Will those responsible for O.C. oil spill pay for the damage? It could be a battle

Asia's Tech News Daily

Six years ago, a ruptured oil pipeline in Santa Barbara County sent 140,000 gallons of crude oil gushing onto the sands of Refugio State Beach.

Will those responsible for O.C. oil spill pay for the damage? It could be a battle
© (Al Schaben / Los Angeles Times) A boat pulls away from the oil platform Holly near Santa Barbara in March 2018. This month’s spill off the shore of Orange County could become an expensive repeat of the Refugio State Beach spill in Santa Barbara County six years ago. (Al Schaben / Los Angeles Times)

The company that owned the pipeline survived the onslaught of lost revenue and lawsuits that followed, but the offshore producer that used the line to transport its oil did not. After twice seeking Chapter 11 bankruptcy protection, Venoco Inc., eventually walked away from its drilling operation in Southern California, leaving the state to deal with millions of dollars in costs to close down the inactive wells.

Will those responsible for O.C. oil spill pay for the damage? It could be a battle
© (Myung J. Chun/Los Angeles Times) Workers from Patriot Environmental Services clean up oil that flowed into the Talbert Marsh in Huntington Beach on Oct. 3 following a spill off the Orange County coast. (Myung J. Chun / Los Angeles Times)

This month’s spill off the shore of Orange County, which dumped an estimated 25,000 gallons into the ocean, could become an expensive repeat of the Refugio spill, some experts say. The firm that operates the San Pedro Bay pipeline is facing intense pressure from federal regulators as well as businesses and residents suing over the effects of the spill.

Filing for bankruptcy protection, as Venoco did, could become an attractive option for the pipeline’s parent company, granting it temporary reprieve from financial and legal duress. But it’s too early to tell if Amplify Energy Corp. will take that step. Its oil production is less dependent on California than Venoco, but it’s also a relatively small player in an industry in which the financial blow from an environmental disaster can be devastating.

“They can easily throw their hands up and declare bankruptcy,” said longtime energy markets analyst and advisor Stephen Schork.

Amplify Energy and its subsidiaries are not considering Chapter 11 bankruptcy “at this time,” focusing instead on environmental cleanup and working with regulatory agencies investigating the spill, said Amy Conway, a company spokeswoman.

As U.S. oil production has declined, larger energy companies have shifted their attention to deep-water drilling, where vast reserves — and profits — remain untapped. The firms have sold off their aging, shallow-water platforms and pipelines to smaller players, which have struggled as the price of oil dropped. The threat of Chapter 11 bankruptcies among those companies surged during the pandemic.

Will those responsible for O.C. oil spill pay for the damage? It could be a battle
© (Allen J. Schaben / Los Angeles Times) Oil and gas platforms Edith, from left, Elly, Ellen are seen off the Southern California coast on Oct. 18. (Allen J. Schaben / Los Angeles Times)

Whether Amplify Energy eventually decides to seek bankruptcy protection depends on several factors, including the terms of the company’s insurance coverage and whether the shipping company operating the vessel that may have originally damaged the pipeline with its anchor is identified and held liable.

Investigators plan to cut apart the San Pedro Bay pipeline and transport the ruptured section to a lab for analysis, crippling the company’s California drilling operations. How long the pipeline remains shut down will be another significant factor for the firm, which draws about 14% of its total energy production from offshore operations in California, according to recent financial filings.

In the wake of the Santa Barbara spill, Venoco went out of business after the state refused to turn the pipeline back on, shutting off half the offshore company’s revenue. The state also refused to allow the company to use tankers to transport oil to shore.

Richard Carson, an economics professor at UC San Diego, was one of the principal economic investigators for the damage assessments after the Deepwater Horizon and Exxon Valdez spills. Contrary to some observers, he said that if the federal government finds that Amplify Energy was ultimately the responsible party, he doesn’t believe the company will be able to avoid financial responsibility for the spill by declaring bankruptcy or deflecting liability to subsidiaries.

