Will ‘sigh of relief’ after US supreme court gun ruling be short-lived?

will ‘sigh of relief’ after us supreme court gun ruling be short-lived?

‘We’ll all brace up and prepare, and get ready for the next court case,’ said Gretta Gardner of Ujima. Photograph: Kristoffer Tripplaar/Alamy

The US supreme court decided to uphold a 30-year-old federal law prohibiting subjects of domestic violence restraining orders (DVROs) from possessing guns. In Friday’s eight-to-one decision, justices – except Clarence Thomas – agreed that Zackey Rahimi’s constitutional rights were not violated when his guns were confiscated following a lengthy history of gun crimes and abuse against his then girlfriend and mother of his child.

While the ruling is not a surprise to many experts who heard the 7 November 2023 oral argument, it represents a small victory for those who advocate for protection orders like DVROs and work with survivors of domestic abuse.

“I think we’re all breathing a sigh of relief that the court did not decide to put more people in direct risk of being killed or seriously injured,” said Kelly Roskam, director of law and policy for the Johns Hopkins Center for Gun Violence Solutions. “There seemed to be a general acceptance among the justices that there is this national historical tradition of disarming people who are dangerous.”

The case focused on Rahimi, a Texas man who assaulted his then girlfriend and the mother of his child in a parking lot in 2019. When bystanders noticed, he pulled out a gun and fired a shot. The woman, referred to as CM in court documents, managed to get away but Rahimi threatened to shoot her if she reported the incident, the majority opinion written by Chief Justice John Roberts reads. Despite the threat, the woman sought and was granted a restraining order by a judge.

But the order didn’t deter Rahimi, who continued to contact CM via social media and showed up at her home. He was also a suspect in another five shootings. Rahimi was indicted for possessing a firearm while being subject to a DVRO, but he moved to have the indictment dismissed, arguing that the original order and criminal code it was based on, 922(g), which prohibits people under DVROs from having firearms and ammunition, violated his constitutional rights.

Despite his history, the fifth circuit court of appeals sided with Rahimi and based their judgment on a rule created by the highly controversial 2022 Bruen decision, which voided many state restrictions on carrying firearms in public and established a new standard for gun regulations, requiring laws to be “consistent with the nation’s historical tradition of firearm regulation”, according to justice Thomas’s majority opinion for Bruen.

Friday’s decision by the supreme court is in direct rebuke of the fifth circuit ruling, with Roberts admonishing the panel for “misapplying the Court’s precedent” when reviewing Rahimi’s case. Roberts added that the disarming of anyone who is found to pose a credible threat to the physical safety of an intimate partner or parent of their child is consistent with the second amendment.

“When a restraining order contains a finding that an individual poses a credible threat to the physical safety of an intimate partner, that individual may – consistent with the Second Amendment – be banned from possessing firearms while the order is in effect,” Roberts wrote.

While the decision upholds a 30-year-old federal law, it also leaves the door open for people to bring new court challenges if they believe that a judge put them under a DVRO erroneously.

“I would say to a fairly high degree of certainty, somebody will bring an ‘as-applied’ challenge to the same law,” said Clark Neily, senior vice-president for legal studies at the Cato Institute. “Someone will say: ‘I’m not asking for a ruling across the board. I’m simply asking for a ruling that has applied to me personally.’”

Neily, who was a constitutional litigator for 17 years, added that the second amendment, unlike the first, which grants the right to free speech, has not been as refined through supreme court decisions. Also, he said, Rahimi and subsequent cases will continue to set precedents for the ways that the second amendment can be applied.

“There will be sympathetic second amendment poster children who go to the court, and there’ll be unsympathetic ones, and that’ll just keep going back and forth,” Neily added. “So it’s nothing new. It’s just happened that [the supreme court] got a later start with a second amendment.

While this was the first case decided in the shadow of the Bruen decision, it almost certainly won’t be the last. Waiting in the wings are cases from Pennsylvania and Florida that will determine whether a man with a 30-year-old food stamp fraud conviction and marijuana users, respectively, will be able to own guns.

As these cases make their way through the courts, advocates who rely on policies like 922(g) and other firearm prohibitions say that they are prepared to continue their efforts to disarm people who are a threat to the life and safety of those closest to them.

“We have a culture of firearms ownership in the United States, and when you talk about taking someone’s firearms, even for a limited duration … people get uncomfortable with that even though we know that there is a direct correlation between domestic violence and the presence of firearms increasing lethality,” said Millicent Shaw Phipps, legal director at Ujima, a non-profit that supports Black women dealing with domestic violence.

