The Supreme Court rejects a settlement in a water dispute between New Mexico and Texas

The Supreme Court rejects a settlement in a water dispute between New Mexico and Texas

The Supreme Court rejects a settlement in a water dispute between New Mexico and Texas

The Supreme Court has rejected a settlement between Western states over the management of one of North America’s longest rivers

ByLINDSAY WHITEHURST Associated Press

June 21, 2024, 10:28 AM

    WASHINGTON -- WASHINGTON (AP) — The Supreme Court on Friday rejected a settlement between Western states over the management of one of North America’s longest rivers.

    In a 5-4 decision, the justices ruled that the water-sharing deal between Texas and New Mexico can't go through because the federal government still has concerns about New Mexico water use on the Rio Grande, which Colorado also draws from.

    “Having acknowledged those interests, and having allowed the United States to intervene to assert them, we cannot now allow Texas and New Mexico to leave the United States up the river without a paddle," said Justice Ketanji Brown Jackson, reading the majority opinion, which crossed ideological lines as it was joined by Justices Sonia Sotomayor, Elena Kagan, Brett Kavanaugh and John Roberts.

    In a dissent, Justice Neil Gorsuch said the United States' theory about how water should be distributed between the two states is “so aggressive that New Mexico fears it could devastate its economy." Joined by Justices Clarence Thomas, Samuel Alito and Amy Coney Barrett, he wrote that the high court's ruling “defies 100 years of this court's water law jurisprudence.”

    New Mexico’s state engineer said it was disappointing the high court scuttled the deal recommended by a federal judge overseeing the case.

    “We need to keep working to make the aquifers in the Lower Rio Grande region sustainable, and lasting solutions are more likely to come from parties working together than from continued litigation," said Mike Hamman, whose office is responsible for administering the state’s water resources.

    Some New Mexico lawmakers had voiced concerns about the proposed settlement, which would have meant reducing the state’s use of Rio Grande water with steps like paying farmers to leave their fields barren and making infrastructure improvements.

    Attorney Samantha Barncastle with the Elephant Butte Irrigation District, the largest in New Mexico, greeted the ruling with pleasure and said her group hopes all the parties will go back to the settlement table and hammer out a new agreement.

    Farmers in southern New Mexico have had to rely more heavily on groundwater wells over the last two decades as drought and climate change resulted in reduced flows and less water in reservoirs along the Rio Grande. Texas sued over the groundwater pumping, saying the practice was cutting into the amount of water that was ultimately delivered as part of the interstate compact.

    U.S. Circuit Judge Michael Melloy had previously deemed the proposal a fair and reasonable way to resolve the conflict consistent with a decadeslong water-sharing agreement.

    The federal government, though, lodged several objections, including that the proposal did not mandate specific water capture or use limitations within New Mexico.

    ___

    Associated Press writer Rio Yamat in Las Vegas contributed to this story.

    Related Topics

    OTHER NEWS

    36 minutes ago

    Zuma Faces ANC Hearing Over His South African Election Rebellion

    36 minutes ago

    If I had £5k to invest today, would I buy Rolls-Royce shares?

    36 minutes ago

    Parts of our cities are Islamist, says Nigel Farage as he backs JD Vance

    36 minutes ago

    Video: Capital FM breakfast star Jordan North lashes out after catching someone 'robbing milk' from his front door

    36 minutes ago

    Video: Welcome to Costa del Un! Grinning North Korean dictator surveys plans for his new tourism resort before strolling on immaculate white sand beach… right next to rocket-testing site

    1 hour ago

    Graeme Souness criticises Man Utd star who 'doesn't understand his position'

    1 hour ago

    Instability will be our GNU reality

    1 hour ago

    Gardening jobs you must do in July - and plants to prune for 'repeat flowering'

    1 hour ago

    3 best free shows on Tubi to stream right now

    1 hour ago

    Emmys 2023: Shogun leads with 25 nominations, Emma Stone snubbed

    1 hour ago

    Armstrong fuels doping speculation surrounding Yellow Jersey Tadej Pogacar

    1 hour ago

    Video: Strictly's Reverend Richard Coles says there's 'so much going on behind the family friendly glittering surface' after claiming the show has a 'dark heart' amid abuse allegations

    1 hour ago

    Tiny Drake's Island off the coast of Plymouth is up for sale - and it could make the perfect spot for a hotel

    1 hour ago

    Video: Is this the anti-ageing elixir we've all been waiting for? Scientists reveal whether it could REALLY slow human aging too - as 'supermodel granny' drug that extends lifespan of mice by 25% is created

    1 hour ago

    Soccer-Spain climb to third in FIFA rankings, Argentina stay top

    1 hour ago

    Dubai princess appears to divorce husband via Instagram

    1 hour ago

    What's it like to train with Simone Biles every day? We asked her teammates.

    1 hour ago

    Why Arsenal's Riccardo Calafiori deal has stalled amid Bologna transfer fee issue

    1 hour ago

    Newcastle planning to sign international striker to help Alexander Isak

    1 hour ago

    Kevin Magnussen and Haas to part ways before F1 2025 season

    1 hour ago

    What is the Karnataka job quota Bill and why it was put on hold

    1 hour ago

    Ex-Man Utd coach at risk of sack in MLS after nine-game winless run

    1 hour ago

    Over 40 statues of Nelson Mandela around the world: Here’s where

    1 hour ago

    How a common blood thinner can protect against spitting cobras

    1 hour ago

    Kobbie Mainoo slammed by Souness for Euro 2024 ‘wander’ as ‘impossible’ Declan Rice stat revealed

    1 hour ago

    Six people found dead in Bangkok hotel killed with cyanide, Thai police say

    1 hour ago

    SCA clips drone fishers’ wings

    1 hour ago

    Morgan Stanley says renewable energy stock is 'underappreciated' as powering AI play

    1 hour ago

    Shoppers praise on-sale silicone strips for fading and flattening scars: 'Improvements after ONE week' (and the before and after images will shock you)

    1 hour ago

    Aussie sporting icon Dylan Alcott announces surprise career move after conquering tennis

    1 hour ago

    Video: Strictly's Reverend Richard Coles says there's 'so much going on behind the family friendly glittering surface' after claiming the show has a 'dark heart' amid abuse allegations

    2 hrs ago

    Putin warns of power shortages due to crypto mining

    2 hrs ago

    Barely an electric car in sight: The areas with the slowest uptake of plug-in vehicles

    2 hrs ago

    Opposition questions UP govt's move to ask proprietors' names of eateries along Kanwar route in Muzaffarnagar

    2 hrs ago

    Secret Service was told police could not watch building used by Trump rally shooter

    2 hrs ago

    NSW fans ecstatic after breakthrough Blues win in Brisbane

    2 hrs ago

    Federal Agriculture Minister agrees with decision to place CFMEU under independent administration

    2 hrs ago

    Rocket scientist. Engineer. Mogul. Meet 10 US Olympians with super impressive résumés

    2 hrs ago

    Acclaimed 2000s US drama 24 to be rebooted as a film

    2 hrs ago

    Mike Tyson reveals real reason behind Jake Paul fight: ‘Can I be honest?’

    ALONGWALKER VIETNAM: Kênh khám phá trải nghiệm của giới trẻ, thế giới du lịch ALONGWALKER INDONESIA: Saluran untuk mengeksplorasi pengalaman para pemuda global