‘Wicked' stepmother and ‘pitiless' father guilty over death of six-year-old

Asia's Tech News Daily

A “wicked” stepmother and a “pitiless” father have been convicted of killing his six-year-old son after subjecting the defenceless boy to a campaign of “evil” abuse.

Emma Tustin, 32, was unanimously convicted at Coventry Crown Court on Thursday of murdering Arthur Labinjo-Hughes.

Her partner and Arthur’s father, 29-year-old Thomas Hughes, was found guilty of manslaughter, after his son suffered an “unsurvivable brain injury” on June 16 2020.

Jurors, who took six hours and 15 minutes to deliver their unanimous verdicts, afterwards held a minute’s silence in Arthur’s memory.

In court, the pair had been described by prosecutors as “utterly ruthless, unthinking and pitiless”.

Speaking after the verdicts, Arthur’s maternal grandmother, Madeleine Halcrow, called them “wicked” and “evil”.

She also described the couple’s behaviour, which included Tustin poisoning the youngster by force-feeding him salt-laced meals, as “unfathomable”.

“I think they are cold, calculating, systematic torturers of a defenceless little boy.

“They’re wicked, evil.

“There’s no word for them, especially your own child,” said the grandmother.

An independent serious case review is now under way into the actions of Solihull Council social workers who found “no safeguarding concerns” after visiting Arthur, just two months before he was murdered.

The NSPCC said the pair’s convictions “must be just the start of the process to uncover the full chain of events that ultimately led to Arthur’s death and to establish the lessons that need to be learned to prevent this awful case from happening again”.

Emma Tustin, who was unanimously convicted of murder (West Midlands Police/PA)

Tustin carried out the fatal assault while in sole care of Arthur at her home in Cranmore Road, Solihull, violently shaking him and repeatedly banging his head, likely against the hallway wall.

She then callously took a photograph of the unconscious youngster on her mobile phone, while he lay dying in her hall, then sending the image to Hughes.

Tustin then took 12 minutes to call 999, instead first ringing Hughes, before lying to medics and later police that Arthur “fell and banged his head and while on the floor banged his head another five times”.

She then claimed at trial he must have thrown himself down the stairs, despite evidence he was so starved he was barely able to pick up his own bedding, or stand.

The attack happened the day before “coercive” and “controlling” Tustin’s birthday.

Hughes, of Stroud Road, Solihull, was convicted of manslaughter after encouraging the killing by his actions, including sending a text message to Tustin 18 hours before the fatal assault telling her “just end him”.

Thomas Hughes was convicted of his son’s manslaughter (West Midlands Police/PA)

On one occasion before his death, Arthur had told his father: “I am in danger with you, dad.”

The pair “de-humanised” Arthur, prosecutors said, with Tustin convicted of two counts of child cruelty by forcing him to eat salt-laced meals and starving the child, while also depriving him of water with Hughes cleared of those offences.

After his death, Arthur was found to have 130 injuries all over his body, after being hit, slapped, kicked, punched and beaten, “over and over”.

Tustin admitted two other counts of child cruelty, by wilfully assaulting the boy and isolating him in the home by making him stand up to 14 hours a day in the hallway with jurors convicting Hughes on both those counts.

The “chubby, happy” and “always smiley” boy, was left a weakened and frail shadow of himself, with one witness describing how he looked “broken” just before his death.

Tests later revealed Arthur had also been “poisoned with salt” in the hours before his collapse.

Arthur struggles to pick up his own bedding on the morning of his fatal assault (West Midlands Police/PA)

Detective Inspector Laura Harrison, the West Midlands Police officer who led the investigation, said the couple’s behaviour was “horrific”, “evil”, and unfathomable.

She added: “It’s the worst case I have had to investigate.”

Tustin, pregnant at the time with Hughes’ unborn child, would also video, photograph and record audio of Arthur while he was being tormented, with Hughes “relishing” inflicting further punishment on his son for minor infractions like failing to stand up for hours on end.

So weakened was Arthur by his ordeal, he was seen on the morning of his collapse struggling to lift his own Marvel Avengers blanket off the floor of the lounge where he was forced to sleep, without a mattress.

And footage of his morning routine showed how Arthur was beaten, manhandled and punished from the moment he was woken, at around 7am, each day, after he and his father moved in with Tustin at the start of the first national lockdown.

Hughes would also “pressure-point” Arthur for up to 15 seconds at a time, removed his son’s favourite teddy bear and cut up his prized Birmingham City FC football shirts in front of him.

But Hughes claimed he had been “manipulated”, “mentally abused” and “gaslighted” by Tustin into going along with her behavioural regime, which began with the strict use of “chair rules” and a “naughty step”, introduced by his partner.

