YOUR TURN: Playing vigilante without consequences

Having spent my entire professional life as a county and state criminal prosecutor and now retired federal judge, I claim a certain level of expertise in commenting on the Kyle Rittenhouse criminal case.

It is difficult to understand how a 17-year-old male resident of Illinois can cross state lines into Wisconsin carrying an assault-type weapon purchased for him by an older friend and kill two men and grievously injure a third and escape any responsibly. This is, of course, what followed from an acquittal by a jury of all charges after trial earlier this month.

Yes, the weapon possession charge apparently was properly dismissed due to an unusual Wisconsin law. Yes, self defense is a legal defense if proven which, I urge, was not done here. Yes, as a democratic society, it is critical the public accept the findings of a jury as the backbone of our judicial system based on our Constitution and state law.

However, that public is entitled, as is the defendant, to a fair and impartial trial free of bias. I submit that did not occur in this proceeding. The loud scolding of the prosecutor on several occasions by an irascible judge — long overdue for retirement, often in the presence of the jury — was disturbing.

Further, while I, as a retired military officer, approve of offering gratitude for one’s military service, for the judge to call for a round of applause for a veteran who was about to testify for the defense, was grossly prejudicial. In doing so, he was potentially extending additional credibility to that witness. I assure you that jurors can be influenced by such improper behavior.

While I personally believe the jury verdict was incorrect, I am very displeased by the conduct of the trial, which, again, I do not believe was a fair one.

As a further observation, the partisan nature of the public discussion of the facts of the case goes beyond rational discussion. Not unlike too many aspects of today’s society, the partisan approach to the circumstances and handling of this incident and its perpetrator is troubling.

There are those who think this young man’s behavior was totally acceptable and that he should never have been charged with a crime and have gone so far as to deem him an appropriate candidate for an internship in Congress. Others view him as no more than an armed vigilante previously, at least on occasion, associated with the white supremacist group, the Proud Boys, which exemplifies the increasing acceptance of violence as a means of enforcing principles and settling disputes.

This trial did nothing to resolve that division but instead sends the message that others may arm themselves and play vigilante without consequences.

Ralph Smith lives in Harwich Port.

This article originally appeared on Cape Cod Times: Rittenhouse case an example of playing vigilante without consequences

News Related

OTHER NEWS

Padma Awards for this Year: N Chandrasekaran, Cyrus Poonawalla, Satya Nadella Among Awardees

© Provided by News18 Padma Awards for this Year: N Chandrasekaran, Cyrus Poonawalla, Satya Nadella Among Awardees Tata Group’s N Chandrasekaran, Microsoft’s Satya Nadella, Alphabet’s Sundar Pichai are among the list of 17 awardees ... Read more »

Movie quotes you're getting WRONG – proving eerie ‘Mandela effect' really exists

THINK you know your movie quotes? Think again. You'll be surprised by how many people get wrong. Did he really say, “Luke, I am your father?” Credit: Alamy And there's ... Read more »

Shark attacks spiked in 2021 after falling 3 straight years: researchers

The number of shark attacks surged across the globe last year after dropping drastically in 2020 due to the pandemic, researchers said. Some 73 unprovoked attacks were tallied worldwide in ... Read more »

15 fiber-packed foods and tasty tips for how to eat them

© Hyoung Chang / Contributor / Getty Images 15 fiber-packed foods and tasty tips for how to eat them High fiber foods include chia seeds, beans, coconut, guava, peas, and ... Read more »

Adams says NYC school mask mandates remain after judge shoots down Hochul rule

Mayor Eric Adams criticized the judge’s ruling against the state-wide school mask mandate but says the NYC mandate will remain. AP Mask mandates in New York City public schools will ... Read more »

3M profit beats on demand for home improvement, personal safety products

© Provided by Business Today 3M profit beats on demand for home improvement, personal safety products 3M Co reported better-than-expected quarterly revenue and profit on Tuesday, as demand for its ... Read more »

Choti Sarrdaarni, 25th January 2022, Written Update: Harleen faces criticism, Seher comes to rescue

© Provided by Pinkvilla In today’s episode, Harleen informs everyone that she acquired the hotel’s CCTV footage to find out what happened to Devika. Amrin is seen in the video ... Read more »

El Chapo's drug trafficking conviction upheld by federal appeals court

Notorious drug kingpin Joaquin “El Chapo” Guzman’s conviction on charges of running a multi-billion-dollar narcotics trafficking operation was upheld Tuesday by a federal appeals court in New York.  In an ... Read more »

