From schools to the Olympics, how France's staunch secularism affects religion in public life

Walk around multicultural metropolises like Paris or Marseille, or any small village in the French countryside, and signs of faith are everywhere. Many Muslim women wear headscarves and historical Catholic churches anchor nearly every neighborhood.

But France’s principle of “laïcité,” loosely translated as “secularism,” means no “excessive” crosses, or kippahs, or Islamic head coverings can be worn by staff, students and players in public schools, hospitals, courts and sports fields — though visitors and spectators can.

As the world’s eyes turn to France, host of the Olympics in two months, this unique way to define the role of religion in public life is getting more scrutiny.

SECULARISM AS A CONSTITUTIONAL PRINCIPLE

The French Constitution states that “France is an indivisible, lay, democratic and social Republic.”

A 1905 law codifying the separation of church and state, freeing each from the other’s influence, is similar to most other modern democratic states’ that also contended with a violent history of religious conflicts and absolutist regimes.

But the French version, diverging from the multiculturalism approaches next door in the United Kingdom or in the United States, allows the restriction of religious expression in public spaces that provide services to citizens. Such places should be strictly neutral, emphasizing “that which unites more than that which separates,” according to a guide written by the Education Ministry’s council on secularism.

NO SEAT FOR RELIGION IN THE CLASSROOM

The first such space to become legally lay was the school, says Ismaïl Ferhat, professor at Paris Nanterre University. Laws from the 1880s that made education free and mandatory also required public schools to present no faith viewpoints in the curriculum, and banned pastors from teaching as well as religious symbols from classrooms.

The context for supporters was, and continues to be, that schools should be free of any expression, political or religious or otherwise, that “disturbs the peace.”

The first big political clash came in 1989, when three students refused to take off their headscarves in a classroom near Paris and were expelled. The country’s highest administrative court found schools could limit religious symbols that are ostentatious or worn “in a spirit of protest.”

After a surge in incidents, a 2004 law banned wearing anything that “clearly manifests religious belonging” in public schools, though not in universities. Last year, the Education Minister, who’s now Prime Minister, said the ban included abayas and qamis, clothing traditionally worn in Muslim-majority countries — a move criticized by the U.S. government’s Commission on International Religious Freedom.

from schools to the olympics, how france's staunch secularism affects religion in public life

France-Secularism-Explainer-Photo Gallery

ANTI-RADICALIZATION OR DISCRIMINATION?

Supporters of this approach say that secularism, especially in schools but also in sports clubs, is crucial for youth to be free from pressures of proselytism and radicalization.

The latter resonates deeply in France, still scarred by the 2015 attacks when Islamist terrorists killed nearly 150 people. Special anti-terrorism measures will be in place for the Olympics, and already heavily armed officers routinely patrol major cities, while signs alerting the public to the threat are posted from amusement parks to theaters.

But critics also see the establishment responding to the rise of anti-immigrant political parties, which fomented the perception of Islam as a danger to the country.

That has only exasperated already marginalized communities. There, fear but also defiance are growing together, and a feeling of alienation from France runs parallel with more attachment to a religious identity, said Françoise Lorcerie, an Aix-Marseille University professor.

THE BATTLEGROUND OF SPORTS

The battle over secularism extends to sports too, from physical education in schools to elite athletes.

The Education Ministry, arguing there's a growing threat of radicalization on sports fields, recently published a booklet reminding schools that students can’t “refuse subject matters that seem to them contrary to their convictions.” It advises what to do if they present “unjustified” medical certificates to avoid swimming lessons or gym classes.

Last year, France’s highest administrative court ruled that the soccer federation can ban headscarves in competitions, dealing a blow to the group of soccer players called “Les Hijabeuses” who had launched legal action against the ban.

WHAT ABOUT THE PARIS OLYMPICS?

France’s ban on religious symbols for its athletes at the Olympics is in line not only with the country’s secularism and neutrality principles, but with the Olympic charter, said Médéric Chapitaux, an expert on sports and religion who’s also a member of the French government's council on laïcité.

Rule 50.2 of the charter prohibits any “demonstration or political, religious or racial propaganda” at Olympic sites — and France is only observing it strictly by not making exceptions, such as for headscarves, he added. Athletes from other countries will observe their own regulations.

The charter rule was created in 1975 after highly visible protests by Black American athletes on Olympic podiums, as organizers feared racial and Cold War tensions would spill over into the Games, said Debbie Sharnak, a Rowan University professor who studies the intersection of sports and politics.

But debates over the rule have long simmered and burst onto the global scene in the last Games, amidst renewed concerns for social justice and freedom of expression.

“Sports has never been a separate entity, and if we start putting limits on athletes’ expression, we are taking away this very important platform,” Sharnak said.

