What Labor MPs REALLY think about nuclear power in Australia - but are too afraid to say in public

At least two Labor MPs want nuclear ban liftedBut they don't support Peter Dutton's plan  

At least two Labor MPs think that the Commonwealth legislative ban on nuclear power plants should be removed, telling Daily Mail Australia that the law is 'stupid, unnecessary and out of date'.

The MPs indicated that they would even be willing to cross the floor and support a Coalition move to lift the ban, if Prime Minister Anthony Albanese were to guarantee that they wouldn't face sanctions for violating party rules when doing so.

'If it's ok for her [WA Labor senator Fatima Payman] to do it why wouldn't it be ok for the rest of us to also exercise our conscience on other issues?' one of the MPs told Daily Mail Australia.

The reference is to Senator Payman crossing the floor last night to side with the Greens on recognising Palestine as a state. The Prime Minister has decided not to sanction his WA senator.

But they insist they do not support Peter Dutton's policy to build state funded nuclear reactors.

'We shouldn't be afraid to lift the nuclear ban. Doing so would expose why [Peter] Dutton's policy isn't financially viable,' one MP says.

Their argument is that by lifting the ban businesses would be entitled to commercially invest in nuclear power, 'but they never will', the MPs says, 'because the business case for doing it doesn't exist'.

Nuclear power was banned at the Commonwealth level back in 1998 as part of a horse trading deal between the then-Coalition government John Howard led.

The calls within Labor for lifting the ban on nuclear power come in the wake of a number of Labor MPs tweeting out juvenile images of three eyed fish and koalas

The calls within Labor for lifting the ban on nuclear power come in the wake of a number of Labor MPs tweeting out juvenile images of three eyed fish and koalas

Labor MPs would consider crossing the floor on the issue if Anthony Albanese would guarantee they wouldn't face censure

Labor MPs would consider crossing the floor on the issue if Anthony Albanese would guarantee they wouldn't face censure

Needing the support of the Greens and the Australian Democrats to pass changes to laws affecting the existing Lucas Heights nuclear rector, the Howard government agreed to a blanket ban for any more nuclear reactors across the country.

The ban is now enshrined in Section 140A(1)(b) of the 1999 Environment Protection and Biodiversity Conservation Act. 'The Minister must not approve an action consisting of or involving the construction or operation of: b) nuclear power plant.'

The law could be simply changed by amending part B of the act, but would need the support of both the House of Representatives and the Senate.

Lucas Heights is a scientific research reactor, not a nuclear power reactor. Australia is one of only a handful of rich developed nations not to embrace nuclear power.

The decision by the Howard government to horse trade away any potential nuclear powered future for Australia came in the wake of French nuclear testing in the Pacific which saw a surge in opposition to nuclear power in Australia.

Australia's national nuclear ban is the result of the Howard Government's horse-trading with Bob Brown's Greens in 1998

Australia's national nuclear ban is the result of the Howard Government's horse-trading with Bob Brown's Greens in 1998

While the Labor MPs are adamant lifting the ban two-and-a-half decades later would prove their case against Dutton's policy, 'including that we are the party of the free market', they aren't willing to be named as wanting to do so because they do believe reprisals would follow if they were.

The calls within Labor for lifting the ban on nuclear power come in the wake of a number of Labor MPs tweeting out juvenile images of three eyed fish and koalas affected by nuclear waste.

'We've gone all-in opposing Dutton's policy and demonising even the concept of nuclear power', one says, adding that you can oppose nuclear power on economic grounds in Australia without ascribing to the hysteria surrounding the environmental risks attached to it.

'Championing lifting the ban would be political suicide, so no thank you,' was one MP's response when asked if they would put their name to the story.

Read More

Deformed pets and three-eyed fish: Albo's childish anti-nuclear scare campaign an insult to Aussies

article image

OTHER NEWS

27 minutes ago

Do immigrants really take jobs and lower wages?

