Why the conviction of 2 Hamilton paramedics in Yosif Al-Hasnawi's death may change health care

paramedics were found guilty, appeal

In a legal first in Canada, two paramedics were found guilty for their part in the death of a Hamilton 19-year-old. Now, emergency responders wonder how that precedent might change the way they do their jobs. 

An Ontario Superior Court judge on Tuesday found Steven Snively and Christopher Marchant guilty of failing to provide the necessaries of life to Al-Hasnawi, who had been shot and later died in hospital.

John Schuman, a paramedic and lawyer, says paramedics followed the trial and conviction with intense interest. 

“From the paramedics' perspective, if we make any mistake now, are we going to get charged? And if we have a bad day, and our judgment's off, are we going to get charged?” said Schuman, who specializes in family law, education law and children's rights in Toronto. 

Judge calls death a 'tragic case'

On Dec. 2, 2017, Al-Hasnawi was outside a mosque with one of his brothers and others. The shooting happened after he intervened when he saw two people accost an older man. Dale King, who shot Al-Hasnawi, was acquitted last year of second-degree murder in a decision now under appeal.

Snively, 55, and Marchant, 32, testified in their trial that they believed the 19-year-old was shot with a BB gun. But they were wrong — it was a .22-calibre handgun, and the teenager died from internal bleeding about one hour later. 

“To say this is a tragic case would be a gross understatement,” Justice Harrison Arrell said in delivering his decision.

The judge ruled there was a “marked departure” from how a properly trained paramedic would have responded. 

The paramedics didn't identify the wound was a penetrating one and participated in dangerous lifts to move Al-Hasnawi from the sidewalk, Arrell said.

They also delayed leaving the scene down the street from the mosque in Hamilton's lower city.

“I conclude these various failures by the accused were not simple inadvertence, thoughtlessness or simple errors in judgment, but instead were a conscious decision to ignore their training and standards,” said Arrell.

paramedics were found guilty, appeal

Ramifications throughout health-care field

Schuman said the charge usually relates to people responsible for those in custody, who are entirely dependent on others or children. He stressed the ramifications aren't exclusive to paramedics, despite them being at the centre of the trial. 

“Because of the way the legal test applies, it should apply to all health-care professions,” he said. 

He wonders if families will insist health-care professionals should be charged if they deviate from protocols or choose a treatment with more “risk” to save someone's life. 

Dr. Najma Ahmed, an expert in trauma and critical care, testified at the paramedics' trial that Al-Hasnawi had about a 50 per cent chance of survival that night. 

Mario Posteraro, president of OPSEU Local 256, the union that represents Hamilton paramedics, attended the entire trial, which started in November 2020.

He said that when charges were laid in 2018, “it sent both a chill through the paramedic profession, [and] a bit of a shockwave to the broader health-care sector as to what the potential precedent might be.”

“I think the concern and the chill that occurred when the charges were filed have now deepened, and we don't really have all of the answers,” he said.

The worry, Posteraro said, is paramedics' treatment on scene, transport decisions, and the care rendered will be scrutinized through a different lens — one that puts workers “in the direct line of fire.”

paramedics were found guilty, appeal

A change for the better, family friend says

Firas Al Najim, a friend of the Al-Hasnawi family and human rights activist, said Tuesday he believes it will change the field for the better. 

“Hopefully there's not going to be any case in the future. The paramedics are going to know not to deal with a patient like this,” he said. 

“When he's telling you he can't breathe, if he's hurt, just take him to the trauma centre. Do your job. You're not there to see if he's acting.”

A substantial section of the trial focused on whether the paramedics followed protocols laid out in the Basic Life Support Patient Care Standards used by Ontario's Ministry of Health.

Failing to follow protocols, Arrell said, deprived Yosif of his only chance of survival.

Delay was unjustified, judge said

The paramedics spent 23 minutes on scene that night; 17 of those minutes were in the back of the ambulance.

Dr. Richard Verbeek, medical director for Toronto paramedics at the Sunnybrook Centre for Prehospital Medicine, testified for multiple days.

He said 23 minutes would be “within what we might expect given average circumstances at a trauma scene” in North America for blunt and penetrating wounds as a combined category. 

But Verbeek, who edited the standards, noted that a penetrating wound qualified Al-Hasnawi as a “load-and-go” situation to the lead trauma hospital.

Arrell said the wait was “unjustified” and it was foreseeable the paramedics were risking Al-Hasnawi's life.

Schuman said paramedics are taught to “assume the worst.” But the tests they perform can also change hospital destination, treatment regimens, and how the hospital may react to an incoming patient, he said.