'Whose side are you on?': Russia war threat shakes Ukraine's faith in ties with Germany

© Reuters/JESCO DENZEL FILE PHOTO: German Chancellor Scholz speaks with U.S. President Biden and European leaders about Russia and Ukraine By Matthias Williams and Sarah Marsh KYIV/BERLIN (Reuters) – So ... Read more »

Senate OKs bill providing COVID-19 benefits to healthcare workers on 2nd reading

A healthcare worker seals a swab sample after testing vendors at Pritil Public Market in Tondo, Manila, October 8, 2020. REUTERS/Eloisa Lopez The Senate on Tuesday approved on second reading ... Read more »

BSP warns of fake bills from ATMs

© STAR/File BSP warns of fake bills from ATMs MANILA, Philippines — The Bangko Sentral ng Pilipinas (BSP) yesterday urged Filipinos to carefully inspect bills dispensed by automated teller machines ... Read more »

Avenatti asks to represent himself against Stormy Daniels

Trump nemesis Avenatti back on trial The disgraced attorney who taunted former President Trump on cable television over comments he made about his porn star client will stand trial on ... Read more »

Zu hohe Fallzahlen: Kanton Zürich stoppt Schultests

Ab 29. Januar hat es sich an Zürcher Schulen ausgespuckt: Der Kanton stoppt die präventiven Tests. Die Fallzahlen seien derart hoch, dass die Tests wegen langen Wartezeiten ihren Nutzen verlieren. ... Read more »

FC Zürich beendet Leihe von Rodrigo Pollero

© KEYSTONE/LAURENT GILLIERON Der Leihvertrag von Rodrigo Pollero mit dem FC Zürich wird aufgelöst. Damit stürmt der Uruguayer wieder für Schaffhausen. Rodrigo Pollero spielt künftig wieder in der Challenge League. ... Read more »

Michel Aebischer verlässt die Young Boys

© KEYSTONE/AP/DAVE THOMPSON Nach Silvan Hefti verlässt ein weiterer Spieler die Young Boys in Richtung Serie A. Michel Aebischer wechselt zu Bologna. Der Transfer erfolgt zuerst leihweise, wobei die Abmachung ... Read more »

I was raised by monkeys aged four after kidnappers dumped me in jungle – but that was just the start of nightmare

A WOMAN who was raised by monkeys after kidnappers dumped her in a Colombian jungle has recounted her harrowing story. Marina Chapman was just four when she claims she was ... Read more »

GM makes $7B investment in Michigan for EV and battery production

General Motors opened its wallet on Tuesday and announced a staggering $7 billion investment in Michigan. The investment, which GM said is its single largest in the company’s 112-year history, ... Read more »

Routine eye tests can flag up people at risk of a heart attack

A routine eye test at the opticians could be used to flag patients at risk of having a heart attack, a study suggests.  Scientists have developed an AI programme that ... Read more »

Nadhim Zahawi announces crackdown on school attendance ‘postcode lottery'

Education Secretary Nadhim Zahawi has vowed to end a “postcode lottery” on school absence across the country, in what will be a “key component” of his Schools White Paper expected ... Read more »

Where to find a pizza party item in Fortnite Chapter 3 Season 1

© Provided by GamePur Unlike most of the food you’ll discover in Fortnite Chapter 3 Season 1, the pizza party item is debatably the best you can possibly find. This ... Read more »

Scottish independence: SNP's new push for a second referendum despite ongoing Covid crisis is the last thing we need – Alex Cole-Hamilton MSP

© A return to a divisive referendum campaign will not help Scotland deal with Covid and its wider effe… Things like the roll-out of state-funded childcare, efforts to address the ... Read more »

China to allow gene-edited crops in push for food security

A farmer plants seeds in a corn field at a farm in Gaocheng, Hebei province, China, September 30, 2015. REUTERS BEIJING, Jan 25 – China has published trial rules for ... Read more »

Monaco's Charlotte Casiraghi rides a horse on Chanel runway at Paris Fashion Week

Grace Kelly’s granddaughter, Charlotte Casiraghi of Monaco, made quite the entrance as she rode a horse on the Chanel runway at Paris Fashion Week on Tuesday. Chanel’s Haute Couture Spring/Summer ... Read more »