He told jurors in evidence that he had “probably” placed the couple’s relationship above the welfare of his son.

Tustin, who had accepted some elements of the cruelty, told jurors she was “disgusted and ashamed” by that behaviour but continued to deny the full extent of her offending.

It emerged in court that after being charged, Tustin aborted the couple’s unborn child at 21 weeks without telling Hughes, while on remand in prison.

Ms Harrison, who said Tustin had shown no remorse, said: “I think Emma Tustin wanted a family unit and that didn’t include Arthur for some reason.”

The discipline started soon after the couple sparked up a “volatile and dysfunctional” relationship from August 2019.

It followed a period of traumatic upheaval for Arthur, whose natural mother Olivia Labinjo-Halcrow was jailed for killing her then partner in 2019, leaving Hughes in sole custody of their son.

Later Hughes would say it was a case of “discipline gone too far”, telling detectives “the last few weeks, I did turn into a monster”.

Tustin’s cruelty was also laid bare, as she recorded more than 200 audio files of Arthur, wailing and crying “no-one loves me” and “no-one’s gonna feed me”.

She would then send the recordings, including videos, to Hughes, encouraging him to punish and beat his son, as she was heard on at least one recording saying “You’re in trouble when your dad gets back”.

The abuse was stepped up towards the end of his life with Arthur poisoned with salt by Tustin, who made most of his meals though she pointed the blame at Hughes.

A medical expert who assessed sodium results in the little boy’s blood on his admission to hospital, found 34mg, a level so high it was off the “normal scale”.

Hughes’ mother, Joanne Hughes, had seen bruises on Arthur’s back, with the boy telling how Tustin “called him an ugly, horrible brat” and shoved him into the stairs.

She alerted children’s social services to the bruises in April, just weeks before his death.

But two social workers who saw Arthur at Cranmore Road, had “no safeguarding concerns”.

Solihull’s Local Child Safeguarding Partnership is now carrying out an independent review of the circumstances surrounding the “terrible tragedy”, including the actions of Solihull Council’s social services.

A council spokesperson said “it would be inappropriate for the council to comment ahead of the findings of that review”.

Peter Grice of the Crown Prosecution Service said the case evidence was “shocking”, adding “little Arthur’s case greatly disturbed me and is something I will never forget”.

An NSPCC spokesman said “The cruelty of Hughes and Tustin and the pain and suffering they inflicted on Arthur before they killed him almost defies belief.”

Tustin and Hughes will be sentenced on Friday.

Internet Explorer Channel Network
Asia's Tech News Daily
News Related

OTHER NEWS

Dubai: Man injured by glass bottle thrown from balcony dies after 10 days in ICU

© Provided by Khaleej Times A man, who was hit by a in JBR, died at a hospital in Dubai after suffering a severe head injury. The Omani national, who ... Read more »

Power Letters 2022: Mohamed Ebeid, CEO, EFG Hermes' Investment Bank; group executive committee member

© Motivate Publishing Mohamed Ebeid 2021 was definitely a great recovery year for EFG Hermes’ Investment Bank. We saw a lot of ECM (equity capital market) deals and M&A (merger ... Read more »

Covid-19: British PM Johnson wishes he had not attended lockdown gathering

© Provided by Khaleej Times British Prime Minister Boris Johnson attends a briefing on the coronavirus disease (COVID-19) pandemic, in Downing Street, London, Britain, January 4, 2022. Jack Hill/Pool via ... Read more »

Australian Open: Nadal beats Giron to launch Grand Slam record bid

© Provided by Khaleej Times Reuters Rafa Nadal launched his bid for a record 21st Grand Slam title with a 6-1 6-4 6-2 trouncing of American Marcos Giron on Monday ... Read more »

PED debate will decide this year's MLB Hall of Fame class

The 2022 Baseball Hall of Fame writers’ ballot might very well be the most fascinating and polarizing such referendum in the museum’s history. This week, ahead of the results being ... Read more »

Three dead and six injured in suspected drone attacks in Abu Dhabi

Three people have been killed and six are injured in suspected drone attacks in Abu Dhabi, according to reports. © Other Three people have been killed in tanker truck explosions ... Read more »

IDLES at Brixton Academy review: Subtle they ain't but this band is still explosively exciting

(Samir Hussein/WireImage) Staging a grand London comeback after spending most of the last two years in lockdown limbo, IDLES delivered a thrillingly kinetic, high-voltage show at the first of four ... Read more »

‘Light at the end of the tunnel' in fight against Covid in UK, says World Health Organisation

© AFP via Getty Images Dr David Nabarro suggests end is in sight for UK and Covid – AFP/Getty The Covid pandemic may be coming to an end in the ... Read more »

