Yellowstone had 1m visitors in July alone. That's unsustainable for US national parks

Photograph: Matthew Brown/AP

National parks have been called America’s best idea, and for good reason. Unlike the castles and cathedrals of Europe, they belong to everyone. They are democracy writ large, where a people otherwise fiercely devoted to capitalism say: no, not here. Here the meadow does not become a mall. Here we safeguard the beauty and sanctity of nature. Not as a potted plant or a manicured garden, but as vast, wild, largely untrammeled nature. Our original home.

Mountains, canyons, glaciers, forests, rivers, bison, bears, birds and more. National parks provoke and inspire us. They give us stories, educate us, change us. “For my life to matter, for me to do the work I’m meant to do in the world,” the wildlife biologist and author Mary Beth Baptiste writes in her park-inspired memoir Altitude Adjustment, “I have to spend my days in mountains and forests like these, among people committed to their flourishing. And all they ask in return is a simple renunciation of everything I’ve ever known to be true.”

We save national parks so they in turn might save us.

How refreshing that we who can alter any landscape on Earth should leave a few as we found them. And how ironic that we should diminish them.

A century ago, Stephen T Mather, the first director of the US National Park Service, worked hard to create new national parks, and to promote them as part of our national experience. Forget Europe, he said: “See America first.”

Yellowstone, the nation’s – and world’s – premier national park, was established in 1872 to provide what one supportive senator called “a great breathing place for the national lungs”.

It seemed enough … at first. America had its national park, something as original as baseball and the Bill of Rights. Good for us. Now, time to resume the march of capitalism, buying and selling, ditching and damming, felling forests and stringing barbed wire to make the land safe for cattle and sheep. But Yellowstone had power. Soon other parks followed: Yosemite, Sequoia, King’s Canyon, Mount Rainier, Crater Lake, Wind Cave, Mesa Verde, Petrified Forest, Lassen Volcanic, Pinnacles, Olympic, Zion, Glacier, Rocky Mountain, Acadia, Hawaii Volcanoes, Mount McKinley (Denali), Grand Canyon and more. A magnificent system was born, and began to grow, one that colored the maps and imaginations of people everywhere.

In 1920, when annual visitation to the parks topped 1 million, Mather celebrated. His dream was here to stay.

Fast forward 101 years to this last summer. Mather would have been astounded – chagrined, perhaps – to witness more than 1 million visitors crowd into Yellowstone in July alone.

Bumper to bumper, pandemic-weary people came in search of beauty and open space; shoulder to shoulder, they sought solitude and fresh air. And what did they find? Traffic, litter, crowds, noise, oppressive heat and long lines; America’s lungs congested with what singer-songwriter Greg Brown might call “the beautiful too many”.

“Visit Yellowstone, Zion, Grand Canyon, Great Smoky, and many other national parks this crowded summer,” wrote Kurt Repanshek, the founder and editor-in-chief of National Parks Traveler, “and you can see firsthand how the crowds are impacting not just the natural resources in these special places, but literally stomping on the national park experience.”

Several parks have introduced congestion management plans – mostly timed-reservation systems – and now, with summer over, will analyze the results.

The crowding problem has been worsening for decades. In 1978, Congress directed park superintendents to identify visitor carrying capacities. It’s a daunting task, always ongoing.

Testifying before a Senate committee in 2002, Hope Sieck, representing the Greater Yellowstone Coalition, said, “For half a decade now, fresh air has been pumped into ranger booths at the West Entrance to prevent headaches, nausea, burning eyes and other health problems caused by snowmobile exhaust … Instead of a quiet, peaceful winter wonderland, visitors today are welcomed by extreme noise, choking pollution, noxious odors and rangers in respirators.”

In his classic memoir Desert Solitaire, the author Edward Abbey recounts his two summers as a park ranger in Arches (then a national monument, in the 1950s). One day, as he’s “watching the flow of evening over the desert … the birds coming back to life, the shadows rolling for miles over rock and sand to the very base of the brilliant mountains,” he hears a “discordant note”. A jeep. Three dusty men drive up and ask for water. Abbey obliges them. They’re a survey crew, staking out a new road – to be paved, of course – that will accommodate 30 times more visitors than are here now. The head surveyor asks a skeptical Abbey what his answer is to that. Abbey’s reply: “‘Have some more water,’ I said. I had an answer all right but I was saving it for later. I knew that I was dealing with a madman.”

