Windows 11: Déjà vu all over again?

Microsoft, Windows 11, Windows 11 FAQ, lawsuit charged Microsoft with deceiving consumers, Microsoft had made $1.5 billion, Microsoft's potential liability at $8.5 billion, here, sometimes with acknowledgements, HP, for example, Dell states

For long-time Microsoft watchers, there might have been a moment of déjà vu last month as the Redmond, Wash. developer announced its upcoming Windows 11 operating system.

The moment? When they read this line in the company’s official Windows 11 FAQ: “If you’re currently shopping for a new PC look for ‘Free upgrade to Windows 11’ on the fact tag.”

A decade and a half ago, Microsoft used something similar to market the PCs that were supposed to run its then-impending Windows Vista, with stickers at retail and labels online stating which machines were “Vista Capable.”

That 2006 campaign was a disaster for Microsoft. A lawsuit charged Microsoft with deceiving consumers with the Vista Capable program, which led to the release of embarrassing internal emails in which executives blasted the campaign and expressed frank opinions about the OS itself.

The company created the Vista Capable program to maintain PC sales momentum, notably during the holiday season of 2006, as the January 2007 launch of Vista neared. As revealed in court documents, Microsoft had bent to pressure from Intel, which needed to unload inventory, by lowering system requirements to include a bottom-level Intel graphics chipset.

Internally, some at Microsoft balked at the change in system requirements, calling Vista Capable PCs “junk” and telling personal tales of spending thousands on a system that, in the end, couldn’t run Vista or couldn’t deal with Vista’s advanced features, including the new Aero UI (user interface).

The lawsuit, which was awarded class-action status — dramatically expanding the pool of plaintiffs and, thus, the amount Microsoft might have to pay in damages assuming a loss — also revealed other bits of interest.

An expert for the plaintiffs, for instance, estimated that Microsoft had made $1.5 billion from the sale of licences for PCs marked as “Vista Capable” in the months leading up to OS launch. Other estimates pegged Microsoft’s potential liability at $8.5 billion if a settlement was reached.

There was no link between the Vista Capable debacle and the operating system’s later ultimate failure. (Vista was adopted by about one in five Windows users at its peak, less than a third reached by the precursor Windows XP or the successor Windows 7.) But the disclosures couldn’t have helped; they reinforced the reputation already being built for Vista, that it was an over-ambitious effort that needed a higher-horsepower PC.

Huge numbers of users decided to stick with XP and ride that pony until it dropped in early 2014, then switch to Windows 7, skipping Vista.

Security drives the bus

Windows 11 could experience similar headwinds because, like Vista, its system requirements are more exacting than its antecedent.

“This next generation of Windows will raise the security baseline by requiring more modern CPUs, with protections like virtualisation-based security (VBS), hypervisor-protected code integrity (HVCI), and Secure Boot built-in and enabled by default to protect from both common malware, ransomware, and more sophisticated attacks,” Microsoft said in a post on the operating system’s approach to security.

Windows 11’s system requirements can be found here and here.

The stumbling block will be the processor requirement, which Microsoft said — after some initial dissembling — would definitely put Intel’s 8th-generation (and AMD’s Zen 2) on the Windows 11-compatible side, with the possibility that 7th-generation (and Zen 1) will be as well. Anything earlier, and the device will be out in the cold.

Bottom line: Some PCs sold relatively recently, say in the last three years, may not run the new OS.

Microsoft couched the harsher requirements — relative to previous OS upticks, anyway — as necessary for security purposes. That’s the case, too, with the requirement of TPM, or “Trusted Platform Module,” version 2.0, for its ability to securely store encryption keys and the like.

Microsoft called TPM 2.0 “a critical building block” for security and contended that “PCs of the future need this modern hardware root-of-trust to help protect from both common and sophisticated attacks like ransomware and more sophisticated attacks from nation-states.”

All this led to confusion right from the start. Which PCs would run Windows 11? Which might? Microsoft botched the opening round so badly that it yanked a compatibility checker and rewrote (or clarified, your pick) pieces and posts about requirements multiple times, sometimes with acknowledgements that it was doing so, sometimes, well, without.

Free upgrade to Windows 11

Microsoft will not want to repeat the Vista Capable mistake with an official declaration on each PC. Instead, sellers will mark such systems with the “Free upgrade to Windows 11” phrase.

