Move to faster stock settlement creates unique hurdles for ETF market

The new T+1 settlement rules may wreak havoc on ETF trading...for now

[video_shortcode_video_embed src="https://video.foxbusiness.com/v/video-embed.html?video_id=6353818234112&d=video.foxbusiness.com" itemprop="image" content="https://video.foxbusiness.com/v/video-embed.html?video_id=6353818234112&d=video.foxbusiness.com" data-src="https://video.foxbusiness.com/v/video-embed.html?video_id=6353818234112&d=video.foxbusiness.com"]

Fed's first rate cut may disrupt the stock market rally: Jason Katz

UBS managing director and senior portfolio manager Jason Katz explains why the Fed's first interest rate cut will be negative for stocks on 'Varney & Co.'

The move to next-day settlement for trading in U.S. securities on Tuesday will require exchange-traded funds (ETFs) and the marketmakers to juggle multiple jurisdictional requirements and capital needs, market participants said.

U.S. trading moves to a shorter settlement on Tuesday, which regulators hope will reduce risk and improve efficiency in the world's largest markets, but is expected to temporarily increase transaction failure for investors.

Ticker Security Last Change Change %
I:DJI DOW JONES AVERAGES 38803.12 -266.47 -0.68%
SP500 S&P 500 5302.68 -2.04 -0.04%
I:COMP NASDAQ COMPOSITE INDEX 17013.085367 +92.29 +0.55%

The biggest headache that many ETF issuers and their service providers face is what happens when there's a "mismatch" between when trades of the ETF wrapper -- the fund itself -- settle, and the settlement schedule for the ETF's holdings traded outside of the United States.

A U.S.-listed ETF will be subject to the new "T+1" settlement rules but not all of the constituents of that fund face the same parameters. Meanwhile, European ETF issuers will have to wait for two days for buyers of their products to pay but they will have only a single day to pay for new orders of any ETF components that trade in the United States.

WARREN BUFFETT'S FAVORITE ETFS

The primary impact will be felt by asset managers whose funds include European holdings, since China and India already have accelerated their settlement periods and Canada, Mexico and Argentina also made the switch this week, said John Hooson, managing director of ETF services at BBH.

SPDR S&P 500 ETF Trust

"The majority of ETF issuers are dealing with this in some way shape or form."

Such dislocations, he added, "will have to be solved with an authorized provider posting additional collateral."

move to faster stock settlement creates unique hurdles for etf market

Trader works on the trading floor at the New York Stock Exchange (NYSE) in New York City, Dec. 14, 2022.  (Reuters/Andrew Kelly / Reuters Photos)

Authorized providers, the marketmakers who respond to ETF orders by purchasing or selling baskets of shares, will have to find ways to continue creating those ETF baskets in a timely and cost-efficient manner, or see their cost of capital and need for short-term liquidity increase.

RETIREMENT ACCOUNT BALANCES HIT HIGHEST SINCE 2021

Time zone differences may stress the settlement process still further, said Todd Rosenbluth, head of ETF research at VettaFi.

"That may lead to wider bid/asked spreads and reduced liquidity as people try to address all these mismatches," Rosenbluth said. He added he expects this to be a short term challenge that "will work its way through the markets over a few weeks."

Ticker Security Last Change Change %
STT STATE STREET CORP. 75.39 +0.58 +0.78%
BK THE BANK OF NEW YORK MELLON CORP. 59.09 +0.76 +1.30%
BLK BLACKROCK INC. 781.90 -2.65 -0.34%

Robert Humbert, global head of ETF product at BNY Mellon, one of the largest custodians and asset servicing firms, said that about 30% of the order volume his company oversees already settles on a T+1 basis, and expects that to bump up to 70% when the SEC-mandated rule change kicks in on Tuesday.

"Certainly, mismatching could be an issue for some but the flip side is that T+1 ultimately is a more capital-efficient process," Humbert said. Market participants "will only need to hold capital for one day, not two."

Both Hooson and Humbert point to another area where ETF market participants will need to adjust. Currently, marketmakers manage their own inventories on a T+1 basis, in order to create or redeem new ETF baskets on the old T+2 settlement cycle. The change means those liquidity providers will now have to shift to T+0.

Humbert, however, argues that the industry is prepared.

"We've spent the last 12 months working with ETF issuers and their authorized participants to iron out problems," he said.

Rosenbluth agrees, noting that asset management firms "tend to be very good at getting ahead of known and anticipated events."

