Trump judge presses his attorneys on ‘shadow government’ claims in Jack Smith hearing

After hundreds of complaints against her, and one day after a report revealed that she ignored other federal judges who urged her to step away from the case, District Judge Aileen Cannon kicked off the first of a three-day series of hearings in Donald Trump’s classified documents case.

Cannon has indefinitely delayed a trial against the former president. So the hearings in her Florida courtroom are instead putting special counsel Jack Smith under a microscope.

On Friday, Trump’s attorneys and his allies argued that Smith — who brought federal charges against the former president — was unlawfully appointed as special counsel. Cannon, who was appointed to the bench by Trump, appeared somewhat skeptical of their long-shot arguments, which join a long list of motions to dismiss the case.

But she also questioned whether Attorney General Merrick Garland has oversight of the case, and took the unusual move of allowing nonparties who support Trump to argue in front of her.

At the center of Friday’s arguments was a claim from Trump’s attorneys that Attorney General Merrick Garland does not have legal authority to appoint a special counsel because, they argue, Smith is a “principal officer” who needs Senate approval.

trump judge presses his attorneys on ‘shadow government’ claims in jack smith hearing

US district judge Aileen Cannon (Southern District of Florida)

Cannon appeared to cast doubt on that argument, telling attorneys that judges in a similar case involving Robert Mueller did a “fairly comprehensive review.”

She also pushed Trump’s attorneys to explain what they meant by saying that Smith’s position amounted to a “shadow government.”

“That sounds very ominous,” she said. “But what do you really mean?”

She asked whether that is “realistic” given the “well-defined” regulations surrounding independent special counsels, and that it wasn’t “fair” to “cast aspersions in that direction.”

It’s not unusual for attorneys to throw whatever they can at trying to dismiss the charges against their clients, but judges rarely hold hearings on them — and almost never invite people who aren’t involved with the case to argue on a defendant’s behalf in an open court.

After indefinitely delaying a trial, guaranteeing that the former president won’t be tried before Election Day, Judge Cannon has instead blocked off three days this month in her Fort Pierce courtroom to question Smith’s legitimacy and hear whether Trump should face a gag order, and if audio evidence against Trump should be tossed out.

On Monday, Cannon will hear more from Trump’s attorneys who argue that Smith was unlawfully funded.

She will also hear a request from prosecutors to restrict Trump from making any other incendiary claims connected to the case, after Trump and his campaign and allies repeatedly falsely claimed that the FBI was going to “assassinate” him when law enforcement agents searched his Mar-a-Lago compound.

Trump is already under limited gag orders in his New York criminal hush money case and in his federal election interference case, which he unsuccessfully tried to block from going into effect.

And on Tuesday, Cannon will hear more arguments from Trump’s attorneys to block potential audio evidence, including recordings that could be used as evidence of his alleged obstruction in the case.

The former president faces 40 separate charges stemming from allegations that he withheld hundreds of classified documents after leaving the White House for his private Mar-a-Lago compound in Florida, then conspired to obstruct government attempts to retrieve them.

He has pleaded not guilty.

His co-defendants Walt Nauta and Carlos De Oliveira, who are accused of helping Trump mishandle documents at the Florida property, have also pleaded not guilty.

The Independent stands for many things, often uniquely so. It stands independent of political party allegiance, and makes its own mind up on the issues of the day. The Independent has always been committed to challenge and debate. It launched in 1986 to create a new voice and in that time has run campaigns for issues ranging from the legalisation of marijuana to the Final Say Brexit petition.