Microsoft may clarify this, but if that’s all the company will do for available PCs, it smacks of an obtuse and opaque manoeuvre meant to avoid responsibility. A label reading “Free upgrade to Windows 11” guarantees nothing about compatibility.

The simplest solution would be to mark devices “Will run Windows 11,” but something that straight forward would risk a repeat of Vista Capable. No surprise — that’s not the direction Microsoft went.

OEMs (original equipment manufacturers) don’t have the luxury of dodging the question. They’re using an if-we-have-it-then-it-will-run-11 tactic to inform potential customers that their wares are capable of running Windows 11. Some have already done so.

HP, for example, tells customers “Our current Windows-based PCs will be upgradeable to Windows 11 when it’s available later this year,” albeit with a caveat that some features require specific hardware. Likewise, Dell states, “All Dell PCs with Windows 10 currently being sold on will be able to upgrade to Windows 11” on its website.

Ironically, Microsoft hasn’t followed the lead of Dell and HP; pages touting its own Surface line do not make the same claim that all will run the new OS. There is some copy about the compatibility checker, however, the one Microsoft withdrew and is reworking.

Older devices can still ‘run’ Windows 11

It’s no coincidence that Microsoft announced Windows 11 and the “Cloud PC” concept dubbed “Windows 365” within three weeks of each other.

Unlike previous OS turnovers, Microsoft has an end-around it can offer customers — commercial customers initially, but you can expect it to filter down to very small businesses/consumers later — who find themselves with hardware that can’t meet the operating system’s system requirements.

According to Microsoft, the virtualised instances of Windows 11 that Windows 365 will create, store, and maintain on the firm’s Azure service will stream to any device equipped with a browser and connected to a sufficiently fat pipe to the Internet. The local PC, if that’s what it is, could be powered by a not-suitable-for-Windows-11 6th-generation Intel processor, and it wouldn’t matter.

Computerworld expects that Microsoft will use this to pitch Windows 365 to organisations that want to move to Windows 11 but that have a heterogeneous collection of desktops and laptops, some able to run the OS natively, some unable to as much as boot up 11. While Windows 11 could be deployed to the former, the latter would need to be physically replaced with newer devices or set up with Windows 365 licences.

Even if the organisation intended to replace the aged PCs with newer, physical devices, Windows 365 could be used until their replacement cycles come around.

News Related


'Integral', 'Closing in' - BBC pundit thrilled as 'massive news for Rangers' emerges

© Provided by Transfer Tavern Ryan Jack in action for Rangers vs Celtic Speaking to Football Insider, BBC Radio Leeds pundit Noel Whelan has been left thrilled by an injury ... Read more »

Premier League table 2021/22: Latest standings, fixtures, results for gameweek 5 - Liverpool top

© Getty Images premierleaguetrophy13082021A.jpg Leeds United and Newcastle got the fifth round of Premier League fixtures off to an entertaining start on Friday night as they drew 1-1 at St. ... Read more »

Father shouts ‘is this really happening' as he returns home to find three daughters dead

© Facebook Dickason famil thumbnail_IMG_5252.jpg A father cried out “is this really happening” after finding his three daughters dead at his new home in New Zealand days after being released ... Read more »

Strictly's John Whaite prepared himself for ‘hate' over show's first all-male partnership

Strictly Come Dancing contestant John Whaite has admitted that he braced himself for ‘hate’ when it was announced that he was to be part of the show’s first ever all-male ... Read more »

Help: Jodie Comer drama praised as ‘heartbreaking' by Channel 4 viewers

Channel 4 viewers are praising the new Jodie Comer–Stephen Graham drama Help as “heartbreaking” and “f****ing amazing” on social media. Set against the backdrop of a fictional care home in ... Read more »

JBL Flip 5 vs JBL Charge 5: the waterproof Bluetooth speakers go head to head

JBL makes some of the best Bluetooth speakers on the planet, and the Flip 5 and Charge 5 are no exceptions – and that makes choosing between them very difficult ... Read more »

50 years of The Persuaders!

