Jamie Carragher rubbishes Arsene Wenger's new offside rule proposal and claims the radical change would be 'TERRIBLE for the game'

The former Arsenal boss first discussed the change to the offside rule in 2020Wenger is reportedly keen to see the change implemented as soon as possibleIAN LADYMAN: The Premier League title race went to the wire, it is not boring compared to other European leagues! - Listen to the It's All Kicking Off! podcast 

Jamie Carragher believes that Arsene Wenger's proposed amendment to the offside rule would be 'terrible for the game'.

On Wednesday it was reported that the former Arsenal boss, now FIFA's chief of global football development, was set to move forward with his idea to introduce the 'daylight' principle to offsides, following positive trials.

The change, which Wenger first discussed in 2020, would mean that a player is onside if any part of their body that can score a goal is behind or level with the relevant defender.

But Carragher reckons the alteration would lead to a seismic shift in the way teams are forced to defend and result in managers resolving to set their sides up more negatively.

'This will be terrible for the game as teams will defend completely differently than we see now.' The former Liverpool defender wrote on X, formerly Twitter. 'Lots of lows blocks & teams being negative.

Arsene Wenger is reportedly set to press ahead with his plans to introduce the 'daylight' principle to offsides

Arsene Wenger is reportedly set to press ahead with his plans to introduce the 'daylight' principle to offsides

Jamie Carragher believes the change will be terrible for the game and lead to more defensive teams

Jamie Carragher believes the change will be terrible for the game and lead to more defensive teams

The former Liverpool defender railed against the proposal on social media, insisting football does not need to provide more advantages to attackers

The former Liverpool defender railed against the proposal on social media, insisting football does not need to provide more advantages to attackers

Podcast All episodes
  • EPISODE 89: Why Manchester City aren't the reason the League is boring
    EPISODE 89: Why Manchester City aren't the reason the League is boring
  • 'It hasn't worked!' Is VAR the problem or the solution?
    'It hasn't worked!' Is VAR the problem or the solution?
  • EPISODE 87: Why United must tear down Old Trafford and move to Wembley
    EPISODE 87: Why United must tear down Old Trafford and move to Wembley
  • PODCAST: How many Manchester United players get in the Arsenal team?
    PODCAST: How many Manchester United players get in the Arsenal team?
  • PODCAST: Listen to the latest episode of 'It's All Kicking Off!'
    PODCAST: Listen to the latest episode of 'It's All Kicking Off!'
Play on Apple Spotify

'How would you defend a set piece!! We don’t need more advantage for the attacker, the game is seeing more goals scored than ever!!!!'

According to The Times, Wenger has become convinced of the idea after good results in trials conducted in Sweden, Italy and the Netherlands.

Read More

Offside checks in the Premier League will be 30 seconds FASTER from next season because of a major VAR upgrade... Here's how it works and what you will see on TV

article image

His bid has the backing of former Gunners and FA vice-chairman David Dein, who told the outlet that the current rules are 'too contentious and problematic'.

Wenger is reportedly keen to adopt the new law as swiftly but it likely to face pressure for trials at more senior levels.

Tight offside calls have continued to enrage football fans this season, perhaps none more so than Coventry's disallowed goal in the closing minutes of their FA Cup semi-final defeat by Manchester United.

A FIFA spokesman told The Times: 'The discussion around changing the offside law is not new and it is not something we will see introduced at higher levels imminently.

'The idea was first discussed in 2020 as we felt it was something worth exploring and testing to see the effect it could have on the game. Fifa committed to trialling the amended offside law, favouring the attacker, which has been applied in selected youth competitions across Europe.

'We will continue with these trials, assess the results and discuss with all relevant stakeholders.'

VAR ruled Coventry's extra-time winner in the FA Cup semi-final against Man United last month marginally offside and a source close to the PGMOL confirmed to Mail Sport that the decision was correct

VAR ruled Coventry's extra-time winner in the FA Cup semi-final against Man United last month marginally offside and a source close to the PGMOL confirmed to Mail Sport that the decision was correct

Last month, Premier League clubs voted unanimously to introduce semi-automated offsides, which has been deployed successfully in the World Cup, Champions League and other major domestic leagues.