“We’ll all brace up and prepare, and get ready for the next court case or whatever other impact litigation is out there to secure firearms for people who shouldn’t have them,” echoed Gretta Gardner, chief legal officer of Ujima.

OTHER NEWS

29 minutes ago

Father killed alongside daughter in Sydney train tragedy identified as Anand Runwal

29 minutes ago

Man denies committing indecent act on Emirates flight from Dubai to Sydney

34 minutes ago

Wighton prepares for daunting Canberra return

34 minutes ago

ANC admits incoherent messaging resulted in KZN loss

42 minutes ago

Shohei Ohtani launches 473-foot, 116.7mph bomb that nearly sails out of Dodger Stadium

43 minutes ago

Ukraine war latest: Around 20,000 Russians killed in Kharkiv offensive, Zelensky says

43 minutes ago

Nine vows to keep investing in youth media, appoints new Pedestrian boss

43 minutes ago

Dolphins to Bring in Former SB Champion LB After Shaquil Barrett's Retirement

43 minutes ago

‘Sprawling’ crisis leaves Aussies on brink

43 minutes ago

Watch: Shohei Ohtani Nearly Hits Home Run Out Of Dodger Stadium

44 minutes ago

Increase in superannuation guarantee rate forecast to boost retirement savings by $21,000

44 minutes ago

Elon Musk asked OpenAI investor Vinod Khosla to support Trump. Khosla said he doesn't 'accept depravity'.

44 minutes ago

Journeyman Dan Brown finally makes a name for himself by surviving Troon test

44 minutes ago

Canada moves to phase out oil-fired furnaces

44 minutes ago

Woodside share price falls despite $1.8 billion 'global LNG powerhouse' bid

44 minutes ago

Wife of Yankees exec and former Mets GM Omar Minaya is 'mysteriously found dead at couple's New Jersey home as suicide is ruled out'

44 minutes ago

Video:

44 minutes ago

Aussie star tests Paris Olympics 'anti-sex beds' in the Athletes Village - and she is NOT happy with the results

44 minutes ago

Why DroneShield, South32, Whitehaven Coal, and Woodside shares are tumbling today

44 minutes ago

Woman dies from tick-borne virus as dangerous illnesses spread

44 minutes ago

Boeing is losing $1 billion a month with planes awaiting parts - and they are sitting in employee parking lots

44 minutes ago

Jeep Gladiator: Up to $25,000 off with drive-away pricing

44 minutes ago

NHS warns of ‘delays’ as services recover from global IT outage

44 minutes ago

Nick Dunlap, still just 20, wins 2024 Barracuda Championship for second PGA Tour title

44 minutes ago

Banner’s defiance keeps Rebels at bay as Tony Kelly bends epic final to his will

47 minutes ago

Harris’ first task: Get emboldened Democrats to fall in line

50 minutes ago

Video: Robert Irwin hits back after fans call out his 'creepy' relationship with mum Terri: 'People forget that loss brings a family together'

52 minutes ago

Adrian Beltre, Todd Helton, Joe Mauer, Jim Leyland enter HOF

52 minutes ago

Cover The Unfinished Underside Of Upper Cabinets With This Brilliant Design Trick

52 minutes ago

Dreams of contention for Elly De La Cruz and the Reds take a hit with a sweep at Washington

52 minutes ago

Rahul Gandhi to receive Oommen Chandy Public Servant Award

52 minutes ago

Gausman looks to help Blue Jays avoid sweep against Tigers

52 minutes ago

Re-live the acid house party

52 minutes ago

BMW R 1300 GS adventure: A breakthrough in motorcycle expeditions

54 minutes ago

Kaufman County sergeant killed in off-duty motorcycle crash

60 minutes ago

Robert De Niro comes out swinging for Kamala Harris

60 minutes ago

Orlando Pirates news: Player shows off new kit, six new faces on tour

60 minutes ago

Joe Biden quits election race: Statement in full

60 minutes ago

Are Pre-Workout Supplements Bad For You?

60 minutes ago

Asia stocks wary; Wall St unfazed as Biden bows out

ALONGWALKER VIETNAM: Kênh khám phá trải nghiệm của giới trẻ, thế giới du lịch ALONGWALKER INDONESIA: Saluran untuk mengeksplorasi pengalaman para pemuda global