by Daily Dot andy ngo in front of Andy Ngô is reportedly on a mission to stop people from reposting a picture of him posing in front of ... Read more »

I got my first COVID shot in Nigeria and the second in the UK, and the difference was infuriating

© Paul Adepoju The author, Paul Adepoju (left), got his first Covid vaccine shot in Nigeria. The center was so crowded that there was no room to sit down. Paul ... Read more »

NFL betting: One bettor needs Buffalo to cash two massive parlays

Did you have a good weekend? Maybe you did, but you probably didn’t have quite as good of a weekend as one bettor at BetMGM.  The same bettor placed two ... Read more »

US Marshals allegedly ambushed Brian Laundrie lookalike on Appalachian Trail

U.S. Marshals allegedly ambushed an innocent man who they mistakenly believed to be fugitive Brian Laundrie, wanted in connection with the Gabby Petito homicide case, The New Yorker reported Saturday. ... Read more »

Kerry's Tommy Walsh announces inter-county retirement

© Ryan Byrne INPHO Tommy Walsh dejected after his final game for the Kingdom. KERRY FOOTBALLER Tommy Walsh has retired from the inter-county game. The 33-year-old walks away with two ... Read more »

Robbie Brady signs with Scott Parker's Bournemouth

Robbie Brady is now with the Cherries. ROBBIE BRADY HAS signed for Bournemouth until the end of the season, the Championship side has announced. The Republic of Ireland player joins ... Read more »

SEC Explains Controversial Calls in Tennessee-Ole Miss Thriller That Led to Trash Incident

© Provided by Sports Illustrated The SEC has offered explanations for two controversial plays in Tennessee’s 31-26 loss to Ole Miss on Saturday, which ended with trash being thrown onto ... Read more »

White House: Biden to host talks on his agenda Tuesday, climate aspects remain key

U.S. President Biden visits Connecticut WASHINGTON (Reuters) -President Joe Biden will host separate meetings on Tuesday with moderate and progressive Democratic lawmakers who are wrangling over aspects of his infrastructure ... Read more »

USAID partners with DepEd to produce gender-responsive TV

© The STAR / Miguel de Guzman, file USAID partners with DepEd to produce gender-responsive TV MANILA, Philippines — The United States Agency for International Development (USAID) has partnered with ... Read more »

No air fare increase for holidays

© Walter Bollozos, file No air fare increase for holidays MANILA, Philippines — Air fares will not increase for the holiday season despite the recent spike in jet fuel prices. ... Read more »

Kangana Ranaut starrer 'Dhaakad' to release in April 2022

© Provided by Zee News MUMBAI: With theatres soon to open in Maharashtra, Bollywood star Kangana Ranaut’s upcoming action film ‘Dhaakad’, has been announced to release on April 8, 2022. ... Read more »

2 More Ontario Doctors Are Banned From Giving Out Medical Exemptions For COVID-19 Vaccines

Two more Ontario doctors have been banned from giving medical exemptions for COVID-19 vaccines, COVID-19 testing and mask requirements. © Provided by Narcity Dr. Rochagne Kilian, a doctor in Owen ... Read more »

Telangana CM to Review Yadadri Temple Works on Tuesday, Likely to Decide Inauguration Dates

© Provided by News18 Telangana CM to Review Yadadri Temple Works on Tuesday, Likely to Decide Inauguration Dates Telangana Chief Minister K Chandrasekhar Rao will visit Yadadri Temple in the ... Read more »

India vs England Highlights, T20 World Cup 2021 Warm-up Match: India Beat England With an Over to Spare

© Provided by News18 India vs England Highlights, T20 World Cup 2021 Warm-up Match: India Beat England With an Over to Spare IND vs ENG, Live Cricket Score, T20 World ... Read more »

Swargate and Katraj BRTS corridor bus-stop doors, a risky proposition

© Provided by Hindustan Times It’s a daily risk for passengers travelling on the Swargate and Katraj BRTS corridor as the automatic doors at bus stops on this route are ... Read more »

National Lottery draw LIVE: Set For Life jackpot of £10k for 30 YEARS to be won TONIGHT after record EuroMillions draw

BRITS have another chance of bagging £10k a month for 30 YEARS in tonight' Set For Life draw. The National Lottery's Set For Life draw will take place at 8pm ... Read more »

Just Dance 2022 will be compatible with last-gen console cameras, not current-gen cameras

As expected, Just Dance 2022 is coming on both previous-gen and current-gen consoles — PlayStation 4, Xbox One, PlayStation 5, Xbox Series X/S, and Nintendo Switch, which sits between two ... Read more »