Why we should switch off from GB News and watch more YouTube

I don’t know what you were doing between 1.45pm and 3pm on Saturday afternoon. But I can be pretty certain you weren’t watching GB News, the UK’s newish rightwing television news channel.

That’s not because I think you’d have any particular issue with the show that was on at that time, which was a programme hosted by the former ITN news anchor Alastair Stewart. Or because of any assumptions about the political leanings of someone reading a newsletter published by the Guardian.

It’s because, according to television ratings I’ve obtained, during those 75 minutes on Saturday afternoon GB News officially had zero viewers. Yup, no one.

(Zero viewers isn’t quite as simple as it seems – the figures are accepted as the industry standard but are ultimately a survey extrapolated from 5,300 monitoring boxes attached to people’s television sets by the UK ratings agency Barb. There probably was someone, somewhere in the country who chose to stay indoors on Saturday afternoon and watch GB News. But that’s a story for another day.)

Another Fox in the hen house?

If you live in the UK, you’ve probably read and heard more about GB News – and its threat to bring Fox News-style current affairs culture war programming to the country – than almost any other media story in recent months. GB News is a new national television station, which has raised £60m of funding from high-profile backers, with a promise to bring US television values to challenge “wokeism” and a perceived anti-Brexit bias in the British media. It has fixated the UK’s political and media classes with its threat to upend the cosy rolling news duopoly of BBC News and Sky News with their gotta-hear-both-sides approach to impartiality.

As the Guardian’s media editor, I’ve repeatedly written pieces about GB News’ disastrous launch and growing reliance on ex-Brexit party leader Nigel Farage. Some of these articles have attracted more eyeballs than GB News itself – the latest one, describing the collapse of its deal with former presenter Andrew Neil, was published on Saturday.

But despite all the press attention, three months after the launch no one is watching some of its shows. And I’m worried we may be focusing on the wrong part of the modern media-tech-industrial-complex, rather than looking at where the audiences actually are.

That’s because it’s still often easier to try to explain our current information environment by looking at it in the context of a series of big, traditional newspapers and radio stations owned by high-profile individuals with Machiavellian instincts. These politically motivated outlets definitely exist and have substantial influence. Yet focusing on them at the expense of the wider online context ignores how many are increasingly insecure in their position and trying to copy the tactics of online challengers.

When I write about GB News, the drama behind the scenes, and the material it puts on air (such as a presenter pushing ivermectin on air as a Covid treatment) it is a simple and easy narrative for the reader to understand. It’s much more difficult to explain how a decentralised anti-vaxx movement can use a mixture of links to mainstream news outlets and roughly made memes to reach millions of people through an interconnected web of private Facebook groups, Telegram channels, and YouTube livestreams.

Clock TikToking on trad media

Even in terms of style, the established players are increasingly learning from the scrappy upstarts who can reach more people. GB News spent millions of pounds building a full television studio and hiring some established names in the industry on large salaries. And yet it fell down in part because its technology simply wasn’t up to scratch. The launch week had numerous audio delays, guests who simply couldn’t get on air, and the lighting was so dark that it was impossible to see some presenters.

At the same time, a new YouTube or Twitch streamer with a few thousand pounds can buy a ring light, knock-up a small studio in their spare room, and then earn enough money to move up to something much more impressive. Editing skills can be learned and provocative content can bring in viewers, while the hosting is provided by a third-party platform. Even the BBC can’t help itself, celebrating its occasional viral TikTok hit rather than wondering how it ended up competing for audiences on that platform.

When the production values of a stream begin to overtake traditional television – and the content is more entertaining or extreme – what is the actual edge that a broadcast outlet offers beyond an easy-access channel number on a TV set? GB News is reportedly looking at hiring popular rightwing YouTubers, but would being paid to be on TV be financially worthwhile for people who can already monetise their audience? When the enormously popular and influential libertarian-leaning podcaster Joe Rogan signed exclusively for Spotify last year, his deal was worth $100m (£70m) – not much more than the amount that GB News’ backers have pledged to put into their channel, but with much less return.

News ahoy!

