Xavi cannot repeat the same mistake Koeman made

Asia's Tech News Daily

Xavi cannot repeat the same mistake Koeman made
© Photo by Jose Breton/Pics Action/NurPhoto via Getty Images

Barcelona’s win against Villarreal was a big one. It was the first time all season Barça have won back-to-back games in La Liga and it extended the unbeaten start of Xavi Hernández as manager. It was also a match that exposed a very worrying aspect of Xavi’s tactics that must be corrected very soon.

To make it as clear as possible: Xavi should drop his man-marking defensive system. Like, right now.

There is still a place in football for man-marking. It is not a defensive tactic of the past. Several of the top teams use today it in the buildup phase, because it’s the best way to shut down passing options and force opponents to either go long or try to dribble their way out of trouble, which can cause mistakes and lead to easy chances.

Thomas Tuchel’s Chelsea goes man-to-man on the buildup. So does Julian Nagelsmann’s Bayern Munich. So does Pep Guardiola’s Manchester City. It is still very effective. But all of those three teams have a simple rule: if man-marking doesn’t result in us winning the ball back or the other team crosses a certain spot on the pitch (usually the midfield line), revert back to our shape (Chelsea’s 5-4-1, Bayern’s 4-4-2, City’s 4-1-4-1) and defend in a zone.

That type of system that uses both man and zone depending on the situation or where the ball is certainly feels like the best current defensive strategy at the highest level. You can’t really defend the buildup in a zone; top teams will find the gaps and pass through you too easily. But defending man-to-man all across the pitch is quite simply suicidal. Assigning every player on the team a specific matchup and asking him to track his man no matter where he goes is the simplest way to destroy your shape, and top teams will easily figure out how to attack the massive spaces you’re leaving in behind.

Of all the problems with Ronald Koeman’s system at Barça, man-marking was without a doubt the worst. We covered this in our tactical analysis of the loss to Bayern at Camp Nou in the Champions League opener, where Nagelsmann and his players quickly figured out that moving around and changing positions would quickly expose the Barça defense.

Against Villarreal last Saturday, we saw the exact same problems. Barça started well and could have scored twice within the first 10 minutes, and after the first 20 it looked like they would destroy the Yellow Submarine. But Unai Emery quickly realized that right-back Eric García was man-marking left winger Moi Gómez, and asked Gómez to not play on the wing and instead move centrally whenever Villarreal had the ball.

He wanted García to vacate the right-back spot, follow Gómez whenever he went even if Gómez never touched the ball, and open up a giant space for left-back Alfonso Pedraza to explore. With Barça B winger Ez Abde making his first start for Barça and being new to such an aggressive a man-marking system, Emery got what he wanted. Time and time again.

Xavi cannot repeat the same mistake Koeman made
© Provided by SB Nation
Xavi cannot repeat the same mistake Koeman made
© Provided by SB Nation
Xavi cannot repeat the same mistake Koeman made
© Provided by SB Nation

That’s bad. Really bad. Abde lost Pedraza every single time, and Eric continued to follow Gómez around even after it was made clear that his man was never going to get the ball and was simply a decoy. The most concerning part about all of this was that Xavi did not adjust at halftime. The same thing kept happening, again and again and again.

Xavi cannot repeat the same mistake Koeman made
© Provided by SB Nation
Xavi cannot repeat the same mistake Koeman made
© Provided by SB Nation
Xavi cannot repeat the same mistake Koeman made
© Provided by SB Nation

There are two teams in Europe’s Top 5 leagues who defend man-to-man as aggressively as Xavi’s Barça have so far: Gian Piero Gasperini’s Atalanta and Marcelo Bielsa’s Leeds United. Both of those teams have something in common: they are wildly entertaining and brilliant offensive sides, but are both horrible at the back which stops them from being truly competitive. Atalanta should be a serious Serie A contender every year, but they simply concede too many goals to be the best team in the league.

Leeds flirted with the Top 6 in the Premier League last season, but their defense let them down too many times. They are too injured to be fairly judged this season, but they’re still bad at the back.

After three games Xavi’s Barça seem to be going in the same direction: every game is going to be a lot of fun with plenty of chances for both sides, and if Barça score theirs and get some luck at the back they will win. Considering their attacking talent once the injured players return, they might win a lot more than they lose. But can they be truly competitive if they continue to allow so many big chances to teams with better attacking talent than Espanyol and Villarreal?

