Why the Musk vs. Bezos space feud is probably fake

Asia's Tech News Daily

Amazon.com, Jeff Bezos, Elon Musk, Space

Flick through a news feed on your phone and you are likely to scroll across an article of the new space race. Forget the geopolitical struggles of a cold war. This time, it’s Tesla CEO Elon Musk versus Amazon founder Jeff Bezos: the in the world duking it out over whether SpaceX or Blue Origin, their respective companies, will be the dominant force in the new industry of private space flight.

Occasionally, Richard Branson of Virgin Galactic gets a mention too, but the Brit being a relative pauper, and his space plane lacking the phallic majesty of his fellow billionaires’ rockets, he has received diminishing attention in recent weeks.

The Musk v Bezos rivalry makes for good press and is stoked occasionally in tweets by both parties, but is it real? Probably not, according to our research, published in the book , which analyses 95 popular books about the technology industry.

It is easy to see that, at a basic level, Musk’s and Bezos’s stated plans for space domination are complementary, rather than competitive. Bezos dismisses Musk’s plan to colonize Mars as unrealistic, while Musk thinks it will take too long to build the infrastructure for the giant orbiting space stations that Bezos proposes. Read between the lines and you can see how they had been rhetorically dividing up the space industry into separate monopolies even before their rockets broke the “” – one definition of where outer space begins.

The reality is that, as with other technology billionaires, such as Alphabet’s Larry Page and Sergey Brin, Facebook’s Mark Zuckerberg or even Palantir’s Peter Thiel, their interests align more often than they diverge. This new space race is partly a celebrity publicity stunt to generate clickbait headlines that build public awareness of, and popular support for, a new commercial frontier. If we focus on the rivalry and keep asking who’s winning, perhaps we won’t ask the big whys of commercial space colonization.

In general, there is little in the tech barons’ interest to actually work against one another. Writing in his 2014 book Zero to One, Thiel that “competition is a relic of history”, and because a competitive market is seen as fundamental to capitalism, “monopolists lie to protect themselves”. These billionaires, all monopolists, may indeed use their celebrity profiles to create the illusion of competition where there is none. Google co-founder Larry Page also stated in that Silicon Valley’s billionaires “travel as if they are pack dogs and stick to each other like glue”.

We learned through our research that the west coast billionaires that dominate the tech industry do indeed support each other financially and strategically. We carried out a digital search of a 10 million word database, containing the books we investigated, which is known as a broad context collocation. The algorithm searched for instances in which the entrepreneurs were listed together, and sorted it by context – such as collaboration, rivalry, friendship, political lobbying and philanthropy. This helped us identity a dense network, which you can see in the diagram.

Amazon.com, Jeff Bezos, Elon Musk, Space
Silicon Valley networks (Ben Little, Author provided)

So while Bezos and Musk haven’t directly financially supported each other, they are part of a wider system that has. Bezos was an early funder of Google, and in turn Google’s founders put money into Musk’s ventures from as early as 2006. As Ashlee Vance writes in his biography of Musk, Google underwrote Tesla to the tune of $5 billion (£3.6 billion) in 2013 when it looked as if it was about to go under, as well as at critical moments.

Race to the bottom?

There are plenty of good reasons to be exploring space, but we just don’t know if these billionaires will prioritize profit or science, benefits to humanity or a much narrower substratum of the wealthy. The signs don’t look good, as Musk launches thousands of Starlink satellites that risk . Meanwhile, the ten minutes of weightlessness offered by Bezos are a – not to mention being damaging for our planet.

As a group, Silicon Valley entrepreneurs present a shared belief in using technological solutions to social problems. Social media platforms are designed to better connect us by fostering divisions, and spaceships offer a way to escape a planet that may no longer be able to comfortably support us. These solutions and the problems they purport to solve have been presented to us, since the days of Steve Jobs, the late chairman of Apple, as the result of the vision of the “genius founder” – an awkward, but dazzling leader: a mythic figure who expands the frontiers of human endeavor. It started with home computers, then went online and now it is soaring into space.

Instead of dividends (another relic, like competition), these businesses are valued in headlines, tweets and “vision”. Tesla is the most valuable car company in the world based almost entirely on Musk’s celebrity inspiring a legion of fans to invest in the company. Amazon is a ruthless monopoly that secured its early market lead after aggressive tax avoidance and punishing hours for its staff. But because Bezos is framed as an inspirational CEO, a culture of overwork has been transformed into the can-do spirit of the American frontier.

These entrepreneurs tell us compelling stories about their lives, their businesses and their vision. We will never know if they are true, manicured and coiffured as they are through one of the most successful publicity machines in history. So if we find ourselves swimming in clickbait about these men, it’s not incidental that we find them alongside celebrity news: it’s absolutely fundamental to their business strategies and thus a key source of their wealth and power.

Written by , Lecturer in Media and Cultural Politics,

This article is republished from under a Creative Commons license. Read the .

