Erik ten Hag facing the same humiliation as Louis van Gaal in latest Manchester United mess

The endgame of Louis van Gaal’s brief, benighted tenure at Manchester United bears the eeriest parallels to what Erik ten Hag is enduring now. Every alarm signal from 2016 − the ineffectual signings, the peevish press conferences, the constant search for excuses in the injury list − finds almost an exact replica eight years later.

In fact, the ordeals of these two Dutch managers are such mirror images that the duo could yet share the least enviable distinction of all, in finding themselves kicked out of Old Trafford straight after winning an FA Cup final.

Both men arrived on three-year contracts but became overwhelmed by systemic failure within two. Both could also be authors of their own downfall: Van Gaal contrived to make such world-class talents as Angel Di Maria, Radamel Falcao and Bastian Schweinsteiger look pedestrian, while Ten Hag has performed similar reverse alchemy with Casemiro, Jadon Sancho and Mason Mount.

For all Ten Hag’s bullishness in public, claiming to have held positive talks about the future with Jim Ratcliffe, we have heard it all before. Van Gaal was still insisting his job was safe just hours before he was fired.

His defenestration felt brutal. He had, after all, assured United of a place in the Europa League, a tournament they would win 12 months later under Jose Mourinho. Ten Hag has no such crutch in his humiliation, with United confronting, in the likelihood of defeat to Manchester City at Wembley, a campaign without European football for only the second time in 42 years.

The chief complaint against Van Gaal was that United were ossifying on his watch, finishing fourth, then fifth in the Premier League. But even this was preferable, surely, to the Ten Hag trajectory of third, then eighth.

Ratcliffe is now poised to make the most consequential decision of his 14-year spell as a sporting investor. Largely, he has avoided any casting as the hatchet man. His less popular moves at United, including the axing of traditional staff trips to the Cup final and the emails berating the state of the IT department, have been a case of tinkering around the edges of a sclerotic club. It is sacking Ten Hag that will define his stewardship.

He cannot tolerate 14 league defeats in a single campaign, a depth not plumbed since relegation half a century ago, as a mere bump in the road. He needs to stay true to his reputation for never settling for mediocrity.

All the indications are that Ten Hag is doomed irrespective of the outcome against City, with United understood to be sounding out Thomas Tuchel, Mauricio Pochettino, Kieran McKenna, Graham Potter and Thomas Frank as potential replacements. Only the Dutchman’s most myopic disciples could accuse them of acting in haste.

He has had two years to leave his imprimatur on this team, only to preside over a directionless rabble whose goal difference in this league campaign was minus-one, a staggering 63 adrift of both City and Arsenal.

That represents not an isolated lapse in form, but an unforgivable collapse in standards.

Even more alarmingly, Ten Hag appears oblivious to the degree of regression. He argued this week that United had been “very competitive” against City last October, a game they lost 3-0 at home. He declared they had been “very good” at the Etihad, too, somehow disregarding the three unanswered second-half goals.

​His diagnosis of United’s situation after the litany of recent horrors? “Very good things. Players coming up, values coming up.”

As for values, the image of Antony, his £85 million marquee signing, taunting Coventry City’s inconsolable players after United squeaked through to the final on penalties told its own story.

This is the fundamental problem with Ten Hag: he strives to sound defiant, but too often he comes across as plain delusional. He talks of continuing with his “project”, despite United turning in displays devoid of any coherent vision.

The stark truth is they are no closer to challenging City than when he took over. That is not just the product of an injury crisis in central defence but of the manager’s failure to communicate a clear philosophy.

He can bemoan the misfortunes and the ever-rotating centre-half partnerships all he likes, but none of it justifies the sheer scale of systems meltdown. United had two of their most vibrant young talents on the pitch against Crystal Palace earlier this month, in Kobbie Mainoo and Alejandro Garnacho, and still they folded 4-0.

They have a soft centre, a susceptibility to panic at the slightest setback. You saw it in the anxiety that engulfed them in the madcap finale to their 4-3 loss at Chelsea. You noticed it in the 17 points they dropped from winning positions.

Any notion of a victory, of a second trophy to decorate his time in charge, seems far-fetched. Ratcliffe would have justification in being ruthless, in thanking Ten Hag for his efforts while acknowledging that United are trapped in a funk that only change at the top can solve.

Get ahead of the day with the morning headlines at 7.30am and Fionnán Sheahan's exclusive take on the day's news every afternoon, with our free daily newsletter.