Roger Moore as Lord Brett Sinclair in The Persuaders! – The Man in the Middle – ITV/REX/Shutterstock At 8pm on 16 September 1971 viewers of Granada and Anglia were treated ... Read more »

Inspiration4 Give Tour of SpaceX Dragon — Including the 'Largest Continuous Window Ever Flown in Space'

Inspiration4 Give Tour of SpaceX Dragon — Including the ‘Largest Continuous Window Ever Flown in Space’ SpaceX/Youtube The Inspiration4 are checking in from outer space! On Friday, the group — ... Read more »

Parents love Hanna Andersson pajamas—and right now, they're 50% off

— Recommendations are independently chosen by Reviewed’s editors. Purchases you make through our links may earn us a commission. Bed time isn’t always easy if you have little ones—but tucking ... Read more »

Communist party leader calls for action as observers report violations in Duma election

© Copyright 2021 The Associated Press. All rights reserved Chechen women wait to fill in their ballots at a polling station during the elections in Grozny, Russia – AP The ... Read more »

ICYMI: We test out the GoPro Hero 10 Black action cam

This week we’ve got a few reviews for music and photography enthusiasts. First, James Trew put the GoPro Hero 10 Black through its paces and was impressed by the capabilities ... Read more »

Sarah Palin Says She's Not Vaccinated Because She Believes ‘In Science'

Sarah Palin, the 2008 GOP vice presidential nominee, said this week that she has not received the COVID-19 vaccine because she believes “in science.” During an interview with Fox News ... Read more »

Rare copy of US Constitution expected to fetch record sum at auction in New York

© Copyright 2021 The Associated Press. All rights reserved Auction US Constitution – Copyright 2021 The Associated Press. All rights reserved A rare copy of the US Constitution is set ... Read more »

Govee Flow Pro Light Bars review: a simple way to add a splash of colour to your gaming setup

Back in the day, RGB lighting for your PC was very much a DIY affair and ambient lighting wasn’t really a thing. Now it’s all the rage as movie and ... Read more »

Save £20 on all iPhone 13 pre-orders instantly with this exclusive code

Apple fans, rejoice! The brand new iPhone 13 series is now available to pre-order. And while just about every retailer under the sun is vying for your attention, Affordable Mobiles ... Read more »

It's not just you: Emergency software patches are on the rise

Apple's iMessage flaw offers a warning: Zero-day flaws have become more common. But there's good reason for people not to worry — as long as they update their devices. Read more »

FIFA 22 Web App release date: When does FUT Web App come out?

© EA SPORTS The FIFA 22 Web App Release Date With many fans waiting to play the latest in the series, loyal gamers don’t have to worry about how long ... Read more »

Judge refuses woman's demand that hospital treat her husband with horse dewormer ivermectin

© Shutterstock / HJBC shutterstock_1953177811.jpg A Kentucky judge has refused to force doctors to administer a horse deworming drug after a Covid patient’s wife sued the hospital treating him. Angela ... Read more »

Strictly's Katie McGlynn's life after Corrie - hair transformation and Hollyoaks role

Strictly Come Dancing star Katie McGlynn is best known for playing Sinead Tinker in Coronation Street, a character who tragically passed away from cervical cancer in emotional scenes in December ... Read more »

‘Gran Turismo 7' director reiterates campaign and GT Cafe are not playable offline to prevent cheating

From the “Gran Turismo 7” trailer | Photo credit: YouTube screenshot “Gran Turismo 7” director Kazunori Yamauchi reiterated that they do not plan on making the game’s campaign mode available ... Read more »

These are the best motherboards to use with the AMD Ryzen 5 5600X

Getting the motherboard right in your PC build is important since it determines what CPU you can use. The AMD Ryzen 5 5600X is a mid-range processor with six cores ... Read more »

Best 2-in-1 Chromebook 2021: top hybrid Chromebooks for students and more

The best 2-in-1 Chromebooks offer the ease and functionality of a laptop with the versatility and touch features of a tablet, all powered by Google’s lightweight Chrome OS. © Provided ... Read more »

Teenager hospitalised after sticking USB cable in his penis

The USB cable knotted inside the teenager’s urethra. (Urology Case Reports) A 15-year-old boy was rushed to hospital after sticking a USB cable in his penis when “triggered by sexual ... Read more »

A pregnant woman who was kicked in the belly by the Taliban has been released from Afghanistan, US rep says

Taliban fighters stand guard at a checkpoint that was previously manned by American troops near the US embassy, in Kabul, Afghanistan, Tuesday, August 17, 2021. AP Photo A 25-year-old pregnant ... Read more »