28 minutes ago

What a stink! Bella Freud's perfume brand goes broke after challenging year

28 minutes ago

Video: Rock band Idles lead Glastonbury crowd in chanting 'f*** the king', discusses Gaza and sticks the boot into Joe Biden while Charlotte Church sings 'free Palestine' as festival turns political

30 minutes ago

Listen to Simmy and Nkosazana Daughter's new single

30 minutes ago

Max Verstappen storms to pole for F1 Austrian Grand Prix sprint race

30 minutes ago

Fernandez, Auger-Aliassime lead Canadian contingent into Wimbledon

30 minutes ago

Channel 4 rejects Nigel Farage's claim Reform UK racist was 'set up'

30 minutes ago

UPDATE: FIFA lift Richards Bay transfer ban

31 minutes ago

Almeida sick after Switzerland and Ayuso’s crash: How are Pogacar’s key domestiques faring?

31 minutes ago

Woman carries SA flag high and wins at a top global competition

31 minutes ago

Grandparents help fund school trips as parents face financial strain - survey

31 minutes ago

Did Danny Ainge put on a ‘masterclass’? How experts graded the Utah Jazz’s overall draft haul

31 minutes ago

Canada’s Leylah Fernandez advances to final of Eastbourne International

31 minutes ago

Dodgers News: Freddie Freeman set as potential replacement starting first baseman for injured Bryce Harper

31 minutes ago

Erin Molan analyses her ‘favourite bits’ from US presidential debate

31 minutes ago

Shein keeps option to list in Hong Kong as backup, FT reports

31 minutes ago

Report: Maple Leafs Targeting Pending Unrestricted Free Agents Chris Tanev and Nikita Zadorov to Reinforce Blueline

31 minutes ago

Bystander captures tourists ignoring basic rules at hot spring: 'Ban them from all national parks'

32 minutes ago

What Happened To Lizzy Musi: The Street Outlaws Star's Tragic Death, Explained

32 minutes ago

New Hampshire teacher who helped student with abortion gets license restored after filing lawsuit

32 minutes ago

Former CEO of Brazilian retail giant Americanas arrested amid allegations of billions in fraud

32 minutes ago

European Union's competition boss signals fresh AI scrutiny for Microsoft-OpenAI deal and Google

32 minutes ago

Jessica Alba shares photos with daughters who wore her dresses from past red carpets

35 minutes ago

Martin Mull Dies: ‘Clue’ & ‘Roseanne’ Star Was 80

38 minutes ago

Grassroots Democrats need to take the party back from the elites who’ve betrayed them

38 minutes ago

Biden’s now-unmistakable mental weakness is an invitation for America’s enemies to attack, attack, attack

39 minutes ago

Boeing Breaks Ground on New Advanced Combat Air Facility

39 minutes ago

Groenewegen’s crucial adjustment ahead of the Tour and thoughts on Yates' potential transfer to Visma | LAB

40 minutes ago

Having spiders in your house can help ease hay fever symptoms

40 minutes ago

US will move Patriot missiles from Israel to bolster Ukraine’s defences, reports claim

40 minutes ago

Collins backs out of ISS spacesuit contract with NASA

40 minutes ago

USS Wasp Assault Ship Sails to Mediterranean Amid High Tensions

40 minutes ago

How this property giant is waging war on office waste

40 minutes ago

65% of Americans feel deprived of vacation time. The French, who take more time off than anybody, say ‘hold my wine’

40 minutes ago

What’s happening with Mirage room rates

40 minutes ago

Why did the BHP share price go backwards in June?

40 minutes ago

England T20 World Cup ratings: Jonny Bairstow and Sam Curran struggle, Jofra Archer proves worth

40 minutes ago

Palace can repeat Wharton masterclass by signing 20m "wonderkid"

40 minutes ago

What it means for the Supreme Court to throw out the Chevron decision, undercutting federal regulators

40 minutes ago

Sense and Sensibility review – lack of decorum drains tension from Austen adaptation