You have a choice: China's top court empowers people to say ‘no' to facial recognition use by private businesses

the Hangzhou court did not determine, international brands including Kohler and BMW, a law professor in Beijing

China’s top court has made a key judgment related to facial recognition technology, empowering individuals to reject unauthorised facial recognition data collection by commercial entities such as hotels, banks and nightclubs.

The decision, which is included in a directive issued to local courts this week by the People’s Supreme Court, makes it clear that any collection and analysis of facial data by commercial operations must receive the “independent” consent of the individual concerned. If not, the act of using facial recognition technology can be defined as an infringement of personal rights and interests, a civil offence that allows the victim to file a lawsuit and claim compensation.

The directive will likely have far-reaching consequences for China’s booming surveillance camera and related data systems industry, increasing legal and operating costs. It also redefines the legal boundary between privacy and surveillance at a time when hotels, shopping malls, bank branches, train stations, airports, stadiums and entertainment venues across China are rushing to install facial recognition systems to digitalise their operations, often without individual consumer consent.

“The Supreme Court was in a hurry. It didn’t even wait for the Personal Information Protection Law to be rolled out,” said He Yuan, executive director of Shanghai Jiao Tong University’s Data Law Research Centre. “Because it cannot wait anymore.”

Although facial recognition technology has been widely-adopted in China, laws pertaining to invasion of privacy have been vague. For example, in China’s first facial recognition lawsuit that took place in Hangzhou, a law professor sued a local zoo for denying entry to customers who did not use its new facial recognition access control system.

Despite ruling in favour of the professor, the Hangzhou court did not determine whether it was legal for the zoo to only allow entrance by facial recognition, but instead made its judgment based on breach of contract.

He said that the new directive from the Supreme Court, which will come into effect on August 1, will provide a clear legal basis and guidance for local courts on how to handle similar cases.

However, the Supreme Court decision on facial recognition technology only covers civil disputes. Chinese police and other government authorities are still legally empowered to use facial recognition technology for the purposes of public security. Chinese police, for instance, have taken advantage of facial recognition cameras at airports and stadiums to spot wanted criminal suspects. The traffic authority in the southern tech hub of Shenzhen has used facial recognition technology to name and shame jaywalkers.

The new directive should help to address public concerns over data leaks from for-profit facial recognition collection. Physical shops, including those operated by international brands including Kohler and BMW, were found to have been discreetly using facial recognition on visitors for sales purposes in China, and were named and shamed at this year’s consumer gala broadcast by the country’s state-owned central television.

The “independent consent” requirement means a person’s facial data must be requested separately from other information requests. As long as facial information is involved, “bundled consent” – a popular digital business practice whereby someone is asked to consent to multiple requests in one swipe – will be outlawed, according to the Supreme Court’s judicial interpretation.

The Covid-19 pandemic has pushed more residential communities into adopting facial recognition access control systems, due to the limitations on physical gatherings imposed by lockdowns. Last year, a law professor in Beijing publicly voiced opposition to a decision by her residential property management to use facial recognition as the only access control system.

According to this week’s Supreme Court directive, in the case where a resident of a property refuses to use facial recognition for access control and requests an alternative entry method, courts should support such requests.

News Related


SpaceX's Inspiration4 mission just opened a new era of private spaceflight

© Provided by Space The four private astronauts of SpaceX’s Inspiration4 mission smile after returning to Earth on Sept. 18, 2021 to end their historic three-day spaceflight on a Dragon ... Read more »

NTSB official says Tesla should address “basic safety issues” before expanding full self-driving

© Illustration by Alex Castro / The Verge NTSB chair says Tesla should address safety issues before expanding its so-called “full self-driving” mode. Jennifer Homendy, chair of the National Transportation ... Read more »

The Chevy Bolt recall is burning up what's left of GM's EV good will

General Motors plans to launch 30 new electric vehicles around the world by 2025, and aspires to sell only zero-emissions vehicles by 2035. But over the last few years, the ... Read more »

Did you know voice over artists can make $30 an hour or more? This course package can help develop your own golden tones.