Xavi has already made tremendous improvement in the attacking side, and Barça will no doubt be a better team than they were under Koeman for that reason. But the defense will not improve if Xavi maintains the man-marking system. The reason it didn’t work under Koeman was not because Koeman was a bad coach: it’s because the players are not good enough to execute what is already a very risky system to begin with.

Ronald Koeman was too stubborn to admit his tactics did not fit his squad and refused to adjust. That was his biggest mistake.

Xavi cannot repeat it. For the team’s sake — and his own.

Internet Explorer Channel Network
Asia's Tech News Daily
News Related

OTHER NEWS

Juventus : cette annonce fracassante de l'Inter Milan pour Dybala !

Paulo Dybala, l’attaquant de la Juventus arrive en fin de contrat dans six mois, ce qui n’a pas manqué d’attiser les convoitises de l’Inter Milan. © Icon Sport Paulo Dybala ... Read more »

Athletic Bilbao - Barça : les compos probables et les absents

Découvrez les compositions probables et les absents à déplorer pour ce huitième de finale de Coupe du Roi entre l’Athletic Bilbao et le Barça. © Icon Sport Athletic Bilbao – ... Read more »

PSG : Wenger répond une nouvelle fois à l'intérêt parisien et encense Mbappé !

Arsène Wenger a une nouvelle fois commenté les rumeurs qu’il l’associait au PSG et a tenu à encenser Kylian Mbappé. © Icon Sport Arsène Wenger Arsène Wenger a une nouvelle ... Read more »

PSG, OL, OM, Lens, ASSE ... la programmation de la J25 est tombée !

Découvrez la programmation TV de la 25e journée de Ligue 1 avec notamment le PSG, l’OM mais aussi l’affiche entre Lens et l’OL. © Icon Sport Lens et l’OL s’affronteront ... Read more »

Manchester United : Cristiano Ronaldo furieux d'avoir été remplacé, Rangnick l'apaise avec philosophie !

Sorti hier à vingt minutes du terme de la rencontre, Cristiano Ronaldo n’a guère apprécié ce changement. Ralf Rangnick a tenu à désamorcer la polémique. © Icon Sport CR7 n’a ... Read more »

Colpo dalla Svizzera, Mihajlovic sfida Walter Mazzarri

© Fornito da Sportal.it Sul centrocampista svizzero in forza allo Young Boys è piombato con decisione il Bologna. Sembrava tutto fatto.Il Cagliari aveva messo sul piatto un prestito con una ... Read more »

Ez a videó egy, az Australian Openen összeeső teniszezőről még a koronavírus-járvány és az oltások előtt készült

Terjedni kezdett 2022 januárjában a közösségi médiában egy videó, amelyen állítólag azt látni, ahogy egy teniszező szívrohamot kap az Australian Openen. A bejegyzés a Pfizer koronavírus elleni oltását nevezte meg ... Read more »

A Manchester United olyat tett, amire angol klub még nem volt képes

© Technológia: Index.hu A Premier League 17. fordulójából bepótolt szerdai mérkőzésein a Tottenham és a Manchester United is idegenben nyert. A „vörös ördögök” a gól nélküli első játékrész után a ... Read more »

Ivory Coast vs Algeria: Prediction, kick off time, TV, live stream, team news and h2h results - AFCON preview

Algeria and Ivory Coast go head to head this afternoon in a crucial heavyweight tussle at the Africa Cup of Nations. It has been a wretched AFCON tournament so far ... Read more »

Staff Takeaways: Brentford 1-3 Manchester United

© Photo by Sebastian Frej/MB Media/Getty Images Colin: Ralf’s willingness to make adjustments and substitutions pays off. Something which had been an all too familiar point of criticism under Solskjaer ... Read more »

Sotto eyes DDB, PDEA, DILG chief post if elected VP in Eleksyon 2022

Senate President’s presser pre-SONA: Senate President Tito Sotto holds a virtual press conference with Senate beat reporters at the Recto Room at the Senate Building in Pasay City after the ... Read more »

Jacobs abbandona Fedez: il rapper non curerà più l'immagine del campione olimpico

