World Bank review finds ‘pattern of government interference' in scrapped ‘Doing Business' rankings

audits revealed data irregularities in reports

Weeks before the World Bank scrapped its flagship Doing Business rankings following a damning independent probe, a group of external advisers recommended an overhaul of the rankings to limit countries’ efforts to “manipulate their scores”.

An 84-page review, written by senior academics and economists, was published on the bank’s website on Monday, about three weeks after it was submitted to World Bank chief economist Carmen Reinhart.

The World Bank on Thursday said it would cancel the “Doing Business” series on country business climates, citing internal audits and a separate independent probe by law firm WilmerHale that found senior World Bank leaders, including Kristalina Georgieva, who now heads the International Monetary Fund, pressured staff to alter data to favour China during her time as World Bank CEO. Georgieva has strongly denied the findings.

World Bank president David Malpass, in his first public comments since the data rigging controversy broke last Thursday, told CNBC that the WilmerHale report “speaks for itself” and that the bank will explore new approaches to helping countries improve their business climates.

The World Bank needs an introspection. It has been advocating country reforms for better governance, transparency, and practices. Now it has to use the prescription for its own reform

Mauricio Cardenas

The review published on Monday was written by a group assembled by the World Bank in December 2020, after a series of internal audits revealed data irregularities in reports on China, Saudi Arabia, the United Arab Emirates and Azerbaijan.

It calls for a series of remedial actions and reforms to address the “methodological integrity” of the “Doing Business” report, citing what it called “a pattern of government efforts to interfere” with scoring for the reports in past years.

“The World Bank needs an introspection. It has been advocating country reforms for better governance, transparency, and practices. Now it has to use the prescription for its own reform,” said Mauricio Cardenas, the Columbia University professor and former Colombian finance minister who chaired the expert panel.

The experts faulted the “Doing Business” series for lack of transparency about the underlying data and questionnaires used to calculate the rankings, called for a firewall between the Doing Business team and other World Bank operations, and creation of a permanent, external review board.

We have been informed of multiple cases where national governments have attempted to manipulate the [Doing Business] scores by exerting pressure on individual contributors

World Bank report

“We have been informed of multiple cases where national governments have attempted to manipulate the [Doing Business] scores by exerting pressure on individual contributors,” the report said, pointing to lawyers, accountants, or other professionals.

“World Bank staff mentioned several countries where they believe government officials have instructed contributors how to respond. And even in the absence of explicit government pressure, of course, the perceived threat of retaliation may influence the scores contributors report.”

The authors also called for the bank to stop selling consulting services to governments aimed at improving a country’s score, noting that they constituted an apparent conflict of interest.

“The World Bank should not simultaneously engage in scoring countries’ business environment while accepting payment to coach countries on how to improve their scores,” the authors wrote.

The World Bank offered Reimbursible Advisory Services (RAS) in a number of countries, including some of those implicated in the data manipulation investigation, such as China and Saudi Arabia, the review said.

In December 2020, the review said, one internal audit reported that bank management had pressured nine of 15 staff to manipulate data in the 2018 and 2020 issues of the Doing Business index, boosting Saudi Arabia to the “most reformed” spot globally and buoying the rankings of the United Arab Emirates and China, while dropping Azerbaijan from the top 10 rankings, the external advisers reported.

The separate WilmerHale report said that changes to Saudi Arabia’s data were “likely the result of efforts by a senior bank staff member to achieve a desired outcome and reward Saudi Arabia for the important role it played in the Bank community, including its significant and ongoing RAS projects”.

Justin Sandefur, a senior fellow at the Centre for Global Development in Washington and another member of the expert panel that produced Monday’s report, said that it showed “a governance problem” at the World Bank and he had not seen any assurances that similar problems would not continue with other data sets.

Internet Explorer Channel Network
News Related

OTHER NEWS

Gold prices climb above Rs 47,500/10 gm on positive global trend, weaker dollar

Gold prices soared above Rs 47,500 per 10 gram on October 19 tracking firm global trend and feeble dollar. The precious metal is trading above $1,780/oz levels breaching the intraday ... Read more »

Stock Blog: Higher Starts on Wall Street; AEX flirts with 800 points

Wall Street will start higher on Tuesday. Johnson & Johnson is in good shape, while Procter & Gabler has to give up ground. AEX is just below 800 points in ... Read more »

HUL's Q2 volume growth falls short of expectations, disappointing investors

Hindustan Unilever Ltd’s (HUL) September quarter results (Q2FY22) weren’t encouraging for investors, which is evident from the more than 3 percent drop in its share price on the National Stock ... Read more »