“You don't want to rush that. You don't want to have people doing the wrong thing because they're in a pressure to get moving.”

For a while, he said, people may feel pressure to treat everyone, regardless of presentation, as “being on death's door.”

“That's going to consume a lot of resources.” 

Future of care

Posteraro also said it's a possibility that care will be impacted following the judgment. 

“It may be an extreme on either side of the equation. Perhaps care may suffer as a result of health-care providers, paramedics, looking at a call or treating a patient through a different lens — looking at it more defensively versus in the best interest of the patient,” he said. 

The outcome, Schuman said, may raise questions for workers about remaining as a frontline paramedic or transitioning to a more distanced role, like a supervisor. 


News Related


New COVID-19 cases have dropped 80 per cent — and 5.3 million more shots are set to arrive next week

After months of mostly bad news, Canada's chief public health officer said today the country's COVID-19 trajectory has improved dramatically and an anticipated flood of doses should put the country “on the path… Read more »

Canada to commit to sharing up to 100 million COVID-19 vaccine doses

Canada will commit to sharing up to 100 million doses of COVID-19 vaccines with the world in a formal announcement that will come later in the G7 summit, the country's high commissioner to the… Read more »

Why sunscreen is your most important skincare product, as Jesse Tyler Ferguson will tell you – Modern Family star just got ‘a bit of skin cancer’ removed

Actor Jesse Tyler Ferguson is sharing an important reminder after getting “a bit of skin cancer” removed from his neck. In a post to Instagram this week, the Modern Family star, 45, urged… Read more »

Coronavirus: What's happening in Canada and around the world Friday

The latest: Canada to commit to sharing up to 100 million COVID-19 vaccine doses, official says. Canada is easing its travel restrictions. Here's what you need to know. Here's what you can and can't… Read more »

MMCA highlights humans’ playful side

Read more »

‘Run to the moon’ to raise mental health awareness, and funds for charity, offers Hongkongers big prizes

Hongkonger Roger Chan looks fresh and energised as he bounds into the foyer of Soho House in Sheung Wan, on Hong Kong Island. It’s hard to believe that earlier in the day he… Read more »

Seoul Auction to hold biggest art auction since 2008

Read more »

More vaccine doses have now been administered in Victoria than NSW

More vaccine doses have now been administered in Victoria than NSW, as vaccination rates spiked during its latest Covid-19 outbreak. Restrictions began to ease in Melbourne on Friday after a two-week lockdown, after… Read more »

How the COVID-19 pandemic lowered life expectancy in Canada last year

COVID-19 deaths led to a  five-month decrease in life expectancy at birth last year, recent data released by Statistics Canada suggest, potentially putting the country at a level not seen in seven years. The… Read more »

Ontario stands firm on 12-week interval for AstraZeneca doses — against experts' advice

Citing the need for speed against the growing threat of the coronavirus delta variant, infectious diseases specialists say they disagree with the Ontario government's decision to maintain a 12-week waiting period before people who received a first… Read more »

U.S. pledge of 500M doses 'a small piece of the puzzle' in global vaccination race: expert

Health officials and experts around the world on Thursday welcomed a U.S. plan to donate 500 million more COVID-19 vaccines to developing countries, but the celebrations came with hesitation. For instance, when exactly… Read more »

Coronavirus: What's happening in Canada and around the world on Thursday

The latest: U.S. legislation seeks to up pressure for Canadian border reopening. Canada still lacks national guidance for fully vaccinated Canadians as travel restrictions ease. Who decided Ontario schools should stay closed? Government won't… Read more »

Who decided Ontario schools should stay closed? Government won't say, but doctors call on Ford to reconsider

There is a simple question that the Ontario government won't answer about its decision to keep schools closed while opening patios and non-essential retail stores: Whose idea was it? Normally, the government says… Read more »

Managers at centre of nursing college probe 'caused or contributed to' young woman's death, mother alleges

Katrina Lavery had a thirst for life. She loved people and animals and rarely argued with her mother — even during her teenage years. “[She was] the happiest camper every morning of every day… Read more »

Canada still lacks national guidance for fully vaccinated Canadians as travel restrictions ease

Confusion about what you can do once fully vaccinated The National 1 day ago 2:04 A lack of guidelines has fully vaccinated Canadians confused about what they can and can’t do, but there’s… Read more »

Man dies in Adelaide hospital after contracting meningococcal disease

A 69-year-old man has died in an Adelaide hospital after becoming ill with meningococcal disease. South Australian Health said the man had been infected with the serotype W strain. “Multiple people who had… Read more »

