Qantas workers unlawfully sacked during the Covid pandemic 'would have lost their jobs anyway', court told

READ MORE: Worrying tourism statistics that could cost Australia billions 

Qantas workers unlawfully retrenched as Covid-19 gripped Australia in 2020 would have lost their jobs anyway as the virulent delta strain reared its head a year later, a judge has heard.

The airline is being sued by the Transport Workers' Union in the Federal Court after laying off almost 1,700 ground staff in November 2020.

In July 2021, Justice Michael Lee found the move was designed to deprive workers of being able to bargain for a new enterprise agreement and, as such, contravened employment law.

Qantas workers unlawfully retrenched as Covid-19 gripped Australia in 2020 would have lost their jobs anyway as the virulent delta strain reared its head a year later, a judge has heard (file picture)

Qantas workers unlawfully retrenched as Covid-19 gripped Australia in 2020 would have lost their jobs anyway as the virulent delta strain reared its head a year later, a judge has heard (file picture)

Qantas and the union returned to court on Wednesday, when the judge heard further submissions about how much compensation should be paid to three workers who lost their jobs and were being used as test cases.

The airline previously argued the workers would have been retrenched anyway in November 2020 and should receive no payout.

There were other lawful reasons for outsourcing such as cutting company costs during the pandemic, it has said.

On Wednesday, Qantas barrister Michael Dalton SC argued if the 2020 outsourcing decision was never made, the company would have taken steps to make staff redundant in August 2021 as the delta strain further stifled domestic and international flying activity.

After an in-house tender process, workers would have eventually lost their jobs in February or March 2022, the court was told.

This situation mirrored the 'unusual concatenation of events' that Justice Lee found occurred in 2020 regarding Covid-19, lockdowns and border closures, Mr Dalton said.

'Are you effectively saying I should find that essentially a certainty?' Justice Lee asked.

'Close to it - we say it's very likely,' Mr Dalton replied.

In 2021, the airline had already stood down 10,000 employees, retrenched thousands more staff and sold its land-holding in the Sydney suburb of Mascot, the court was told.

'Everything was on the table at that time,' Mr Dalton said.

Justice Lee said everything he had seen in the case showed a company focused on cutting costs as quickly as possible in a catastrophic set of circumstances.

'Qantas was intent on doing everything it could to save as much money as it could in this process, irrespective of how it affected the employees,' he said.

Qantas is being sued by the Transport Workers' Union in the Federal Court after laying off almost 1,700 ground staff in November 2020 (file picture)

Qantas is being sued by the Transport Workers' Union in the Federal Court after laying off almost 1,700 ground staff in November 2020 (file picture)

Representing the TWU, barrister Philip Boncardo rejected arguments that Qantas would have considered outsourcing in August 2021.

At that time, and over the next few months, the airline had announced it was expecting borders to open after the vaccine roll-out and hoped flight activity would fully take off by early 2022, Mr Boncardo said.

However, Justice Lee pointed out that these positive announcements were made when the airline had pocketed $100 million from unlawfully retrenching employees in November 2020.

Mr Boncardo also argued Qantas' decision-making was infected in 2020 and there was no evidence to show its executive would have acted lawfully the following year.

In determining compensation, the judge will have to consider factors such as whether employees sought other work, what social security payments they received and whether jobs they took up paid more than their salary at Qantas.

Once the judge makes findings for the three test-case employees, it is hoped the union and airline can work out how much compensation is owed to all retrenched staff.

The TWU is also seeking penalties against Qantas, although these will be determined at a later date.

In December 2021, Justice Lee rejected a bid by the union to have the workers reinstated at Qantas after finding that proposal was impractical.

The judge's findings that the terminations were unlawful were unsuccessfully appealed by Qantas in both the Full Court and the High Court.

The hearing continues on Thursday.

OTHER NEWS

8 minutes ago

Quebec hospital uses virtual reality to help with nurse shortage

10 minutes ago

It's a cathedral of football in the streets of Cologne as On The Road's HUGH MACDONALD catches up with Tartan Army for the latest instalment of his Euro 2024 diary

10 minutes ago

“Bridgerton” Producer Denies Rumors of Season 3 Deleted Scenes Involving Colin and Penelope: They 'Don't Exist'

10 minutes ago

Blue Jackets’ Waddell open to moving fourth overall pick in right deal

10 minutes ago

Yen could be 'bullish' for the second half of the year, FAB says

10 minutes ago

Hull KR edge Castleford after late Litten drop-goal

10 minutes ago

Turkey to impose tariffs on all Chinese cars

12 minutes ago

‘Strawberry moon' will bring another rare sight to the sky this week. When to see it

13 minutes ago

Justin Timberlake has no rehab plans after DWI bust, apologizes to tour crew: reports

13 minutes ago

Ryan Garcia punishment revealed as troubled boxer 'settles doping scandal' after failed tests from Devin Haney win

15 minutes ago

Grey's Anatomy Season 20 Confirms Netflix US Release Date

15 minutes ago

An airline startup that hopes to fly Airbus A380s between New York and London is delaying its launch to 2025

15 minutes ago

David Robinson on Tim Duncan being similar to Michael Jordan: “Tim is every bit the assassin that Michael was”

15 minutes ago

The US can cut rates if inflation stays around 2%: Austan Goolsbee

15 minutes ago

"Yall dug this hole, then get out of it" - The Phil Jackson tactic Lue used with LeBron and the Cavaliers

15 minutes ago

Doug Christie on playing with Jason Williams: "Jason is Houdini with the ball, and that rubs off on everybody else in the locker room"

15 minutes ago

Lakers agree to deal making J.J. Redick their next head coach

16 minutes ago

Euro 2024 day seven: England fail to impress as Spain seal last-16 spot

16 minutes ago

UH removes Chris Pezman as athletics director

18 minutes ago

Jessica Alba 'spent months preparing for Trigger Warning'

18 minutes ago

Selflessness is key to happiness, says Tom Brady

18 minutes ago

Rob Lowe hails Donald Sutherland as 'one of our greatest actors'

18 minutes ago

Yankees' Top Prospect Suffers Yet Another Injury

18 minutes ago

Syracuse Football: 2024 Orange Season Preview and Prediction

18 minutes ago

He Loves His Bugatti So Much, He Parks It In the Living Room of His $10.999 Million Las Vegas Home

18 minutes ago

I'd love to star on The Traitors, says Lala Kent

18 minutes ago

Who Are Donald Sutherland's Five Kids? Everything to Know

18 minutes ago

Canada takes on South America's best at the Copa America

18 minutes ago

Atletico Madrid ‘target Chelsea striker’ after rejecting bid for key frontman

18 minutes ago

Trump Media Stock Tumbles as SEC Decision Could Flood Market With New Shares

18 minutes ago

‘It still hasn’t sunk in’: B.C. woman wins $1.2 million

20 minutes ago

Stock futures are little changed after S&P 500 briefly tops 5,500: Live updates

22 minutes ago

Extremely wet spring causes boom in mosquito population

22 minutes ago

Big check for housing in Fort Worth's Stop Six neighborhood

22 minutes ago

A German town's referendum on culling pigeons has led to an uproar by animal rights activists

22 minutes ago

Sunak ‘extremely angry’ over gambling scandal but refuses to suspend candidates involved

22 minutes ago

Half of America desperately needs a Fed rate cut right now: Charles Payne

22 minutes ago

Late leveler by Serbia denies Slovenia first Euros win

22 minutes ago

Brian Windhorst Has Stern Reality Check For Mark Cuban After Mavericks Lose In Finals

22 minutes ago

Prince William pays England stars personal visit in dressing room after Denmark display