Alembic Pharma Q2 PAT may dip 49.2% YoY to Rs 169.4 cr: ICICI Direct

India business helped by COVID-19 and lower base of last year rose 57 percent to Rs 481 crore. ICICI Direct has come out with its second quarter (July-September’ 21) earnings ... Read more »

Tencent to set up privacy oversight committee, a requirement of China's personal information law starting next month

Tencent Holdings announced a new privacy oversight committee tasked with assessing the company’s user data protections, making it the first Big Tech firm in China to set up such a ... Read more »

Axis AMC, Inversion to raise Rs 3,500 crore buyout fund to invest in underperforming companies

Representative image Axis Asset Management Company and Inversion Advisory Services on October 19 announced a partnership to invest in underperforming companies. The two entities plan to jointly raise up to Rs ... Read more »

Nestle India Q3 Results | Profit rises to Rs 617 crore, revenue grows to Rs 3,883 crore on broad based domestic sales growth

Nestle has reached out to consumers through its advertisements in newspapers and asked them to reach out directly and raise their concerns about its products. FMCG giant Nestle India Limited, ... Read more »

Reliance Retail acquires 52% stake in Ritu Kumar brand

Ritu Kumar (Image: Company website) Reliance Retail Ventures on October 19 announced that it has acquired a 52 percent equity stake in Ritika Pvt Ltd that owns Ritu Kumar, Label Ritu ... Read more »

Coal, railway, power ministers discuss coal supply situation at power plants

Coal minister Pralhad Joshi on Tuesday discussed ways to improve coal stocks at thermal power plants with railway minister Ashwini Vaishnaw and power minister R K Singh. The meeting comes ... Read more »

Rural growth moderated in second quarter: HUL CMD Sanjiv Mehta

REUTERS/Danish Siddiqui Consumer demand in rural India, which was resilient since the onset of the pandemic, is now plateauing as the second wave of the pandemic wanes, Sanjiv Mehta, chairman ... Read more »

Here's why Democrats' proposed elimination of Roth conversions for the wealthy doesn't start until 2032

Photo by Mike Kline (notkalvin) | Moment | Getty Images House Democrats proposed a rule to forbid Roth conversions for the wealthy as part of a broad package of tax ... Read more »

Armenia, Russia agreed on gas price — Deputy PM

Gazprom is the sole gas supplier to Armenia Read more »

ACC Q3 Result | Profit rises to Rs 449 crore, revenue grows to Rs 3748.9 crore

acc ltd ACC, one of the top cement manufacturers in India and a subsidiary of Holcim Group, reported a consolidated profit after tax of Rs 449 crore for the quarter ... Read more »

PM's charm offensive yet to convince investors to part with their trillions

As the government bids to win over the richest international investors to its green agenda, Paul Kelso finds scepticism that the government means business despite a big energy partnership with Bill Gates. Read more »

Beer prices could jump by 30p per pint as pubs struggle with staff, energy and supply shortages

There are concerns that £6 a pint could become commonplace in pubs in London and the South East. Read more »

IMF cuts Asia's growth forecast, warns of supply chain risks

The International Monetary Fund on Tuesday slashed this year’s economic growth forecast for Asia and warned that a fresh wave of COVID-19 infections, supply chain disruptions and inflation pressures pose ... Read more »

Xpeng-backed HT Aero secures US$500 million in Asia's largest financing deal for a flying car start-up

HT Aero, a Chinese company that is developing flying cars, has raised US$500 million from a clutch of investors, the most for any urban air transport start-up in Asia. The ... Read more »

Chennai Super Kings' win in IPL 14 to dial up Dhoni's brand value

MS Dhoni has invested in companies including Khatabook, Cars24, and RunAdam Sports. (Image: IPL/BCCI/Twitter) Cricketer MS Dhoni leading his team Chennai Super Kings (CSK) to fourth win in the Indian Premier ... Read more »

Travel and tourism industry resumes hiring, momentum to pick up from Q4

The travel and tourism sector, one of the worst affected by the pandemic-induced lockdown and resultant job losses, is seeing a revival in hiring. Following the lifting of travel restrictions, ... Read more »

HeidelbergCement India Q2 profit down 4.55% to Rs 59.56 crore

HeidelbergCement India Ltd on Tuesday reported a 4.55 per cent decline in its net profit to Rs 59.56 crore for the second quarter ended September 2021 on account of increased ... Read more »

Russian media watchdog expects removal of prohibited information from Twitter — official

"Sanctions applied against them led to their removal of more than 90% of prohibited information and just a little is left to achieve complete purity," head of the regulator Andrei Lipov said Read more »

Alibaba launches own chip for its servers, cloud computing platform in ‘new breakthrough' for e-commerce giant