OTHER NEWS

48 minutes ago

5 high-speed trains that will blow you away

48 minutes ago

Salman Rushdie stabbing suspect now faces federal terrorism charges

49 minutes ago

Microsoft to take massive hit as Fortune 500 firms suffer $5.4B in losses from Crowdstrike outage: study

49 minutes ago

Coffee prices poised to surge again as supply-chain disruptions create bean shortages

49 minutes ago

Cher, 78, reveals she is releasing a TWO part memoir that will share her 'true story in intimate detail' while posting a first look at the book cover

49 minutes ago

NOA Bridal: Perth brides left scrambling to find dresses as wedding boutique owner Elizabeth Lyndon-James filed for bankruptcy

49 minutes ago

Council chiefs issue desperate cash plea to Swinney to stop strikes

49 minutes ago

Long Covid cannot be blamed for constant tiredness, brain fog or muscle pain, study suggests

49 minutes ago

Video: Hear the terrifying mayday call from boaters who watched huge humpback whale breach above ship and sink it

49 minutes ago

Video: Timothée Chalamet's Bob Dylan is seen in action for the first time as the actor performs A Hard Rain's A-Gonna Fall in the trailer for the singer's biopic A Complete Unknown

49 minutes ago

Video: It's just not cricket! Shocking moment two warring spectators pull out stumps and wield bat as they square up to each other on the field

49 minutes ago

Video: Stunning Colorado mansion with glorious mountain views and VERY lavish barn lists for $12m

49 minutes ago

‘Presumed Innocent’ Finale Delivers Double Twist; Does It Set Up Season 2?

49 minutes ago

Argentina scores chaotic equalizer in stoppage time vs. Morocco to open Olympics

49 minutes ago

Two people rescued after breaching whale capsizes boat off New Hampshire coast

49 minutes ago

Tua Tagovailoa's practice status 'fluid' amid contract talks

49 minutes ago

Stan Bowman, after Blackhawks case, hired as GM of Oilers

49 minutes ago

Tennis world No 1 Jannik Sinner forced to pull out of Olympics

49 minutes ago

Captain Sir Tom Moore’s daughter’s company warned it could be struck off

49 minutes ago

Formula One statistics for the Belgian Grand Prix

49 minutes ago

Verstappen on two triple runs but one must end

49 minutes ago

Derrick Henry says he will let 'play speak' for itself when asked about wear and tear

49 minutes ago

46 days until Saints' season opener: Every player to wear No. 46

49 minutes ago

Tortilla Mexican Grill shares tumble on sales hit from move to quit Deliveroo

49 minutes ago

Unburdened by What Has Been, Bernie Bros Join the KHive

49 minutes ago

Vikings agree to 4-year extension with LT Christian Darrisaw worth up to $113M

49 minutes ago

Twelve classic novels to read this summer that aren’t War and Peace

49 minutes ago

Disruptive rainfall to hit Cape Town and surrounding areas

49 minutes ago

Pep Guardiola breaks silence on Ederson transfer as Man City boss takes notable stance

49 minutes ago

IOC, fearing U.S. FBI probes, drops a bombshell in Salt Lake 2034 Olympics contract

49 minutes ago

Trafford Centre owner sees profit slump by more than half despite revenue nearing £100m

49 minutes ago

Golf icon warns Shane Lowry may regret comments after Open Championship woes

49 minutes ago

Haason Reddick rejected Jets contract offer | The Carton Show

49 minutes ago

Severe storms return to Ontario, Quebec with more rain and a tornado risk

49 minutes ago

Imran Khan to run for chancellor of Oxford University from prison

49 minutes ago

Thabiso Monyane said Orlando Pirates new signing Gilberto can help the side win a treble

49 minutes ago

Kamala Harris, dozens of lawmakers sit out Netanyahu speech to Congress

49 minutes ago

Prince William opts not to declare how much tax he pays on billion-pound Duchy of Cornwall empire - despite King Charles regularly doing so when he was Prince of Wales

49 minutes ago

Did DEI crash 8.5M computers? CrowdStrike probed for sidelining its white, male coders

49 minutes ago

Video shows female 'doctor' leaving hospital with three-hour-old baby...but all is not what it seems

ALONGWALKER VIETNAM: Kênh khám phá trải nghiệm của giới trẻ, thế giới du lịch ALONGWALKER INDONESIA: Saluran untuk mengeksplorasi pengalaman para pemuda global