“It would be really hard to have a federal oil lease off the coast of California and have set this thing up in such a way to deny the state and feds restitution making the public whole,” Carson said.

Amplify Energy said this month in a public notice that ran in several local newspapers that the firm may be liable for spill cleanup costs and damages. The notice, required by the 1990 federal Oil Pollution Act, says claims that may be reimbursed include damage to natural resources, damage to or loss of personal property, and loss of profits and earnings capacity.

Will those responsible for O.C. oil spill pay for the damage? It could be a battle
© (Allen J. Schaben / Los Angeles Times) A man takes in the scene of oil streaks in the sand after a major oil spill washed ashore at Huntington State Beach earlier this month. (Allen J. Schaben / Los Angeles Times)

Claims that are denied or not settled within three months can be sent to the National Pollution Funds Center for payment from the Oil Spill Liability Trust Fund, the company said in the notice. The fund, administered by the Coast Guard, is funded through a per-barrel tax on crude oil.

Federal law requires that oil companies keep $35 million available for oil spills of this size.

Since 2016, U.S. regulators have sought to tighten liability and decommissioning rules for offshore drillers, particularly in the Gulf of Mexico, where the majority of U.S. offshore drilling occurs, fearing that taxpayers would be forced to pay to close down unused oil platforms if more small players folded under financial pressure, said Tyler Priest, a University of Iowa associate professor who studies the history of oil and gas drilling.

But that attempt to increase bonding and insurance requirements, first proposed under the Obama administration, met heavy pushback from the industry. The rule was “nixed” under the Trump administration, said Priest, and remains unfinished despite forward momentum under the Biden administration.

It’s unclear how much insurance Amplify Energy carried at the time of the spill, but experts say it’s unlikely that the policies could pay for every claim.

The number of lawsuits piling up “may be a significant driver” of a potential bankruptcy, said Lexi Hazam, a San Francisco lawyer representing a group of plaintiffs that includes commercial fishers and a whale-watching company.

The number of legal complaints has already reached double digits, including those filed by Laguna Beach coastal property owners, a Huntington Beach surf school, a Seal Beach bait and tackle store, and several groups of fishing and seafood sales companies.

If Amplify Energy were to file for bankruptcy, there’s a good chance that plaintiffs wouldn’t see as much compensation as they hoped, experts say. Bankruptcy judges set the amount of potential damages that can be paid out by companies in Chapter 11, and even the federal government can’t force a company to cough up more than that amount, said Eric Smith, a business professor at Tulane University and associate director of the Tulane Energy Institute.

“You can bankrupt the company but there’s very little you can do to be completely reimbursed,” Smith said.

A potential bankruptcy wouldn’t spell the end of litigation, Hazam said, but it would result in “a different kind of process, and obviously, it involves a limit on the amounts that can be recovered.”

How much Amplify Energy ends up paying could also depend on how successfully the company isolated the risk of oil spills into its subsidiaries, a complicated web of limited liability companies and corporations.

An Amplify Energy subsidiary, Beta Operating Co., operates the oil rigs off the Orange County coast. Another, the San Pedro Bay Pipeline Co., is responsible for the pipeline that burst.

If the smaller outfits were deemed solely responsible for the spill and prosecutors and claimants could not connect blame for the pipeline spill back to Amplify Energy, then the company could cut the subsidiaries loose, allow them to fail and avoid a direct financial hit to its core business, some experts say.

“You can toss your subsidiary to the wolves,” said Ted Borrego, an oil and gas lawyer with five decades’ experience in the industry and adjunct professor at the University of Houston Law Center.

Amplify Energy is a relatively small firm with a balance sheet that pales in comparison to big international oil corporations. Its leadership has pursued a corporate strategy in recent years that left the company with little cash on hand when the spill took place.

A Times review of years’ worth of Amplify Energy’s financials reveals that the company’s leaders have long emphasized slashing costs, rebuying stock and paying millions of dollars in dividends to shareholders over maintaining a substantial cash reserve.

