OpenAI's defense: We're not liars, we're just incompetent. Yikes!

microsoft, openai's defense: we're not liars, we're just incompetent. yikes!

OpenAI CEO Sam Altman's company is using the "we're incompetent" defense in its dustup with Scarlett Johansson. Credit line: Andrew Caballero-Reynolds/ Getty Images; Isabel Fernandez-Pujol/ BI

  • Scarlett Johansson says OpenAI took her voice without permission.
  • Open AI's response: Not true! The real story is that our CEO had no idea what he was doing.
  • That kind of move-fast-break-things argument is OK for a young startup. But OpenAI also wants our trust because it wants to be embedded in our lives. Uh oh.

Earlier this week, the consensus around OpenAI was that the company was a lying, rapacious soul-stealer. A company that wanted to use Scarlett Johansson to promote their product — and when she declined, went ahead and did it anyway, using a fake Scarlett Johansson.

Now, here comes a counter-narrative: Nah, they're just incompetent.

Here's the problem: The second version of reality is the one OpenAI itself is pushing. That's the same OpenAI that's supposed to be ushering in a new era of possibility and wonder — the same company that's either partnering with the biggest companies in tech, is about to do so, or is forcing them to pivot their entire business to fight OpenAI.

Gulp.

The OpenAI defense — first put forth by the company itself in a blog post on Sunday and expanded upon in a Washington Post report Wednesday, boils down to this: The people who generated the "Sky" voice for OpenAI's newest product — the one people think sounds just like Scarlett Johansson — did so last year and never intended it to sound like Scarlett Johansson. The fact that OpenAI CEO Sam Altman reportedly asked Johansson — twice — to lend her voice to the product is just an unfortunate coincidence, made possible by the fact that Altman was out of the loop.

Here's the Post's Nitasha Tiku, quoting and paraphrasing product manager Joanne Jang:

"Jang said she 'kept a tight tent' around the AI voices project, making Chief Technology Officer Mira Murati the sole decision-maker to preserve the artistic choices of the director and the casting office. Altman was on his world tour during much of the casting process and not intimately involved, she said."

And maybe all of that is true! But, again: The choices we are now faced with are pretty gnarly: Either OpenAI is run by liars who take what they want, or OpenAI is run by bumblers.

The bumblers theory is a well-worn idea in tech because it's quite common for young, fast-growing companies to stub their toes — or fall over completely — in their early days. And Open AI is a relatively young company, with a particularly chaotic history, which includes a foundational fight with Elon Musk and last year's well-publicized Thanksgiving coup-that-wasn't.

But the reason all of this matters — why it's much more important than scandals of the day like a tone-deaf Apple ad (Remember that? From a couple weeks ago?) — is that it seems like we are headed for a future where OpenAI is going to be a very big part of our lives, whether we like it or not. (I asked the company for comment, but it didn't respond.)

OpenAI's tech is already embedded in all kinds of other tech — most notably in just about everything Microsoft makes these days — and will be even more so in the future. It's reportedly about to show up in Apple's new phones. And when we use it to accomplish a task — knowingly or not — we are going to have to simply trust that it's doing a good job.

That's because the generative AI that OpenAI is pioneering and productizing is a black box — not just to us normals, but to the people who actually build this stuff. So hoping that they get this stuff right is just that — a hope. Now they're telling us they can't handle the most basic stuff, like telling the left hand what the right hand is doing. Yikes.

If you enjoyed this story, be sure to follow Business Insider on Microsoft Start.

OTHER NEWS

15 minutes ago

Manchester United 'close to £27m Erik ten Hag deal' as Manuel Ugarte bid tabled

15 minutes ago

The new £110,500 BMW M5 is a 717bhp plug-in hybrid that weighs as much as a Bentley

15 minutes ago

NHS weight loss services unable to keep up with spiralling demand

15 minutes ago

IRS apologizes to Ken Griffin and thousands of Americans for tax data leak

15 minutes ago

LARRY KUDLOW: Why is President Biden so 'intent on disrespecting' the Supreme Court?

15 minutes ago

2024 Chicago Pride Parade: New timing, route, closures and more

15 minutes ago

Cramer's Lightning Round: Hartford Financial Services Group ‘can go even higher'

15 minutes ago

How will Ald. Ed Burke pay his $2 million fine after his sentencing?

15 minutes ago

Dallas Mayor will host 28th annual Back to School Fair in August, register now

15 minutes ago

Houston public official accused of misusing millions in public funds

15 minutes ago

Reports: Jim Schlossnagle to leave Texas A&M for head coach job at Texas

15 minutes ago

VERIFY: Yes, In Texas, pedestrians have to yield to vehicles in some cases

17 minutes ago

England in line for more criticism after bore draw confirms their passage to the final 16 of the Euros

17 minutes ago

Data centers, EVs to significantly boost US power load by 2030, consultancy says

21 minutes ago

Woman gets help from NBC 5 Responds after fraudsters hacked her Facebook account selling fake Taylor Swift concert tickets

21 minutes ago

DHS identifies over 400 migrants brought to the U.S. by an ISIS-affiliated human smuggling network

21 minutes ago

Source: Jim Schlossnagle leaving Texas A&M for Texas baseball job

23 minutes ago

After a June filled with rain, mosquitoes are on the horizon for Regina

23 minutes ago

Inaugural downtown Calgary office-to-residential project called an instant success

23 minutes ago

Can't stop the (classical) music

25 minutes ago

Dallas City Council may consider weed legalization amendment for voter approval

25 minutes ago

Stock futures are little changed after S&P 500 ends 3-day decline: Live updates

25 minutes ago

Aussies feel social media fails to stop 'scam war'

25 minutes ago

Clarence Thomas just confirmed the dangers of his favorite judicial philosophy

25 minutes ago

Poilievre to attend AFN annual general assembly for first time as Conservative leader

25 minutes ago

Bayern Munich maintain pursuit of Fulham midfielder Joao Palhinha

25 minutes ago

Monica Lewinsky wants Judge Aileen Cannon overseeing Trump classified docs case impeached

25 minutes ago

Emma Raducanu relishing 'being independent' after stunning Sloane Stephens win in Eastbourne

25 minutes ago

Game of Thrones star Ian Gelder left £250,000 estate to his husband

25 minutes ago

‘In Over Her Head’: Judge Aileen Cannon Hands Trump Another Gift

25 minutes ago

Some of the youngest Fortune 500 CFOs share an interesting common thread: They’re homegrown talent

25 minutes ago

Massive auto dealer outage: CDK Global says it won’t be able to come back online this month

28 minutes ago

Jim Cramer's top picks for pet-centric stocks

28 minutes ago

Vinnie Viola delivers on promise as Florida Panthers win first-ever Stanley Cup

31 minutes ago

Nvidia shares surge nearly 7%, bouncing after $430 billion market slump

31 minutes ago

2024 Rocket Mortgage Classic DFS: Optimal DraftKings, FanDuel daily Fantasy golf picks, lineups, strategy

31 minutes ago

Calgarians may see full water service restored earlier than expected: mayor

31 minutes ago

The tragic reason why there are no great white sharks in aquariums

31 minutes ago

Now is the time to bite the bullet and lock your savings away for longer, says SYLVIA MORRIS

31 minutes ago

I Am: Celine Dion – A cross between Spinal Tap, Sunset Boulevard and a harrowing medical documentary