And yet despite this, rich people like the idea of being a swashbuckling media chairman, owning television channels, and being lauded by your peers. One of them is Rupert Murdoch, the founder of Fox News, who likes the idea of being Rupert Murdoch again, as opposed to a 90-year-old man laid low by the phone-hacking scandal at his UK newspaper group and the sale of most of his entertainment business.

Having watched the failure of GB News, last week Murdoch decided to revive his own plans for bringing a similar product to UK airwaves, under the name of talkTV. Yes, he’s splashed the cash on an evening show hosted by Piers Morgan, a man whose truffle pig-esque instinct for finding and fighting viral culture war topics predated the internet by decades. But the bedrock of the channel is built on two things supercharged by the internet: streaming-style content and endless debate.

Murdoch’s pitch is to take live streams of his radio stations, especially the culture war-centred talkRadio, and build them out into a television channel that people are happy to watch. Sure, it’s not got the same glamour as an expensive TV operation. But the audience doesn’t necessarily care if it doesn’t look too cheap. Suddenly we’re looking at the convergence of traditional media money and internet values in one package.

People can generally conceptualise the radicalisation impact of a television news presenter’s furious spit-flecked rants being beamed on to their aunt’s television set. They find it much harder to imagine how their aunt is being driven quietly to extremes on her phone due to relentlessly watching a YouTuber she discovered after being sent a link. The reality on how the media influences our modern society is just so much messier than we’d like to believe – and people like me need to do a better job of explaining that.

So in that spirit, which influential political YouTube/TikTok/Insta/Twitch accounts do you think deserve more in-depth coverage? Hit reply on this email to let me know.

Public service announcement

You may have noticed, I’m not Alex Hern. That’s because he’s on parental leave for the next six months. But fear not, he’ll still be writing one newsletter a month, and we’ll have a rotating cast of writers covering in his absence. Next week, our West-Coast tech correspondent, Kari Paul, will take the reins.

Twitter balls-up

If you want an example of how technology and the media have made everything into one big global interconnected mess, then Nicki Minaj’s tweet claiming (sadly still without evidence) that her Trinidadian cousin’s friend gained, ahem, giant testicles after being vaccinated against Covid is a case in point.

Aside from the issue of an enormously influential figure being able to spread such claims to millions of followers on Twitter and earn a rebuke from Boris Johnson, it opened another debate about ethics in journalism. Minaj posted the contact details of a reporter for the Trinidad and Tobago Guardian who were competing with CNN to find whether the allegedly unfortunately endowed man really existed.

In response, the newspaper’s parent company, Guardian Media Ltd (no relation), issued a strong statement defending the freedom of the press to fact check stories about engorged testicles, which enraged Minaj fans further.

Unfortunately for me, a Google search for “Guardian Media editor” leads to my much less exciting Twitter account, leading to some slightly unusual exchanges with confused Minaj fans over the weekend who felt I had sent a reporter to besmirch their hero.

The Wider TechScape

One of the unfortunate lessons from the politics of the last few years is the growing belief that if you’re apologising, you’re losing. The New York Times reports that Facebook has decided to go on the front foot following years of criticism and use its own Newsfeed to push pro-Facebook messaging and generally … stop saying sorry quite so much. The effort involves top Facebook executive Nick Clegg, a man who in a previous life as the UK’s deputy prime minister learned the hard way that saying sorry doesn’t necessarily help improve your reputation online.

But Mark Zuckerberg has already pushed back on one aspect of the reporting, about his decision to upload a video of a trip to the beach. As the Facebook boss posted on his personal account:

Look, it’s one thing for the media to say false things about my work, but it’s crossing the line to say I’m riding an electric surfboard when that video clearly shows a hydrofoil that I’m pumping with my own legs.”

***

Eight years ago Netflix was a plucky upstart streaming company that baffled the world when it began making its own high-quality shows. (They’re remaking House of Cards but it’ll only be available … on the internet? Huh?)

In a sign of how far they’ve come, this morning Netflix has announced they’ve bought the rights to everything associated with Roald Dahl for an undisclosed (but no doubt enormous) sum, and it’s barely even a surprise.

