Landmark ConCourt ruling on right to fair procedure during retrenchments

landmark concourt ruling on right to fair procedure during retrenchments

Image source: Mohd Khairil –

In a pivotal legal decision, the Constitutional Court has upheld key principles of fairness in employment law, ruling on applications for leave to appeal and cross-appeal against orders of the Labour Appeal Court (LAC), which had been hearing an appeal from the Labour Court (LC). This judgment sets a precedent for future cases involving procedural fairness and highlights the importance of fair procedures in employment disputes.

Image source: Mohd Khairil – 123RF.com

Regenesys Management, a business school providing advanced business education in South Africa and beyond, faced a legal challenge from former employees who were retrenched in 2015. The retrenchments led to the employees filing for reinstatement and procedural fairness under sections 191(5)(b)(ii) and 189A(13) of the LRA.

The Labour Court (LC) consolidated the employees’ applications and found the dismissals both substantively (for some) and procedurally unfair (for all), ordering their retrospective reinstatement. It was either common cause or undisputed that Regenesys had not followed a fair procedure.

Appeal

Regenesys appealed to the LAC, and challenged the conclusions reached by the Labour Court that the dismissals of certain specified employees were substantively unfair and that it had jurisdiction to determine whether the dismissals of the employees were procedurally unfair.

The LAC upheld the substantive unfairness of the dismissals but ruled that the LC lacked jurisdiction to adjudicate procedural fairness due to section 189A(18) of the LRA. However, in respect of substantive fairness, the LAC found no basis to overturn the LC’s decision.

ConCourt

Regenesys applied to the Constitutional Court for leave to appeal against the LAC’s judgment, which upheld the LC's conclusions of substantive unfairness and ordered reinstatement and compensation. The cross-appeal applicants sought to challenge the LAC's ruling that the LC had no jurisdiction to determine procedural fairness.

The Constitutional Court granted leave to appeal and cross-appeal, affirming its jurisdiction and setting aside the LAC’s decision that the LC lacked jurisdiction in procedural fairness disputes.

A key aspect of the judgment dealt with the jurisdiction of the LC to determine the procedural fairness of a dismissal in terms of large scale retrenchments.

The Court traversed the historical case law that led to the law developing in a way that read section 189A(13) and section 189(18) to mean that the Labour Court did not have jurisdiction to determine procedural fairness in retrenchments outside of remedies designed to bring the retrenchment process back on track as specified in terms of section 189A(13).

The Court then went on to do an in depth analysis of the abovementioned sections and in arriving at its judgment, interpreted the limitation in section 189A(18) – which states that the Labour Court has no jurisdiction to adjudicate a dispute about the procedural fairness of a dismissal for operational requirements to which section 189A applies - as indicative of the special procedure and special remedies set out in section 189A(13).

The matter reaffirms employee’s rights to claim compensation for procedural unfairness during retrenchment processes and no doubt has a significant impact on retrenchment and the law associated therewith.

Grant Wilkinson, director of Kirchmanns Inc, share some key takeaways from the Constitutional Court judgment.

- Retrospective reinstatement: The Constitutional Court upheld the LC’s decision to order retrospective reinstatement of the unfairly dismissed employees. This ruling confirms that employees subjected to procedural irregularities in retrenchment processes can be reinstated to their previous positions with backdated effect.

- Emphasis on fair procedures: The judgment underscores the necessity for employers to adhere strictly to fair procedures during retrenchments. This includes proper consultation processes, adequate notice, and meaningful engagement with affected employees. Employers failing to meet these standards risk procedural unfairness claims.

- Compensation for unfair dismissals: The decision also highlights that employees who suffer procedural unfairness are entitled to compensation, highlighting that employees should not be left without recourse when their rights are violated.

- Jurisdiction clarified: The judgment clearly deals with the balancing of s189A(18) and (13) and sets a precedent for future retrenchment proceedings as well as remedies should there be non-compliance.

According to Wilkinson: "The judgment sets a precedent for future cases involving procedural fairness and highlights the importance of fair procedures in employment disputes."

