If Paula Vennells's first day was about ignorance, then day two made ignorance look like bliss

If Paula Vennells's first day in the witness stand was memorable for her tears and self-justifications at facing public scrutiny for the first time in nine years, the second was less dramatic but more substantial.

if paula vennells's first day was about ignorance, then day two made ignorance look like bliss

Former Post Office boss Paula Vennells leaves after her second day of giving evidence to the Post Office Horizon IT inquiry

During her seven years as chief executive, hundreds of sub-postmasters were sent to jail based on flawed evidence thrown up by the Post Office's Horizon IT system.

Ms Vennells's defence is that despite her experience - she was in senior roles for five years before taking the top job - she just did not know.

She spent much of day one establishing just how complete her ignorance was.

Post Office inquiry: Day 2 of evidence from former CEO - As it happened

She didn't know there were bugs in the Horizon system before she became CEO. She didn't know that branch accounts could be accessed remotely.

if paula vennells's first day was about ignorance, then day two made ignorance look like bliss

Ms Vennells was in tears during her first day of evidence

She didn't even know the Post Office carried out its own prosecutions, a power it has held since the days when Dick Turpin was a greater threat to the bottom line than sub-postmasters.

if paula vennells's first day was about ignorance, then day two made ignorance look like bliss

Former Post Office boss Paula Vennells arrives for her second day of giving evidence to the Post Office Horizon IT inquiry. Pic: PA

Day two was largely concerned with what she did when she finally did find out what was going on, and it made ignorance look like bliss.

Over more than six hours of questioning, a picture emerged of an obsession with spin, public relations, media management, and the Post Office's reputation being placed over and above concern for sub-postmasters.

It was most clearly exposed in correspondence between Ms Vennells and the then Post Office communications director Mark Davies.

It concerned her suggestion in 2013 that the Post Office conduct a review of all false accounting cases over the previous five to 10 years.

That plan was never pursued, and inquiry counsel Jason Beer asked if that amounted to "a lost decade until miscarriages of justice were discovered?"

if paula vennells's first day was about ignorance, then day two made ignorance look like bliss

Post Office Horizon IT scandal inquiry counsel Jason Beer KC

"It may well have done," she agreed. "It may well have done."

That begged the question, why didn't it happen, and part of the answer came in an email from Mr Davies offering his view.

"If we say publicly that we will look at last cases… whether from recent history or going further back, we will open this up very significantly into front page news. In media terms it becomes very mainstream, very high-profile," he wrote.

"To what extent did what Mr Davies advice here affect your decision-making?" she was asked.

"I would never - it was simply not the way I worked," she said.

Mr Beer then produced her reply to Mr Davies: "You were right to call this out. And I will take your steer, no issue," she wrote.

"There are two main objectives, the most urgent being to manage the media, the second to make sure that we do address the concerns of JA [James Arbuthnot] and Alan Bates."

Former chief exec 'agreed with PR advisor'

Key questions ex-Post Office boss must answer

'I've got no sympathy for her', Mr Bates says

"You did take the advice of the PR guy, didn't you?" Mr Beer asked.

Her response, that she really didn't remember, was drowned out by groans of derision from the sub-postmasters in the room, prompting chair Sir Wyn Williams to call for order.

Failure to remember is a consistent theme of Ms Vennells's evidence, perhaps peaking with this, when asked about a 2013 board meeting: "My recollection," she said, "is that I don't recall."

