Democrats demand Alito recuse himself from Trump, Jan 6 cases, citing impartiality concerns over flag scandal

Senate Democrats are demanding that Supreme Court Justice Samuel Alito recuse himself from certain cases and have called for a meeting with Chief Justice John Roberts to discuss ethics in the court after news broke that Mr Alito had flown flags used by Capitol riot participants.

Senators Sheldon Whitehouse and Senate Judiciary Committee Chair Dick Durbin requested a meeting with Mr Roberts to discuss their concerns about Mr Alito’s impartiality, CBS News reports.

Reports in The New York Times and other outlets revealed that Mr Alito had previously flown an "Appeal to Heaven" flag outside his New Jersey vacation home in the summer of 2023.

In 2021, shortly after Joe Biden took office, Mr Alito flew an upside down American flag at his home in Virginia. Under US flag code, a flag is never to be flown inverted “except as a signal of dire distress in instance of extreme danger to life or property.”

Both inverted American flags and "Appeal to Heaven" flags were carried by individuals participating in the January 6 attack on the US Capitol in 2021.

democrats demand alito recuse himself from trump, jan 6 cases, citing impartiality concerns over flag scandal

People carry an

The "Appeal to Heaven" flag is a Revolutionary War-era standard that some conservatives have co-opted to express their belief that the 2020 election was stolen from Donald Trump.

Mr Durbin and Mr Whitehouse sent the chief justice a letter on Friday asking him to push Mr Alito to recuse himself from cases involving the 2020 presidential election and the Capitol riot.

“By displaying the upside-down and ‘Appeal to Heaven’ flags outside his homes, Justice Alito actively engaged in political activity, failed to avoid the appearance of impropriety, and failed to act in a manner that promotes public confidence in the impartiality of the judiciary,” they said in their letter. “His recusal in these matters is both necessary and required.”

Two such cases are pending: Mr Trump's claim of presidential immunity, and whether or not it was appropriate for federal investigators to bring obstruction charges against all of the Capitol riot defendants.

Mr Alito has already participated in oral arguments in both cases. Regarding presidential immunity, Mr Alito made the bizarre argument that immunity would protect US democracy by providing outgoing presidents reassurance that their political rivals would not have them arrested.

Mr Durbin and Mr Whitehouse called his recusal "necessary."

In addition to forcing Mr Alito to recuse himself in future rulings, the senators also called on the court to adopt an enforceable code of conduct to "address the Supreme Court's ethics crisis."

democrats demand alito recuse himself from trump, jan 6 cases, citing impartiality concerns over flag scandal

Supreme Court Justice Samuel Alito Jr., left, and his wife Martha-Ann Alito, pay their respects at the casket of Reverend Billy Graham at the Rotunda of the U.S. Capitol Building in Washington, Feb. 28, 2018 (Copyright 2018 The Associated Press. All rights reserved.)

"Until the court and the Judicial Conference take meaningful action to address this ongoing ethical crisis, we will continue our efforts to enact legislation to resolve this crisis," the letter said.

Mr Alito has denied flying the inverted American flag, and told the New York Times that his wife had hoisted the banner as part of an ongoing feud with a neighbor involving "objectionable and personally insulting language on yard signs."

The Supreme Court justice has not explained the "Appeal to Heaven" flag, but House Speaker Mike Johnson has him covered.

Mr Johnson brushed off the controversy, and told the Associated Press that he did not know the "Appeal to Heaven" flag was associated with Mr Trump's stolen election claims.

As Mr Johnson tells it, the flag is just a simple, wholesome reference to George Washington and the founding fathers.

democrats demand alito recuse himself from trump, jan 6 cases, citing impartiality concerns over flag scandal

An

“I have always used that flag for as long as I can remember, because I was so enamored with the fact that Washington used it,” Mr Johnson said. “The 'Appeal to Heaven' flag is a critical, important part of American history. It’s something that I’ve always revered since I’ve been a young man.”

He went on to say that "people misuse our symbols all the time, it doesn't mean we don't use the symbols anymore" and called people's objection to the flag "contrived."

“It’s nonsense,” he said. “It’s part of our history. We don’t remove statues and we don’t cover up things that are so essential to who we are as a country.”

Mr Johnson is wrong. The US does remove statues, change offensive location names, and stops using flags that no longer reflect the values of American citizens.

The Speaker's Democratic colleagues in the House were not sympathetic to his line of reasoning.

House Democratic Whip Katherine Clark of Massachusetts called Justice Alito’s flag use “not just another example of extremism that has overtaken conservatism."

"This is a threat to the rule of law and a serious breach of ethics, integrity and Justice Alito’s oath of office,” she told the Associated Press. She has also called for him to recuse himself from cases involving Mr Trump and January 6, 2021.

