Wordle rip-offs want your cash — but are they legal?

Asia's Tech News Daily

Mobile app, Software developer, Apple, apps, also rip off, developers, Follow @plugged

A viral game that’s inspired copious clones has exposed the complexities of copyrighting apps — and the shamelessness of greedy imitators.

has attracted more than 2 million daily players since its launch in November. The puzzles challenge you to guess a five-letter word, but you can only play one of them a day — an appealing constraint in an era of ruthlessly addictive games.

Another of its charms is that Wordle’s creator, Josh Wardle, made the browser-based game completely free.

That good deed was soon punished.

Zachary Shakked, an NYC-based entrepreneur, swiftly exploited Wardle’s generosity. Not only did Shakked steal Wordle’s name, gameplay, and layout, he also had the gall to monetize his rip-off. Users were offered trial subscriptions for a $29.99 a year “Pro” version of his iOS app.

I love Wordle so much I decided to make my own Wordle app but with a twist! There’s not just 5-letter words, but also 4, 6, and 7 letter words too! You can also play unlimited times if you’re on the Pro version.

— Zach (@zachshakked)

Apple has now removed the clone from the App Store, but the company’s move doesn’t mean that Shakked violated copyright laws.

Simon Portman, a partner at IP law firm , told TNW that the episode exposes a legal gray area:

Just because someone makes their own game or app available for free, [it] doesn’t mean no proprietary rights attach to it or that the entity making the game available has chosen to waive the rights it has.

What’s in a name

The biggest legal issue for Shakked may have been his choice of title: “Wordle – The App.” It certainly sounds familiar.

While the original game doesn’t appear to be trademark protected, the clone could still have violated IP rights.

In the UK, for instance, copying a name — or even using a similar one — can be a breach of “passing off,” a law that protects unregistered rights from misrepresentation.

The Wordle copycat could be accused of passing off because the market may assume that the two games come from the same source.

However, the “free to play” aspect of Wordle could undermine this allegation.

“Is the creator trading if there are no user costs involved and no revenue is generated through advertisements? The answer is, probably not,” said Daniel Goodall, associate and IP expert at the law firm .

“This puts Wordle’s creator in a difficult position in terms of protecting the name without any evidence of trading activity.”

Gaming the system

The name is not the only IP issue at play. There are also potential infringements of gameplay elements, but these are harder to protect.

“You cannot copyright an idea, so the game mechanics could not be protected in this way,” said Goodall.

“However, copyright can exist in various aspects of the game itself, for example, graphics, text, and sounds, provided they are sufficiently original.”

Wordle, however, is quite a basic concept, so the creator may struggle to provide sufficient originality. Indeed, the game has faced its own accusations of plagiarism.

Forms of flattery

After his app was removed by Apple, Shakked that “he had crossed a line.” Yet he argued that Wordle is itself a ripoff of the game show Lingo.

Lingo’s current presenter, Adil Ray, tweeted that Wordle “basically is OURS.”

Hey peeps, if you’re going to play a game that looks like ours, works like ours, smells like ours and basically is OURS it’s only right you give us a plug. Lingo back today 😍🤪

— Adil Ray OBE (@adilray)

Yet Ray didn’t mention that his show was also strikingly similar to several predecessors, such as Mastermind and Jotto.

As former Kickstarter CTO , games with similar mechanics have existed since at least the 19th century.

There is, however, a difference between adapting mechanics and tricking people into paying for a game that they could already get for free. In the end, Apple intervened before the law did.

“What is clear is that, whether or not these cloned games constitute an infringement of Wardle and [his partner’s] intellectual property rights from a legal perspective, they violate the terms of service of the Apple App Store, which has already taken action to remove them accordingly,” said Lucy Marlow, a senior associate at .

Apple may also rip off developers, but this was a welcome intervention. The lines between imitation and inspiration can be blurry, but cloning a free game for a cash grab is clearly a dick move — whether it’s legal or not.

 

Internet Explorer Channel Network
Asia's Tech News Daily
News Related

OTHER NEWS

Jalen Reagor's brutal day a painful reminder to Eagles fans he's not Justin Jefferson

Jalen Reagor wasn't the reason the Philadelphia Eagles lost to the Tampa Bay Buccaneers on Sunday. But he didn't help. In a game where pretty much everything that could go ... Read more »

Where to watch Euphoria season 2 episode 2 online, get 20% off HBO Max now

After one heck of a season premiere, the second season of Euphoria has already delivered plenty of drama, drugs, and violence, as well as emotional declarations and sparks flying in ... Read more »

Jordan Cashmyer, '16 and Pregnant' Alum, Dies at 26

Jordan Cashmyer, a woman who was featured on MTV’s “16 and Pregnant” in 2014, died in Maryland on Sunday. She was 26 years old. News of Cashmyer’s death was shared ... Read more »