Marcell Jacobs lascia Fedez. Prima di vincere l’oro olimpico a Tokyo, il velocista aveva siglato anni fa un contratto con la Doom, agenzia di promozione di proprietà di Fedez e ... Read more »

SIC: questa sera su Sky il documentario dedicato a Marco Simoncelli

Sarà un omaggio decisamente speciale quello che Sky farà ai propri abbonati. In occasione del compleanno di Marco Simoncelli, a dieci anni dalla tragica scomparsa, renderà disponibile l’omonimo documentario in ... Read more »

Jérôme Rothen inquiet concernant un possible retour de Thierry Henry en Ligue 1 : "Il va se mettre en difficulté"

Thierry Henry envisagé par les Girondins de Bordeaux 19èmes de Ligue 1, une fausse bonne idée? © Walfoot.be Thierry HEnry Thierry Henry fait partie des pistes envisagées par Bordeaux pour remplacer ... Read more »

F1 | La spalla non si deforma più? E la gomma non si surriscalda!

Nel paddock della F1 si discute quanto saranno effettivamente più lente le monoposto a effetto suolo rispetto alle regine che hanno lasciato la scena alla fine dello scorso anno. Nella ... Read more »

Emmanuel Agbadou est suivi de très près en Premier League

Après y avoir enregistré le départ d’Edo Kayembe, les Pandas pourraient à nouveau céder un élément important de leur effectif en Angleterre. © photonews Agbadou Emmanuel Le défenseur central ivoirien ... Read more »

Tennis – Open d'Australie (H) : Paire sort Dimitrov, Gasquet jette l'éponge

© Panoramic benoit paire Après qu’Arthur Rinderknech, blessé, a dû déclarer forfait avant son match contre Evans, cela a été au tour de Richard Gasquet de devoir abandonner dans le ... Read more »

Proteas trio included in ICC Womens ODI team of the year

© Provided by Independent Online (IOL) Johannesburg – Marizanne Kapp, Lizelle Lee and Shabnim Ismail were all included in the ICC Women’s ODI team of the Year, which was named ... Read more »

Novak Djokovic news: Judges state it was ‘plainly open' to conclude world No 1 was anti-vaccination

© PA Images Novak Djokovic looking up The Federal Court of Australia published the reasons for the decision not to quash the cancellation of Novak Djokovic’s visa. It was reasonable ... Read more »

England in the West Indies: Jason Roy marks return with rapid century in Barbados

© PA Images CRICKET T20 ENGLAND AUSTRALIA Jason Roy marked his return to England duty with a scintillating 36-ball hundred to usher his side to a thumping win in their ... Read more »

Is Carlo Aquino, Trina Candaza's relationship on the rocks?

Netizens speculated that Carlo Aquino and Trina Candaza’s relationship is on the rocks following their cryptic posts on Instagram on Monday, January 17. © Provided by LionhearTV Aquino shared a ... Read more »

Van Amersfoort Racing kiest voor Belgisch talent in de Formule 2

© Aangeboden door GPblog NL Van Amersfoort Racing heeft de line-up voor het eerste seizoen in de Formule 2 bekendgemaakt. Naast de eerder bekendgemaakte Jake Hughes kiest VAR ook voor ... Read more »

Southampton vs Man City: Prediction, kick off time, TV, live stream, team news, h2h results

© ES Composite PLSouthamptonManCity2122.jpg Manchester City travel to Southampton on Saturday evening looking to extend their lead at the top of the Premier League to sixteen points. With both Chelsea ... Read more »

Qui est la compagne de Benzema ?

© Fournis par Sports.fr Cora Gauthier est la compagne de Karim Benzema depuis 2016. Privé de l’Euro suite à son implication dans l’affaire de la sextape de Mathieu Valbuena, Karim ... Read more »

Euro 2022 de handball : quelle défense pour l'équipe de France en l'absence de Karl Konan contre les Pays-Bas et l'Islande ?

Testé positif au Covid-19 mardi, Karl Konan manquera au moins les deux premières rencontres du tour principal, contre les Pays-Bas et l’Islande. Cette absence oblige Guillaume Gille à revoir ses ... Read more »

Lorenzana sees hurdles in proposed mandatory military service

Defense Sec. Delfin Lorenzana at Dec. 21, 2020 briefing Defense Secretary Delfin Lorenzana on Thursday said funds and resources would be the big challenge in implementing the proposed mandatory military ... Read more »

Mercato: Bonne nouvelle pour l'OM !

