Trump rejects Jack Smith's authority in classified documents case hearing

trump rejects jack smith's authority in classified documents case hearing

An aerial view of former U.S. President Donald Trump's Mar-a-Lago home after Trump said that FBI agents raided it, in Palm Beach, Florida, U.S. August 15, 2022.

In former President Donald Trump's latest bid to get criminal charges over his handling of classified documents tossed out, one of his lawyers argued at a Friday hearing that special counsel Jack Smith wasn't authorized to bring the case.

"Jack Smith does not have a superior who is operating with sufficient oversight authority over his decisions right now," Trump lawyer Emil Bove told U.S. District Judge Aileen Cannon, who set aside Friday to hear Trump's challenge to special counsel Jack Smith's appointment in the case.

Smith was appointed by Attorney General Merrick Garland in November 2022 to oversee the investigation into Trump's post-White House retention of classified documents and a separate investigation into Trump's efforts to overturn the 2020 presidential election. Smith ultimately brought charges against Trump in Florida based on the documents investigation and in Washington, D.C. based on the election interference investigation.

Start the day smarter. Get all the news you need in your inbox each morning.

Justice Department lawyer James Pearce said at the hearing that Smith still faces oversight because Garland can weigh in on important decisions and even overrule the special counsel is necessary.

Garland said at the time of Smith's appointment that the move underscored the Justice Department's "commitment to both independence and accountability in particularly sensitive matters."

Trump is charged with mishandling classified documents, including by willfully retaining national defense information such as documents on U.S. and foreign military capabilities after his presidency.

Trump argues special counsels are unlawful

In a motion ahead of Friday's hearing, Trump's team argued that Garland lacked authority to appoint a special counsel to oversee any criminal investigation without Senate approval, and that Garland's appointment of Smith to oversee Trump investigations in November of 2022 was therefore unlawful. Prosecutors have argued that Congress has empowered the attorney general to appoint "inferior officers" such as a special counsel.

Special counsels have been appointed for decades by Democratic and Republican administrations to oversee investigations with greater independence from the Justice Department. An attorney general may decide to appoint a special counsel based on conflict-of-interest concerns.

Previous special or independent counsels (a precursor to special counsels) have been consistently upheld in court. Cannon nonetheless held a lengthy hearing on Trump's argument. Cannon also allowed outside groups to argue before the court in support of Trump's argument, which is not standard practice in a district court.

Garland has also appointed special counsels to oversee an investigation into President Joe Biden's retention of classified documents after he was vice-president and two investigations into Hunter Biden, one dealing with a form he filled out to get a gun and another dealing with his tax filings. The investigation headed by special counsel Robert Hur didn't result in charges against the president, but Hunter Biden was convicted June 11 in a gun-related case and faces trial on tax charges in September in cases headed by special counsel David Weiss.

Case has survived – so far

Trump's challenge to Smith's authority is one of several bids he has made to get the case dismissed. For instance, Trump has also argued that many of the charges should be dismissed because they fall under a law – the Espionage Act – that is too vague to be applied in his case.

So far those efforts have been unsuccessful, although several legal experts have criticized decisions by Cannon that they say contravene the law in ways that are favorable to Trump, such as temporarily blocking investigators from reviewing documents in advance of the indictment against the former president. That decision was reversed by a panel of three Republican-appointed appellate judges in a sharply-worded rebuke. Although Cannon rejected Trump's Espionage Act argument, she left the door open for him to raise it again.

Cannon was appointed by Trump, and he has praised her since she took on his case.

Cannon indefinitely postponed a trial, another decision widely viewed as favorable to Trump. If Trump wins the upcoming presidential election, he could − in what many say would be a significant blow to judicial independence and the rule of law − order the Justice Department to drop the case.

Cannon is also slated to hear arguments on Monday and Tuesday over Trump's challenge to funding for the investigation, Smith's request to block Trump from saying the FBI was authorized to shoot him during a raid of his Mar-a-Lago club, and Trump's request to block prosecutors from using documents seized during the raid.