Self-isolation law set to be scrapped in favour of move towards ‘learning to live with Covid'

People would no longer be legally bound to self-isolate after catching coronavirus – Rasid Necati Aslim/Anadolu Agency via Getty Images People will no longer be legally bound to self-isolate when ... Read more »

A 61-year-old man was arrested and charged with murder after turning himself in to police for pushing an Asian woman in front of an oncoming subway train, authorities said

Times Square 42 St subway underground station in NYC with an old vintage inscription mosaic sign on the wall from tiles with symbols in terra cotta.Nicolas Economou/NurPhoto via Getty Images ... Read more »

Ukraine reveals website attacks were 'cover for more destructive actions'

A government official dismissed the fake ransomware note's threat, but warned the country would feel the consequences of the destructive attack "in the near future". Read more »

Steelers vs Chiefs live stream: how to watch NFL playoff game online

Will Ben Roethlisberger’s career end on a bum note, or can he summon the spirit of 2005 and pull off the shock of the Wild Card Weekend? With all of ... Read more »

Tencent's 2022 strategy indicates a downsizing of vast tech empire to ride out China's regulatory storm, fuel new growth

Chinese internet giant Tencent Holdings may opt for more divestments and pursue fewer acquisitions this year, according to analysts, in the wake of Beijing’s tightened regulation of the country’s Big ... Read more »

How to watch Australian Open 2022 and live stream tennis online from anywhere, schedule, draw

Once upon a time they called it the Happy Slam, but Novak Djokovic’s scrape with the Aussie authorities has injected a feverish blaze into proceedings. The squabbling will of course ... Read more »

Shop Anthropologie home décor, clothing and more at up to 70% off for a limited time

— Recommendations are independently chosen by Reviewed’s editors. Purchases you make through our links may earn us a commission. Stay on-trend this winter with stylish staples from Anthropologie. Whether you’re ... Read more »

Trump claims he couldn't have lost the 2020 presidential election because his Arizona rally boasted thousands of attendees and 'had cars that stretch out for 25 miles'

Former President Donald Trump reacts to the crowd prior to speaking at a “Save America” rally in Florence, Ariz., on January 15, 2022.AP Photo/Ross D. Franklin Former President Trump on ... Read more »

'Keep doors and windows locked', locals told after deadly attack on elderly couple

Freda Walker, 86, is killed and her husband, Kenneth, 88, left with ‘horrific injuries‘ in shocking incident at their Derbyshire home Residents in a Derbyshire town have been told to ... Read more »

This laptop from 1989 can mine Bitcoin, but it definitely won't make you rich

A developer has managed to turn a laptop from 1989 into a cryptocurrency mining machine, but it won’t be making anyone rich any time soon. The computer in question is ... Read more »

Wayfair's huge home and kitchen sale lets you save up to 60% on Cuisinart, KitchenAid and more

— Recommendations are independently chosen by Reviewed’s editors. Purchases you make through our links may earn us a commission. Spruce up your home for less this year with best-selling pieces ... Read more »

I don't care if gaming chairs suck, I'm not buying a Herman Miller

If you ask for any recommendations online when looking for a new gaming chair, chances are you’ll be told at least once that all ‘racing’ style chairs (named such as ... Read more »

49ers vs Cowboys live stream: how to watch NFL playoff game online

It’s being tipped as the game of the Wild Card Weekend, with Dallas D looking like the perfect opponents for the Niners’ run-heavy offense, but more importantly, if you watch ... Read more »

A 74-year-old woman was exonerated of the rape and murder of her niece after spending 27 years in prison

A cell in the new HMP Bronzefield (women’s prison) in Ashford Middlesex, England.Tim Ockenden – PA Images/PA Images via Getty Images Joyce Watkins was exonerated after a wrongful conviction led ... Read more »

Giant crocodile found under floorboards of primary school classroom goes on display

The remains of a saltwater crocodile found underneath a classroom at a Welsh Primary School have gone on display after being restored. (Rhondda Cynon Taf Council) A 120-year-old crocodile found ... Read more »

Take 25% off best-sellers during this 48-hour Everlane sale—shop jeans, leggings, outerwear and more

— Recommendations are independently chosen by Reviewed’s editors. Purchases you make through our links may earn us a commission. A minimalist wardrobe makes getting dressed in the morning really simple. ... Read more »

The 48 best MLK Day sales to shop right now—Michael Kors, Fenty Beauty, Macy's, QVC and more

— Recommendations are independently chosen by Reviewed’s editors. Purchases you make through our links may earn us a commission. Martin Luther King Jr. Day honors the groundbreaking work of minister ... Read more »

Correction: Virgin Orbit-Launch story

LOS ANGELES — In a story published January 13, 2022, about a Virgin Orbit launch, The Associated Press erroneously reported that Richard Branson said 480 countries can use Virgin Orbit. ... Read more »

