US Supreme Court upholds federal domestic-violence gun ban

us supreme court upholds federal domestic-violence gun ban

Rev. Patrick Mahoney, director of the Christian Defense Coalition, holds up a sign after U.S. justices rejected a Second Amendment challenge to a federal law that makes it a crime for people subject to domestic violence restraining orders to possess a gun, outside the U.S. Supreme Court in Washington, U.S., June 21, 2024. REUTERS/Amanda Andrade-Rhoades

By Andrew Chung

WASHINGTON (Reuters) -The U.S. Supreme Court on Friday upheld a federal law that makes it a crime for people under domestic violence restraining orders to have guns, handing a victory to President Joe Biden's administration as the justices opted not to further widen firearms rights after a major expansion in 2022.

us supreme court upholds federal domestic-violence gun ban

FILE PHOTO: A general view of the U.S. Supreme Court building in Washington, U.S., June 1, 2024. REUTERS/Will Dunham/File Photo

The 8-1 ruling, authored by conservative Chief Justice John Roberts, overturned a lower court's decision striking down the 1994 law as a violation of the U.S. Constitution's Second Amendment right to "keep and bear arms." The law was challenged by a Texas man who was subject to a restraining order for assaulting his girlfriend in a parking lot and later threatening to shoot her.

us supreme court upholds federal domestic-violence gun ban

FILE PHOTO: A view shows firearms at the National Rifle Association (NRA) annual convention in Indianapolis, Indiana, U.S., April 15, 2023. REUTERS/Evelyn Hockstein/File Photo

The New Orleans-based 5th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals had concluded that the measure failed the Supreme Court's stringent test set in 2022 that required gun laws to be "consistent with the nation's historical tradition of firearm regulation" to comply with the Second Amendment.

But Roberts wrote that since the nation's founding, firearm laws have targeted people who threaten physical harm to others.

"When a restraining order contains a finding that an individual poses a credible threat to the physical safety of an intimate partner, that individual may - consistent with the Second Amendment - be banned from possessing firearms while the order is in effect," Roberts wrote.

Biden's administration defended the law as critical to protect public safety and abuse victims, who often are women.

"No one who has been abused should have to worry about their abuser getting a gun," Biden said, touting his record on gun control. "As a result of (Friday's) ruling, survivors of domestic violence and their families will still be able to count on critical protections, just as they have for the past three decades."

Conservative Justice Clarence Thomas, who authored the 2022 ruling in a case called New York State Rifle and Pistol Association v. Bruen, was the lone dissenter.

"Not a single historical regulation justifies the statute at issue," Thomas wrote, adding that "in the interest of ensuring the government can regulate one subset of society, (Friday's) decision puts at risk the Second Amendment rights of many more."

The case involved Zackey Rahimi, who pleaded guilty in 2021 to illegally possessing guns in violation of this law while subject to a restraining order. Police found a pistol and rifle while searching Rahimi's residence in connection with at least five shootings, including using an assault-type rifle to fire at the home of a man to whom he had sold drugs.

A federal judge had rejected Rahimi's Second Amendment challenge and sentenced him to more than six years in prison before the case went to the 5th Circuit. Violating this law was punishable by up to 10 years in prison at the time of Rahimi's indictment but has since been raised to 15 years.

'A SIGH OF RELIEF'

Gun control advocates welcomed Friday's ruling.

"As millions of domestic violence victims breathe a sigh of relief, it's worth remembering who put them in jeopardy: extreme Trump-appointed judges on the 5th Circuit who sided with an abuser who wanted to keep his guns," said John Feinblatt, president of Everytown for Gun Safety, referring to Republican former President Donald Trump.

Rahimi's lawyer declined to comment.

In a nation bitterly divided over how to address firearms violence including frequent mass shootings, the Supreme Court often has taken an expansive view of the Second Amendment. It broadened gun rights in landmark rulings in 2008 and 2010 before the 2022 Bruen decision, which recognized a constitutional right to carry a handgun in public for self defense and struck down New York state's limits on carrying concealed handguns.

In Friday's ruling, Roberts made clear that the history and tradition test set in Bruen for gun regulations is not as inflexible as the 5th Circuit's ruling and Thomas's dissent suggested.

Roberts said that under the Bruen precedent, modern gun restrictions do not require a "historical twin" in order to be lawful.

Five justices who joined the majority in the ruling wrote concurring opinions, reflecting a vigorous debate over the workability of the Bruen test. Liberal Justice Ketanji Brown Jackson said the Rahimi case demonstrated that lower courts are struggling to apply the Bruen tenets.

