Supreme Court Allows South Carolina’s GOP-Drawn Congressional Map, Rejecting Racial Discrimination Claim

supreme court allows south carolina’s gop-drawn congressional map, rejecting racial discrimination claim

WASHINGTON—A 6-3 Supreme Court approved a white-dominated congressional district enacted by South Carolina’s Republican-controlled legislature, overruling a lower court that found the map divided Charleston County into different districts to reduce Black voters’ political power.

Because white voters heavily favor Republicans in South Carolina, the decision is a boon to the GOP incumbent, Rep. Nancy Mace, and good news for her party’s fight to retain its narrow House majority in the November election.

Writing on Thursday for the court’s conservative majority, Justice Samuel Alito recalled the court’s 2019 decision finding no constitutional problem with gerrymanders drawn to benefit the party in power. And in places where race and party preference are closely linked—as in South Carolina, where Black voters favor Democrats by 90% or more—plaintiffs must produce extraordinary evidence of racial bias before a court could find mapmakers violated the Constitution’s equal-protection guarantee, he said.

“We start with a presumption that the legislature acted in good faith,” Alito wrote, crediting the state’s claim that it sought to draw district lines that fortified Republican control of six of South Carolina’s seven congressional districts without regard to voters’ race.

No direct evidence of racial bias was produced, and circumstantial evidence plaintiffs entered didn’t rule out the possibility that moving a disproportionate number of Black voters out of the district “was simply a side effect of the legislature’s partisan goal,” Alito wrote.

Chief Justice John Roberts and Justices Neil Gorsuch, Brett Kavanaugh and Amy Coney Barrett joined Alito in full. Justice Clarence Thomas joined most of the opinion but wrote separately to argue it didn’t go far enough to limit court oversight of redistricting.

In dissent, Justice Elena Kagan said the court had invited legislators “to use race as a proxy to achieve partisan ends,” allowing them even “to straight-up suppress the electoral influence of minority voters.”

She accused Alito of turning the legal standard “upside-down,” elevating the legislature’s claims over factual findings made by a special three-judge federal court after a nine-day trial involving some two dozen witnesses and hundreds of exhibits.

That the legislature’s goal was to help Republican political aims didn’t ameliorate racial discrimination in map-drawing, Kagan wrote. “One surefire way of making a South Carolina district more Republican is to make it less Black,” she wrote, joined by Justices Sonia Sotomayor and Ketanji Brown Jackson.

The South Carolina State Conference of the NAACP and an individual voter challenged the state’s electoral maps. Thursday’s decision threw out a January 2023 ruling from the three-judge court that said the state’s First Congressional District was a racial gerrymander. That court had found two other challenged districts were permissible.

South Carolina Senate President Thomas Alexander on Thursday said the map was meticulously crafted to comply with legal requirements. “The Supreme Court affirmed the hard work of South Carolina senators and the product they produced as constitutional,” he said.

President Biden was less enthusiastic.

“The Supreme Court’s decision today undermines the basic principle that voting practices should not discriminate on account of race and that is wrong,” Biden said.

The Roberts Court has been skeptical both of policies that take account of race and of judicial review of political redistricting. Those strands came together in a 5-4 decision from 2013, Shelby County v. Holder, that significantly reduced federal power to police election procedures and legislative maps in states or regions that historically discriminated against minority voters.

Then in 2019, the 5-4 decision in Rucho v. Common Cause put an end to claims that partisan gerrymanders violated the federal Constitution, leaving the issue to state law.

But the court has left open at least some pathways to challenge racial gerrymanders under the Voting Rights Act of 1965. Last year, a 5-4 vote upheld a lower court decision that Alabama violated the Voting Rights Act when it splintered a cohesive Black population into white-majority districts. Under a new court-ordered map, a second of Alabama’s seven congressional districts now has a Black majority.

And last week, the court issued an emergency order keeping in place, at least for the 2024 election, a Louisiana congressional map creating a second Black-majority district that a lower court had found the Voting Rights Act required.

But Thursday’s case, Alexander v. South Carolina State Conference of the NAACP, involved facts that didn’t amount to a Voting Rights Act violation. For that reason, plaintiffs filed suit under the 14th Amendment’s equal-protection clause, where the standards of proof, already more stringent, now are tougher still.

Voting in South Carolina is racially polarized; the state’s House delegation includes six white Republicans and, in the sole Black majority district, Black Democrat Jim Clyburn.

