Book details how federal government used bribery to end relationships with Native American tribes

book details how federal government used bribery to end relationships with native american tribes

Credit: Unsplash/CC0 Public Domain

Federal policy toward Native American tribal nations in the first half of the 20th century sought to end the government's legal and political relationship with tribes. A new book by University of Illinois Urbana-Champaign history professor David Beck looks at one aspect of termination policy: bribery.

The book, titled "Bribed With Our Own Money: Federal Abuse of American Indian Funds in the Termination Era," examines how officials coerced tribal nations to accept termination by threatening to withhold money owed them by the federal government. Beck found that such coercion was a government policy, with both Congress and the interior department advocating using the money owed to tribes to force the end of the government's relationship with them.

For example, in 1954, Congress appropriated money owed to the Menominee Indian Tribe of Wisconsin, which it won in a lawsuit over timber mismanagement after the federal government clear-cut tribal forests. Congress forced the tribe to accept termination of its federal trust relationship with the government as a condition of being paid the money it won in the lawsuit.

"Termination was foisted onto the tribes as a quid pro quo for the payments that were due to them," Beck wrote of such tactics.

Federal Indian policy established a trust or fiduciary relationship with tribes under which the government is to provide protection and ensure the survival of the tribal nations. Among the government's responsibilities are overseeing the governance of reservation lands and managing resources such as forests, minerals and game.

"It's a legal as well as a moral responsibility. Almost from the very beginning, the federal government has been trying to get out from under that responsibility," Beck said.

Beginning in the 1920s, tribes and the government sought to create greater self-governance within tribal communities. From the government's perspective, this meant ending its trust relationship with tribes, Beck said. In 1953, the Termination Act gave Congress permission to pass laws terminating its trust relationship with specific tribal nations, which it immediately began doing, he said. Termination ends the political and legal relationship between the tribes and the government and disestablishes reservations.

Federal officials presented termination as advancing the "freedom" and "emancipation" of tribes.

"They tried to couch it in language that was euphemistic, with terms that were supposed to provide tribes with the idea that they had this great opportunity to move into the modern world, in a way that was defined by federal officials and not by tribal leaders," Beck said.

In his book, Beck looks at the time period leading up to the Termination Act. He uses six case studies to illustrate how the government used tribal monies to try to force termination, with varying success.

In a section of the book on "Forests and Termination," Beck wrote about the Menominee Indian Tribe of Wisconsin and the Klamath of Oregon, both tribes with vast forest resources. The Klamath were promised payments to individuals for their forest land. Federal officials considered the two tribal nations model cases for termination, and in 1954 laws were passed to end their relationship with the U.S., Beck wrote.

In "Dams and Termination," Beck wrote about the Three Affiliated Tribes of Fort Berthold in North Dakota and the Seneca Nation of Indians of New York, both of which were owed large payouts for loss of reservation land to flooding due to newly built dams. Both avoided termination after a long fight that impacted their abilities to revitalize their communities and recover from their losses, Beck wrote.

A final section of the book, "Lands and Termination," describes the situations of the Colville Confederated Tribes of Washington and the Mixed-Blood Utes of Utah. Both tribes won lawsuits for compensation for lands taken from them. The Utes' lawsuit led to a split in the tribe based on amount of Native American blood of individual members. Those of full blood avoided termination by letting the government end its relationship with those of mixed blood. The Colville tribes were split on the question of termination because a portion wanted their land returned to them, but ultimately they avoided termination.

The terminations of the Menominee, Klamath and Mixed-Blood Utes "caused lasting trauma to individual Indians and created dysfunction in tribal governance, economics and social structures," Beck wrote.

"One way to view the termination policy is as one more brutal attack in a centuries-long assault on Indigenous rights to their lands, their resources, their cultural heritage and their self-determination. Another way is to view it within the context of the U.S. legal system that established a federal fiduciary responsibility to America's Indigenous nations. The termination efforts that intensified in the 1940s are reflective of a century and a half of actions contradictory to the protections the law theoretically instituted for U.S. dealings with Indian nations," he wrote.

Eventually, those fighting termination were able to convince legislators that termination would be more costly to the government than keeping the trust relationship intact. The Civil Rights movement also increased awareness of how minority populations in the U.S. had been mistreated, but not before more than 100 tribes were terminated, Beck said.

The Menominee tribe later brought another lawsuit over hunting and fishing rights, and was able to reverse its termination and regain federal recognition, he said.

The book's conclusion focuses on "the lasting specter of termination." While Congress has never repudiated termination, tribes now have much more authority and a stronger relationship with the federal government, thanks to new laws that empowered tribal governments, Beck said.

