400bn euros price tag for united Ireland ‘just wrong’, expert says

A recent report which suggested that a united Ireland would cost 400 billion euros is “widely inaccurate”, a leading academic has contended.

Last month, a report from the Institute of International and European Affairs (IIEA) calculated the cost of unification at 20 billion a year for two decades.

The analysis took into account the current level of funding Northern Ireland receives from the British Government, as well as the share of UK national debt it presumed the province would carry into a unified state.

It was authored by Prof John FitzGerald, adjunct professor at Trinity College Dublin, and DCU economics professor Edgar Morgenroth.

However, DCU’s vice president of research cast significant doubt on the study on Thursday as he calculated a true total of 25 billion euros spread across 10 years.

Prof John Doyle told the Oireachtas Committee on the Good Friday Agreement that the IIEA study “contains significant errors and is based on entirely unreasonable assumptions”.

He added: “Consequently, the figures in the report are not even a worst-case scenario – they are just wrong.”

Outlining his main objections, Prof Doyle said that the IIEA report adds more than 4.2 billion euros to the annual cost of unity through increasing public sector wages to Republic of Ireland levels.

However, he said this made no allowance for the taxes (which would be overwhelmingly at the higher rate of 40%), PRSI (4%) and pension contributions (expected to be around 10%) to be paid on that increase.

Prof Doyle’s calculations reduce the real cost of salary increases by 2.2 billion euros annually.

400bn euros price tag for united ireland ‘just wrong’, expert says

A defaced road sign on the border (Niall Carson/PA)

Furthermore, he said it was “unrealistic and unnecessary” to suggest that public-sector pay would immediately increase to Republic of Ireland levels in year one.

“Merging salary levels over 15 years – half the time taken by Germany – would mean a cost of approximately 133 million euro in year one, rising on average by that amount each year.”

The IIEA report includes an annual cost of 3.8 billion euros to bring average pensions in NI up to average rates in the Republic.

However, Prof Doyle said that it was “highly unlikely” to assume the state would cover the entire cost of the increase and that the figure again failed to account for tax to be paid on the pensions of those with higher outcomes.

He calculated the true cost at 400 million euros per annum.

Prof Doyle, who has expertise in cross-border studies, said the IIEA report “uncritically” uses the UK Government’s figure for a subvention to Northern Ireland of £10 billion as a starting point for the fiscal balance of a united state.

“It completely ignores recent research on this issue. For example, it includes the full cost of both state debt and pensions, currently paid by the UK, and which are part of the UK subvention figure.

“It is impossible in reality, that after negotiations between the Irish and British Governments, and where the British side abandon all responsibility for paying pensions to those who have paid national insurance or employer-based public sector pension contributions, that the Irish side would then volunteer to pay a pro-rate share of UK state debt, for which they have no legal liability.

“This is not a question of the debt being waived, as the IIEA report suggests. The state debt is owed by the UK and not by Ireland or Northern Ireland.”

Prof Doyle said it “is not believable” that the Government of a united Ireland would agree to be left with liability for both debt and pensions.

Additionally, he told committee members that the previous study excluded any analysis of economic growth after unification and contained assumptions that other areas would not change.

“It assumes that with the same political system, EU membership, policy framework, education system and tax regime, that NI would not economically converge with the

South.

“This is a very unlikely outcome. Why would Belfast perform so much worse than Cork and Kerry with the same EU access, policies, education and tax system?”

Prof Doyle put forward his own calculations which would see Northern Ireland running a surplus after approximately a decade.

He told the committee that the opening deficit for Northern Ireland in a United Ireland would be 1.5 billion euros, taking account of debt, pensions, defence and tax changes.

He also said there would be an increase in public spending of a further one billion euros per annum to cover the cost of likely policy decisions, including to state pensions and public-sector salaries.

“An increase in the underlying growth rate in Northern Ireland, of 2% above recent long-term patterns would see the costs of transition covered and the fiscal deficit ended in approximately 10 years, after which Northern Ireland would run a surplus.