The First District, which covers much of the state’s coast, had been closely contested in recent years, with Mace ousting a Democratic incumbent by less than 1% of the vote in 2020. Following the 2020 census, when congressional districts were redrawn to equalize their population, the Republican-led legislature bolstered the GOP grip on District 1, and in 2022 Mace won re-election with 56% of the vote.

Write to Jess Bravin at [email protected]

OTHER NEWS

19 minutes ago

Medihelp reports strong growth, more younger members join

19 minutes ago

Never (really) too young to have a will

19 minutes ago

Exciting call for nominations for the 2024 AWIEF Awards

19 minutes ago

Blockchain vs Crypto

19 minutes ago

Texas A&M beats Florida 6-0 to make CWS finals for 1st time as Gators shut out 1st time in 2 years

19 minutes ago

Generative AI sent to the dock in RIAA ‘BBL Drizzy’ legal action

19 minutes ago

The Matric mandate: a barrier to employment for South African youth

19 minutes ago

One of 2024's biggest new anime series will be shown in cinemas – one month before its Netflix and Crunchyroll release

19 minutes ago

Money Show host Bruce Whitfield to leave Primedia

19 minutes ago

Great Wolf Lodge water park in Webster will open earlier than expected, according to website

19 minutes ago

Employers' role in health and wellness to promote employee well-being, by Medshield

19 minutes ago

How environmental toxins and pollution affect our health, by Medshield

19 minutes ago

LA broadcast TV legend Tom Van Amburg — who gave Regis Philbin his daytime start — dead at 83

19 minutes ago

Video: Shocking moment thugs armed with Rambo knives fight in the middle of the day on residential London street

19 minutes ago

Everything you need to know about changes coming July 1

19 minutes ago

Coalition slams Prime Minister for not expelling rogue Labor Senator Fatima Payman

19 minutes ago

Former Fremantle Dockers and Brisbane Lions star Lachie Neale and wife Julie Neale announce baby news

19 minutes ago

Toronto's Zach Edey eyes top 20 pick as Raptors continue rebuild in NBA draft

19 minutes ago

Aston Martin Valiant: A Hardcore Track Star With a Manual

19 minutes ago

Wes Streeting says Labour's rail nationalisation plan would bring down fares

19 minutes ago

Anthony Joshua set to land chance to become a three-time heavyweight champion against Daniel Dubois on September 21... as Oleksandr Usyk VACATES his IBF belt after taking rematch with Tyson Fury

19 minutes ago

Kevin Rudd joins Julian Assange as he arrives for court appearance

19 minutes ago

Now Nigel Farage suggests Zelensky should make peace with Putin

19 minutes ago

Multi-talented Kea Zawadi first female presenter of Algoa FM Top 30

19 minutes ago

5 free agents Kaizer Chiefs could bring to Naturena to bolster their squad

23 minutes ago

ESPN analyst ranks Patriots defense as top-five unit in NFL

23 minutes ago

Daybreak Foods, YES Programme partner to combat youth unemployment

23 minutes ago

CNBC Daily Open: Nvidia rallies after sell-off, lifts S&P 500 and Nasdaq

27 minutes ago

Gavin Newsom blasts 'delusional California bashers' in speech

28 minutes ago

Dragon Age: The Veilguard is Teasing Answers to a Big Qunari Mystery

28 minutes ago

Fed's Bowman Says 'Not Yet' Appropriate to Cut Rates

28 minutes ago

Why Dunkin' Donuts' New Commercial Actress Looks So Familiar

28 minutes ago

Costly election pledges in France stoke fears of splurges that risk pushing country deeper into debt

28 minutes ago

Mark Cuban offloads 14 NFTs from his collection in two days

28 minutes ago

Rashee Rice on maturity: 'This is a step in a better direction for me'

28 minutes ago

Oleksandr Usyk no longer undisputed champion just a month after beating Tyson Fury

28 minutes ago

Julian Assange formally admits spying charge as part of a plea deal with US authorities

28 minutes ago

The Continuous Hockey Hall of Fame Snub of Former Maple Leafs Forward Alex Mogilny is Starting to Get Ridiculous

31 minutes ago

Kelowna city manager earned $100K more than B.C. premier in 2023

34 minutes ago

Higher ed: Top CUNY official gets eye-popping 16% pay bump, bringing salary to over $320K