TLDR: With the Learn to Become a Successful Voice Over Artist course collection, you can develop your voice and start working as a professional voice actor. Maybe you’ve got a ... Read more »

Save 60 percent on Apple AirPods Pro and thousands of books to turn you into a walking brainiac

TLDR: The Learn Smart Lifetime Subscription Bundleteams up thousands of book summaries you can down in 12 minutes with Apple’s premium earbud technology. Smart people are smart enough to know ... Read more »

Get your iPhone 13 contract paid for 24 months with this fonehouse competition

The new iPhone 13 is finally here and Fonehouse has launched this competition to give one customer the chance to have their 24-month contract paid for.  © Provided by TechRadar ... Read more »

Sonos Beam (Gen 2) vs Sonos Arc: how does the new sound bar compare?

Sonos has announced a new version of its pint-sized soundbar the Sonos Beam (Gen 2) This more budget-friendly option promises a few upgrades over the original, but how does it ... Read more »

Here's the best PS5 SSD with heatsink to buy right now

When Sony first announced the list of requirements that had to be met in order to find a suitable PS5 SSD upgrade, it gave us all a bit of a ... Read more »

Single mum transformed kitchen and living room of her rented home - with just £218

A single mum-of-two has revealed how she managed to transform her kitchen and living room with just £218. Charli Jones, 29, from Berkshire, moved into her new home, which she ... Read more »

Spanish island braces for volcanic eruption after earthquake swarm

San Antonio Volcano, located in the south of La Palma in the area known as Cumbre Vieja (The Independent ) The Spanish Canary island of La Palma is on alert ... Read more »

You're running out of time to save $450 on this Dell prebuilt desktop

Dell regularly has some awesome deals on its site, but they are always fairly limited, too. The limitation is usually either time or quantity, and in this case it’s both. ... Read more »

Having trouble finding your soul mate? Let mom do it for you

It’s no secret that online dating can be a stultifying, painful, and sometimes traumatizing experience. But to the general discomfort of small talk with a stranger or the fear of ... Read more »

Tom Cruise leaves hiker 'flabbergasted' after landing helicopter in the Lake District

Watch: Tom Cruise spotted parachuting over the Lake District A hiker said they were left “flabbergasted” when they encountered Hollywood superstar Tom Cruise during their walk in the Lake District. ... Read more »

Verizon has unveiled THOR, a custom Ford F650 that can deploy a satellite dish, 5G mast, and drones to respond to natural disasters and emergencies

Verizon‘s THOR prototype vehicle Verizon Verizon has unveiled THOR, an emergency relief vehicle built to bring 5G coverage to first responders during natural disasters. Considered the “Swiss Army Knife of ... Read more »

To mask or not to mask? Opinion split on London underground

Photograph: Sophia Evans/The Observer The “do as I say, not as I do” approach to political messaging was again displayed last week when Boris Johnson urged people to wear masks ... Read more »

UK insurer Prudential plans to raise almost US$3 billion in stock placement in Hong Kong

Prudential, the UK-based insurer, plans to raise about HK$22.5 billion (US$2.9 billion) from a share placement in Hong Kong, as a global roll-out of Covid-19 vaccinations improves its growth outlook. ... Read more »

The world's cheapest 8K monitor could bring some big changes to how we work in 2022

More and more 8K displays are being developed and released – but now they’re also becoming much more affordable, as earlier this year, the NANO956NA, a 55-inch 8K TV set ... Read more »

Beko Telvo Duo TKM8961 Turkish Coffee Machine

© Provided by TechRadar Beko Telvo Duo 30-second review While there are plenty of espresso makers out in the market, it’s rare that you see a machine dedicated to making ... Read more »

Forget the new iPhone 13 - Motorola thinks it just made your next work phone

© Provided by TechRadar Motorola Edge 20 Lite Business Edition As the battle for work phone supremacy hots up with employees begin returning to the office, Motorola has announced that ... Read more »

The future of a portless iPhone is already here - and you may own one

Rumors of a new iPhone are a tradition that began as far back as the iPod Photo in 2004, when video was a constant rumor to feature for Apple’s music ... Read more »

Apple reveals battery size of iPhone 13 series; Pro Max has 18% more battery capacity

(Image: News18 Creative) Apple tends to put a major focus on the chipset, cameras, software, and displays of its iPhones. However, the one thing that is primarily missing from Apple’s ... Read more »

Facebook's risks for young people add to bipartisan backlash in the US

Politicians have pledged to hold social media companies accountable for their impact on mental health, civil discourse and democracy. WASHINGTON (BLOOMBERG, AFP) – Facebook is facing renewed fury from Washington ... Read more »