Thousands of Sydneysiders on Covid alert over Castle Hill wastewater detection

NSW Health has identified more than 300 contacts linked to the infectious Victorian couple who escaped lockdown, with Sydneysiders put on Covid-19 alert following virus fragments found in sewage. Traces of coronavirus have… Read more »

Melbourne: Dr Ahmed Kamil Mohamed Cassim accused of sexually assaulting young female patients

A Melbourne doctor is accused of sexually assaulting three young female patients, groping one’s buttocks and calling her a “pretty lady” and joking about the age another had become sexually active. Dr Ahmed… Read more »

Pandemic has left backlog of almost 16 million medical procedures in Ontario, doctors say

The COVID-19 pandemic has left an estimated backlog of 15.9 million surgeries, diagnostic exams, screenings and other medical procedures that should otherwise have been performed in Ontario, the Ontario Medical Association (OMA) says. … Read more »

Treatments for post-vaccine blood clots show promise but no 'slam dunk,' Canadian doctors say

Ever since health officials announced Canada's first known case of rare, post-vaccination blood clots back in April, scientists have been racing to learn more about what causes the potentially deadly condition — and… Read more »

U.S. vaccines may be able to make up for India's export controls: World Bank president

Head of World Bank on global vaccine equity and the economic legacy of pandemic Power and Politics 1 hour ago 9:03 “If you have excess doses this month and next month, release them… Read more »

After weeks of uncertainty, Moderna says 7 million vaccine doses will arrive this month

Public Services and Procurement Minister Anita Anand said today that Moderna will ship seven million more vaccine doses to Canada this month, ending weeks of uncertainty over when the Massachusetts-based company would deliver the long-promised… Read more »

Politics, nationalism hamper global COVID-19 vaccination efforts

The global threat of COVID-19 vaccine inequality The National 1 day ago 7:26 As Canada reopens, about 88 per cent of the world hasn’t had a single COVID-19 shot and experts warn the… Read more »

Coronavirus: What's happening in Canada and around the world on Wednesday

The latest: Quebec gives high school seniors green light for proms and graduation ceremonies. Rehiring is finally on the table for more restaurants — but not all workers are coming back. Fully vaccinated… Read more »

Woolies apologises for ‘insensitive’ push to build massive Darwin Dan Murphy’s store, not properly consulting Indigenous people

Woolworth’s consultation process for a new booze barn in Darwin prioritised commercial objectives over good relations with the community and was insensitive towards local Indigenous people, a panel has found. Through its subsidiary… Read more »

[Herald Interview] Digital artist Cody Choi questions nature of ‘digital art’

A cropped image of “Database Painting Series 1 – Stolen Data, Tiger #00” by Cody Choi (PKM Gallery)When PKM Gallery showed Cody Choi’s “Database Painting Series 1 – Stolen Data, Tiger #00” at… Read more »

[Feature] NFT art shakes up Korean art market

A screenshot of Mr. Misang’s virtual gallery that shows the “Modern Life is Rubbish” series (Park Yuna/The Korea Herald)When it was recently announced that NFT-based artworks by Korean modern art masters — Kim… Read more »

Jim’s Mowing franchisee has small win in lockdown battle with Vic government

Jim’s Mowing has won a bid to have its legal challenge to Victoria’s lockdown heard separately to six other businesses. Jim’s Mowing founder Jim Penman is bankrolling his franchisee Steve Thompson in a… Read more »

AMA calls for 20 per cent tax on sugary drinks, flags support for rise in alcohol prices

Australia’s peak medical body has demanded a tax on high-sugar drinks. Speaking to the National Press Club on Wednesday, Australian Medical Association (AMA) President Omar Khorshid also indicated support for a rise in… Read more »

The number of people with second jobs continues to climb after Covid dip

About 23,000 more Australians are holding down multiple jobs, compared to the start of the pandemic, latest figures reveal. The proportion of people working more than one job jumped over the March quarter,… Read more »

Union calls for police to be prioritised in vaccine rollout

Victorian police are arguing they should be prioritised in the vaccine rollout, claiming the health department has been “slow to move”. Police association state secretary Wayne Gatt said the infrastructure of Victoria’s centralised… Read more »

Attempted suicide rates among Victorian teenagers soar by 184 per cent in past six months, Kids Helpline reveals

Attempted suicide rates among Victorian teenagers have skyrocketed by 184 per cent in the past six months. Disturbing new data from the Kids Helpline revealed the shocking statistic after Victoria was plunged into… Read more »

2 paramedics found guilty in death of Hamilton teen Yosif Al-Hasnawi

Two Hamilton paramedics who treated dying teenager Yosif Al-Hasnawi in 2017 are guilty of failing to provide the necessaries of life, an Ontario Superior Court judge has found.   Steven Snively, 55, and Christopher Marchant,… Read more »