Amplify Energy itself arose from bankruptcy. Its corporate predecessor restructured four years ago, clearing $1.3 billion in debt. The new firm emerged leaner, with comparatively little cash on hand.

When the pandemic hit and oil prices dipped, Amplify Energy said it slashed costs 37%. A subsidiary also received a $5.5-million Paycheck Protection Program loan, later forgiven, to cover payroll costs for 292 employees.

In July, Amplify Energy had $235 million in debt and $21 million in cash on hand, far less than the anticipated cost of the cleanup and any legal damages.

Like the Santa Barbara spill, which is still being litigated, the Orange County disaster will be in court for years to come — and likely continue to incur costs in the interim.

This story originally appeared in Los Angeles Times.

Internet Explorer Channel Network
Asia's Tech News Daily
News Related

OTHER NEWS

Niederreiter trifft, Fiala mit Assist

© KEYSTONE/FR170489 AP/STACY BENGS Kevin Fiala feiert in der NHL mit Minnesota den dritten Sieg in Serie. Die Wild gewinnen zu Hause gegen Titelverteidiger Tampa Bay Lightning 4:2. Fiala steuerte ... Read more »

King scores 18 to lead Alcorn State past Milwaukee 61-57

MILWAUKEE (AP) — Paul King came off the bench to score 18 points, hitting 3-for-3 3-pointers, to lift Alcorn State to a 61-57 win over Milwaukee on Sunday. Lenell Henry ... Read more »

Sappy ending: Canada digs deep into strategic reserves to cover maple syrup shortage

Maple syrup producers have been forced to raid the world’s only stockpile of the highly valued sweet treat, as surging worldwide demand combined with an unusually short harvest season in ... Read more »

Deutschland: Polizei stoppt illegale Impfaktion mit selbstgemachtem Impfstoff

Offenbar haben sich in Deutschland bereits Tausende den selbstgemachten Impfstoff von einem Mediziner spritzen lassen. Bei einer öffentlichen Impfaktion griff die Polizei durch. Dem streitbaren Professor werden Experimente am Menschen ... Read more »

Jets report card: Win doesn't hide glaring problem

Grading the Jets’ 21-14 win over the Texans in Houston on Sunday. Offense Overall, the offense struggled. The Jets managed just 266 yards in the game and only 109 passing ... Read more »

Notae scores 28, No. 13 Arkansas tops Penn to stay unbeaten

FAYETTEVILLE, Ark. (AP) — JD Notae scored 28 points and No. 13 Arkansas handled Pennsylvania 76-60 on Sunday. Stanley Umude had 19 points and Au’Diese Toney scored 12 for the ... Read more »

Gabriella Brooks shows off her toned figure in a zebra print bikini

GABRIELLA Brooks gets striped for action in this zebra print bikini. The model, 25, posed up as the global ambassador of Aussie swimwear brand Seafolly. Gabriella is said to be ... Read more »

Saban: RB Brian Robinson suffered pulled muscle in Iron Bowl

Alabama tailback Brian Robinson Jr. has a pulled muscle that makes his status for the Southeastern Conference Championship Game against No. 1 Georgia uncertain. No. 4 Alabama’s coach Nick Saban ... Read more »

The Citadel defeats South Carolina State 91-79 in OT

ORANGEBURG, S.C. (AP) — Rudy Fitzgibbons, III scored six of his 20 points as The Citadel defeated South Carolina State 91-79 in overtime on Sunday. The Bulldogs, after ending regulation ... Read more »

Those old carrier bags at the back of your cupboard could be worth up to £225

VINTAGE plastic bags are being offered online for up to £225. Carriers from high street stores and supermarkets are being retrieved from the back of cupboards where they have sat ... Read more »

Vaani Kapoor shares BTS clips from Chandigarh Kare Aashiqui sets with Ayushmann Khurrana; Watch

© Provided by Pinkvilla Recently, Vaani Kapoor posted a compilation BTS clip from the sets ahead of Chandigarh Kare Aashiqui‘s release. The video is a reflection of the cast and ... Read more »