Wenger championed the system's use at the 2022 World Cup, where it debuted to great success.

OTHER NEWS

28 minutes ago

How to understand the 2024 general election? These books will help

28 minutes ago

Lust before love: finally the full story of the wild boy magic of Christopher Isherwood can be told

28 minutes ago

Police searching for knife-wielding teens after string of Melbourne supermarket robberies

30 minutes ago

Israeli military announces ‘tactical pause' in Rafah area to allow increased human aid deliveries

31 minutes ago

I was diagnosed with aggressive cancer at 38 after one tell-tale symptom. I danced my way through chemo with my dad by my side - and then he had a heart attack

33 minutes ago

Anderson Silva vs. Chael Sonnen full fight video highlights

33 minutes ago

WNBA Fans Outraged by Kelsey Plum's Disrespectful Actions Towards Sabrina Ionescu

33 minutes ago

Clive Myrie 'shaken' by death threats - including 'kind of bullet killer would use'

33 minutes ago

Army renames air defense system after Medal of Honor recipient

33 minutes ago

Arsenal transfer news: Mikel Arteta could secure £75million for three wantaway stars

33 minutes ago

I'm a dentist, here are three times you should NEVER brush your teeth

33 minutes ago

Israeli military announces ‘tactical pause' in Rafah area to allow increased human aid deliveries

35 minutes ago

You can’t really judge Proteas batters’ form on New York pitches, says Rabada as SA hold off Nepal

39 minutes ago

Qatar-based businessman offers aid for Kuwait victims’ families

39 minutes ago

Rahul Dravid surprises Canada by entering dressing room after washout, touched by 'memorable' gesture in India swansong

39 minutes ago

‘Really sorry’: Premier speaks after Vivid drone show cancellation

39 minutes ago

England take assist from Australia into securing a Super 8 berth

41 minutes ago

Pregnant Hailey Bieber cradles her baby bump in a gray crop top as she celebrates '2 years of Rhode' skincare

41 minutes ago

Simone Holtznagel makes a bold statement with X-rated umbrella as she braves the rain for dinner with her sisters Madeline and Anna in Coogee

44 minutes ago

US Open fans make feelings clear on Cam Smith's alcohol-inspired shirt

44 minutes ago

Patriots Notes: 7 Lingering Questions as Players, Coaches Begin Summer Break

44 minutes ago

First new Alzheimer’s drugs in 20 years to bring hope for early-stage patients

46 minutes ago

Lions beat Stampeders in front of record 53K fans and 50 Cent

46 minutes ago

England sneak through to Super Eight stage of T20 World Cup after Australia seal tense five-wicket win over Scotland

46 minutes ago

Jaylen Brown's Juice Foundation holds sweepstakes for tickets to Game 5

49 minutes ago

Trump denies Milwaukee ‘horrible’ city comment: ‘Democrats are making up stories’

51 minutes ago

Trump Confuses Doctor's Name While Challenging Biden to Cognitive Test

51 minutes ago

Why these strong ASX ETFs could be top long term picks

51 minutes ago

Cameron insists Tories are ‘fizzing with ideas’

51 minutes ago

Fastest goal in Euros history: Albania’s Nedim Bajrami breaks all-time record for quickest opening goal in UEFA European Championship match

51 minutes ago

Why this photo of a mobile speed camera operator on a lawn has sparked outrage

57 minutes ago

Investors Fear Long Stretch of Calm in Markets Can’t Last

57 minutes ago

Actress Patricia Heaton: It's up to Christians to do something about antisemitism

57 minutes ago

Lessons Learned from Kings' Championship 10th Anniversary

57 minutes ago

McDavid, Oilers avoid sweep, thump Panthers 8-1 in Game 4 of Stanley Cup final

57 minutes ago

'Custody For 90 Days Will Ruin Lives': NCP (SP) Leader Jitendra Awhad On New Criminal Laws

57 minutes ago

Indian Documentaries Ride Global Wave as Local Funding and Distribution Concerns Remain

57 minutes ago

Jarrett Stidham may be current leader in Denver Broncos' QB race

57 minutes ago

Francoise Hardy, French singer and 60s pop icon, dies aged 80

57 minutes ago

Dodgers face injury attrition as ace leaves with triceps tightness