As my colleague Mark Sweney reports, the deal will help Netflix “build its content arsenal in the streaming wars against rivals including Disney+, Amazon Prime Video and HBO Max”. Expect Dahl-themed everything coming to a screen near you.

One of the stranger aspects of the fragmented internet media era is that it becomes harder than ever to build truly universal audience for a story/drama/musician who is loved by all generations. And yet people flock to such material. So the value of universally known brands created in the analogue era, when everyone did watch TV together and read the same books, just keeps going up.

What’s more, the UK’s copyright laws mean the Dahl family’s rights to Roald’s works will expire in 40 years’ time – meaning they potentially sold them before they were left with an asset of declining value.

***

Sarah Manavis in the New Statesman is always worth reading on internet culture. She recently published a piece reflecting on how 9/11 created the blueprint for online conspiracy theories. As someone who experienced the terrorist attacks by very slowly refreshing the recently created BBC News website, then grew up online in its aftermath, a lot of it hit home. She quotes writer Garrett M Graff as saying:

There’s this through-line from 9/11 right up to Covid-19 vaccine misinformation today: this idea of ‘do your own research’. This idea of sitting at home with a computer and googling your way through YouTube and bulletin boards, that you can figure out more than every government scientist and engineer who has ever looked at this problem before.”

***

On a cheerier note, here’s a video of how television studios used to switch from the news to the weather before the era of fancy technology.

You can follow me at @jimwaterson on Twitter if you want more media news, next week you’ll be in the safe hands of Kari Paul.

Internet Explorer Channel Network
News Related

OTHER NEWS

Bill Clinton “Up And About,” But Still Hospitalized; Joe Biden Sends “Best Wishes,” Says The Two Will Speak Today

UPDATED throughout with latest: Former President Bill Clinton has been admitted to UCI Medical Center in Orange to receive treatment for a non-Covid related infection, his spokesman said on Thursday. ... Read more »

Fatal stabbing of British MP David Amess declared a terrorist incident

Authorities have declared the death of David Amess a terrorist incident, hours after the Conservative Party lawmaker in the U.K. was fatally stabbed while meeting with local constituents in a ... Read more »

Trump-endorsed Max Miller's congressional campaign is largely self-funded, campaign finance reports show

WASHINGTON, D. C. – Former White House aide Max Miller emailed his supporters last week to boast that his congressional campaign, which former President Donald Trump endorsed before incumbent Anthony ... Read more »

Watchdog group files complaint against Psaki for promoting McAuliffe

A government watchdog group filed a complaint against White House Press secretary Jen Psaki, accusing her of violating the Hatch Act by appearing to endorse a candidate in Virginia’s governor ... Read more »

Clean energy program will likely be cut from budget bill

The Clean Electricity Performance Program, the cornerstone climate policy in Democrats’ massive social safety net package, will likely be dropped from the final budget deal after pushback from Sen. Joe ... Read more »

UK police rule MP David Amess murder a 'terrorist incident'

© Provided by dw.com Amess was a champion of animal welfare during his time in Parliament, having opposed practices such as fox hunting UK Member of Parliament David Amess was ... Read more »

Beasley again the top fundraiser in NC US Senate race

© Provided by Associated Press FILE – In this Saturday, Sept. 25, 2021, file photo, Republican U.S. Senate candidate Pat McCrory poses for a photo in Mount Airy, N.C. North ... Read more »

Health ministry reports 89 new Covid-19 deaths

© Provided by Free Malaysia Today PETALING JAYA: The health ministry reported 89 Covid-19 deaths yesterday, according to its GitHub database. Of the total, 19 were classified as brought-in-dead. The ... Read more »

Police: Connecticut man charged with murder worked at Fryeburg Fair with stabbing victim

Oct. 15—The Connecticut man charged with stabbing a fellow worker to death early Wednesday morning at the Fryeburg Fairgrounds allegedly was fighting with the victim after a night of drinking ... Read more »