OTHER NEWS

30 minutes ago

Slovenia vs Denmark: Euro 2024 prediction, kick-off time, TV, live stream, team news, h2h, odds today

30 minutes ago

Poland vs Netherlands: Euro 2024 prediction, kick-off time, TV, live stream, team news, h2h, odds today

30 minutes ago

Larsson: Barca need signings to win trophies next season

30 minutes ago

I have a terminal brain tumour and doctors have given me a year to live - I want this Father's Day to be the best ever in case it's my last one

30 minutes ago

Israel announces daily 'tactical pause' in fighting in southern Gaza to let humanitarian aid flow into the war-torn region

30 minutes ago

Tom Parker widow Kelsey says their young children, Aurelia, 4, and Bodhi, 3, still make Father's Day cards for the singer two years on from his death

30 minutes ago

We're parenting experts and here are 9 tips to help you survive Father's Day as a single mother

30 minutes ago

Inside King Charles's changing relationship with Prince William and Prince Harry amid family turmoil in recent years - as he celebrates Father's Day without his youngest son

32 minutes ago

Jayden Daniels has signed his rookie contract with the Washington Commanders

34 minutes ago

Taylor Swift Chokes Up On Stage During Final Liverpool Concert In Eras Tour

36 minutes ago

Michael Clarke appears to confirm romance with new real estate guru Arabella Sherborne as they enjoy romantic holiday on the Gold Coast

36 minutes ago

Driver shares frustration with photo of 'gas guzzler' parked in electric charging spot: 'Why is it that pickup truck drivers have such hate for EVs?'

36 minutes ago

The Wanted singer Tom Parker's kids make him Father's Day cards two years after death

36 minutes ago

New tool for tactical votes in Tory-held seats aims to change voting system

36 minutes ago

Whatever way you look at it, the Dublin Mayo rivalry covered up for years of poor football

38 minutes ago

Billy Crystal poked fun at Robert De Niro’s acting on set of ‘Analyze This’

38 minutes ago

Céline Dion believes late husband’s spirit is still in her life

38 minutes ago

Keith Richards got so wasted on Rolling Stones tour he was flown to another country while still in bed

39 minutes ago

Clive Myrie reveals shocking extent of racial abuse faced as BBC newsreader

39 minutes ago

France seek fast start to help end 24 years of waiting for European Championship glory

40 minutes ago

Richards Bay have Premiership fate in own hands with AmaTuks draw

40 minutes ago

In Sudan, Russia's Africa strategy advances another step

40 minutes ago

Cape mom advised to open fraud case after being registered to vote in Pakistan

40 minutes ago

Video: England's high hopes for Euros glory! Bullish Three Lions fans sing 'Sweet Caroline' in boozy scenes ahead of clash with Serbia TODAY - with 40,000 Brits set to descend on Gelsenkirchen

40 minutes ago

Michael Clarke appears to confirm romance with new real estate guru Arabella Sherborne as they enjoy romantic holiday on the Gold Coast

40 minutes ago

Cate Campbell breaks her silence after swimming golden girl's Olympics 2024 heartbreak as legend posts emotional message

43 minutes ago

Struggle to damp down inflation leaves Tories’ election hopes high and dry

43 minutes ago

Chelsea respond after Bayern Munich approach for Levi Colwill

43 minutes ago

Matt Smith: 'Pursuit of chaos'

43 minutes ago

Where to buy a seaside home minutes inland – for half the price

44 minutes ago

Fujairah Ruler performs Eid Al-Adha prayer at Fujairah's Sheikh Zayed Mosque

44 minutes ago

Jack has been to hell and back. Now, finally, she will be an Olympian

46 minutes ago

Big Blue View mailbag: Evan Neal, roster-building, Daniel Jones, more

46 minutes ago

China Premier Li starts Australia trip with Adelaide panda announcement

46 minutes ago

Footy star is given brutal ultimatum after unveiling shocking and highly offensive tattoos: 'They are just so vile'

46 minutes ago

You've bin shamed! Council's 'petty' recycling scheme starts putting public notices on rubbish bins if families fill it with the wrong refuse

46 minutes ago

Antonio Pierce's message to the team following minicamp

46 minutes ago

Australia news live: Minns ‘really sorry’ final Vivid drone show cancelled with 20 minutes notice; Malinauskas welcomes ‘exciting’ panda news

46 minutes ago

Steelers' John Rhys Plumlee Prepared To Kickstart His Career On Special Teams

46 minutes ago

Raiders preseason will be televised