Why Valve's Stance On NFTs Will Probably Change, And Soon

Asia's Tech News Daily

Over the weekend, Steam banned blockchain and NFT games. The crypto gaming world has responded, and it will live on. But it’s undeniably a blow to not be able to publish on PC’s main storefront for the foreseeable future – a blow that will perhaps convince some developers to pivot towards mobile, console and HTML5.

On the front line of this kerfuffle, and in close communication with Valve, was Enjin-backed puzzle game Age of Rust, which was able to shed light on Valve’s reasoning:

Valve’s stance has nothing to do with the environment, and is likely a combination of marketplace control and legal compliance.

Of course as a private company, it could simply say “Valve doesn’t like crypto” and post a GIF of Gabe Newell burning a Dogecoin while blowing a raspberry to the internet en masse, and it’d be within its rights. But Valve didn’t do that. It put forward an argument, and now we get to point out that it’s fundamentally flawed.

You Wanna Go There, Valve?

© Provided by Kotaku Australia A golden AK-47 skin purchasable on the DMarket trading site

For years, Valve has been the primary example of in-items having value.

Steam has a “soft” cashout system in which you can sell items for in-store credit to buy other items or Steam games. Then there’s a “hard” cashout in which you use a third-party, external website to sell the item for real-world cash.

Because the soft cashout technically uses “Steam bucks” instead of money, Valve gets to deny it’s a true cashout. Because the third-party websites aren’t Valve-affiliated, it gets to pretend it doesn’t know much about it.

One of the most popular of these third-party websites is DMarket. I was able to speak to its CEO Vlad Panchenko, who walked me through how they communicate with Valve as much as possible, ensuring compliance and security. Valve are fully aware this exists. To add an extra helping of irony, DMarket’s items are now based on a new blockchain/NFT system.

Over time, Valve has introduced limitations to curtail some of the dodgier practices around this system, such as imposing a wait before you can resell an item to slow down fraudulent activity and money laundering, or outright banning the gambling scene that flourished around item value. But you can still buy, sell and trade items, and ultimately cash out.

Publishers and industry lobby groups pleading the case of loot boxes are fond of saying there’s no cash out system in in-game stores. If you believe them – and you shouldn’t – that means these items have no value, therefor loot boxes don’t constitute gambling. Except, of course, there’s that one company. There’s Valve. The one that does let you cash out.

So by a commonly-used industry definition of item value, Valve’s skin economy is quite valuable indeed. But even this is too generous, as the definition of value doesn’t depend on cashing out.

In-game items have “value” because people are willing to pay for them. Riot’s ludicrous price tags on Valorant skins are what people will pay, so they’re worth that. The Steam marketplace just makes this easier for us because its value is collectively agreed – instead of a retailer pricing an item, we can say a particular knife is worth X because the market decided it. Combined with drop rates, even the value of Valve’s loot boxes can be calculated.

With NFT economies knocking at the door, it’d probably be better for Valve to honestly say “This sidesteps our marketplace and we don’t know how to deal with it yet”. Or even perhaps “The lack of intermediary currency ruins the legal loopholes we’ve enjoyed and now we need to figure out a plan”.

But it’s the height of hypocrisy for Valve to disallow crypto games for proposing to do the very same thing that Valve was doing all along, albeit with some semi-intermediary funny-money that didn’t fool anyone.

Valve lacks an endgame in the NFT war

© Provided by Kotaku Australia CSGO’s new FAMAS skin from Operation Riptide

Neither of these scenes needs the other. Steam will do just fine, and so will the flowering crypto gaming scene. NFT games would rather be able to rely on PC’s dominant digital storefront, but one can see how NFTs might cut Valve out of potential Workshop revenue.

That’s the irony of this whole fiasco – just how similar Steam is to the thing it just banned. As if it highlights its own unrealised potential with the Steam marketplace and Steam inventory.

Steam’s features are the closest thing gaming has had to NFTs. It tolerates internal and external trades on its items, taking a cut when it can. Its inventory could be used for some basic level of interoperability, but hasn’t.

Heck, it’s even technically play-to-earn, if you count the bottom-of-the-barrel drops you get mid-match – it’s just that in order to make its economy work, it maintains a ridiculous policy of implementing hundreds of “ugly” skins to flesh out the bottom of the pyramid of value, drowning out the truckloads of beautiful community-made skins.

No one serious would propose that Valve is threatened by NFTs, but comparing the two is more like apples to apples than Valve would like. And the newer of these apples looks tastier.

It wouldn’t surprise me if Valve changed its messaging around the issue quite soon, perhaps even within the next six months. The “your items have value but ours don’t” line is garnering the appropriate ridicule. I believe it’ll eventually change its policy as well – though first it needs to decide how, if possible, it can capitalise on a technology that fundamentally wrests control from middle-men.