Man wounded in Portland police shooting charged

Oct. 15—A New York City man wounded in a police shooting last weekend in Portland has been charged. Edward C. Hyman, 42, was charged Tuesday with criminal threatening and failure ... Read more »

Adele: Fans react to Easy On Me - singer's first new song since 2015

Fans around the world had been waiting since 2015 to hear new music from Adele and her new single Easy On Me was finally released overnight, causing a social media ... Read more »

Warriors new plan – chasing wins – might just pay off

© Provided by NBC Sports Last season, Warriors coach Steve Kerr said they weren’t chasing wins. Golden State finished eighth in the West, lost a nail-biter on the road to ... Read more »

How to watch Tennessee vs. Ole Miss: Live stream, TV channel, start time for Saturday's NCAA Football game

© Provided by CBS Sports Sep 29, 2018; Athens, GA, USA; A Tennessee Volunteers cheerleader on the sidelines during the game against the Georgia Bulldogs during the first half at ... Read more »

Boris Johnson gives adorable lookalike son Wilfred a ride on his shoulders

BORIS Johnson gives son Wilfred a ride on his shoulders as the tot’s grandad Stanley lends a steadying hand from behind. The PM, who was enjoying a glass of red ... Read more »

Lefty NY pol ripped for saying hospitals ‘allegedly saving lives' amid COVID-19

Assemblywoman Catalina Cruz (D-Queens) insists that hospitals “make money out of allegedly saving lives,” as corporations. Hans Pennink A progressive New York lawmaker said Friday that local hospitals are “allegedly ... Read more »

Chandigarh: Coaching institute told to refund fee of student who quit midway

© Provided by Hindustan Times The District Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission, Chandigarh, said a student or a trainee may leave midstream if he/she finds the service deficient, substandard and non-yielding. ... Read more »

GMADA e-auction: Only 9 of 61 properties in Mohali find takers

© Provided by Hindustan Times A 5-acre commercial site in Aerocity proved to be the star property for GMADA, as it went for ₹192 crore against a reserve price of ... Read more »

Chandigarh: Woman buying vegetables falls prey to snatchers

© Provided by Hindustan Times The 55-year-old woman lost her chain to snatchers while buying vegetables near her housing society. (HT Photo) Two motorcycle-borne youths snatched the gold chain of a ... Read more »

12 held for gambling in Ambala, r₹r2.4 lakh recovered

© Provided by Hindustan Times The Ambala police teams raided several locations in the district on Thursday night and lodged nine cases at various police stations. (AFP) The Ambala police ... Read more »

Celtics waiving Ryan Arcidiacono, Juwan Morgan

The Celtics are releasing a pair of training-camp invitees, according to Jay King of The Athletic, who reports that guard Ryan Arcidiacono and forward Juwan Morgan are hitting waivers. © Alonzo Adams-USA TODAY ... Read more »

Fantasy Basketball: Biggest value risers from NBA preseason

We’re closing in on the start of the 2021-22 NBA regular season, which only means one thing… it’s 2021 fantasy basketball draft time. We all know about the stars, the LeBron ... Read more »

Passenger in pickup seriously injured after truck slams into SUV, home in Derry

Oct. 15—Elmer Derry said he and his wife were literally “shaken out of bed” when a pickup truck slammed into the side of their Derry home at 10:30 p.m. Thursday. ... Read more »

Truck driver convicted in Colorado pileup that killed 4

GOLDEN, Colo. (AP) — A truck driver accused of causing a fiery pileup that killed four people and injured six others on a Colorado highway has been convicted of vehicular ... Read more »

Fatal stabbing of U.K. lawmaker declared a terrorist incident by police

London's Metropolitan Police Department has declared the fatal stabbing of British lawmaker David Amess a terrorist incident. Amess died earlier Friday after he was stabbed multiple times while meeting with ... Read more »

Ruling could block Alabama execution scheduled next week

FILE – This undated file photo provided by the Alabama Department of Corrections shows Willie B. Smith III. Federal judges heard arguments Wednesday, Oct. 13, 2021 about whether Willie B. ... Read more »

Ida flooding victim says Queens not getting federal aid that de Blasio promised

Woodside resident Julia Nieves ripped Mayor Bill de Blasio and FEMA for failing to get any federal aid to victims of Hurricane Ida. Matthew McDermott A Hurricane Ida flooding victim ... Read more »

Anti-vaxxer claims doctors banished unvaccinated from surgeries

© Provided by Daily Mail MailOnline logo A furious patient claims he was forced to wait outside a medical centre in a makeshift plastic booth after the practice banned him ... Read more »

David Ortiz clowns Alex Rodriguez's yoga video: ‘WTF is that?'