“In this case, the level of transition costs can be covered by the Irish state, through a modest increase in borrowing or taxation.”

The IIEA has been contacted for comment.

OTHER NEWS

19 minutes ago

Cups thrown at England manager Gareth Southgate after 0-0 draw with Slovenia

19 minutes ago

Airplane suddenly drops 25,000 feet midflight, injuring 17 passengers

20 minutes ago

Asia-Pacific markets mostly lower ahead of Australia's May inflation figures

20 minutes ago

After losing home, family hopes for historic café’s survival as Rapidan Dam collapse looms

22 minutes ago

Attractions work on affordability to draw staycationing Calgarians this summer

24 minutes ago

Video: Lemurs in the wild serenade each other with a distinct rhythm, study finds - suggesting the ability to sing evolved early in primates

25 minutes ago

Joe and Jill Biden refinanced their Delaware home 20 times — raking in $4.2M from the $350K property

25 minutes ago

Boxing-Usyk vacates IBF heavyweight title

25 minutes ago

FTX customers to vote on multi-billion dollar repayment plan

25 minutes ago

New footage of Adelaide Westfield shopping centre incident emerges

25 minutes ago

Lytton, B.C., rebuild continues three years after wildfire destroyed most of town

25 minutes ago

Report: Dallas Cowboys’ Stephen Jones Is ‘Pulling’ Jerry Jones Back From Going All-In On Free Agency

25 minutes ago

‘We’re confident’: Not over yet for Cats great

25 minutes ago

Anti-Labour placards backfire for the Green Party

25 minutes ago

Millionaire residents fury that town has turned into dumping ground

25 minutes ago

Bears D-line gets poor ranking ahead of 2024 season

25 minutes ago

Cole Palmer speaks after making Euros debut against Slovenia

28 minutes ago

Claim Trump can make tips tax-free needs context

29 minutes ago

Whistleblower's attorney says Baylor St. Luke's heart surgeons were routinely double or triple-booking surgeries

29 minutes ago

Israelis' lawsuit says UN agency helps Hamas by paying Gaza staff in dollars

31 minutes ago

Kylian Mbappé scores but encounters issues wearing protective mask on return for France at Euro 2024

31 minutes ago

Inflation expected to ‘slightly rise’ in May

31 minutes ago

Almost half of people on antidepressants could quit

31 minutes ago

Einhorn’s Greenlight Slams ‘Head of Macro’ in Fresh Lawsuit

31 minutes ago

Packers Rookie Preview: Kitan Oladapo

31 minutes ago

International court issues warrants over Russian attacks on Ukrainian civilians

31 minutes ago

Issues about nuclear waste are a 'smokescreen'

31 minutes ago

Video: Hawaii becomes the first US state to have an official hand gesture - here's how you do it

33 minutes ago

Argentina vs. Chile live score: Copa America 2024 updates, result as Lionel Messi faces second group match

33 minutes ago

Do the dividends from AMP shares come fully franked?

33 minutes ago

Australians ‘choosing between heating and eating’ this winter

33 minutes ago

Mortgage portability: A solution to the housing market's 'lock-in effect'?

33 minutes ago

‘Doors open to everybody else’ if Senator Payman ‘allowed to slip through’

33 minutes ago

‘Creation is Not a Democracy’: Why Panerai’s Design Philosophy is Staunchly Unapologetic

33 minutes ago

'Winning again feels special' says Hatton after seizing maiden LIV Golf title in Nashville

33 minutes ago

Luka Modric speaks out on retirement as Croatia near Euro 2024 exit

33 minutes ago

Mums tackling childcare waiting list stress gather their own data to put solutions on the table

33 minutes ago

Volkswagen And Rivian Are Teaming Up On Software In $5 Billion Deal

33 minutes ago

Furyk and Weir set to square off in biennial 2024 President’s Cup in Canada

34 minutes ago

Judge Cannon is skeptical that evidence from Mar-a-Lago should be thrown out