Labor’s international student cap an ‘unprecedented’ overreach and ‘recipe for chaos’, experts warn

labor’s international student cap an ‘unprecedented’ overreach and ‘recipe for chaos’, experts warn

Labor wants to reduce net annual migration to 260,000 by 2025, in large part by tackling international student numbers. Photograph: Dean Lewins/AAP

The Albanese government’s proposed cap on international students is a “recipe for chaos” and the largest ever government overreach in Australia’s higher education system, leading policy experts have warned.

A bill introduced to parliament by the education minister, Jason Clare, last week, would give him powers to set a maximum number of new international student enrolments for courses and providers, with universities’ ability to enrol more students dependent on the establishment of new purpose-built student accommodation. A similar cap would operate for the VET sector based on advice from the skills and training minister.

The changes come after the number of international students in Australia shot up from about 580,000 pre-pandemic to 700,000 in February. Clare has argued the changes are aimed at ensuring international education “delivers the greatest benefit to Australia, whilst maintaining its social licence”.

Labor wants to reduce net annual migration to 260,000 by 2025, in large part by tackling international student numbers, but immigration and higher education experts have fiercely criticised the “unprecedented” plans for a cap set by the minister.

The former immigration department deputy secretary Abul Rizvi described it as a “recipe for chaos” that risked the closure of universities if managed poorly.

Rizvi suggested the cap was likely being introduced as a “stopgap measure” in response to historically high net migration levels and low housing supply, with Labor hoping it won’t need to be used.

“It’s quite extraordinary [policy] and all about getting to the 2025 election,” he said. “The levels of intervention exceed anything I’ve ever seen in any other industry. This gives them the power to tell a business how many customers you can have, what they can buy from you and how much.

“The power and its use is unsustainable. You can’t run an industry this way.”

If passed, the legislation would come into effect from 1 January. Rizvi described what he claimed would be 12 months of “chaos” where institutions rushed to get applications in over the next 12 months, while providers facing lengthy visa approval wait times would be under pressure to refund the tuition fees of unprocessed students.

Andrew Norton, a professor in higher education policy at ANU, said a cap was the most “radical limits on student choice and university autonomy” he had witnessed.

In a blog post this week, Norton wrote that the wide ministerial discretion of powers was entirely “new legal territory” and a “significant problem over-and-above the direct consequences of capping”.

According to the bill, the minister could cancel international enrolments for providers and/or courses on the basis of “systemic quality issues”, courses providing “limited value” to Australia’s skills needs or because it is in the “public interest to do so”, such as due to student exploitation.

Consultation with regulators, higher education providers or the department of education would not be needed in most cases and institutions that exceed their cap would risk a year-long suspension from enrolling new students.

“The level of ministerial discretion is unprecedented … the powers are there [and] the mere possibility of their use changes the government-university relationship,” Norton wrote.

“With the government and opposition united against international students we have to accept that provider caps will happen. But course level caps … are in fundamental conflict with principles of student choice and university autonomy.”

International students are Australia’s most successful service export industry, contributing $48bn to the economy in 2023. With federal investment in research and development at 30-year-lows, universities have become increasingly reliant on the sector to remain viable.

Group of Eight (Go8) universities educate one in three international students, who account for more than 30% of entire revenue streams at the University of Sydney, Monash, UNSW and the University of Queensland.

The vice-chancellor of the University of Sydney, Mark Scott, prospective students looking Sydney or Melbourne would also be considering “other top international universities”. “We need students to continue to feel welcome here,” he said.

“We’re competing … with universities across the world, and want to make sure the best and brightest have Australia and Sydney at the top of their list as a study destination.”

The University of Sydney was the only institution in NSW to record a surplus last year and 46% of its enrolments now come from overseas.

The Go8 chief executive, Vicki Thomson, said universities and purpose-built student accommodation providers were “already investing heavily” in affordable options.

Asked how universities will offset the sharp decline in international student numbers, Rizvi claimed “they’re going to have to start cost cutting”.

“They’ve designed the system not in terms of academic excellence, but revenue generation,” he said.

“A better policy would be to place a higher cutoff score on entrance exams so universities don’t put forward students with poor scores. You’d still control the numbers by letting them compete.”

