Star Wars: Darth Vader Fans Are Still Divided By One Huge Debate

Movies Science Fiction Movies

star wars: darth vader fans are still divided by one huge debate
Static Media/Shutterstock

Redemption can be a tricky thing to pull off as a writer. For the arc to really work, the character in question typically goes pretty far down the path of darkness. That moment when they finally see the light and do the heroic deed is satisfying to watch, but it can also lead to more complicated questions. Did the redemptive act trump the crime? And what do we do with the characters now?

There is perhaps no more famous example of the cinematic redemption arc than the story of Darth Vader, who goes from Jedi hero to murderous Sith Lord throughout the Star Wars saga before finally saving the galaxy in his final moments when he turns on Emperor Palpatine. Anakin Skywalker turns back to the light, but does he actually redeem himself? It's a question that Star Wars fans have debated for decades, and we're no closer to reaching a consensus.

The fact is, Darth Vader is directly responsible for countless killings and indirectly responsible for far more. The pit of rage, hatred, and self-loathing he falls into after his loss on Mustafar consumes him and kicks off two decades of violence across the galaxy. While he turns away from the dark side before dying, saving his son and stopping Palpatine in the process, it's hard to argue that this single act actually wipes clean the years of brutal acts he committed.

How was Vader viewed after the fall of the Empire?

star wars: darth vader fans are still divided by one huge debate
Lucasfilm/Disney

One thing to remember regarding Darth Vader's would-be redemption is that most of the galaxy never knew that he was actually Anakin Skywalker, a famous hero from the Clone Wars. The fact of his parentage to Luke and Leia is also a well-kept secret for many years. In the canon novel "Star Wars: Bloodline" by Claudia Gray, these truths come out into the open, used as a political weapon against Leia in the burgeoning New Republic. The public learns the full nature of Vader and his children, and this information severely hinders Leia's political career.

This proves that most of the galaxy doesn't really care about what Vader did at the end of his life. The facts of his Imperial campaign are more important, and he's hardly redeemed in the people's eyes. Leia struggles to deal with the truth that Vader was her father, as her only memories of him include him capturing her, killing her crew, torturing her, and destroying Alderaan. Unlike Luke, she doesn't get to look into Anakin's eyes as the life drains from them. She doesn't get to see her father do one good deed before the end.

A different version of events plays out in "Star Wars Infinities: Return of the Jedi," a non-canon, alternate universe comic published between 2003 and 2004. In that story, Vader survives the ending of "Return of the Jedi" and recreates himself as an agent of the light, emerging in a striking all-white version of his iconic armor. While a fun what-if, it doesn't really make sense given all the evil he did for the Empire.

George Lucas had interesting thoughts on Darth Vader's redemption

star wars: darth vader fans are still divided by one huge debate
Jb Lacroix/Getty Images

On the matter of Darth Vader's redemption, there is perhaps no one better to ask than George Lucas. In J.W. Rinzler's 2005 book "The Making of Star Wars Revenge of the Sith," the Star Wars creator shared his perspective on what actually happens to Anakin in those final "Return of the Jedi" moments.

"It really has to do with learning," Lucas said. "Anakin can't be redeemed for all the pain and suffering he's caused. He doesn't right the wrongs, but he stops the horror." He added that while Vader isn't really redeemed by what he does, he does fulfill the prophecy. "Anakin was the Chosen One, and he does bring balance to the Force. He takes the ounce of good still left in him and destroys the Emperor out of compassion for his son."

Lucas' opinion on the matter is essentially canon, but even if it wasn't, this explanation makes sense. Redemption after so many years of violence and brutality isn't really an option for Vader, no matter how much good he does by saving Luke. It's also true that Anakin really only does what he does to protect his son, not to save the whole galaxy. Is he happy just before he dies that the Empire will fall? Yes, but that isn't the main motivation for his turn. However, that simpler reading of Vader has been complicated a bit by other Star Wars stories.

Anakin Skywalker's current Star Wars storyline complicates his legacy

star wars: darth vader fans are still divided by one huge debate
Lucasfilm/Disney+

Back when "Return of the Jedi" was the end of the mainline Star Wars story (sorry Expanded Universe), it was much easier to grapple with how Anakin Skywalker's story concludes. However, in the years since Disney acquired Lucasfilm and the Star Wars license, the character's legacy has gotten increasingly more complicated. He doesn't appear in the sequel trilogy except as one of the Jedi voices who speak to Rey at the end of "The Rise of Skywalker." He never steps in as a Force ghost to correct his grandson, Kylo Ren, and tell him that actually, maybe you shouldn't be worshiping that burnt Darth Vader helmet after all.

For years, that didn't seem weird. But then "Ahsoka" Season 1 came out, bringing with it a deluge of Anakin fan service. It's exciting to see him back and interacting with his former Padawan, both in the World Between Worlds and as a Force ghost watching over her on Peridea. Still, it's a bit strange that he'd get involved with her and not have anything to do with the sequel trilogy. Some of this can be explained away by the ambiguous nature of the World Between Worlds (Is it really him? Or is it Ahsoka's imagination?), but no matter how much fun it is to see Hayden Christensen in action, these cameos have made Vader's redemptive legacy more complicated.