BBC to pay Tiggy Legge-Bourke ‘significant' damages over Martin Bashir smears

Tiggy Pettifer, née Legge-Bourke, was the nanny to the Dukes of Cambridge and Sussex between 1993 and 1999 – Heathcliff O’Malley for The Telegraph Tiggy Legge-Bourke has been offered “significant” ... Read more »

Computer vision can help spot cyber threats with startling accuracy

This article is part of our , a series of posts that explore the latest findings in artificial intelligence. The last decade’s growing interest in was triggered by the proven ... Read more »

Gabby Petito and Brian Laundrie: Who are they and what do we know about their disappearance?

© Instagram/@gabspetito Untitled design.png On Saturday 11 September, a young woman named Gabby Petito was reported missing by her mother. She had been on a road trip with her boyfriend ... Read more »

Nancy Pelosi says Republican Party has been ‘hijacked by a cult'

© Copyright 2021 The Associated Press. All rights reserved Britain US Pelosi – Copyright 2021 The Associated Press. All rights reserved House Speaker Nancy Pelosi has urged Republicans to “take ... Read more »

Boy, 9, dies after being hit by a van in suspected hit-and-run

© File photo Police tape.jpg A man has been arrested after a nine-year-old boy died when he was hit by a van which is said to have made off from ... Read more »

Want to save the Earth? Then don't buy that shiny new iPhone

Photograph: Brooks Kraft/Apple On Tuesday, Apple released its latest phone – the iPhone 13. Naturally, it was presented with the customary breathless excitement. It has a smaller notch (eh?), a ... Read more »

COVID-19: Delhi records 41 new cases, zero death

No death due to COVID-19 was recorded in Delhi on Saturday, while 41 fresh cases were reported with a positivity rate of 0.06 per cent, according to data shared by ... Read more »

Start holiday shopping for the kids early with this sale on Melissa and Doug toys

— Recommendations are independently chosen by Reviewed’s editors. Purchases you make through our links may earn us a commission. When it comes to educational entertainment for kids and toddlers, it ... Read more »

Succession season 3 trailer reveals first look at Alexander Skarsgård in HBO show

© YouTube/HBO Alexander Skarsgård in ‘Succession’ season three – YouTube/HBO A new Succession trailer has given viewers a first glimpse at Alexander Skarsgård’s forthcoming performance on the HBO show. The ... Read more »

Gogglebox star Paige Deville reveals why she really left show

© Instagram/ Paige Deville Paige Deville_IMG_5249.jpg Gogglebox’s Paige Deville has revealed that she quit the show after falling out with her co-star mother Sally Hayward. The TV personality, 25, from ... Read more »

Israel reportedly used a remote-controlled gun to assassinate an Iranian scientist

Countries have assassinated people with drones, but those attacks now appear to include robotic weapons on the ground. The New York Timessources claim Israel assassinated top Iranian nuclear scientist Mohsen ... Read more »

Protesting DoorDashers want CEO Tony Xu to ‘step up', end ‘miserably underpaid' work

Earlier this month, social media was set abuzz by DoorDash (DASH) drivers in California protesting outside the home of CEO Tony Xu, in an effort to push for more transparency ... Read more »

As The GameCube turns 20, we look back on Nintendo's beloved, maligned, one-of-a kind console

Another year, another anniversary for the Nintendo GameCube – but as it reaches it’s 20th year, it’s hard not to look back wistfully on the console that formed so many ... Read more »

Save $800 on this 55-inch OLED TV at Best Buy this weekend

OLED TVs have developed a reputation for being sharp, clean, fragile, but also remarkably expensive. But this weekend you can save a whopping $800 on this 55-inch OLED TV from ... Read more »

iPhone 13 Pro Max vs Samsung Galaxy S21 Ultra: which 2021 flagship phone is for you?

Apple’s iPhone 13 range is official, and the iPhone 13 Pro Max is the big and shiny flagship phone leading the charge. © Provided by TechRadar iPhone 13 Pro Max ... Read more »

Recommended Reading: 'The Facebook files'

The Facebook files © Joshua Roberts / Reuters Facebook Chief Executive Mark Zuckerberg walks past members of the news media as he enters the office of U.S. Senator Josh Hawley ... Read more »