View this post on Instagram A post shared by Alex Rodriguez (@arod) Alex Rodriguez worked out with David Ortiz, then he got worked over by the ex-Red Sox slugger. “Much ... Read more »

Female former Afghan lawmakers, judges meet Greek PM

1 / 3Greece AfghanistanAfghan women attend a meeting with Greece’s Prime Minister Kyriakos Mitsotakis at Maximos Mansion, in Athens, Friday, Oct. 15, 2021. The Afghan women, part of a group ... Read more »

2nd Judicial Circuit Judge, Clifton Newman to hear Alex Murdaugh bond hearing Tuesday morning

Oct. 15—On Friday afternoon, Attorney General Alan Wilson announced Alex Murdaugh's bond hearing on charges of obtaining property by false pretenses will take place at the Richland County Courthouse before ... Read more »

Wagener man charged with attempted murder in Holley Street shooting

Oct. 15—A Wagener man was arrested Wednesday in connection to a May shooting . Frankie Lee Walker II, 34, is charged with attempted murder and possession of a weapon during ... Read more »

Police say accomplice in Wagener Road murder drove a getaway car, police warn suspect is 'armed and dangerous'

Oct. 15—The Aiken County Sheriff's Office is seeking the public's assistance in locating a suspect in an Oct. 2 shooting death . Robert Gene Payne II, 29, is wanted for ... Read more »

Aiken man charged with sexual exploitation of a minor, criminal sexual conduct with a minor

Oct. 15—An Aiken man was arrested Wednesday in connection to multiple sex crimes against a minor. Matthew Ramon Drayton, 23, is charged with first-degree sexual exploitation of a minor, second-degree ... Read more »

UK police review security as Sir David Amess' killing declared extremism

© Provided by The National Sir David Amess attends Old Leigh Regatta in Leigh-on-Sea, in 2019. Alamy Prayers were offered for the British Conservative MP Sir David Amess on Friday ... Read more »

Aviation, tourism industries rushing to prepare for 'living with COVID-19'

Traveler wait to check in at Terminal 2 of Incheon International Airport, Oct. 4. Yonhap By Jun Ji-hyeExpectations toward demand recovery for overseas travel are rising in the aviation and ... Read more »

Join the race for half-term hols with savings up to £1,000 for families

WILL you be joining the race for cut-price half-term hols? As testing and red-list restrictions ease, the next weekend offers the best chance for a low-cost and hassle-free overseas trip ... Read more »

Jeff Bezos' Girlfriend Lauren Sanchez Gives Her Little Brown Dress a Sporty Twist in Alexander McQueen Sneakers on Lunch Date

© Christopher Peterson / SplashNews.com Billionaire Jeff Bezos And His Girlfriend Lauren Sanchez Leave Cipriani Soho In New York City Lauren Sanchez gives a lesson in being effortlessly chic. The ... Read more »

Josh Gordon plans on making most of his latest opportunity

© Provided by NBC Sports Chiefs receiver Josh Gordon had not played a game since Dec. 15, 2019, when he stepped on the field last week. Gordon saw nine snaps ... Read more »

NFL: No one else in league cited with violation for vulgar emails

The NFL has found no other current team or league personnel to have sent emails containing racist, homophobic or misogynistic language similar to messages written by Jon Gruden that led ... Read more »

Bill Clinton to spend 4th night in Orange County ICU for IV treatment

Former President Clinton, hospitalized at an Orange County hospital because of an infection, will remain another night in the intensive care unit to continue intravenous antibiotic treatment, a spokesman said ... Read more »