OTHER NEWS

16 minutes ago

Video: The Block's Eliza and Liberty are left stunned after their REAL ages are revealed on Tracy Grimshaw's Do You Want To Live Forever?

16 minutes ago

Video: Heidi Klum, 51, flaunts her sensational figure in lace lingerie as she shares behind the scenes clip from her latest sizzling shoot

16 minutes ago

When I walk, I feel like I am about to faint. Could it be caused by my medication? DR MARTIN SCURR replies

16 minutes ago

King Frederik of Denmark and twins Princess Josephine and Prince Vincent, 13, donned football tops to wish their country 'great luck' in the Euros

17 minutes ago

Scottish Labour manifesto will chart a path to 2026 elections, says Sarwar

17 minutes ago

Cyril Ramaphosa Re-Elected As South African President | IN18V | CNBC TV18

17 minutes ago

Goldman Sachs raises S&P 500 year-end target to 5,600

17 minutes ago

Kaizer Chiefs: Pitso, Benni and Amakhosi legend linked – UPDATE

17 minutes ago

Forecaster's verdict on if 38C European heatwave that killed two is coming to UK

17 minutes ago

Romania vs Ukraine lineups: Confirmed team news, predicted XIs, injury latest for Euro 2024 game

17 minutes ago

The Sims 4's Newest Feature Seems Inevitable for Project Rene

17 minutes ago

All the dragons in House of the Dragon

17 minutes ago

French right wing parties in turmoil ahead of early elections

17 minutes ago

Trump resurrects Biden's 'devastating' 1994 crime bill as he courts Black Detroit voters: ‘Super predators'

17 minutes ago

Mbappe warns over 'extremes' in France

17 minutes ago

Rachel McAdams stuns in sheer black gown at Tony Awards 2024

20 minutes ago

When the mask comes off, pro-Hamas demonstrators in the US are no longer anonymous

20 minutes ago

Germany Plans to Deport Afghan Refugees via Uzbekistan

20 minutes ago

Cody Gakpo impressive but Netherlands saved against Poland by ex-Man Utd loanee

20 minutes ago

Midtown Manhattan’s shelter-lined ‘8th Ave. Corridor’ plagued by open drug use: ‘strip of despair’

20 minutes ago

The astonishing stat that shows how painful Rory McIlroy's US Open collapse was... as Nick Faldo admits his capitulation will 'haunt him for the rest of his life'

20 minutes ago

I'm a flight attendant and here are the 5 things you should never wear on a plane to stay safe and comfortable

20 minutes ago

Video: Alexei Navalny's daughter, Dasha, celebrates graduating from Stanford alongside beaming mother Yulia

20 minutes ago

Video: Fresh Labour chaos over tax hikes as Jon Ashworth says party has 'ruled out' changes to council tax bands - despite Wes Streeting and Rachel Reeves repeatedly refusing to do so

20 minutes ago

Video: Instant karma for 'British' parkour runner as he damages UNESCO World Heritage Site building during roof-top jump when masonry gives way beneath him - sending him crashing to the ground

20 minutes ago

Video: Shocking moment pro-Palestinian protesters use hammers to break in to highly secure Kent weapons factory and damage equipment

20 minutes ago

Israel Adesanya confirms UFC return date... but did Dana White accidentally give the big secret away?

21 minutes ago

The Rest of Xbox Game Pass' 2024 Line-Up Is Betting Big on One Genre

22 minutes ago

Meghan Markle moves on from jam to dog biscuits as she teases latest American Riviera Orchard product

22 minutes ago

Jeremy Clarkson addresses shocking footage of police mowing down baby cow

22 minutes ago

Swiss swap training base after new turf dies

22 minutes ago

UK weather: Exact date maps turn dark red as 26C 'heatwave' sweeps across Britain

22 minutes ago

Scrapping two-child benefit cap would cost £3.4bn, says IFS

22 minutes ago

Yankees prospects: Yankees best Bombers in intra-org clash

22 minutes ago

Putin lays out ceasefire demands to Ukraine

22 minutes ago

Who won Tony Awards for 2024: full list of winners and nominees

22 minutes ago

Illawarra community ‘divided’ over proposed wind farm

25 minutes ago

Democrats launch summer spending blitz highlighting state legislative races

27 minutes ago

‘House Of David’ Biblical Drama At Amazon Adds Iraqi-American Actor Alexander Uloom

27 minutes ago

Are you handing over your personal data? Forgetting this action before selling a car could see you hand over your private details to strangers