To be fair, though, that all really started in "Return of the Jedi." Anakin appearing to Luke as a Force ghost at all confirms that he became one with the Force in the end — something that suggests a cosmic redemption if not a moral one. Even under Lucas, the question of Anakin's redemption was never fully clear.

OTHER NEWS

23 minutes ago

Doctor Who, finale review: Ncuti finds his oomph at last, but Russell T Davies has work to do

23 minutes ago

Robinsons and J20 maker Britvic rejects £3.1bn takeover bid from Carlsberg

23 minutes ago

Thompson into Queens semi-final

23 minutes ago

South Africa continue unbeaten run in T20 World Cup with tense win over England

23 minutes ago

Blitzboks begin Olympic qualifying tournament with eight-try win over Mexico

23 minutes ago

'May they all come home': Son of Israeli Judoka Oren Smadga killed in Gaza after father's birthday

23 minutes ago

What new TAB boss Gillon McLachlan really said – straight from the horse’s mouth

23 minutes ago

Alex Trebek Will Be Honored With ‘Jeopardy!' Postal Stamps

23 minutes ago

Video: Royal Ascot best dressed! From Zara Tindall to Elizabeth Hurley, all the most fabulous frocks and fascinators

23 minutes ago

Video: How Kate Middleton's flair for photography gave the Royal Family some of their most heartwarming portraits - and they're a far cry from the formal pictures once released by King Charles and Princess Diana

26 minutes ago

US have lofty ambitions at Copa America but won't overlook Bolivia in opener

26 minutes ago

Lockheed Martin subsidiaries reach $70 million settlement for claims they overcharged Navy for parts

26 minutes ago

Lindsey Vonn goes sailing with Team USA and joins grinder Anna Weis on the winches

28 minutes ago

Gavin Newsom Scores Tax Win in California

28 minutes ago

Bucking bull owners spend months caring for and training their bovines but few of them ever reach the rodeo arena

28 minutes ago

Sunak is dubbed ‘poundshop Farage’ during bruising LBC radio call-in

28 minutes ago

How “The Bikeriders” compares to the true story of the Chicago motorcycle club it was based on

28 minutes ago

Farage: NATO expansion 'provoked' Ukraine war

28 minutes ago

Man stabbed to death in NYC subway station during evening rush: NYPD

28 minutes ago

Rob Burrow's tearful dad, Geoff, shares emotional memories of his son in touching tribute before Leeds Rhinos' game against Leigh - after rugby legend's death aged 41

28 minutes ago

Juventus 'could offer Italy star to Man United in part-exchange for Jadon Sancho or Mason Greenwood' after agreeing similar swap deal for Aston Villa midfielder Douglas Luiz

28 minutes ago

England's T20 World Cup semi-final hopes hang in the balance after agonising defeat by South Africa...with Jos Buttler's side needing victory over USA on Sunday for a chance of making the last four

32 minutes ago

Donna Langley Preaches The Power Of Optimism & Meeting Consumers Where They Really Are To Ken Ziffren & UCLA

34 minutes ago

PFA chief claims England 'need to protect' Jude Bellingham after revealing the shocking statistics behind the Real Madrid star's career... and insists player welfare needs to be considered for the 'quality' of the sport

34 minutes ago

How 'food wars' have broken out between rival Euros fans from Albanians snapping pasta in front of Italians to Austrians breaking French baguettes... and a VERY rude Danish tea bag chant

34 minutes ago

Video: Katy Perry flashes her taut midriff and teases pink thong as she previews new song - amid Ozempic speculation

34 minutes ago

Video: The hottest ticket in town! Taylor Swift kicks off London leg of Eras Tour at sold-out Wembley with boyfriend Travis Kelce, celebs and politicians in attendance... but were Prince William and his kids also secretly in the crowd?

34 minutes ago

Video: Beauty and the Geek star mercilessly mocked over his dance moves live on air: 'You looked like you were in a top-load washing machine'

34 minutes ago

Clip of Taylor Swift waving to Travis Kelce as he sings along to 'So High School' at Wembley Eras Tour show goes viral: 'He looked so happy'

35 minutes ago

Brazilian prodigy Endrick looks to make major tournament debut at Copa America

35 minutes ago

Chaos at suburban shopping centre in Melbourne’s north after a shot was fired

35 minutes ago

What Is Botulism? Mass Poisoning Reported in Russia

35 minutes ago

Trump camp scrutinizes Arizona delegates in move to prevent disruptions at convention

35 minutes ago

Car Dealers Grapple With Dayslong Software Outage After CDK Cyberattack

35 minutes ago

Trump classified docs hearing and USC student not charged in fatal stabbing: Morning Rundown

35 minutes ago

Trump Posts About Cassidy Hutchinson, Alyssa Farah Griffin, Brad Raffensperger in Likely Bond Violation

35 minutes ago

Noose tightens around neck of ‘racist’ DA MP

35 minutes ago

Bernard Parker is yet to make a decision on his future as Galaxy offers him a coaching position

36 minutes ago

Coyotes slam cancellation of June 27 Arizona land auction

39 minutes ago

Suspended NRL star Taylan May has HUGE win in court that will prevent the Panthers from sacking him - for now