Chinese e-commerce giant Alibaba Group Holding has unveiled its own general-purpose central processing unit (CPU), the Yitian 710, for its Panjiu servers that will drive the company’s vast cloud computing ... Read more »

Cabinet approves B92 bn more support measures

A sign announces that a shop is participating in the Kon La Krueng (Half-Half) co-payment scheme at the Chatuchak weekend market in Bangkok. (Photo: Pornprom Satrabhaya) The cabinet on Tuesday ... Read more »

ACC profit rises to Rs 449 crore, revenue grows to Rs 3748.9 crore in September quarter

acc ltd ACC, one of the top cement manufacturers in India and a subsidiary of Holcim Group, reported a consolidated profit after tax of Rs 449 crore for the quarter ... Read more »

Technical View: Nifty forms Bearish Engulfing pattern, experts say avoid buying the dip

The Nifty started off the day above 18,600 but failed to sustain the momentum due to selling pressure in FMCG, metals, pharma and some banking & financial stocks. The index ... Read more »

DCM Shriram Q2 profit up 33.2%; says business environment remains disruptive

DCM Shriram on Tuesday posted a 33.2 per cent increase in consolidated net profit to Rs 159 crore for the second quarter of 2021-22 on strong sales. The company’s net ... Read more »

WGC predicts strong demand for gold in India in 2022 provided there are no fresh Covid outbreaks

The World Gold Council (WGC) has said that though demand for gold may be more subdued than expected this year following India’s prolonged battle with COVID-19, in 2022 economic growth ... Read more »

Network 18 Media Q2 Result | Consolidated revenue rises 31% to Rs 1,387 crore

Representative image Network 18 Media & Investments on October 19 posted consolidated revenue of Rs 1,387.2 crore for the quarter ended September 30, 2021, against Rs 1,061 crore logged in ... Read more »

Demand slump and output rise hit cardamom price, hurt growers

Tepid domestic demand and a slowdown in exports owing to Saudi Arabian concerns over pesticide presence in Indian shipments have hurt trading in cardamom at a time when India is ... Read more »

Austrian, Russian ministers plan intergovernmental commission in Vienna for October 21

On the whole, it is planned to sign three agreements Read more »

Hometown Cha-Cha-Cha star Kim Seon-ho loses endorsements after dating abuse allegations are linked to him

Kim Seon-ho, the star of hit South Korean television show Hometown Cha-Cha-Cha, was embroiled in scandal shortly after the series finale aired on October 17. The following day, anonymous allegations ... Read more »

Axis Bank to waive 12 EMIs on select home loans under festive offer

Axis Bank (Representative image) Private sector lender Axis Bank on Tuesday announced waiver of 12 EMIs on select home loan products, and discounts on various online purchases as part of ... Read more »

Upcoming office supply likely to keep vacancies high, rents under pressure: Edelweiss Research

Office rentals remained stable across the major markets in India in Q2 2021. Progress on vaccination rollout and resumption of employees’ return to offices bode well for office demand but ... Read more »

Simply Save | Why it is important to make international investments across emerging and developed markets?

Investing in international funds has got much wider acceptance among mutual fund (MF) investors. AMFI data shows the number of mutual fund folios in fund of funds (FoFs) investing in ... Read more »

Nestle India Q2 Results | Profit rises to Rs 617 crore, revenue grows to Rs 3,883 crore

Nestle has reached out to consumers through its advertisements in newspapers and asked them to reach out directly and raise their concerns about its products. FMCG giant Nestle India reported profit ... Read more »

Evergrande: concerns linger even as embattled developer's Hengda unit makes interest payment on US$327 million onshore bond

China Evergrande Group made its first interest payment on its corporate bonds in nearly a month on Tuesday as questions continue to swirl about its ability to service its massive ... Read more »

Evercore ISI downgrades Marriott to in-line, says stock has little upside left after recent rally

This photo shows a woman walking past Marriott signage in Hangzhou in China's Zhejiang province.- | AFP | Getty Images The hotel industry appears to be rebounding faster than many ... Read more »

Gainers & Losers: 10 stocks that moved the most on October 19

The Indian market snapped its seven-day winning run to end lower on October 19. At close, the Sensex was down 49.54 points, or 0.08%, at 61,716.05, and the Nifty was ... Read more »

Taking Stock: Market slips from record high; realty, metal, FMCG take a hit

On a day of volatile trade, benchmark indices hit record highs in the opening hours on October 19 only to slip on profit-booking to close in the red, snapping a ... Read more »

Russia plans to invest $1 bln in the Armenian economy in the near future

In particular, the investments will contribute to the creation of new high-tech jobs and facilitate exchange in various areas of the economy, culture, and infrastructure development Read more »