Provided by SyndiGate Media Inc. (Syndigate.info).

OTHER NEWS

21 minutes ago

Fortnite's Impressive Crossovers May Not Even Be Its Biggest Strength

21 minutes ago

Florida Insurance Company Sets Stage for Another Rate Hike

21 minutes ago

Soccer-Tired Italy outclassed by superior Spain - Spalletti

21 minutes ago

Adnams chairman to step down as brewer makes headway securing financial backing

21 minutes ago

How to get a head start on Ascot Ladies' Day: Race-goers bring out the pageantry - and sunshine - with My Little Pony and owl-themed outfits

21 minutes ago

DAILY MAIL COMMENT: Do the courts now run this country?

21 minutes ago

Heart muscle can undergo Dr Who-style regeneration thanks to shockwave therapy, study finds blood pumped by heart increased by 11 per cent after treatment

21 minutes ago

Furious star brands Australians 'lazy pieces of s**t' and says the country is 'breeding a weaker race' in stunning rant on live radio

25 minutes ago

Kyle Chalmer announces engagement to fellow swimmer Ingeborg Loyning

28 minutes ago

Trump proposes green cards for foreign grads of US colleges, departing from anti-immigrant rhetoric

28 minutes ago

The stock market is showing cracks and the trading environment is murkier

28 minutes ago

Should the Toronto Maple Leafs Use Their First-Rounder In a Package for a Strong Goalie?

28 minutes ago

Kendrick Perkins Says Anthony Davis Could Request A Trade From The Lakers Next Season

28 minutes ago

Does Marquise Brown Have 'Golden Opportunity' With Chiefs?

28 minutes ago

Donald Sutherland Lost Out on Millions for Not Accepting “Animal House” Backend Offer

28 minutes ago

Mock Draft Has Spurs Go All-In on Backcourt

28 minutes ago

Scotland youth international edges closer to Manchester United move

28 minutes ago

“Kaizer Chiefs need to sign 11 new starting players”

28 minutes ago

Bills Rookie Gets Helping Hand from Teammates - VIDEO

28 minutes ago

Amanda Balionis makes PGA Tour return as Rory McIlroy takes golf break

28 minutes ago

14 adorable puppies rescued from rollover crash in Connecticut

28 minutes ago

The dream of homeownership is fading — here’s how to navigate the market

28 minutes ago

Video: Eminem hit 'Without Me' rises up the charts as Nigel Farage makes it the theme tune of his election campaign... but Reform UK leader gets the song title wrong and suggests he doesn't know who the rapper is during rally

32 minutes ago

Orioles rout Yankees 17-5, set MLB record with series win

33 minutes ago

Como leaders, Fort Worth police partnering to launch new safety effort around Comofest

33 minutes ago

Japan markets climb after inflation data release; other Asia markets sink

34 minutes ago

Older voters want candidates who will protect Social Security, poll finds. Yet parties are tied for their support.

34 minutes ago

For some women, hormone therapy isn't an option. Are menopause supplements any better?

34 minutes ago

Coquihalla Canyon Park, Othello Tunnels set to reopen 2.5 years after flood

34 minutes ago

Oshkosh CEO talks electrifying USPS fleet

34 minutes ago

Coming off injury, Broncos CB is 'firmly in mix' to start

34 minutes ago

Pilbara Minerals shares drop on major P2000 lithium expansion news

34 minutes ago

BRE Stock: Should You Buy the 10.5% Yield?

34 minutes ago

Dutton defends lack of detail in nuclear plan

34 minutes ago

Concreter marks Latrell in Blues training

34 minutes ago

Country Star Mark Chesnutt Cancels Shows Following Emergency Quadruple Bypass Surgery

43 minutes ago

Alvin Bragg gets more than 100 threats in the three weeks after Trump’s conviction - more than all of 2023

43 minutes ago

US bans Russia's Kaspersky software over national security concerns

43 minutes ago

Hidden Mechanics In Fortnite's Battle Royale

43 minutes ago

Masked Mbappe trains for Netherlands match, coach optimistic he’ll play