Texas councilwoman can sue over arrest she claims was politically motivated, Supreme Court rules

texas councilwoman can sue over arrest she claims was politically motivated, supreme court rules

Sylvia Gonzalez, a 76-year-old retiree and a resident of Castle Hills, Texas, who was arrested as punishment for criticizing the city's management and officials.

The Supreme Court on Thursday allowed a Texas woman who served on a small-town council to continue her lawsuit against her mayor after she was arrested for what she claims were political reasons.

In an unsigned opinion, the high court said a federal appeals court took an “overly cramped view” of an earlier precedent that control when people may sue for First Amendment retaliation claims. Justice Clarence Thomas authored the only public dissent.

Sylvia Gonzalez was arrested in 2019 shortly after she took her seat as a council member in Castle Hills, Texas, following a campaign in which she heavily criticized the city manager.

Gonzalez, then 72, was arrested for stealing a government document at a council meeting – a charge that stemmed from what she said was an inadvertent shuffling of papers and what city officials said may have been motivated by a cover-up.

Though it was a messy local political dispute, the case nevertheless presented an important First Amendment question for the Supreme Court: When may people sue government officials for First Amendment retaliation claims – and when are those suits barred by a legal doctrine known as qualified immunity that shields those officials from certain suits?

Normally, a person alleging retaliatory arrest must demonstrate police had not proven probable cause. But there is an exception: Police are not shielded from such lawsuits if officers often exercise discretion not to arrest – say, for petty crimes like jaywalking.

But unlike jaywalking, taking government documents during a city council meeting is a rare occurrence. Gonzalez’s attorneys said there is no way to demonstrate that police had let slide similar infractions involving others – since there were none.

In its opinion Thursday, the court ruled that Gonzalez should be allowed to present her evidence that she was arrested as retaliation for her actions.

The court wrote that while the exception to the rule on bypassing probable cause is “slim,” the appeals court’s “demand” for identical situations “goes too far.”

Gonzalez’s evidence should be at least considered “because the fact that no one has ever been arrested for engaging in a certain kind of conduct – especially when the criminal prohibition is longstanding and the conduct at issue is not novel – makes it more likely that an officer has declined to arrest someone for engaging in such conduct in the past,” the court wrote.

The court’s decision will allow Gonzalez’s case to continue.

In dissent, Thomas asserted that there shouldn’t be an exception to the probable cause rule on retaliatory arrests and he criticized the court for what he described as further expanding that exception.

“I would adhere to the only rule grounded in history,” Thomas wrote. “Probable cause defeats a retaliatory arrest claim.”

Prosecutors ultimately dropped the charges against Gonzalez. She sued in federal court, alleging retaliation in violation of the First Amendment and saying that city officials engineered a plan to arrest her and remove her from office.

A district court denied qualified immunity to the officers, allowing the case to continue, but Gonzalez lost at the 5th US Circuit Court of Appeals, which held that there was probable cause to arrest her and that it “necessarily defeated” her retaliatory arrest claim.

Justice Samuel Alito was not present Thursday as his colleagues took their seats to announce the day’s opinions – a relatively rare absence.

The Supreme Court did not immediately respond to a request for comment about Alito’s absence.

This story has been updated with additional details.

For more CNN news and newsletters create an account at CNN.com

OTHER NEWS

26 minutes ago

Shaquille O'Neal picks 'definite' favorite in Caitlin Clark vs Angel Reese Rookie of the Year race

26 minutes ago

Tom Brady accused of 'disrespect' by former NFL star over claims he 'ignored' shock comeback offer

26 minutes ago

This 'new deal' for workers is a mortal threat to jobs and living standards, writes JOHN LONGWORTH

28 minutes ago

End of an era: 'The Grand Tour' trio bids farewell

29 minutes ago

Asia-Pacific markets tumble as chip stocks drop, Nasdaq records its worst day since 2022

29 minutes ago

Delta organizes send-off for Team USA Olympic athletes at Atlanta airport

29 minutes ago

Brian Miles: Police urgently seeking public’s help to find missing 71y/o man in Murchison near Byro Station

29 minutes ago

Hyundai in no rush to take on Mitsubishi with PHEVs

29 minutes ago

Russia's Arctic Gas Project Faces Uncertainty as Production Crashes

29 minutes ago

Spurs Found Their Rhythm in Summer League

29 minutes ago

Old video and photos recirculate, falsely claiming Trump wasn't injured

29 minutes ago

Researcher describes unlikely yet effective catalyst for renewable energy: 'It could revolutionize the modern push'

29 minutes ago

Madame Tussauds unveils Whoniverse-inspired set with Ncuti Gatwa waxwork

29 minutes ago

New Nightfall Wireless Gaming Headset from JLab Promises Big Sounds for a Small Price

33 minutes ago

Gov. Abbott says Texas will continue busing migrants to Chicago during RNC speech

33 minutes ago

Asia-Pacific markets tumble after Nasdaq records its worst day since 2022; Japan trade deficit narrows

36 minutes ago

Luis Suarez's infamous spat with Patrice Evra and Rodrigo Bentancur's bizarre Son Heung-min 'cousin' claim - several football players from South America have landed themselves in hot water over racism storms

36 minutes ago

Game three: The wild State of Origin moment you missed: ball boys are caught in a surprising act during the brawl that made footy history

37 minutes ago

New rules for bringing dogs into U.S. could affect thousands, Canadian truckers say

37 minutes ago

National Hot Dog Day: going full cylinder in Calgary

37 minutes ago

Chicago's Millennium Park marks 20th anniversary

37 minutes ago

First Horizon CEO talks regional bank competition after earnings miss

37 minutes ago

Former CIA official charged with being secret agent for South Korean intelligence

37 minutes ago

Sofia Vergara, Robert Downey Jr., Lily Gladstone and more react to their 2024 Emmy nominations

37 minutes ago

MLB All-Star Game viewers up 6% to 7.44 million after falling to record low last year

37 minutes ago

In pivotal Year 3, Florida's Napier leaning on QB Mertz

37 minutes ago

California's ban on LGBTQ parental notification policies faces legal challenge

37 minutes ago

Pitch perfect: roar of UK jets takes to Aussie skies

37 minutes ago

President Joe Biden tests positive for COVID

37 minutes ago

‘Superman' Is "Close" to Being Done Filming, James Gunn Says

37 minutes ago

As Biden proposes overhaul of Supreme Court, how did we get here?

37 minutes ago

Paul George says rapper’s comments regarding finances helped him decide to move on from the LA Clippers

37 minutes ago

Who is buying 55,000 Liontown shares this week?

37 minutes ago

WA Labor multicultural group in revolt over treatment of Fatima Payman

37 minutes ago

Scarlett Johansson Says ‘I Don't Hold a Grudge' Against Disney After ‘Black Widow' Legal Battle, Thinks OpenAI CEO Could Be a Marvel Villain: ‘Maybe With a Robotic Arm'

37 minutes ago

Kohl's Gets More ‘Dressed Up' by Expanding Offering

37 minutes ago

Despite back-to-back championships, Chiefs are coming into training camp hungry

37 minutes ago

Dolphins' Pangai back to Penrith with debt of gratitude

37 minutes ago

2 No-Brainer Stocks to Buy Now With $7,000

37 minutes ago

Bill Belichick won't allow media roles to derail coaching plans

ALONGWALKER VIETNAM: Kênh khám phá trải nghiệm của giới trẻ, thế giới du lịch ALONGWALKER INDONESIA: Saluran untuk mengeksplorasi pengalaman para pemuda global