If Paula Vennells's first day was about ignorance, then day two made ignorance look like bliss

If Paula Vennells's first day in the witness stand was memorable for her tears and self-justifications at facing public scrutiny for the first time in nine years, the second was less dramatic but more substantial.

if paula vennells's first day was about ignorance, then day two made ignorance look like bliss

Former Post Office boss Paula Vennells leaves after her second day of giving evidence to the Post Office Horizon IT inquiry

During her seven years as chief executive, hundreds of sub-postmasters were sent to jail based on flawed evidence thrown up by the Post Office's Horizon IT system.

Ms Vennells's defence is that despite her experience - she was in senior roles for five years before taking the top job - she just did not know.

She spent much of day one establishing just how complete her ignorance was.

Post Office inquiry: Day 2 of evidence from former CEO - As it happened

She didn't know there were bugs in the Horizon system before she became CEO. She didn't know that branch accounts could be accessed remotely.

if paula vennells's first day was about ignorance, then day two made ignorance look like bliss

Ms Vennells was in tears during her first day of evidence

She didn't even know the Post Office carried out its own prosecutions, a power it has held since the days when Dick Turpin was a greater threat to the bottom line than sub-postmasters.

if paula vennells's first day was about ignorance, then day two made ignorance look like bliss

Former Post Office boss Paula Vennells arrives for her second day of giving evidence to the Post Office Horizon IT inquiry. Pic: PA

Day two was largely concerned with what she did when she finally did find out what was going on, and it made ignorance look like bliss.

Over more than six hours of questioning, a picture emerged of an obsession with spin, public relations, media management, and the Post Office's reputation being placed over and above concern for sub-postmasters.

It was most clearly exposed in correspondence between Ms Vennells and the then Post Office communications director Mark Davies.

It concerned her suggestion in 2013 that the Post Office conduct a review of all false accounting cases over the previous five to 10 years.

That plan was never pursued, and inquiry counsel Jason Beer asked if that amounted to "a lost decade until miscarriages of justice were discovered?"

if paula vennells's first day was about ignorance, then day two made ignorance look like bliss

Post Office Horizon IT scandal inquiry counsel Jason Beer KC

"It may well have done," she agreed. "It may well have done."

That begged the question, why didn't it happen, and part of the answer came in an email from Mr Davies offering his view.

"If we say publicly that we will look at last cases… whether from recent history or going further back, we will open this up very significantly into front page news. In media terms it becomes very mainstream, very high-profile," he wrote.

"To what extent did what Mr Davies advice here affect your decision-making?" she was asked.

"I would never - it was simply not the way I worked," she said.

Mr Beer then produced her reply to Mr Davies: "You were right to call this out. And I will take your steer, no issue," she wrote.

"There are two main objectives, the most urgent being to manage the media, the second to make sure that we do address the concerns of JA [James Arbuthnot] and Alan Bates."

Former chief exec 'agreed with PR advisor'

Key questions ex-Post Office boss must answer

'I've got no sympathy for her', Mr Bates says

"You did take the advice of the PR guy, didn't you?" Mr Beer asked.

Her response, that she really didn't remember, was drowned out by groans of derision from the sub-postmasters in the room, prompting chair Sir Wyn Williams to call for order.

Failure to remember is a consistent theme of Ms Vennells's evidence, perhaps peaking with this, when asked about a 2013 board meeting: "My recollection," she said, "is that I don't recall."

OTHER NEWS

26 minutes ago

Jerry Jones' and Mike McCarthy's Cowboys relationship might be on the rocks

26 minutes ago

Best Landing Spots in Fortnite Reload

26 minutes ago

Where to watch Euros 2024 in Dubai

26 minutes ago

Revered New York hot dog joint that closed after 100 YEARS announces comeback

26 minutes ago

EUROS DAILY: Sub-par Scotland sent packing as Lineker rattles England

26 minutes ago

Video: Harry Kane appears to take direct swipe at Gary Lineker by lashing out at 'people with podcasts' who are trying to 'promote their own channels' after Match of the Day host slated England on his 'The Rest is Football' show

26 minutes ago

Two years after Dobbs; militants attack in southern Russia

29 minutes ago

Empty Stocks and Shares ISA? Here’s how I’d start earning a second income from scratch

30 minutes ago

Kaizer Chiefs: Five IN, FIVE OUT? New coaching staff

30 minutes ago

Emmanuel Macron's biggest gamble?

30 minutes ago

Mario and Luigi: Brothership Will Differ from Previous Games in the Series in 1 Big Way

30 minutes ago

CeCé Telfer, transgender athlete who won NCAA title, vows to 'take all the records' in indoor competitions

30 minutes ago

Watch Gogo Maweni's inspiring new home renovations

30 minutes ago

Zelda: Echoes of Wisdom Likely Means One Trend is Here to Stay

30 minutes ago

Best Sonic Game Reveals

30 minutes ago

The Elder Scrolls 6's Main Quest Has to Avoid Repeating a Skyrim Mistake

30 minutes ago

Fact check: Trump says George Washington ‘probably didn’t’ own slaves. Washington did

30 minutes ago

The Case For and Against Fortnite Unvaulting Battle Pass Skins

30 minutes ago

Pokemon Gen 10 May Need to Cool it with One Recent Trend

30 minutes ago

Fallout 76's Playable Ghouls Should Only Be the Beginning

30 minutes ago

Best Progression Systems in Bethesda Games

30 minutes ago

Ukraine destroyed columns of waiting Russian troops as soon as it was allowed to strike across the border, commander says

30 minutes ago

Bindi and Robert Irwin air hilarious public spat over Logie award nominations

31 minutes ago

Victorian Premier Jacinta Allan confirms pill testing trial at festivals, events

34 minutes ago

Arnold Schwarzenegger Demands Action On Climate Change: “We Have To Do Whatever It Takes To Stop The Bleeding In Order To Save Our Children”

36 minutes ago

Rebuilding Paradise: Nonprofit's $500 'defensible space' grants help cut residents' insurance costs

36 minutes ago

Rugby League convert Regan Grace gets shock Wales call-up for Australia tour

36 minutes ago

Judy Murray hits out after son Andy’s ‘medical details leaked’ before Wimbledon

36 minutes ago

Zach Edey mock draft: Where will star Purdue basketball center go in 2024 NBA Draft?

36 minutes ago

ST Full-time Report: Ex-Lion out to prove Singaporean coaches’ abilities | Transmission woes mar Euro 2024 telecast

36 minutes ago

Man and 2 car passengers arrested in Boon Keng after allegedly evading nearby roadblock

36 minutes ago

Ukraine and Belgium dare not slip up as Group E on a knife edge

36 minutes ago

England teams have gone to New Zealand expecting defeat, but that is not the case this time

36 minutes ago

Zelenskiy orders purge of state guard after assassination plots

36 minutes ago

IFS: Reform UK and Green Party 'unattainable' manifesto policies 'poisons' debate

36 minutes ago

PhD historian breaks down how anti-nuclear movement drastically impacted global energy sector: 'Nuclear energy is the most misunderstood'

36 minutes ago

Made in France: How French basketball turned so many young talents into NBA players

36 minutes ago

Sir Jim Ratcliffe, Sir Ben Ainslie and Toto Wolff bringing F1 to the world of sailing

36 minutes ago

Man Utd told four urgent signings they need as Ratcliffe is told ‘gospel truth’ on failed Ten Hag transfer

36 minutes ago

Shein, Temu strike Takealot where it hurts as e-commerce giant grapples with loss