Coronavirus: What's happening in Canada and around the world on Tuesday

What's keeping the world from getting vaccinated against COVID-19? The National 12 hours ago 7:26 Voices on the ground in Venezuela, India and Nigeria paint a picture of how politics, nationalism and capitalism… Read more »

New Alzheimer's drug approved in U.S. despite concerns about effectiveness

U.S. government health officials on Monday approved the first new drug for Alzheimer's disease in nearly 20 years, disregarding warnings from independent advisers that the much-debated treatment hasn't been shown to help slow… Read more »

Coex Urban Park festival to send message of hope amid pandemic

An illustrated image of Lee Ki-taek’s media art that will be on display during Coex Urban Park festival (Coex)Public art festival Coex Urban Park will kick off Wednesday for a four-day run, aiming… Read more »

Melbourne couple quarantining in Brisbane after Qatar return denied chance to meet premature newborn

A Melbourne couple who gave birth while in quarantine and were immediately separated from their baby have had a request for an exemption to meet their son denied by health authorities. Sarah and… Read more »

Coronavirus: What's happening in Canada and around the world on Monday

Quebec cheers on Canadiens, further loosening of restrictions The National 13 hours ago 1:38 Some Montreal Canadiens fans were able to cheer on the team in person as more restrictions lifted in Quebec,… Read more »

More new mothers are seeking mental health supports amid overwhelming strain during the pandemic

Abigail Morran was no stranger to anxiety, but for years, she had it under control. Then the first-time mom, who lives in a town just outside Winnipeg, started to feel more anxious while… Read more »

New national hotline to help Australians living with autism

Australians with autism will have access to online, digital and phone-based support services that can offer specific advice through a new national hotline. The federal government will announce the $8.4 million funding boost… Read more »

Peta Hickey: Victorian executive had allergic reaction to dye during heart check

A Victorian woman wasn’t given a potentially life-saving injection when she had a deadly allergic reaction to a dye before she had a heart scan, a court has heard. Peta Hickey died in… Read more »

Architecture biennale to explore impact of pandemic

A poster promotes the third Seoul Biennale of Architecture and Urbanism. (Seoul Metropolitan Government)The third Seoul Biennale of Architecture and Urbanism will run Sept. 16 to Oct. 31. The theme is “Crossroads, Building… Read more »

Postpartum mental health visits spiked by more than 25 per cent in pandemic, research shows

Abigail Morran was no stranger to anxiety, but for years, she had it under control. Then the first-time mom, who lives in a town just outside Winnipeg, started to feel more anxious while… Read more »

Man hits out at Coles over treatment of his father after he struggled with QR code

A Melbourne man has hit out at Coles over the way his father, who has Parkinson’s disease, was treated after struggling with using the QR code. Mark, a caller to 3AW radio, explained… Read more »

Meningococcal outbreak: St Paul’s Catholic College in Manly offered antibiotics for students and staff following outbreak on Sydney’s northern beaches

A Sydney school has been offered antibiotics as a preventive measure following an outbreak of meningococcal disease late last month. NSW Health issued a public health alert about two weeks ago after two… Read more »

Colombian worker returns to Perth hotel quarantine as a precaution

A maritime worker who tested positive to Covid-19 for a second time has been returned to hotel quarantine as a precaution after he posed a “very, very low risk” of spreading the virus,… Read more »

St Paul’s Catholic College in Manly offered antibiotics following meningococcal outbreak on Sydney’s northern beaches

A Sydney school has been offered antibiotics as a preventive measure following an outbreak of meningococcal disease late last month. NSW Health issued a public health alert about two weeks ago after two… Read more »

Queensland Premier Annastacia Palaszczuk and her health team receive Covid-19 vaccine

Annastacia Palaszczuk has received a Covid-19 vaccination, becoming the last eligible state or territory leader to be administered with a jab. The Queensland Premier was administered her first dose of the Pfizer vaccine… Read more »

COVID-19 shows pharmacists have bigger role to play in Canada's health-care system, experts say

White Coat Black Art26:28Pharmacists rising In the confusing early days of the pandemic when many family doctors' offices unexpectedly closed to in-person appointments, phones started ringing off the hook at pharmacies across the… Read more »

Coronavirus: What's happening in Canada and around the world on Saturday

The latest: Race between vaccines and variants is back on as B.1.617 takes hold in Canada. Worried about heart inflammation and COVID-19 vaccines? Here's what we know. Church closed by Alberta Health Services… Read more »