Nora Fatehi's sizzling belly dance on India's Best Dancer 2 leaves Terence Lewis bewitched; WATCH

© Provided by Pinkvilla India’s Best Dancer 2 has been entertaining viewers ever since it started airing on the small screens. The popular dance reality show is being loved widely ... Read more »

KitchenAid Black Friday and Cyber Monday deal 2021: 25% off the artisan stand mixer

Bake cookies and cakes at home with the help of one of these machines (iStock/The Independent) Great British Bake Off fans rejoice, for this candy-coloured stand mixer is in Amazon’s ... Read more »

Ku Li mahu berundur daripada politik pada PRU15

© Provided by Free Malaysia Today Tengku Razaleigh Hamzah adalah Ahli Parlimen Gua Musang selama 11 penggal sehingga kini. KUALA LUMPUR: Selepas lebih 50 tahun menjadi wakil rakyat, veteran Umno ... Read more »

'The Tories are drowning in a sea of desperation with incompetence and malice'

Demonising desperate men, women and children as if they are an Omicron Covid virus to be kept out of “Global Britain”, is the dirtiest politics. Shameless Boris Johnson and a ... Read more »

How to check the current Apex Legends map rotation?

© Provided by Dot Esports All Apex Legends players will get to learn the ins and outs of all the maps in the game as they continue to play. With enough time, ... Read more »

FIFA 22: How to complete Silver Stars Moments Phil Jones SBC – Requirements and solutions

© Provided by GamePur EA Sports and the FIFA 22 team are celebrating Black Friday with all kinds of new Squad Building Challenges (SBCs) for players to complete. And the ... Read more »

Fact Check: Picture of Amit Shah reading the Preamble goes viral with wrong claim

A picture of Union Home minister Amit Shah is widely circulating on social media, with netizens claiming he was reading the blank reverse side of the Preamble. Trinamool Congress spokesperson ... Read more »

MVA govt has failed on all counts: BJP, AAP; worked with all honesty, says deputy CM Ajit Pawar

© Provided by The Indian Express DESCRIBING THE two-year-old regime of Maha Vikas Aghadi (MVA) government as a “total failure on all counts”, BJP’s state president Chandrakant Patil on Sunday ... Read more »

UP teachers' exam cancelled over paper leak, 26 held

© Provided by The Indian Express Shortly before the recruitment exam for government teachers in Uttar Pradesh – Uttar Pradesh Teacher Eligibility Test or UPTET, 2021 – was set to ... Read more »

Reports: USC to hire coach Lincoln Riley away from Oklahoma

Southern California is finalizing a deal for Oklahoma’s Lincoln Riley to be its next coach in a stunning and rare move of one traditional college football powerhouse swiping another’s highly ... Read more »

Palm Springs quadruple homicide trial starts Monday; death penalty possible

Palm Springs quadruple homicide suspect Jose Larin Garcia makes an appearance in court Wednesday, Feb. 20, 2019. The murder case against a man accused of killing four people in Palm ... Read more »

Ava White: Boy, 14, charged with murder of 12-year-old in Liverpool

A teenager has been charged with the murder of 12-year-old Ava White in Liverpool city centre, police have said. The youngster had been in the city with friends on Thursday ... Read more »

Dutch police arrest couple who fled omicron quarantine hotel

© Provided by Daily Mail MailOnline logo Dutch police have arrested a couple who ‘fled’ an Omicron quarantine hotel and boarded a flight out of Holland – as the super-mutant ... Read more »

'Boris Johnson should be held accountable for going maskless in hospitals and theatres'

The third Omicron Covid case in the UK and the panicky tightening of restrictions, particularly mask wearing and travel tests, is Boris playing catch-up again? Bringing England into line with ... Read more »

Strictly's Shirley Ballas wows with a dramatic hair transformation

© Provided by Daily Mail MailOnline logo Shirley Ballas, 61, wowed fans as she revealed her dramatic hair transformation after deciding to get hair extensions for the first time.  The ... Read more »