Provided by University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign

This story was originally published on Phys.org. Subscribe to our newsletter for the latest sci-tech news updates.

OTHER NEWS

29 minutes ago

China Premier Li starts Australia trip with Adelaide panda announcement

29 minutes ago

Footy star is given brutal ultimatum after unveiling shocking and highly offensive tattoos: 'They are just so vile'

29 minutes ago

You've bin shamed! Council's 'petty' recycling scheme starts putting public notices on rubbish bins if families fill it with the wrong refuse

29 minutes ago

Antonio Pierce's message to the team following minicamp

29 minutes ago

Australia news live: Minns ‘really sorry’ final Vivid drone show cancelled with 20 minutes notice; Malinauskas welcomes ‘exciting’ panda news

29 minutes ago

Steelers' John Rhys Plumlee Prepared To Kickstart His Career On Special Teams

29 minutes ago

Raiders preseason will be televised

29 minutes ago

China to replace Australia's popular giant pandas

29 minutes ago

A shooting at splash pad in Detroit suburb injures 9, including 2 children

31 minutes ago

Jason Kelce Wants His Daughters to ‘Know How Much It Sucks' to Lose

31 minutes ago

Dixon on UW Receivers

31 minutes ago

Who are France's far-right party voters?

34 minutes ago

Gervonta Davis returns to the ring with eighth-round knockout after a year away

37 minutes ago

Fury after police ram terrified runaway cow with their squad car down London street - with cops forced to refer itself to watchdog amid backlash and Home Secretary demanding explanation over 'heavy-handed' incident

38 minutes ago

Where Drag Queens Shop, From Online Markets To Emerging Boutiques

38 minutes ago

‘Only goal was to come out of poverty’: Vijay Sethupathi says he misses his past life as ‘innocent’ young man

39 minutes ago

Depleted Sea Eagles rally to defeat Dragons 30-14

39 minutes ago

Here’s how to invest £60k in a SIPP to target a 7% yield in 2024

39 minutes ago

Rayhan Thomas shoots 67 on ‘Moving Day’ at Korn Ferry Tour in Kansas

39 minutes ago

Chairman Powell is happy with the Federal Reserve's trajectory on rate cuts: Diane Swonk

39 minutes ago

France eye strong start against Austria in pursuit of overdue Euros title

40 minutes ago

US accuses Iran of ignoring Red Sea distress call from vessel hit by Houthi strike

40 minutes ago

Manchester United 'given asking price by Bayern Munich for Matthijs de Ligt' after having £43m offer for Jarrad Branthwaite REJECTED by Everton

40 minutes ago

England's high hopes for Euros glory! Bullish Three Lions fans sing 'Sweet Caroline' in boozy scenes ahead of clash with Serbia TODAY - with 40,000 Brits set to descend on Gelsenkirchen

40 minutes ago

Revealed: Gareth Southgate adds fourth star to his England leadership group... with Kyle Walker and Declan Rice already assisting captain Harry Kane during Euro 2024 campaign

40 minutes ago

12/1 Featured RequestABet on offer for selected Euro 2024 fixtures today - as Denmark take on Slovenia and England battle Serbia in their respective openers

40 minutes ago

King Charles shares sweet throwback footage with the late Prince Philip as he leads tributes on Father's Day

40 minutes ago

Trump challenges Biden to cognitive test, but confuses name of doctor who tested him

44 minutes ago

The lingering England questions that Euro 2024 opener against Serbia will answer

44 minutes ago

Luka Modric, the problem with ageing, and the worst day for Croatia’s best generation

45 minutes ago

Your cheap Netgear router might have some serious security flaws — here's what we know so far

45 minutes ago

Canoe star Jessica Fox completes golden half-century

45 minutes ago

Alan Titchmarsh wife’s health warning as green-fingered star banned from huge TV show

45 minutes ago

“I wanted to switch from Strats”: Vito Bratta on why he made the leap to his iconic ’88 Steinberger GM2T

45 minutes ago

Beth Gibbons review – an unapologetically intense triumph

45 minutes ago

Labour sends activists to 13 seats where it fears losing Muslim voters over Gaza

45 minutes ago

Prestigious Dulwich Prep whose former pupils include BBC's John Simpson drops use of tribe names over fears of 'cultural appropriation'

48 minutes ago

Moment father and son rescued from overturned yacht as search continues

48 minutes ago

Buy Buy Home: The Perth houses for sale you must know about in City Beach, Kensington and Innaloo

51 minutes ago

How the Dan Hurley failure proved Lakers are the Cowboys | The Herd