More tech support scams targeting Singapore consumers: Microsoft

Police received twice as many reports of such ruses last year amid a Covid-19 fuelled rise in online scams. PHOTO ILLUSTRATION: ST FILE SINGAPORE – More people here have been ... Read more »

K-pop stars making affairs of the heart public isn't career-ending any more – look at HyunA and Dawn releasing an album together

On September 9, K-pop lovers HyunA and Dawn released their first album collaboration, 1+1=1, fronted by the single Ping Pong. The pair’s romance taking centre stage in their musical output ... Read more »

Contemplating a road trip? These are the US cities with the rudest and most polite drivers

If you’re planning a road trip to a city or state you’ve never been to before, it’s reassuring to know ahead of time what to expect from its drivers. Will ... Read more »

Strictly Come Dancing series launch sees viewing numbers fall

The launch episode of Strictly Come Dancing was watched by an average of seven million viewers, according to overnight ratings. This marked a drop in viewing figures from 2020’s launch ... Read more »

Danny O'Donoghue admits he had to go to hospital after night of drinking with Tom Jones

Danny O’Donoghue says he couldn’t keep up with Tom Jones at the bar. (Ben Pruchnie/Getty Images) Danny O'Donoghue has revealed he struggled to match the drinking prowess of Sir Tom ... Read more »

Realme GT Neo 2 key specs confirmed ahead of September 22 launch: Everything you need to know

Realme is gearing up to launch a new smartphone in its GT series this week. The Realme GT Neo 2 is arriving in China on September 22. However, the smartphone ... Read more »

Why does my internet connection feel slow and jumpy, even when my internet speed is high?

Of the 8.2 million homes and businesses active on Australia’s National Broadband Network (NBN) in July 2021, 77% are now reported to be on a broadband plan that delivers speeds ... Read more »

With US$595 truffle and gold leaf mooncakes, Mid-Autumn Festival 2021 is all about luxury for people with money to spend and nowhere to travel in the coronavirus pandemic

Demand for the most extravagant mooncakes, which are often given as gifts, has been intense for years. Since the start of the Covid-19 pandemic, it has ramped up even more ... Read more »

8 houseplants that are proven to repel spiders naturally

<img alt="<p<strongAs the temperatures begin to tumble, you may notice spiders creeping into your home through open windows, doors and small cracks in search of somewhere warm. While common 1/98 ... Read more »

Adele appears to confirm new romance

Adele has appeared to confirm her romance with American sports agent Rich Paul. The chart-topping singer, 33, shared a photo on Instagram showing them posing together in a photobooth and ... Read more »

Man discovers 'human hair' sticking out of 100-year-old grave

Man discovers ‘human hair‘ sticking out of 100-year-old grave Read more »

Sid Owen says he 'never ever dreamt I would have kids' as fiancée announces pregnancy

‘EastEnders‘ legend Sid Owen will soon become a father for the first time. (Karwai Tang/WireImage) EastEnders star Sid Owen said he is “over the moon” as he prepares to become ... Read more »

The best earbuds in UAE 2021: our top earphones and in-ear headphones for any budget

Choosing the best earbuds for your needs and your budget can be a challenge. After all, there are so many different types vying for your attention, including wired in-ear headphones, ... Read more »

Another Google Pixel Fold device could arrive with Android 12.1

Rumors of a Google Pixel Fold have been swirling for quite some time now, but code inside the upcoming Android 12.1 release suggests that there’s another foldable phone on the ... Read more »

Best wireless earbuds in UAE: the top true wireless buds for 2021

The best wireless earbuds of 2021 deliver a combination of reliable Bluetooth connectivity, unbeatable audio performances, and comfortable, compact designs. © Provided by TechRadar A woman by the sea holding ... Read more »

Hong Kong's weekend homebuyers balk at Henderson's The Holborn amid supply increase

Hong Kong homebuyers were hesitant on the second day of weekend property sales on Sunday, amid an increase in supply that had left them with more options. Henderson Land Development ... Read more »

Stan Twitter: toxic fans are ‘encouraged' by artists - but music stars need to condemn, not enable, the angry online mobs that harass critics and minorities

Ethan first knew something was wrong when fans of a popular rapper told him to choke on the chips he tweeted about. Ethan, who asked to remain anonymous and is ... Read more »

Here's why the fast internet you pay for is sometimes slow as hell

Of the 8.2 million homes and businesses active on Australia’s National Broadband Network (NBN) in July 2021, 77% are now to be on a broadband plan that delivers speeds of ... Read more »