Contributing: Reuters; Bart Jansen

This article originally appeared on USA TODAY: Trump rejects Jack Smith's authority in classified documents case hearing

OTHER NEWS

38 minutes ago

Chelsea to finish top four, Crystal Palace to finish in the top half and Leeds to win the league valued at 18/1 - as the Premier League and Championship kick off next month

38 minutes ago

Man United and Liverpool 'set to battle it out to sign France star on a free transfer'... as Red Devils look to beat their arch-rivals to another target after landing £52m Leny Yoro

38 minutes ago

What the 9 human cases of bird flu in the U.S. so far tell us about the disease

38 minutes ago

UK pay growth slows but likely still too high for Bank of England to keep lid on inflation

38 minutes ago

Michelin-rated restaurant fights back against online blackmailers

38 minutes ago

India taking 'baby steps' to get involved in semiconductor value chain: Goldman Sachs

38 minutes ago

Indianapolis Turning Point: Reddick set to steal regular-season title? What to expect in Indy return?

38 minutes ago

This is what it's like to party in a country on the brink of war

38 minutes ago

Oil and gas regulator rejects reports of govt meddling in North Sea drilling applications

38 minutes ago

Refused to give up first-class seat to child: Online debate erupts

38 minutes ago

Six NFL Quarterbacks Taken In The UFL Draft On Wednesday

38 minutes ago

German coalition approves controversial 2025 budget to boost economy

38 minutes ago

Shady's back: Eminem to perform at Abu Dhabi F1 after-race concert

38 minutes ago

I’ve placed a big bet on this forgotten FTSE 100 share and think I’m onto a winner

38 minutes ago

Motor racing-Magnussen to vacate Haas F1 seat at end of season

38 minutes ago

North Korean Defector to Lead South Korea's Unification Council

38 minutes ago

New Minister wants to form a state-owned water company

38 minutes ago

Manipur Govt launches re-verification drive to curb illegal immigration from Myanmar

42 minutes ago

Revealed: The coronavirus outbreak plan ignored by the government during the pandemic

42 minutes ago

Mystery buyer sets record for most spent at dinosaur auction

42 minutes ago

Charlize Theron explains The Old Guard 2 release delay

42 minutes ago

Man Utd's stance on Matthijs de Ligt transfer emerges after medical completed

42 minutes ago

EU’s von der Leyen vows to fight for democratic, ‘strong’ Europe in bid for second term

42 minutes ago

Wage growth falls back further but continues to outstrip inflation

42 minutes ago

Joe Biden walks slowly off Air Force One after testing positive for Covid

42 minutes ago

Nawazuddin Siddiqui admits he did Rajinikanth’s Petta only for the money, says he feels ‘guilty’ for ‘cheating’ in his performance: ‘Itna saara paisa…’

43 minutes ago

Weather damage estimated to be in excess of R1bn as next storm hits today

43 minutes ago

Huge sale in Dubai: Amazon's Prime Day is underway

43 minutes ago

Here’s how the repo rate impacts your pocket

43 minutes ago

Former Secret Service agent says Trump would-be assassin Thomas Crooks scouted rally spot in advance

43 minutes ago

Bellingham ‘set up’ by senior England players who were ‘happy’ Real Madrid star took media ‘flak’

43 minutes ago

Is this the anti-ageing elixir we've all been waiting for? Scientists reveal whether it could REALLY slow human aging too - as 'supermodel granny' drug that extends lifespan of mice by 25% is created

47 minutes ago

China investigators suspect construction work caused fire that killed 16 people in shopping mall

47 minutes ago

Vietnam's President To Lam becomes caretaker of Communist Party while chief Trong focuses on health

52 minutes ago

Real Madrid fans will 'be made to wait for Kylian Mbappe's debut', with club's new superstar signing set to MISS their pre-season tour of the US

52 minutes ago

FA 'set to interview diverse coaches' in hunt for new England manager - with search for Gareth Southgate's successor the first since introduction of Football Leadership Diversity Code

53 minutes ago

Most intact stegosaurus fossil sold for record $44.6m at auction

53 minutes ago

The Acolyte star Manny Jacinto says he wasn’t surprised by Top Gun cutting all his lines

53 minutes ago

The FOMO over old buildings before they go

53 minutes ago

Mediacorp’s recent redecoration of a conserved bungalow done without necessary approval: URA

ALONGWALKER VIETNAM: Kênh khám phá trải nghiệm của giới trẻ, thế giới du lịch ALONGWALKER INDONESIA: Saluran untuk mengeksplorasi pengalaman para pemuda global