© Fournis par Sports.fr Deuxième recrue hivernale de l’OM, il sera présenté ce jeudi après-midi au Centre RLD. L’Olympique de Marseille a décidé de tenter des paris lors de ce mercato ... Read more »

Paire enchaîne, Gasquet s'arrête là

© Fournis par Sports.fr Tennis – Open d’Australie (H) : Paire sort Dimitrov, Gasquet jette l’éponge Ce Benoît Paire est décidément déroutant. Beaucoup lui avaient montré la sortie du doigt ... Read more »

Tennis: les non-vaccinés autorisés à jouer en Italie... mais sans aucun accès aux vestiaires

© ICON Sport Novak Djokovic ne pourra pas participer à l’Open d’Australie Après la confusion autour du cas Novak Djokovic en Australie, l’ATP réfléchit à instaurer de nouvelles règles pour ... Read more »

NBA roundup: Nikola Jokic carries Nuggets to OT win

© Reuters/Isaiah J. Downing NBA: Los Angeles Clippers at Denver Nuggets Nikola Jokic had 49 points, 14 rebounds and 10 assists, Aaron Gordon hit a 3-pointer with 2.2 seconds left ... Read more »

Warriors slip to No. 3 in latest NBA power rankings from Rookie Wire

© Provided by WarriorsWire After a red-hot start to the season, the Golden State Warriors have officially hit a bumpy patch of their 2021-22 campaign. While the Warriors still hold ... Read more »

NBA Power Rankings: Suns reclaim No. 1 spot after Warriors' struggles

© Provided by WarriorsWire MORE: Read more »

Owen Hargreaves: Man Utd’s cursed yet brilliant midfield maestro

© PA Images Manchester United’s Owen Hargreaves, Champions League Final, Luzhniki Stadium, Moscow, 21 May 2008 Football is full of what-if stories, and nobody encapsulates that quite like former Manchester ... Read more »

Transfer rumours: Ronaldo demands, Bayern may sell Lewandowski

© Provided by 90min Cristiano Ronaldo / Robert Lewandowski | Clive Rose/Alexander Scheuber/Getty Images Cristiano Ronaldo’s entourage have told Manchester United that failure to qualify for the Champions League will ... Read more »

Sania Mirza e “CiCi” Bellis annunciano il loro ritiro dal tennis-

© Fornito da Quotidiano.Net La giornata di oggi, giovedì 20 gennaio, è stata caratterizzata anche da due annunci di ritiri nel circuito WTA. A dire addio sono due personaggi a ... Read more »

Links: Fresh in the GM role, it’s time for Kent Hughes to break out the to-do list

© Photo by Minas Panagiotakis/Getty Images Montreal News and Notes In his first press conference as GM, Kent Hughes admits he’s more excited about the challenges of his new role ... Read more »

Dallas Cowboys' coordinators Kellen Moore, Dan Quinn seeking NFL head coaching jobs

By all accounts, the Dallas Cowboys are not replacing head coach Mike McCarthy. But the shocking 23-17 loss to the San Francisco 49ers in Sunday’s NFC wild card game, abruptly ... Read more »

Newcastle fail in £29m Hugo Ekitike transfer bid after including ‘impossible bonuses', claims Reims president

REIMS have revealed they have rejected Newcastle United’s £29million offer for Hugo Ekitike due to the ‘impossible bonuses’ in the deal. Struggling Toon’s leading scorer Callum Wilson suffered a calf ... Read more »

Forget Tanganga: £26m-rated Spurs calamity who won 33% duels proved Conte right again - opinion

© Provided by Football FanCast Spurs duo Emerson Royal and Hugo Lloris Tottenham Hotspur bolstered their claims for a top-four finish in the Premier League this season with a stunning ... Read more »

Meet Josh Oyinsan - the Paul Pogba body double who drove 500 miles to sign for Dumbarton

Joshua Oyinsan has revealed he will invite his French superstar pal Paul Pogba to watch him at Dumbarton. And new signing Josh admits he was so keen to Rock up ... Read more »
On free-english-test.com you will find lots of free English exam practice materials to help you improve your English skills: grammar, listening, reading, writing, ielts, toeic