(Reporting by Suzanne McGee; editing by Megan Davies and Chizu Nomiyama)

OTHER NEWS

23 minutes ago

Video: Travel hell at Manchester Airport after 'two-hour' power cut sparks chaos - with passengers left in the dark and stuck in huge queues with fears of mass flight delays

31 minutes ago

25-year-old pays $1,472/month for a live-work space in the ‘first car-free neighborhood in the US'—take a look inside

34 minutes ago

Cameron Norrie has slumped badly this year but as Wimbledon approaches the former British No 1 insists he will be a 'tough draw for anyone'

34 minutes ago

'Baroness Bra' Michelle Mone 'hires celebrity bodyguard' after receiving torrents of abuse and 'acid attack threat' amid investigation into her role in the Covid PPE scandal

34 minutes ago

Video: King Charles set to drop Fiji leg of autumn tour to Oceania as medical team order him to pace himself as he continues his cancer recovery

36 minutes ago

Chelsea must rue selling superstar whos just as influential as Palmer

36 minutes ago

Can Deadpool save the Marvel Cinematic Universe?

36 minutes ago

Sean Penn recalls SWAT team raiding home during Madonna marriage

42 minutes ago

What are Teddy Sheringham's picks for Euro 2024? The England legend caught up with Sky Bet this week and gave a run-down on the teams and players he thinks will star in Germany

42 minutes ago

David Beckham 'keen to lure Raphael Varane to Inter Miami after defender's Man United exit' as he looks to add to squad of superstars including Lionel Messi and Luis Suarez

43 minutes ago

Health warning to UK as temperatures soar to 30C within DAYS

43 minutes ago

Restricted dog breeds should be banned in Ireland, says leading plastic surgeon

44 minutes ago

Barry Keoghan set to model his favourite football team's new kit

44 minutes ago

With 10 parties signed up for GNU, the ANC says first phase for parties to join now concluded

44 minutes ago

Ramaphosa at helm of battered ship in troubled waters

44 minutes ago

2FM's Aifric O'Connell moonlighting with ex-colleagues The 2 Johnnies on podcast

44 minutes ago

Al Salam Bank Unveils Exclusive Financing Offer for Tas’heel and Enhanced Mazaya Schemes Beneficiaries Facilitating Homeownership in Deerat Al Oyoun, and Danat Al Lawzi Projects

44 minutes ago

Rookie Jackson Merrill hits a 440-foot, 3-run homer in the Padres' 6-4 win over the Brewers

44 minutes ago

I helped save 13 football players from a cave, but life still goes on as normal

44 minutes ago

Portugal coach bemoans risk to player safety as pitch invaders chase Cristiano Ronaldo selfies

47 minutes ago

‘Technologies have improved’: Price of renewables cheaper than originally forecast

47 minutes ago

If I’d invested £100 when the Lloyds share price crashed 15 years ago, here’s what I’d have now

47 minutes ago

‘Strange message’ from Valtteri Bottas could end F1 career, claims Ted Kravitz

47 minutes ago

COMMENT: Is Nasreddine Nabi’s ‘helicopter football’ the right fit for Kaizer Chiefs?

47 minutes ago

The Black neighborhood home appraisal gap is real. Can we close it?

47 minutes ago

What Prince William told dejected England players at Euro 2024

47 minutes ago

The schools debate is asking all the wrong questions

50 minutes ago

Galvin finishes stunning long-range try

50 minutes ago

2024 Logie Award nominations: Tony Armstrong, Robert Irwin and Andy Lee among the top nods

50 minutes ago

Wes Foderingham Set for West Ham Medical As Agreement Reached

50 minutes ago

Hardik Pandya buries IPL hate, converts boos into monstrous batting pyrotechnics en route to rediscovering his mojo

50 minutes ago

Arne Slot told what he must do to avoid Liverpool sack talk as dazzling first signing goes up in flames

52 minutes ago

Westfield Marion: Major police operation unfolding at Adelaide shopping centre

55 minutes ago

Sonia Kruger shows off her sensational figure as she attends TV Week Logie Awards nominations in Sydney

56 minutes ago

What to know about Eddie Murphy and his 10 kids

56 minutes ago

Jay Slater: What is the official GoFundMe page for missing teenager and how will the money be spent?

56 minutes ago

‘Members see him as the Messiah’: How Farage could take over the Tories

56 minutes ago

The Legend Of Zelda Games, In Chronological Order

56 minutes ago

NetApp CEO: We protect most of the world’s important data

56 minutes ago

MultiVersus Character Guide: Jason Voorhees