Internet Explorer Channel Network
Asia's Tech News Daily
News Related

OTHER NEWS

Extended Cyber Monday Sale: Get an Apple TV Remote That Actually Makes Sense

Apple has made innovation an event. Every year, Apple’s World Wide Developers Conference (WWDC) serves as a self-congratulatory festival in which Apple reveals new products and describes the new developments ... Read more »

Meta Forced To Sell Giphy After U.K. Regulator Pressure

Meta Platforms Inc (NASDAQ:FB) –formerly known as Facebook Inc– is facing a fresh setback in the U.K. as the country’s regulator decided to stop the company’s acquisition of Giphy, the ... Read more »

Moderna: Current Vaccines Not As Effective Against Omicron

Vaccines currently trying to fight COVID-19 may not be as effective against the omicron variant, warned the CEO of Moderna Inc (NASDAQ:MRNA) Stephane Bancel. He stated it is unlikely that ... Read more »

Extended Cyber Monday Discounts on 10 Apple Products

Apple has made a name for itself in small business. Offering powerful, flexible solutions for entrepreneurs and small businesses in all industries, Apple makes small business life easier. But Apple ... Read more »

New Twitter CEO Parag Agrawal steps from behind the scenes to high profile

Newly named Twitter CEO Parag Agrawal has emerged from behind the scenes to take over one of Silicon Valley’s highest-profile and politically volatile jobs. But his prior lack of name ... Read more »

This robot vacuum with more than 11,000 reviews is 30% off during Amazon's extended Cyber Week sales

Looking for more Cyber Week deals, gift guides and holiday tips? Sign up for Yahoo Lifestyle Canada’s newsletter! One of Amazon Canada‘s top-rated robot vacuums is on sale for 30 ... Read more »

Owlet baby socks discontinued after FDA warning. Parents argue device offers 'peace of mind.'

Owlet’s Smart Socks, baby monitoring socks programmed to track a baby’s sleep patterns, have halted sales after a warning letter from the U.S. Food and Drug Administration. The FDA stated ... Read more »

Star Wars: Ahsoka: everything you need to know about The Mandalorian spin-off

If you’re yet to watch the animated Star Wars TV shows, you may be asking why Ahsoka Tano warrants her own TV show. Everyone else, however, will simply be wondering ... Read more »

Once led by founders, Twitter set for fresh path

The passing of the baton could herald a new era of innovation for the company. Read more »

The Grand Tour's Carnage A Trois special has a release date on Amazon Prime Video

The latest episode in The Grand Tour’s fourth season has finally been given a release date – and a full-length trailer, too. The trusty trio of Jeremy Clarkson, James May ... Read more »

Cyber Monday gaming laptop deals 2021: the best offers still available

Many Cyber Monday gaming laptop deals are still available despite the day now being in our rearview mirror. Some of the best gaming laptops have had their prices slashed considerably ... Read more »

Sorry, AI isn't going to stop the spread of fake news

Disinformation has been used in . But it is undeniably being intensified by the use of smart technologies and social media. This is because these communication technologies provide a relatively ... Read more »

Windows 11 could finally solve one of the most common video call problems

Microsoft is looking to solve a major annoyance for video conferencing users with a new preview update for Windows 11. The Windows 11 Insider Preview Build 22494, which was released ... Read more »

Elon Musk reportedly warned that SpaceX faces the 'risk of bankruptcy' from lack of Starship engine progress

Yichuan Cao/NurPhoto via Getty Images Elon Musk told SpaceX employees that lack of progress on Raptor engines creates a “risk of bankruptcy.” The SpaceX CEO expressed his concern in a ... Read more »

Balance, Pokémon Unite: These were the best Android apps of 2021

The best app on the Android marketplace Google Play helps users create their own meditation plan. Balance was named the Best App of 2021 on Google Play, the company announced ... Read more »

WhatsApp rolls out first beta update for new Windows app

WhatsApp rolled out a new Windows app a few weeks ago. The app looks similar to the web version of the platform and it is available to download on the ... Read more »

Live now: the Cyber Monday TV deals still going

Refresh 2021-11-30T15:03:56.652Z (Image credit: TCL) The deals aren’t over yet folks! Just when I thought I was out, they pull me back in again. But that’s cool, because I love ... Read more »

MacBook Pro 16-inch reportedly has MagSafe charging issues for some owners

Apple’s MacBook Pro 16-inch reportedly suffers from a glitch that means some users are finding that the laptop isn’t charging up properly using the MagSafe connection in one particular scenario. ... Read more »

Lotfi Zadeh: Google doodle honors Azerbaijani-American computer scientist

Google is paying tribute Tuesday to the computer scientist who created the mathematical framework “fuzzy logic.” The search giant thonored Azerbaijani-American electrical engineer and professor Lotfi Zadeh. On this day ... Read more »

Watch: Is Honda reviving its self-balancing motorbike?