Doubts over Novak Djokovic's being able to compete in French Open as plane touches down in Serbia

Novak Djokovic could be denied permission to compete in the French Open as his plane touched down Serbia on Monday after being deported from Australia. The tennis star’s deportation from ... Read more »

NHS will start sacking unvaccinated staff early next month

The NHS will begin sacking staff who have not had a Covid vaccine in just over two weeks, new guidance reveals. © Andy Rain/EPA-EFE/Shutterstock NHS ambulances, London – Andy Rain/EPA-EFE/Shutterstock ... Read more »

Paying NHS bosses more doesn't boost hospital quality, study suggests

Employing more health managers or paying them higher salaries does not improve the quality of NHS hospitals, a study suggests. Those with lots of highly paid bosses are just as ... Read more »

Keith Urban and Nicole Kidman enjoy a humble kebab in Sydney

They’re entertainment royalty, sharing between them Grammy awards, Golden Globes and even an Oscar. And Keith Urban and wife Nicole Kidman revealed their no-fuss guilty pleasure meal last month as ... Read more »

Four-bedroom home in a pleasant Australian suburb goes on the market for FREE - but the lucky buyer should know there's a HUGE catch

Four-bedroom home in Kirrawee in Sydney's south is on the market for freeBut the new owner will need to pay to transport the home to a new locationSeller said the tenants living in the property were paying $700-a-week in rent Can be cheaper to offer house for removal than paying $25,000 for demolition Read more »

The incredible story of cricket star Usman Khawaja and his wife's selfless act before marrying him - but life hasn't always been easy

Usman Khawaja, 35, is a popular member of the Australian Test cricket teamJunior prodigy from NSW, his talent is obvious, yet career has been inconsistentRecently hit classy centuries in successive innings against England at the SCGAway from cricket, Khawaja is a qualified pilot, and also a proud father of one  Read more »

Peru communities reject latest proposal to end Las Bambas mine conflicts

© Reuters/ANGELA PONCE FILE PHOTO: Peru’s Andean rural residents complain of negative effects of mining activity By Marcelo Rochabrun SAYHUA, Peru (Reuters) – Leaders of a group of Peruvian communities ... Read more »

‘Picking quarrels': China critics overseas at increasing risk

Wang Jingyou was living in Turkey last year when he found that the 7,000 kilometres (4350 miles) between him and his homeland was no obstacle to an offended Chinese state. ... Read more »

Erde künstlich kühlen? Wissen­schaftler warnen vor Folgen

Weil es die Menschheit mit den Klimazielen nicht hinkriegt, sollen Flugzeuge Partikel in der Atmosphäre verstreuen. Doch einmal damit begonnen, gibt es vielleicht keinen Weg mehr zurück. © Foto: Nasa ... Read more »

Die 15 besten Materialien für einen gemütlichen Winter zuhause

Wer macht es sich im Winter nicht auch gerne zuhause so richtig gemütlich? In der meist doch eher dunklen, ungemütlichen und kalten Jahreszeit sind wir froh, wenn wir drinnen im ... Read more »

Tough travel across Quebec as up to 35 cm of heavy snow covers roads

Conditions will rapidly deteriorate across southern Quebec through the day on Monday as a major winter storm pushes its way into Eastern Canada. Heavy bands of snow could leave up ... Read more »

Eine vierte Corona-Impfdosis schützt offenbar nur bedingt vor der Omikron-Variante des Virus. Dies gehe aus ersten Ergebnissen einer klinischen Studie mit den Impfstoffen von Pfizer/Biontech und Moderna hervor, teilte das israelische Sheba-Krankenhaus nahe Tel Aviv am Montag mit. Eine vierte Dosis erhöhe zwar den Antikörperspiegel, "sie bietet aber nur teilweise Schutz vor dem Virus", erklärte die Studienleiterin Gili Regev-Yochay.

© picture alliance / Eibner-Pressefoto | Eibner/Fabian Steffens Eine vierte Corona-Impfdosis schützt offenbar nur bedingt vor der Omikron-Variante des Virus. Dies gehe aus ersten Ergebnissen einer klinischen Studie mit den ... Read more »

New Brunswick government offering some workers a $3 per hour wage top-up

FREDERICTON — The New Brunswick government is offering a $3 per hour wage top-up for some workers who provide services to vulnerable residents.  © Provided by The Canadian Press The ... Read more »

Quebec calls on bureaucrats to work in hospitals amid staffing shortage

© CBC / Radio-Canada An attendant cleans equipment at Jean-Talon Hospital in Montreal. The Quebec government is asking workers to opt-in to work in a hospital setting as service aides. ... Read more »