___

Associated Press religion coverage receives support through the AP’s collaboration with The Conversation US, with funding from Lilly Endowment Inc. The AP is solely responsible for this content.

From news to politics, travel to sport, culture to climate – The Independent has a host of free newsletters to suit your interests. To find the stories you want to read, and more, in your inbox, click here.

OTHER NEWS

28 minutes ago

In Sudan, Russia's Africa strategy advances another step

28 minutes ago

Cape mom advised to open fraud case after being registered to vote in Pakistan

28 minutes ago

Video: England's high hopes for Euros glory! Bullish Three Lions fans sing 'Sweet Caroline' in boozy scenes ahead of clash with Serbia TODAY - with 40,000 Brits set to descend on Gelsenkirchen

28 minutes ago

Michael Clarke appears to confirm romance with new real estate guru Arabella Sherborne as they enjoy romantic holiday on the Gold Coast

28 minutes ago

Cate Campbell breaks her silence after swimming golden girl's Olympics 2024 heartbreak as legend posts emotional message

31 minutes ago

Struggle to damp down inflation leaves Tories’ election hopes high and dry

32 minutes ago

Chelsea respond after Bayern Munich approach for Levi Colwill

32 minutes ago

Matt Smith: 'Pursuit of chaos'

32 minutes ago

Where to buy a seaside home minutes inland – for half the price

32 minutes ago

Fujairah Ruler performs Eid Al-Adha prayer at Fujairah's Sheikh Zayed Mosque

32 minutes ago

Jack has been to hell and back. Now, finally, she will be an Olympian

35 minutes ago

Big Blue View mailbag: Evan Neal, roster-building, Daniel Jones, more

35 minutes ago

China Premier Li starts Australia trip with Adelaide panda announcement

35 minutes ago

Footy star is given brutal ultimatum after unveiling shocking and highly offensive tattoos: 'They are just so vile'

35 minutes ago

You've bin shamed! Council's 'petty' recycling scheme starts putting public notices on rubbish bins if families fill it with the wrong refuse

35 minutes ago

Antonio Pierce's message to the team following minicamp

35 minutes ago

Australia news live: Minns ‘really sorry’ final Vivid drone show cancelled with 20 minutes notice; Malinauskas welcomes ‘exciting’ panda news

35 minutes ago

Steelers' John Rhys Plumlee Prepared To Kickstart His Career On Special Teams

35 minutes ago

Raiders preseason will be televised

35 minutes ago

China to replace Australia's popular giant pandas

35 minutes ago

A shooting at splash pad in Detroit suburb injures 9, including 2 children

36 minutes ago

Jason Kelce Wants His Daughters to ‘Know How Much It Sucks' to Lose

36 minutes ago

Dixon on UW Receivers

36 minutes ago

Who are France's far-right party voters?

39 minutes ago

Gervonta Davis returns to the ring with eighth-round knockout after a year away

42 minutes ago

Fury after police ram terrified runaway cow with their squad car down London street - with cops forced to refer itself to watchdog amid backlash and Home Secretary demanding explanation over 'heavy-handed' incident

44 minutes ago

Where Drag Queens Shop, From Online Markets To Emerging Boutiques

44 minutes ago

‘Only goal was to come out of poverty’: Vijay Sethupathi says he misses his past life as ‘innocent’ young man

44 minutes ago

Depleted Sea Eagles rally to defeat Dragons 30-14

44 minutes ago

Here’s how to invest £60k in a SIPP to target a 7% yield in 2024

44 minutes ago

Rayhan Thomas shoots 67 on ‘Moving Day’ at Korn Ferry Tour in Kansas

44 minutes ago

Chairman Powell is happy with the Federal Reserve's trajectory on rate cuts: Diane Swonk

45 minutes ago

France eye strong start against Austria in pursuit of overdue Euros title

46 minutes ago

US accuses Iran of ignoring Red Sea distress call from vessel hit by Houthi strike

46 minutes ago

Manchester United 'given asking price by Bayern Munich for Matthijs de Ligt' after having £43m offer for Jarrad Branthwaite REJECTED by Everton

46 minutes ago

England's high hopes for Euros glory! Bullish Three Lions fans sing 'Sweet Caroline' in boozy scenes ahead of clash with Serbia TODAY - with 40,000 Brits set to descend on Gelsenkirchen

46 minutes ago

Revealed: Gareth Southgate adds fourth star to his England leadership group... with Kyle Walker and Declan Rice already assisting captain Harry Kane during Euro 2024 campaign

46 minutes ago

12/1 Featured RequestABet on offer for selected Euro 2024 fixtures today - as Denmark take on Slovenia and England battle Serbia in their respective openers

46 minutes ago

King Charles shares sweet throwback footage with the late Prince Philip as he leads tributes on Father's Day

46 minutes ago

Trump challenges Biden to cognitive test, but confuses name of doctor who tested him