The Independent stands for many things, often uniquely so. It stands independent of political party allegiance, and makes its own mind up on the issues of the day. The Independent has always been committed to challenge and debate. It launched in 1986 to create a new voice and in that time has run campaigns for issues ranging from the legalisation of marijuana to the Final Say Brexit petition.

OTHER NEWS

37 minutes ago

‘We wouldn’t let animals die in misery. Why should humans?’: Susan Hampshire on why dying must be a choice

38 minutes ago

Severe weather forecast around US with high Southwest temperatures, Gulf rain and Rockies snow

38 minutes ago

FTSE 100 Live 17 June: Index seen higher, Japan's Nikkei 225 slides 2%

38 minutes ago

Father-Son Legacies Embodied by Belichicks, Patriots Football

38 minutes ago

Joe Mazzulla Speaks Ahead of Game 5 of NBA Finals

38 minutes ago

Heather Wells: American Airlines flight 1774 passenger who tried to open cabin door mid-flight being sued

38 minutes ago

2GB radio star Chris O’Keefe celebrates new $6.9m arthritis funding

38 minutes ago

Alarming video reveals dog attacks on posties

39 minutes ago

Scandal-hit private hospital group in financial crisis threatened to stop paying for food, drugs, agency staff

39 minutes ago

A new airport could spark the economy in a rural part of Florida. Will the workforce be ready?

39 minutes ago

The high cost of living is still biting the UK. Many don't think the election will change anything

41 minutes ago

Sister of missing woman Emily Janetzki and niece shares desperate plea for help as search continues almost two weeks on

41 minutes ago

Dress to impress! 10 Ascot-ready dresses for the perfect race day look - shop tailored, wrap and body sculpting dresses from just £49

41 minutes ago

Virgin Airlines engine catches alight forcing aircraft to make emergency landing at Invercargill Airport

41 minutes ago

Cricket-Pakistan's World Cup failure down to poor batting, Babar says

42 minutes ago

Safety Cars Ran Out of Fuel During the Four-Hour Weather Delay at Le Mans

42 minutes ago

Ian Wright slams 'anonymous' England star after nervy Euro 2024 opener

42 minutes ago

Best Character Redesigns In Fighting Games

42 minutes ago

Enhancement and manipulation of second- and third-harmonic generation based on all-dielectric nonlinear metasurfaces

42 minutes ago

'I didn't see that': Albanese questioned after Cheng Lei blocked by Chinese officials

42 minutes ago

Bowing out at Wimbledon or Olympics would be fitting, Murray says

45 minutes ago

Shoppers say this neck tightening cream makes their 'lines less visible' and it's finally back in stock after selling out: 'I saw a big improvement'

45 minutes ago

Ready to ditch the tampons? Shoppers are 'obsessed' with these stylish leak-proof period pants - and they suit all flows (here's how to get £10 off)

45 minutes ago

Video: Brisbane family horrified after making deadly discovery in their daughter's bed

45 minutes ago

Woman reveals her husband insists she covers up around the house if she's not interested in having sex with him - and people warn he needs to see a therapist

46 minutes ago

Celtic and Rodgers make 7m+ offer to sign new "hero" playing at Euro 2024

47 minutes ago

Steady demand for workers as recruiters place 1.7m job adverts

47 minutes ago

Manly eye debutants with 14 men out against Rabbitohs

47 minutes ago

Protests outside parliament as PM meets with Chinese premier

47 minutes ago

“House of the Dragon” season 2 comes with new opening titles sequence

47 minutes ago

Eid Al-Adha: HM the King Receives Congratulatory Message from Crown Prince of Bahrain

47 minutes ago

West Bengal: Goods Train Crashes Into Kanchenjunga Express, Many Injured

47 minutes ago

From recruiter, to the recruited: How late-blooming McCartin is turning the heads of AFL scouts

47 minutes ago

Politicians receive pay rise, with Prime Minister Anthony Albanese's salary jumping over $600,000

47 minutes ago

Royal family news: King Charles ramps up return as Kate and children send heartfelt message to William

47 minutes ago

German efficiency? Euro 2024 trains are a shambles - and fans are paying the price

48 minutes ago

Men’s Beach Outfits: 21 Surefire Ways to Dress for the Beach

48 minutes ago

National Party leader David Littleproud promises to scrap NSW offshore wind zones in Labor heartland

48 minutes ago

Analysis-Global central banks recalibrate as the big policy easing of 2024 fizzles

48 minutes ago

Final rites of Haj: Pilgrims perform Tawaf as Muslims celebrate Eid Al Adha