Internet Explorer Channel Network
Asia's Tech News Daily
News Related


Bereaved families ‘sickened' by No 10 lockdown parties

Boris Johnson in front of the Downing Street Christmas tree in 2020 (Justin Tallis/PA) Families who lost loved ones during the pandemic say they are “sickened” by reports that Downing ... Read more »

George Clooney turned down $35m for one day of work

Watch: George Clooney turned down $35m for one day of work George Clooney has revealed he once turned down $35 million (£29.8 million) for one day’s work. The actor has ... Read more »

Swiss district puts 2,000 people in quarantine after two Omicron cases at school

The entrance of the Châtaigneraie campus of the International School of Geneva which has closed after two cases of the Omicron variant were identified (Fabrice COFFRINI / AFP) More than ... Read more »

Minister claims Tory Xmas party backlash is 'rumour and hear'say' in excruciating exchange

Maggie Throup, the Minister for Vaccines and Public Health, was challenged about the Conservatives’ Christmas parties in 2020 but said the backlash surrounding the COVID rule-breaching events was ‘rumour and ... Read more »

The GoPro Hero 10's superb Black Friday accessory bundle deal is still going strong

GoPro’s Black Friday deal on its flagship Hero 10 Black camera is still running, with the deal effectively giving you a bunch of free accessories with the action cam – ... Read more »

New MP: Bexley by-election win 'greatest honour of my life'

The newest Conservative MP has promised to “get on delivering” for the people of Old Bexley and Sidcup, as he retained his party’s seat in the by-election following the death ... Read more »

Met not investigating No 10 over reported Christmas party, says Cressida Dick

Met not investigating No 10 over reported Christmas party, says Cressida Dick Read more »

One of the best Nintendo Switch Cyber Monday deals is still live and ripe for Christmas shopping

Cyber Monday is over, but we’re still seeing some excellent deals alive and kicking across the internet. Take this superb Nintendo Switch Cyber Monday deal hosted right now at Best ... Read more »

Satellite image shows how vital ocean current is affected by climate crisis

A satellite image shows a major ocean current that is speeding up due to climate change. The Antarctic Circumpolar Current (ACC), which sweeps around the abyss off Antarctica, is the ... Read more »

Washington wants to restrict exports of surveillance tech used in rights abuses

Surveillance technologies cover a wide range of increasingly sophisticated tools whose use is spreading all over the world, from surveillance cameras and drones. WASHINGTON (AFP) – The United States wants ... Read more »

Russia has banned a whole load more VPN services

Russia continues to wage war against virtual private network (VPN) services, adding half a dozen more to its list of banned services, which already contained nine such services. According to ... Read more »

This is how government plans to use Blockchain in its systems

The electronics and IT ministry on Friday released a national strategy on blockchain for adopting the technology in government systems especially for e-governance services.The ministry has adopted a multi-institutional approach ... Read more »

Save $600 on This Solar Generator for Your Home for Cyber Week

Entrepreneurs know they always have to have a plan. But when things don’t go according to that plan, you also have to be ready to adapt on the fly. Working ... Read more »

8 Critical Email Rules for Optimal Efficiency

Even though you have many other ways to communicate (e.g., Zoom, Teams, phone calls, text), email still dominates the workday. Thoroughly controlling your inbox will allow you to be more ... Read more »

How to Navigate Data Privacy Regulations When Deploying Enterprise Blockchain Solutions

As businesses in nearly every sector focus on digital transformation, more aim to incorporate enterprise blockchain technology into their operations. According to a Deloitte study, more than half of global ... Read more »

This Robot's Facial Expressions Will Freak You Out

Engineered Arts A U.K. robotics firm called Engineered Arts just debuted the first videos of its new humanoid robot, which is able to make hyper-realistic facial expressions. It’s a pretty ... Read more »

Want that dev job? Make sure you can answer these 7 questions

Note: please know that the views and opinions shared in this story are my own and do not reflect or represent my employer. When you run a search for the ... Read more »

SoundMagic P23BT review

Two-minute review A reliable name in headphones and earphones despite not being the first brand you’d probably think of, SoundMagic has released its first wireless over-ear headphones in the form ... Read more »

Save $150 on these noise-cancelling Sony headphones, along with more Best Buy Top Deals of the week

Looking for more Cyber Week deals, gift guides and holiday tips? Sign up for Yahoo Lifestyle Canada’s newsletter! These noise-cancelling Sony headphones are $150 off this week at Best Buy. ... Read more »

Diabetes drug may help improve symptoms for people with heart failure – new research

Half of people with heart failure have a type called preserved ejection fraction. Explode/ Shutterstock Heart failure is one of the most common cardiac diseases, affecting more than 30 million ... Read more »

ProWritingAid writing tool review

There is a huge market for assist tools of various types nowadays, and many professionals rely on them heavily for their daily work. The complexity and features of those tools ... Read more »