Westen-Pullover-Styling: Diese 5 Looks sind perfekt für alle, die keine Lust mehr auf Wintermäntel haben - aber auch nicht frieren wollen

© Getty Images Westen-Pullover-Styling: Diese 5 Looks tragen wir jetzt statt Wintermänteln Statt dem schönen Pullover mit Strickmuster, der coolen neuen Skinny Jeans oder der verspielten Weste bestimmt im Winter ... Read more »

Glenn Youngkin is right — mask mandates harm kids

Critics believe Youngkin doesn’t have the authority to issue his order because Virginia passed a statute that schools should follow the CDC guidelines. AP Glenn Youngkin promised to be on ... Read more »

Drivers get stuck along major Toronto-area highways as winter storm blasts southern Ontario

Thousands of drivers out along Toronto-area highways got stuck in snow Monday morning as a historic winter storm blasted southern Ontario. OPP Sgt. Kerry Schmidt said drivers got stuck in ... Read more »

"Gipfel der Quizgiganten": Elfriede Awadalla gewann vor 17 Jahren WWM – heute ist die Million weg

© picture alliance / dpa | Christian Bruna Elfriede Awadalla In der RTL-Sendung “Gipfel der Quizgiganten” ist der Name Programm. Der Sender vereint drei der beliebtesten Moderatoren Deutschlands mit klugen ... Read more »

Goalie duo keeping Islanders in games despite ugly offense

The Islanders’ offense has been ugly this season. Through 30 games, they’re 30th in the league in goals per game, 20th in expected goals percentage and 23rd in high danger ... Read more »

15 Bilder und Videos, die das gewaltige Ausmass des Vulkanausbruchs in Tonga zeigen

© EUROPEAN UNION, COPERNICUS SENTI/keystone-sda.ch epa09690859 (COMPOSITE) – A handout composite satellite image made available by Copernicus, the European Union’s Earth Observation Programme, shows imagery produced using data from the ... Read more »

Winter storms pummeling Ontario and Quebec

Ontario and Quebec residents are dealing with severe winter weather Monday as two storms continue to dump snow on the provinces. © THE CANADIAN PRESS/Darryl Dyck A woman shovels snow ... Read more »

Cummings wirft Johnson Lüge zu Partys vor – Foto von Carrie Johnson sorgt für Ärger

© Alastair Grant/keystone-sda.ch Dominic Cummings erhebt schwere Vorwürfe gegen Boris Johnson. Der britische Premierminister Boris Johnson hat im Skandal um Lockdown-Partys im Regierungssitz auch zu Beginn der neuen Woche keine ... Read more »

N.S. government seeks delay in housing rights hearing for people with disabilities

HALIFAX — Nova Scotia’s government is asking to delay a human rights case involving access to housing for people with disabilities until the country’s top court rules on the matter. ... Read more »

Why Our Team Is Obsessed With These Cozy Thermals

The weather outside is frightful, so all the more reason to up your layering game. Thermal leggings and/or undershirts worn under your regular clothing are a great way to make ... Read more »

‘Betty White: A Celebration' released on what would have been her 100th birthday today

A new documentary featuring the last interview with beloved comedian and actress Betty White is being released today, on what would have been her 100th birthday. © Provided by National ... Read more »

Winter storm brings traffic to a standstill in Ontario, Quebec (PHOTOS)

A wide-reaching winter storm blanketed parts of Ontario and Quebec Sunday evening into Monday with more than 35 cm of snow accumulating in some places, leading to dangerous roadways, delays, ... Read more »

Ontarians should wait out dangerous blizzard at home, major highways close

Drivers are being urged to avoid any non-essential travel on Monday, as heavy snow and powerful winds make for treacherous road conditions across Ontario. Although the blizzard warnings dropped across ... Read more »

Vaccine mandates increased uptake of COVID shots by almost 70%, Canadian study finds

When Quebec recently ordered that anyone wanting to buy liquor or cannabis from government stores had to be vaccinated against COVID-19, the results were striking. © Provided by National Post ... Read more »

Kim Kardashian 'is upset about Kanye West's accusations'

© Provided by Independent Online (IOL) Kim Kardashian has been frustrated by Kanye West’s recent comments. The 41-year-old star – who has North, eight, Saint, six, Chicago, four, and Psalm, ... Read more »

Ontario buried under epic snow totals as lake-effect setup takes over

Parts of southern Ontario are digging out after one of the most impactful winter storms in recent years powered through the region Sunday night and Monday. The storm shut down ... Read more »
On free-english-test.com you will find lots of free English exam practice materials to help you improve your English skills: grammar, listening, reading, writing, ielts, toeic