Clare told Guardian Australia the federal government was working closely with state and territory governments and education providers to help international students find housing, adding the reforms will help to “provide certainty for universities”.

OTHER NEWS

18 minutes ago

Never (really) too young to have a will

18 minutes ago

Exciting call for nominations for the 2024 AWIEF Awards

18 minutes ago

Blockchain vs Crypto

18 minutes ago

Texas A&M beats Florida 6-0 to make CWS finals for 1st time as Gators shut out 1st time in 2 years

18 minutes ago

Generative AI sent to the dock in RIAA ‘BBL Drizzy’ legal action

18 minutes ago

The Matric mandate: a barrier to employment for South African youth

18 minutes ago

One of 2024's biggest new anime series will be shown in cinemas – one month before its Netflix and Crunchyroll release

18 minutes ago

Money Show host Bruce Whitfield to leave Primedia

18 minutes ago

Great Wolf Lodge water park in Webster will open earlier than expected, according to website

18 minutes ago

Employers' role in health and wellness to promote employee well-being, by Medshield

18 minutes ago

How environmental toxins and pollution affect our health, by Medshield

18 minutes ago

LA broadcast TV legend Tom Van Amburg — who gave Regis Philbin his daytime start — dead at 83

18 minutes ago

Video: Shocking moment thugs armed with Rambo knives fight in the middle of the day on residential London street

18 minutes ago

Everything you need to know about changes coming July 1

18 minutes ago

Coalition slams Prime Minister for not expelling rogue Labor Senator Fatima Payman

18 minutes ago

Former Fremantle Dockers and Brisbane Lions star Lachie Neale and wife Julie Neale announce baby news

18 minutes ago

Toronto's Zach Edey eyes top 20 pick as Raptors continue rebuild in NBA draft

18 minutes ago

Aston Martin Valiant: A Hardcore Track Star With a Manual

18 minutes ago

Wes Streeting says Labour's rail nationalisation plan would bring down fares

18 minutes ago

Anthony Joshua set to land chance to become a three-time heavyweight champion against Daniel Dubois on September 21... as Oleksandr Usyk VACATES his IBF belt after taking rematch with Tyson Fury

18 minutes ago

Kevin Rudd joins Julian Assange as he arrives for court appearance

18 minutes ago

Now Nigel Farage suggests Zelensky should make peace with Putin

18 minutes ago

Multi-talented Kea Zawadi first female presenter of Algoa FM Top 30

18 minutes ago

5 free agents Kaizer Chiefs could bring to Naturena to bolster their squad

22 minutes ago

ESPN analyst ranks Patriots defense as top-five unit in NFL

22 minutes ago

Daybreak Foods, YES Programme partner to combat youth unemployment

22 minutes ago

CNBC Daily Open: Nvidia rallies after sell-off, lifts S&P 500 and Nasdaq

26 minutes ago

Gavin Newsom blasts 'delusional California bashers' in speech

27 minutes ago

Dragon Age: The Veilguard is Teasing Answers to a Big Qunari Mystery

27 minutes ago

Fed's Bowman Says 'Not Yet' Appropriate to Cut Rates

27 minutes ago

Why Dunkin' Donuts' New Commercial Actress Looks So Familiar

27 minutes ago

Costly election pledges in France stoke fears of splurges that risk pushing country deeper into debt

27 minutes ago

Mark Cuban offloads 14 NFTs from his collection in two days

27 minutes ago

Rashee Rice on maturity: 'This is a step in a better direction for me'

27 minutes ago

Oleksandr Usyk no longer undisputed champion just a month after beating Tyson Fury

27 minutes ago

Julian Assange formally admits spying charge as part of a plea deal with US authorities

27 minutes ago

The Continuous Hockey Hall of Fame Snub of Former Maple Leafs Forward Alex Mogilny is Starting to Get Ridiculous

30 minutes ago

Kelowna city manager earned $100K more than B.C. premier in 2023

33 minutes ago

Higher ed: Top CUNY official gets eye-popping 16% pay bump, bringing salary to over $320K

33 minutes ago

Sydney’s Luna Park listed for sale, tipped to fetch $70m price tag