There’s an interesting video circulating on and , claiming that Honda unveiled a self-balancing motorcycle on November 29 in Japan. In fact, if you watch it above, you’ll see a ... Read more »

How to use two VPNs on one device

Installing your first VPN gets you all kinds of benefits. You’re more protected when you access public Wi-Fi, you can unblock Netflix and hundreds of other sites, and go torrenting ... Read more »

Elon Musk warns rocket trouble risks bankrupting SpaceX

Elon Musk‘s SpaceX‘s super heavy-lift Starship explodes during a return landing attempt in December 2020 – REUTERS/Gene Blevins Elon Musk has warned staff at SpaceX that the company faces a ... Read more »

Rain to replace snow in the Arctic as climate heats, study finds

Photograph: Mario Tama/Getty Images Climate models show switch will happen decades faster than previously thought, with ‘profound’ implications Rain will replace snow as the Arctic’s most common precipitation as the ... Read more »

Parliamentary panel on Data Protection Bill to seek extension for report submission

Representative image The Joint Committee of Parliament (JCP) on the Personal Data Protection Bill will move a motion in Lok Sabha on December 1 seeking extension of time for presentation ... Read more »

Toyota: First UK Human Support Robot Home Trial at the Home of Anthony Walsh

© Getty Images Anthony Walsh Meets HSR Anthony Walsh lived in Southgate, North London, with his wife Siobhan and two young children.  He was diagnosed with MND in May 2021 ... Read more »

Live Cyber Monday deals still available

Read more »

COVID-19: Mild and moderate cases during pregnancy doesn't harm babies' brains, finds study

Parents should be reassured, there is "no evidence that a maternal SARS-CoV-2 infection has any effect on the brain development of the unborn child" say scientists. Read more »

OnePlus 8 series gets stable Android 12 update in the form of Paranoid Android Sapphire Alpha

Android 12 was finally released in its stable form on October 4 and the source code of the same was uploaded to AOSP on that particular day. The Paranoid Android ... Read more »

RNLI lifeboat 'blocked from going to rescue migrants by angry fishermen'

The RNLI Hastings lifeboat heads out to sea during a training exercise. (File photo: PA) A group of angry fishermen blocked a lifeboat from going to sea to rescue migrants ... Read more »

Johnson admits Moderna CEO 'probably right' about Omicron

Boris Johnson admits Moderna CEO Stephane Bancel is “probably right” about the possibility that current vaccines may struggle against the new Omicron Covid variant. He stresses though that Bancel was ... Read more »

Best Bluetooth speaker deals live now: Bose, JBL, Ultimate Ears and more

Online retailers often run so many Bluetooth speaker deals, you may find yourself thinking ‘where do I start’? Well, we humbly suggest that if you want the sonic performance to ... Read more »

Woman awarded $2.1 million in damages after Walmart got her arrested for shoplifting

An Alabama woman who says she was falsely arrested for shoplifting at a Walmart and then threatened by the company after her case was dismissed has been awarded USD 2.1 ... Read more »

MI6 boss warns of cyber threat from China

© Stefan Rousseau/PA Wire/PA Images Richard Moore Richard Moore will say terrorists, organised crime gangs and hostile states are wreaking havoc in both the physical and digital worlds. The Chief ... Read more »

Best identity management software of 2021

The best identity management software makes it simple and easy to implement and manage user authentication with Single Sign-On (SSO) apps. The best identity management software Click the links below ... Read more »

These Google Pixelbook Go Cyber Monday deals are brilliant...and end today

Out of the many Chromebooks you can currently buy, the Google Pixelbook Go is easily one of the best out there, and showcases what can be done with ChromeOS. It’s ... Read more »

Why open source makes enterprises more secure and innovative

Open source software is everywhere. It is pervasive, in every sector, with 99% of software projects containing an open source component. And the reason is that open source is an ... Read more »

AWS re:Invent 2021 keynote live blog

Refresh 2021-11-29T17:22:56.100Z (Image credit: Future / Mike Moore) This is of course the first in-person AWS re:Invent since 2019, and thousands of attendees, customers and AWS employees have flocked to ... Read more »

Many workers were stuck with barely functional laptops during the pandemic

Poorly performing laptops and an often unresponsive IT department were some of the toughest challenges facing remote and hybrid workers during the pandemic, new research has found. Polling more than ... Read more »

Why I call bullshit on “the Apple Car's” rumored 2025 release

If you’re a fan of “allegedly,” “people close to the source,” and other rumor-inducing phrases — any coverage about the Apple iCar should be your cup of tea. This week, ... Read more »

Elizabeth Holmes testifies alleged sexual assault by former partner influenced her to mislead investors

The former CEO of Theranos, who is charged with falsely claiming to investors that her company had invented a revolutionary blood test, is on trial in the US. Read more »
On free-english-test.com you will find lots of free English exam practice materials to help you improve your English skills: grammar, listening, reading, writing, ielts, toeic