Today, Abbey’s Arches – a place of quiet summer solitude – is gone.

Granted, the National Park Service (NPS) has an impossible mandate – a 1916 “Organic Act” – that says it must conserve the parks and provide for their enjoyment while leaving them “unimpaired” for future generations. The NPS is also starved for money, with a maintenance backlog estimated at $13bn that grows by more than $300m each year. During the disastrous 34-day government shutdown of 2018-19, when the parks remained open but understaffed, visitors died, toilet paper blew like confetti through campgrounds, and off-road vehicles left scars that will take years to heal.

How to fix this?

Increase the NPS budget. If the US can spend roughly $300m a day for 20 years on a war in Afghanistan, it can fix its national parks. Save America first.

In Deb Haaland, we have our first Native American secretary of the interior. If the Senate confirms Charles “Chuck” Sams, a navy veteran and member of the Confederated Tribes of the Umatilla Reservation, we’ll have our first Native American director of the NPS, which could help imbue park management with indigenous sensibilities. A new directive could prioritize the scenic, historic, cultural and ecological integrity of all parks in part by establishing carrying capacities, visitor limits, a national reservation system, electric-powered public transportation, and increased opportunities for the underprivileged.

Many national monuments could be elevated to national parks. Other new parks could be carved from national forests and Bureau of Land Management lands. Neighboring state parks could be enlarged, and private lands purchased. All to help take pressure off our existing marquee national parks.

None of this will be easy, or impossible.

Our finest concert halls do not seat people in the aisles or stand them along the walls. They invite us to a later performance.

We love our national parks and want them safeguarded today and tomorrow. It will take sacrifice and patience, democracy writ large.

America’s best idea – made better.

  • A frequent contributor to the Guardian, and a former ranger with the National Park Service, Kim Heacox is the author of many books, including The Only Kayak, a memoir, and Jimmy Bluefeather, a novel, both winners of the National Outdoor Book Award. He lives in Alaska

Internet Explorer Channel Network
News Related


Maharashtra Witnesses 5-year High in Chikungunya Cases, Over 2,000 People Infected Till October

© Provided by News18 Maharashtra Witnesses 5-year High in Chikungunya Cases, Over 2,000 People Infected Till October With 2,006 cases of chikungunya between January and October this year, Maharashtra has ... Read more »

'No Central govt file to pass over 4 hands': Centre to push for major governance reform

© Provided by Firstpost ‘No Central govt file to pass over 4 hands’: Centre to push for major governance reform It has taken six years for the Narendra Modi government ... Read more »

Nykaa IPO Opens Today: Price, GMP, Strength, Valuation, Key Risks; Should you Invest?

© Provided by News18 Nykaa IPO Opens Today: Price, GMP, Strength, Valuation, Key Risks; Should you Invest? Nykaa IPO Opens Today: The much awaited initial public offering (IPO) of FSN ... Read more »

Sedition charges will be pressed against those celebrating Pakistan's victory, warns UP CM Yogi Adityanath

© Provided by Zee News NEW DELHI: Uttar Pradesh Chief Minister Yogi Adityanath has warned that his government will press sedition charges against those celebrating Pakistan’s victory against India in ... Read more »

Petrol price rises to Rs 114.14 in Mumbai, diesel rate increases to Rs 105.12

© Provided by CNBCTV18 The oil marketing companies (OMCs) hiked petrol and diesel prices on Thursday for second consecutive day. While petrol price was raised by 34-35 paise, diesel rate ... Read more »

Top stock tips by Sudarshan Sukhani, Mitessh Thakkar: Petronet LNG, Bajaj Finance, Cholamandalam Finance and more

© Provided by CNBCTV18 Indian equity benchmarks Sensex and Nifty50 are likely to start Thursday’s session on a flat note amid mixed global cues. At 8:35 am, Nifty futures trading ... Read more »

Bharat Biotech's US partner Ocugen filed with US FDA for clinical trial of Covaxin

© Provided by Business Today Bharat Biotech’s US partner Ocugen filed with US FDA for clinical trial of Covaxin Bharat Biotech’s US partner Ocugen, a Pennsylvania-based biopharmaceutical company, announced that ... Read more »