Florian Marku signs with Sky Sports and BOXXER

Florian Marku will continue to thrill fans on Sky Sports Florian ‘The Albanian King’ Marku has signed a new long-term promotional agreement with BOXXER as he continues his pursuit for ... Read more »

How to join and leave a Guild in Guild Wars 2

© Provided by GamePur Guilds bring a social aspect to the game that brings together people from around the world to unite towards common goals. The tricky thing is recruiting ... Read more »

'Nightmares', 'Moshiri, I swear to God' - Many Everton fans horrified by fresh Martinez report

© Provided by Transfer Tavern Roberto Martinez at Euro 2020 Roberto Martinez could still end up being appointed Everton manager for a second time.  The Mirror‘s David Maddock wrote that ... Read more »

New shows for Beth Rigby, Sophy Ridge and Trevor Phillips in Sky shake-up

Sky is launching new programmes hosted by Beth Rigby, Sophy Ridge and Trevor Phillips to highlight “lively debate, discussion and opinion,” the broadcaster has announced. In the shake-up, Sky News’ ... Read more »

IMF slashes global growth forecast due to Omicron, inflation

The International Monetary Fund has downgraded its global growth forecast for 2022. AFP via Getty Images The International Monetary Fund cut its global growth forecast for 2022 due to slowing ... Read more »

Fauci says 'prudent' to have Omicron vaccine, but may not be needed

© (photo credit: J. SCOTT APPLEWHITE/REUTERS) TOP INFECTIOUS disease expert Dr. Anthony Fauci responds to accusations by Sen. Rand Paul during testimony before the US Senate Health, Education, Labor, and ... Read more »

Apex Legends players collide in gravity cannon, immediately duel

© Provided by Dot Esports The last place you expect to duel in Apex Legends is at the top of a gravity cannon’s arc. But that’s exactly what happened to ... Read more »

Liverpool fan posts eye-opening video of VAR decisions from 20/21 after dodgy penalty v Palace

Liverpool‘s 3-1 victory away at Crystal Palace last Sunday was shrouded in controversy. In the latter stages of the match when things were most certainly in the balance, the Reds ... Read more »

Fall Guys Monopoly is now available

© Provided by Dot Esports Fall Guys fans can now enjoy the colorful and unique gameplay from Mediatonic’s smash hit in Monopoly with Fall Guys Monopoly.  Monopoly is one of ... Read more »

Attacks on the UAE: 'A new chapter has begun in the Yemen conflict'

© AFP (illustration) One week after a first attack on the United Arab Emirates, Yemen’s Iran-backed Houthi rebels fired ballistic missiles at Abu Dhabi and Dubai on Monday. The attacks mark a ... Read more »

‘You pack of wet lettuces' – Furious Tyson Fury takes aim at heavyweight rivals

Tyson Fury has branded rivals Anthony Joshua Dillian Whyte and Oleksandr Usyk “wet lettuces” and “cowards” – among other things – in a series of foul-mouthed videos. Fury, the WBC ... Read more »

How to create a Guild in Guild Wars 2

© Provided by GamePur There’s nothing better than having a place to call home, particularly in a game where there are so many areas and random players doing their own ... Read more »

Ghosts Season 2: CBS comedy series gets the greenlight for second outing

Breakout sitcom, Ghosts, has been renewed for a second season on CBS as part of its 2022-2023 comedy line-up.  The show has been adapted from the British BBC sitcom, also titled Ghosts, ... Read more »

Back to the future: Christian Eriksen is training with Ajax

AMSTERDAM (AP) — Denmark playmaker Christian Eriksen is training with Ajax’s reserves to regain fitness while seeking a new team, his former club said Tuesday. The 29-year-old Eriksen has not ... Read more »

Stocks lower as Fed meeting looms

Volatility is gripping financial markets as investors gauge several threats, including inflation and the pandemic. (Jan. 25) Read more »

American Idol has BTS shake-up ahead of new series - all the details

American Idol is undergoing a major shift ahead of its season five premiere, which might look a lot different. MORE: Luke Bryan’s children star in emotional new video Veteran showrunner Trish ... Read more »

Camilla hails domestic abuse charity as it marks 50 years

The Duchess of Cornwall has called for domestic abuse campaigners to carry on their vital work, after an explosion in demand for specialist services during the pandemic. As the charity ... Read more »
On free-english-test.com you will find lots of free English exam practice materials to help you improve your English skills: grammar, listening, reading, writing, ielts, toeic