Facebook parent Meta expands advertising options for crypto

Meta’s stance on crypto ads has changed dramatically over the last few years. MENLO PARK (BLOOMBERG) – Meta Platforms, the parent of Facebook and Instagram, is making it easier for ... Read more »

Netflix Scoops Up ‘Three Songs for Benazir' for Doc Shorts Slate (EXCLUSIVE)

Netflix has bolstered its slate of Oscar short hopefuls with the acquisition of “Three Songs for Benazir.” Directed by Gulistan and Elizabeth Mirzaei, the 22-minute docu tells the story of ... Read more »

Government has Rs 100 crore budget for chip design related activities this fiscal: Vaishnaw

The government on Friday said it is cognizant of the importance of semiconductor design and has a budgetary allocation of Rs 100 crore for chip design related programmes the ongoing ... Read more »

Hackers steal $120 million in crypto from DeFi platform

Hackers have stolen crypto tokens worth $120 million from Blockchain-based decentralised finance (DeFi) platform BadgerDAO. Several crypto wallets were drained before the platform could stop the cyber attack.In a tweet, ... Read more »

Government must back UK train travel or risk long-term retreat to cars

Jon Fitton/Shutterstock There’s no doubt that the UK’s railways have been hit hard by the pandemic. Recent figures from the Office of Rail and Road show a huge drop in ... Read more »

Businesses set to face an onslaught of ransomware attacks over holiday season

In each of the past three years, the number of ransomware attacks increased by almost a third over the holiday season as compared to the monthly average, new data from ... Read more »

Finland battles 'exceptional' malware attack spread by phones

The messages started beeping Finns’ mobiles late last week, prompting the National Cyber Security Centre to issue a “severe alert”. HELSINKI (BLOOMBERG) – Finland is working to stop a flood ... Read more »

7 new movies and TV shows on Netflix, Amazon Prime, HBO Max and more this weekend

We’ve been warning you all for the past few weeks, but Christmas has well and truly arrived on streamers in 2021. This weekend will see several new festive movies and ... Read more »

Everyone's been talking about AWS, and Google Cloud is jealous

Just as the curtain falls on Amazon Web Services’ re:Invent 2021 event, Google Cloud has announced a series of new cloud regions, not just in the US, but around the ... Read more »

Microsoft to stop forcing Edge on Windows 11 users

Microsoft has changed the way Windows 11 handles switching default web browsers, thankfully, reversing an unpopular decision it made when the OS was still in pre-release testing (back in August). ... Read more »

Robots doing brain surgery: CEO describes the latest in medical AI

The development of the Moderna (MRNA) coronavirus vaccine relied on it. The early discovery and modeling of COVID-19 outbreaks depended on it. And new drugs for the disease benefited from ... Read more »

Video: £100k Robot displays life-like facial expressions and 'could go to meetings'

Ameca is billed as the "world's most advanced human shaped robot". CEO of Engineered Arts Will Jackson says the machine could take someone's place in a meeting, and costs more than £100,000. Read more »

Tesla recalls one in every four Model Ys it has made in the first 1o months of the year to fix faulty steering

Tesla will recall more than 20,000 of its bestselling made-in-China Model Y sport-utility vehicles (SUVs) to fix a steering issue. The US electric vehicle (EV) giant will recall 21,599 Model ... Read more »

COVID-19: First encounter with virus shapes body's future immune response to new infections, research shows

Instead of having a one-size-fits-all approach, developers could, researchers suggest, tailor make vaccines according to a person's infection history. Read more »

China wants to turn Macau from a casino den into a tech base for the Greater Bay Area

China is forging a new identity for Macau, the world’s largest casino den, as a regional technology hub, according to Chinese technology industry executives and officials. As the former Portuguese ... Read more »

Hey Google, here's a blueprint for a Pixel smartwatch to rival the Apple Watch

The cat’s out of the bag, once more. After a few years of silence, we are again seeing reports about Google working on its own Pixel-branded smartwatch. We just know ... Read more »

Ghislaine Maxwell's 58-page rule book for staff at Jeffrey Epstein's mansion revealed

Ghislaine Maxwell Ghislaine Maxwell wrote a household manual for staff at Jeffrey Epstein’s Florida home, instructing employees to “see nothing, hear nothing, say nothing”, a former housekeeper revealed in testimony ... Read more »

Ghislaine Maxwell trial – live: Defence to quiz former Epstein employee after graphic sex toy testimony

Day five of the trial of British socialite Ghislaine Maxwell starts in New York City, as the 59-year-old answers to charges related to her alleged involvement in financier Jeffrey Epstein’s ... Read more »

Need a doctor? Google can now help you find places that accept your health insurance

Looking for a new doctor who takes your health insurance? An update to Google search might make that easier. Google announced updates to search results providing more information on doctors, ... Read more »
On free-english-test.com you will find lots of free English exam practice materials to help you improve your English skills: grammar, listening, reading, writing, ielts, toeic