UPSC interview schedule released for IES, ISS Exam 2021 on

© Provided by DNA Union Public Service Commission (UPSC) has released the interview schedule for UPSC IES, ISS Exam 2021. Candidates can go through the interview schedule for Indian Economic ... Read more »

Covid: 16k new cases as infections rise in Bengal, Odisha & HP

© Provided by The Times of India NEW DELHI: There seems to be no respite in the states that saw a minor surge in cases following the Durga Puja week. ... Read more »

Can't find workers? Why not pay more instead of exploiting children and migrants

The senate of the US state of Wisconsin has just approved a bill allowing 14-year-old children to engage in paid work until as late as 11pm. © Provided by The ... Read more »

Tom Hanks Surprises Couple on Their Wedding Day: 'It Was the Cherry on Top'

© Provided by People access hollywood Tom Hanks has made a newlywed couple even happier on their wedding day! Diciembre and Tashia Farries were recently celebrating their big day on ... Read more »

Brad Pitt's Petition for Review in His and Angelina Jolie's Custody Case is Denied

© ET Brad Pitt’s petition to challenge a decision on his ongoing custody battle with Angelina Jolie has been denied. ET can confirm that the California Supreme Court denied Pitt’s ... Read more »

Blackhawks scandal: Kyle Beach reveals himself as 'John Doe' victim of coach's sexual assault

Kyle Beach announced he is “John Doe” in the Chicago Blackhawks‘ sexual assault case on Wednesday. The Blackhawks’ first-round pick in the 2008 NHL Draft (11th overall), Beach filed a ... Read more »

Fossil fuel executives set to testify on climate disinformation at House Oversight hearing

For the first time, the executives of major fossil fuel companies and industry groups will testify in front of Congress on Thursday about disinformation on the climate crisis and the ... Read more »

Global finance group urges greater use of carbon markets to meet climate goals

FILE PHOTO: Smoke and steam billows from Belchatow Power Station LONDON (Reuters) – Countries must increase the use of carbon markets to meet the Paris climate goals of limiting a ... Read more »

North Korea tells citizens food shortage will last through 2025: Report

North Korea has reportedly told its citizens to expect food shortages until 2025. AP North Korea’s totalitarian government has told its people to tighten their belts — literally — for ... Read more »

UAE then and now: the transformation of Downtown Dubai in pictures

© Provided by The National Burj Khalifa in 2008 as it rises on Sheikh Zayed Road in Dubai and the same scene in 2021. Jumana El Heloueh / Reuters and ... Read more »

Billie Eilish and Rainn Wilson call for ‘urgent action' from world leaders ahead of UN Cop26 climate summit

Billie Eilish and Rainn Wilson have joined forces with scientists from Arctic Basecamp, calling on world leaders to take urgent action at the United Nations Cop26 climate summit in Glasgow ... Read more »

American flight diverted after passenger assaults attendant, airline says

An American Airlines flight was diverted Wednesday evening after a passenger reportedly assaulted a flight attendant. Flight 976 had departed New York’s John F. Kennedy International Airport and was headed ... Read more »

Italy hosts a climate-focused G20 as geopolitics shift

Italy G20 Diplomacy (Copyright 2021 The Associated Press. All rights reserved) The leaders of Russia and China aren’t coming. Turkey nearly set off a diplomatic incident on the eve of ... Read more »

NS 101: What Is "Exercise Wallaby" And Does It Involve Marsupials?

A successful exercise in Queensland, Australia amid the COVID-19 pandemic reflects our SAF’s commitment to defence and maintaining high-end training. A successful exercise in Queensland, Australia amid the COVID-19 pandemic ... Read more »

Menjelang pembentangan Belanjawan 2022, pengusaha bas rayu bantuan kerajaan

© Provided by MalaysiaNow Menjelang pembentangan Belanjawan 2020, Persatuan Pengusaha Bas Seluruh Malaysia (PMBOA) merayu supaya kerajaan memberikan bantuan kepada mereka kerana terjejas teruk akibat pelaksanaan perintah kawalan pergerakan bagi ... Read more »

Honda Civic Hybrid Spotted in Japan, But It's Not Coming to the US

The 11th-generation Honda Civic is creating plenty of buzz in the automotive world. With new refined styling and upgrades over the outgoing model, it’s brought fresh interest to what is ... Read more »

Coronavirus digest: Singapore investigates 'unusual surge' amid record daily rise

© Provided by Singapore has recorded its highest single-day rise in COVID-19 cases Singapore is looking into an “unusually high” rise in infections as the city-state recorded an all-time ... Read more »

Gordhan: Power cuts should be over by the weekend

© Provided by eNCA JOHANNESBURG – Public Enterprises Minister Pravin Gordhan says measures are being put in place to reduce the country’s power cuts to Level 2 by the weekend. ... Read more »

Chicago Med: Does Connor's Old Storyline Indicate What's Next For Crockett In Season 7?

