Swiss parliament snubs European court climate ruling

swiss parliament snubs european court climate ruling

FILE PHOTO: Supporters and members of the association Senior Women for Climate Protection hold banners as they arrive for the ruling in the climate case Verein KlimaSeniorinnen Schweiz and Others v. Switzerland, at the European Court of Human Rights (ECHR) in Strasbourg, France, April 9, 2024. The slogan reads "Climate justice". REUTERS/Christian Hartmann/File Photo

By Emma Farge

BERN (Reuters) -The lower house of the Swiss parliament voted on Wednesday to reject a ruling ordering Switzerland to do more to combat global warming in a move that could encourage others to resist the influence of international courts.

In April, the European Court of Human Rights (ECHR) in Strasbourg issued an unprecedented judgment that said Bern had violated the human rights of a group of older Swiss women, the KlimaSeniorinnen, by failing to tackle climate change.

swiss parliament snubs european court climate ruling

FILE PHOTO: The building of the European Court of Human Rights is seen ahead of the start of a hearing in Strasbourg, France, September 11, 2019. REUTERS/Vincent Kessler/File Photo

But Bern's lower house on Wednesday followed in the steps of the upper house and passed a non-binding motion with 111 votes in favour and 72 against blasting the court's "judicial activism". It argued there was no reason to take further action because Switzerland was already doing enough.

swiss parliament snubs european court climate ruling

FILE PHOTO: Supporters of the Senior Women for Climate Protection association hold paper flowers and a banner outside the European Court of Human Rights in Strasbourg, France March 29, 2023. REUTERS/Emma Farge/File Photo

During the debate, lawmakers denounced the court's "interference" in Swiss democracy and one called the Strasbourg ruling "erroneous" as several older women who brought the case to Strasbourg looked on.

One of the MPs from the right-wing Swiss People's Party (SVP)People's Party (SVP) which is the biggest party in parliament, appeared to mock the women, criticising them for bringing a case "because they are a bit too hot in the summer".

swiss parliament snubs european court climate ruling

FILE PHOTO: A female supporter smiles while holding a banner in support of the Senior Women for Climate Protection in front of the European Court of Human Rights in Strasbourg, France March 29, 2023. REUTERS/Emma Farge/File Photo

He was referring to the women's argument that the government's inadequate efforts to combat climate change put them at risk of dying during heatwaves.

"It's really disgraceful what just happened," Stefanie Brander, 68, told Reuters after the vote, her voice shaking with anger. "It's an insult and a lack of respect of our rights which were confirmed by an international court."

Outside parliament, a small group of climate protesters sat held up signs saying "betrayed" "shocked" and "alarmed".

While the governing Federal Council is free to break with parliament, the environment minister, one of its members, has also appeared to play down the ruling.

Isabela Keuschnigg, legal researcher with the London School of Economics, said that if the government refused to implement the ruling, it could "set a concerning precedent, undermining the role of legal oversight in democratic governance".

Such an act, if formalised, would be unprecedented in the Council of Europe.

But it would also be evidence of political pushback against international climate action, especially after broad far-right gains in this month's European parliament election.

The case is part of a raft of climate litigation moving through world courts. Latin America's human rights court is set to issue an advisory opinion later this year after staging hearings across the region.

(Reporting by Emma Farge in Geneva and Gloria Dickie in London; Editing by Angus MacSwan)

OTHER NEWS

2 hrs ago

White Sox designate struggling veteran catcher for assignment

2 hrs ago

When the Press Turns Its Back on Press Freedom

3 hrs ago

NFL refused to allow Caleb Williams tax moves

3 hrs ago

Two city parks lose prestigious green status

3 hrs ago

Steve Kerr, Steph Curry push gun control after Donald Trump shooting

3 hrs ago

Emmys 2024: List of Nominees

3 hrs ago

Three things to watch for in JD Vance's convention speech

3 hrs ago

Fox Sets Fall Premiere Dates for '9-1-1: Lone Star,' 'The Masked Singer'

3 hrs ago

‘The Bear' Sets New Comedy Series Record With 23 Emmy Nominations

3 hrs ago

ESPN Radio host says Browns fans are the best in all professional sports

3 hrs ago

'Twister' Director Jan de Bont on the Shot It Took Almost 30 Years to Finish

3 hrs ago

Why Red Bull can't afford failure with Ford-backed F1 engine plan

3 hrs ago

‘Successor,' Chinese Smash Hit Comedy Film, Sets Worldwide Release (EXCLUSIVE)

3 hrs ago

Don't be alarmed if Andrew Van Ginkel lands on the PUP list

3 hrs ago

HRD Corp has retracted letter of demand to The Edge, says HR minister

4 hrs ago

Thunder's recent growth helped lure impressive big man away from New York

4 hrs ago

Joel Embiid's struggles continue as Team USA dominates Nikola Jokic, Serbia

4 hrs ago

Making the case for Steve Cherundolo as USMNT boss

4 hrs ago

I've been a Trader Joe's superfan for 15 years—these 9 products are worth the hype (and money)

4 hrs ago

Confirmed: Snoopy Loves This Charlie Brown Thanksgiving-Inspired Chocolate Bark

4 hrs ago

UN chief slams Israel for dooming prospects for two-state solution

4 hrs ago

With the Playoffs on the Line, What Do the Red Sox Need to Succeed?

4 hrs ago

Frasier Sets Premiere Date for Season 2, Including a Return to Seattle

4 hrs ago

Dodgers' Shohei Ohtani, Teoscar Hernández bring the boom to All-Star Weekend

4 hrs ago

Giuliani spent on Florida condo, RNC trip instead of bankruptcy fees

5 hrs ago

New York storm topples B-52 bomber, tears roof off church

5 hrs ago

Synergy House gets UMA query as shares fall to lowest in three months, short-selling suspended

5 hrs ago

Hot Prime Day Deals: Grills from Coleman, Blackstone, and Weber Are Up to 45% Off at Amazon

5 hrs ago

'Eyesore' hotel that lay empty for decades demolished

5 hrs ago

Tiger Woods is back at the British Open, a championship where the unthinkable is sometimes in play

5 hrs ago

Cosmetic surgery provider collapses

5 hrs ago

Manchester City: Three Things to Look for as Pre-Season Kicks Off

5 hrs ago

Plea for Virgin to retake north Wales train services

5 hrs ago

Hearts 1-5 Tottenham: youngsters impressive as Spurs roll in Edinburgh

5 hrs ago

Golf best bets: 3 top props for the British Open

6 hrs ago

Smart Mulls Electric Fortwo Replacement But Won’t Make It Alone

6 hrs ago

British Open 2024: Why Patrick Cantlay may be a galaxy-brain pick at Royal Troon

6 hrs ago

Hong Kong journalist group head says she was fired by WSJ amid press freedom row

6 hrs ago

Chiefs season tickets 2024: Cheapest price, cost, seating map for every home game at Arrowhead Stadium in Kansas City

6 hrs ago

For Caleb Williams-driven Bears offense, this unit must be top-notch

ALONGWALKER VIETNAM: Kênh khám phá trải nghiệm của giới trẻ, thế giới du lịch ALONGWALKER INDONESIA: Saluran untuk mengeksplorasi pengalaman para pemuda global