A guide to finding your favorite streaming program: Talking Tech podcast

Hit play on the player above to hear the podcast and follow along with the transcript below. This transcript was automatically generated, and then edited for clarity in its current ... Read more »

Super Bowl TV deal at Best Buy: Sony's 85-inch 4K TV gets $400 slashed off price

The Super Bowl is officially less than a month away, and Best Buy is kicking things off with epic TV deals that you can shop right now. Our favorite bargain ... Read more »

Shop best-selling lululemon leggings, hoodies, joggers and more during the We Made Too Much sale

— Recommendations are independently chosen by Reviewed’s editors. Purchases you make through our links may earn us a commission. lululemon’s cult-favorite leggings are luxurious and certainly splurge-worthy for good reason. ... Read more »

Carol Vorderman looks incredible in curve-hugging activewear on Portuguese health retreat

Carol Vorderman set pulses racing on Sunday as she posed in activewear ahead of a long day of hiking on her luxe Portuguese health retreat. SEE: Carol Vorderman's grand home ... Read more »

Dozens of people flee in panic after hearing a "gunshot" in a UK McDonald's

Shocking footage shows dozens of people fleeing in panic after hearing a “gunshot” in a packed McDonald’s in Manchester. Video shows a huge 30-people brawl break out at the restaurant ... Read more »

‘Such a mess': Andy Murray and tennis world react to Djokovic's deportation

Photograph: Loren Elliott/Reuters Most players have avoided addressing case on social media Murray: ‘I respect Novak, I don’t like that he is in this situation’ The tennis world reacted with ... Read more »

6 ways open-source devs can make money

The amount of money you can make from open source code depends on several factors. First of all, the popularity of your open source project plays a significant role that ... Read more »

Eagles vs Buccaneers live stream: how to watch NFL playoff game online

Tom Brady to go one and done? Surely not, but then again he is missing two of his favorite targets, in Chris Godwin and Antonio Brown. Even so, the Eagles ... Read more »

Samsung Galaxy Z Fold 4 needs to up its game to compete with other foldable phones

The Samsung Galaxy Z Fold 3 currently holds the ‘best foldable phone’ title in its grip – but it’s a weak grip, that looks set to break very soon if ... Read more »

The iPad Pro 2022 could support MagSafe through a glass Apple logo

It looks likely that there will be an iPad Pro 2022 making an appearance at some point this year, and new details have emerged about one of the new features ... Read more »

Peloton Bike review

Two-minute review If you’re interested in fitness, it’s likely you’ve heard of Peloton. It’s a relatively recent addition to the home fitness market that aims to give you a boutique ... Read more »

Nvidia RTX 3090 Ti leaked pricing suggests a wallet-damaging GPU

Nvidia RTX 3090 Ti pricing has leaked from some European retailers, and it seems the new flagship graphics card will take perhaps a chunkier bite out of your wallet than ... Read more »

Novak Djokovic deported: tennis star leaves Australia after losing visa case - latest updates

Djokovic says he is 'extremely disappointed' at decision World No 1 to leave Australia on flight at 11.30am GMT on Sunday ​Novak Djokovic has been deported from Australia after federal ... Read more »

How to get started with open water swimming

Swimming is a great activity if you’re looking to get in shape and stay that way. Hitting the local pool on a regular basis is perfect for burning calories, keeping ... Read more »

'Non-fungi-what?' How I explained NFTs to my boomer parents

NFTs, or “non-fungible tokens,” are having their breakthrough moment. In just the past few months, they’ve evolved from mostly curiosity’s to more commonplace collectibles. On Thursday alone, people spent nearly ... Read more »

Here's another reason you should be careful about what you post online

There are plenty of reasons to exercise caution when posting content online, but more attention needs to be paid to the potential impact on employability, a new report suggests. According ... Read more »

British girl, 5, dies in horror ski slope accident in French Alps

The girl died in the ski resort of Flaine (pictured) (Pixabay ) A 5-year-old British girl has been killed in a tragic accident on a ski slope in the French ... Read more »

Amanda Holden enlists vacuum cleaner and thigh-high black boots for 'epic' garage singing session

Amanda Holden channelled her inner pop star to wind down at home this weekend. (Getty Images) Possibly as part of a commendable effort to lift people's January spirits, Amanda Holden ... Read more »

Covid tests for fully vaccinated travellers ‘to be scrapped this month'

Travel bosses will welcome the new changes (AFP via Getty Images) Vaccinated travellers will be able to go on holiday without taking <a href="/tag/covid-tests“>Covid tests on their return to the ... Read more »
On free-english-test.com you will find lots of free English exam practice materials to help you improve your English skills: grammar, listening, reading, writing, ielts, toeic