© Provided by CinemaBlend dominic rains crockett marcell chicago med nbc Spoilers ahead for the sixth episode of Chicago Med Season 7, called “When You’re A Hammer Everything’s A Nail.” ... Read more »

World faces growing threat of 'unbearable' heatwaves

© Frederic J. BROWN If nothing is done to slow climate change, the record temperatures and deadly heatwaves it brings will only get worse, experts warn From Death Valley to ... Read more »

France warns two British fishing boats in its waters in wake of Brexit

© Reuters/BENOIT TESSIER A sign reading “security area” is pictured at the entrance of the Port of Le Havre PARIS (Reuters) – France gave verbal warnings to two British boats ... Read more »

'These guys don't worry': Astros even World Series with Atlanta at one game apiece behind four-run rally

HOUSTON — The Houston Astros’ biggest stars were immersed in an offensive funk. Their young starting pitcher was coming off a brutal performance. And they were facing a red-hot Atlanta ... Read more »

Man to plead guilty in Mac Miller overdose death, documents say

A plea agreement filed in federal court calls for a 17-year sentence. Three people were indicted in the rapper's 2018 overdose death. Read more »

Homefront: ‘What rights do I have if a bank repossesses my landlord's property?'

© Provided by The National No landlord can evict a tenant without serving a 12-month notice. Even then, there has to be a valid reason for eviction. Alamy I have ... Read more »

Review: Apple's new AirPods find middle ground between high-end and entry level segments

© APPLE INC. HANDOUT Apple’s new AirPods is water and sweat-resistant. EPA A combination of top-of-the-line sound quality and familiar designs all rolled into one makes Apple’s new AirPods the ... Read more »

'We had to change XI thrice': New Zealand coach Gary Stead slams ICC for not allowing Adam Milne to play vs Pakistan

‘Disappointed’ New Zealand head coach Gary Stead questioned ICC for not allowing Adam Milne as a replacement to the inured Lockie Ferguson before their T20 World Cup 2021 opener against ... Read more »

Expert Shares Tips To Get Relief From Nausea During Early Months Of Pregnancy

Pregnancy brings along some unpleasant symptoms which can cause a lot of discomfort through the phase. Morning sickness or nausea is one of the most common symptoms of pregnant women. ... Read more »

T20 World Cup: England outclass Bangladesh by 8 wickets

© Provided by The Times of India If you look at two of the most in-form teams in the ICC T20 World Cup, you will struggle to get past Pakistan ... Read more »

T20 World Cup: Jason Holder Replaces Obed McCoy in West Indies Squad

© Debayan Bhattacharya | Sports Desk Jason Holder (Image: AFP) Dubai, Oct 28: Sunrisers Hyderabad bowler and former Test captain of the West Indies cricket team, Jason Holder gets ... Read more »

Joe Biden is hopelessly out of touch with voters' priorities

Inflation is at its highest level in decades. Store shelves are empty. The southern border is in chaos. Hundreds of Americans are still trapped in Afghanistan. China just tested a ... Read more »

A White hospital executive says he was fired and replaced by two women as part of diversity push. He was just awarded $10 million in a wrongful termination lawsuit

A White man has been awarded a $10 million payout in a wrongful termination lawsuit filed against his former employer, which he said fired him and replaced him with a ... Read more »

Brexit: France detains British trawler as fishing rights row intensifies

France has detained a British trawler and given a verbal warning to another fishing in waters off its coast, the French government has said In a tweet the the French ... Read more »

Australia proposes 'Trumpian' voter ID laws

Australia’s conservative government on Thursday proposed laws requiring voters to prove their identity when casting a ballot, a move slammed by the opposition as an attempt at voter suppression and ... Read more »
On you will find lots of free English exam practice materials to help you improve your English skills: grammar, listening, reading, writing, ielts, toeic