MLB free agency roundup: Marcus Semien heads to Rangers; Byron Buxton inks Twins extension

With murmurs of a lockout and a collective bargaining agreement that will expire at midnight Dec. 2, Major League Baseball had a busy holiday weekend on the free-agency front. The ... Read more »

Giants report card: A defensive masterclass

Grading the Giants’ 13-7 win over the Eagles at MetLife Stadium on Sunday. Offense Yay, team! There were 264 total yards, 3 of 12 third-down conversions, no pass completion of ... Read more »

Test your musical knowledge against the experts behind iconic PopMaster quiz

RECKON yourself top of the pops? Now you can prove your charts knowledge in a PopMaster quiz. DJ Ken Bruce’s Radio 2 music quiz has run for two decades, and ... Read more »

Toy touts take advantage of supply shortage fears by hiking prices online

TOY touts are taking advantage of the HGV crisis and supply shortage fears by ramping prices online. The CoComelon Bedtime JJ Doll, out of stock at some retailers, is almost ... Read more »

TMJ, legenda dunia bincang bola sepak Asia Khamis ini

© Provided by Sinar Harian JOHOR BAHRU – Tunku Mahkota Johor (TMJ), Tunku Ismail Sultan Ibrahim akan menjadi penceramah undangan dalam perbincangan meja bulat secara digital bersama-sama legenda bola sepak ... Read more »

Jesy Nelson confirms romance with Emily in Paris hunk Lucien Laviscount on London date night

JESY Nelson has confirmed her romance with Emily in Paris hunk Lucien Laviscount as they were spotted out on a date night in London. The singer could be seen kissing ... Read more »

Impoverished family of five feared to have drowned in Channel tragedy after trying to reach UK for a ‘good life'

AN impoverished family of five who told The Sun they wanted to reach Britain for a “good life” are feared to have drowned in the Channel tragedy. Mum Kazhal Rzgar, ... Read more »

I'm a Celeb's Ant and Dec admit they ‘don't know when the show will be back' after Storm Arwen destruction

ANT McPartlin and Declan Donnelly have confessed they're not sure when I'm a Celebrity will be back on screens after the damage caused by Storm Arwen. The ITV show was ... Read more »

Omicron variant 'almost definitely' in U.S. -Former FDA chief

“Just looking at the number of cases coming off planes this weekend,” Gottlieb said, “it’s almost a certainty that there have been cases that have gotten into the United States.” ... Read more »

Children Kayak in Flooded Gunnedah Park After Days of Heavy Rain Hits New South Wales

Flooding prompted hundreds of New South Wales residents to request help from emergency services by Sunday, November 28, after heavy rain hit the southeastern Australian state. As of Saturday, more ... Read more »

U.S. Futures Rise, Oil Up as Traders Weigh Omicron: Markets Wrap

1 / 2U.S. Futures Rise, Oil Up as Traders Weigh Omicron: Markets Wrap (Bloomberg) — U.S. equity futures and crude oil rose Monday as traders weighed the possible impact of ... Read more »

Antiques Roadshow guest fears 'family dispute' after picture is valued at £20,000

A guest on Antiques Roadshow worried she’d started a “family dispute” after getting a small painting valued. A lady bought her prized possession, that was given to her from her ... Read more »

'Tear up the ENTIRE deal!' Boris urged to strike back in Brexit row if EU refuses to cave

The UK’s Brexit minister Lord Frost has continued to insist the Northern Ireland Protocol is not working, and has called for large parts of the mechanism to be completely overhauled. ... Read more »

Omicron symptoms mild so far; South Africa registers 2,858 new cases

South Africa registered 2,858 new Covid-19 cases, bringing the cumulative total to 2,961,406. A further six Covid-19-related deaths were reported, taking total official deaths to 89,797. A total of 25,288,417 ... Read more »
On free-english-test.com you will find lots of free English exam practice materials to help you improve your English skills: grammar, listening, reading, writing, ielts, toeic