"In my view, the blame may lie with us, not with them," Jackson wrote.

In another firearms-related decision, the Supreme Court on June 14, declared unlawful a federal ban on "bump stock" devices that enable semiautomatic weapons to fire rapidly like machine guns, although that case did not involve the Second Amendment.

In a May Reuters/Ipsos poll, 75% of registered voters, including 84% of Democrats and 70% of Republicans, said that a person subject to a domestic violence restraining order should not be allowed to possess firearms.

(Reporting by Andrew Chung; Editing by Will Dunham)

OTHER NEWS

50 minutes ago

England football fans look on in horror as they watch a TV screen at a restaurant in Leicester Square as Spanish football fans gleefully watch their team win

50 minutes ago

Brussels, my love? Freak-out over French vote

50 minutes ago

Video: Donald Trump says he has completely rewritten convention speech after shooting as aides plan toned down Milwaukee event amid calls for unity

50 minutes ago

CNBC Daily Open: Trump assassination attempt

50 minutes ago

In prime-time address, Biden warns of election-year rhetoric, saying ‘it's time to cool it down'

50 minutes ago

Trump in Milwaukee for convention as authorities investigate motive, security in assassination attempt

50 minutes ago

'Please God, stop harassing these people' | County leaders, law enforcement call for end to threats against crews restoring power

50 minutes ago

The Only Main Actors Still Alive From 1969's Midnight Cowboy

50 minutes ago

Former Peruvian leader Alberto Fujimori plans to run for presidency in 2026, daughter says

50 minutes ago

Vikings receiver Jordan Addison arrested on suspicion of DUI

50 minutes ago

Google parent Alphabet in talks to buy cyber-security start-up Wiz for $30.8 billion

50 minutes ago

Bianca Censori: Kanye West’s wife spotted wearing tiny bra in Los Angeles

50 minutes ago

Analysis-Thai economy faces upheaval due to factory closures and cheap Chinese imports

50 minutes ago

Patriots Training Camp Position Preview: Defensive Tackle

50 minutes ago

Alert: The First Pics of the ‘Outlander’ Prequel Series Are Here

50 minutes ago

Google Nears $23 Billion Deal to Acquire Cybersecurity Firm Wiz: WSJ

50 minutes ago

Greene fires as Giants tame Tigers in rare MCG outing

50 minutes ago

England's Euro 2024 final loss 'will hurt for a long time', says Kane

50 minutes ago

Trump Trade Has Huge Implications for Bond Market: Purves

50 minutes ago

Tom Brown’s top 10 veg to grow in July

50 minutes ago

Falcons receiver ready to breakout in new offense according to CBS Sports

50 minutes ago

Foster carers in Victoria leaving system due to rising costs and red tape, child welfare advocates concerned

50 minutes ago

Las Vegas Summer League Game Thread: San Antonio Spurs vs Atlanta Hawks

50 minutes ago

Experts stunned by discovery in wetlands 10 years after reintroduction of centuries-extinct beavers: 'Can transform local environments'

50 minutes ago

The Copa America final was delayed after unticketed fans breached the stadium grounds in Miami Gardens

50 minutes ago

England could face Argentina in Buenos Aires for first time since Falklands War

50 minutes ago

World leaders condemn assassination attempt on Trump: 'Tragedy for democracy'

50 minutes ago

Video: Off-duty cop is praised for unbelievably cool response after shopper was caught doing the unthinkable at Woolworths

50 minutes ago

2024 MLB draft picks so far: First round results, every pick from opening night

50 minutes ago

‘Oh my god moment’: Queensland Lotto winners who thought they won $1000 become millionaires instead

50 minutes ago

Gridlock on new energy transmission adds to bill shock

50 minutes ago

Petrol, rent, insurance keeping pressure on inflation

50 minutes ago

Harry Kane responds to claims he was injured after England's Euro 2024 final loss

50 minutes ago

Phillies select Dante Nori with their first round pick

50 minutes ago

Dap Recap: The top three storylines heading into SEC Media Days

50 minutes ago

Victoria demands Labor to suspend union from party

50 minutes ago

Ambani wedding: Celebrity highlights including John Cena praising Shah Rukh Khan

50 minutes ago

England's best and worst players in Euro 2024 final

50 minutes ago

Gary Lineker 'expects' Gareth Southgate won't mange England again after Euro 2024 defeat

50 minutes ago

Gal: This infamous moment should put Blues on guard

ALONGWALKER VIETNAM: Kênh khám phá trải nghiệm của giới trẻ, thế giới du lịch ALONGWALKER INDONESIA: Saluran untuk mengeksplorasi pengalaman para pemuda global