Why Partition of India still awaits a conscientious litterateur

the latest tech news, global tech news daily, tech news today, startups, usa tech, asia tech, china tech, eu tech, global tech, in-depth electronics reviews, 24h tech news, 24h tech news, top mobile apps, tech news daily, gaming hardware, big tech news, useful technology tips, expert interviews, reporting on the business of technology, venture capital funding, programing language

Why partition of india still awaits a conscientious litterateur

Partition of India

the latest tech news, global tech news daily, tech news today, startups, usa tech, asia tech, china tech, eu tech, global tech, in-depth electronics reviews, 24h tech news, 24h tech news, top mobile apps, tech news daily, gaming hardware, big tech news, useful technology tips, expert interviews, reporting on the business of technology, venture capital funding, programing language

Leon Uris is a name largely unfamiliar to both the millennial and the woke “generation”. But even on the anvil of the 1990s — especially in the aftermath of the fall of the USSR followed by Iraq’s invasion of Kuwait — Uris was quite a force to reckon with in the annals of popular novelists. But the work that flung him overnight into literary superstardom still remains the landmark Exodus, published in 1958. It is undoubtedly a classic in that genre.

Speaking in 1959 about the motive and inspiration that impelled him to write the work and the extreme reactions it elicited, Uris said: “There is a whole school of American Jewish writers who spend their time damning their fathers, hating their mothers, wringing their hands and wondering why they were born. This isn’t art or literature. It’s psychiatry. These writers are professional apologists. Every year you find one of their works on the best-seller list. Their work is obnoxious and makes me sick to my stomach. I wrote Exodus because I was just sick of apologizing — or feeling that it was necessary to apologise.”

Global Tech News Daily

And now, 63 years since, Leon Uris’ lambast of defiant courage in the face of such widespread pusillanimity endures both as a beacon of light and as an eternal reminder that truth has few friends. His classic Exodus is still relevant not only because of Uris’ abiding conviction in Israel and the Jewish cause but because it is also a contemporary showcase of that other truth: that literature (or generally speaking, art) is an intensely powerful — and in many cases, an unerring key to understanding history, civilisation, and culture in the profoundest sense: through real people.

We find a deeply philosophical expository echo of the truth of Leon Uris’ words in the preface of SL Bhyrappa’s explosive bestselling literary phenomenon, Aavarana. On another occasion, responding to a question about whether he wasn’t afraid to write such a no-holds-barred novel, Bhyrappa said, “My view of literature is that it is a quest for truth, and if I don’t tell it even now, I think that there will be no meaning for my life as a writer. The freedom of expression that our Constitution guarantees us also includes the freedom to tell the truth.” [Paraphrased]

Global Tech News Daily

This, in my view, is one of the simplest maxims to conquer fear.

Civilisational apologia as literature

On the plane of pure passion, the lament of the righteous anger of Leon Uris applies 100 per cent to the corpus of literature churned out in independent India about a definitive epoch in its long history: Partition of Bharatavarsha. Partition remains one of humankind’s greatest tragedies engineered by the combined forces of two Abrahamisms. But literary works based on Partition written in India by Indians exemplify Leon Uris’ description: an agglomeration of textual apologia and an attempt to induce civilisational amnesia in the present tense.

A brief contrast of the global impact of Exodus brilliantly illustrates the existential grand canyon of post-Independence literary shame in India. Here are a few quotes:

“Two months after the tenth anniversary a novel was published in America that changed the public perception of Israel and the Jews. Exodus by the Jewish US ex-marine Leon Uris became an international publishing phenomenon, the biggest bestseller in the United States since Gone with the Wind. Both the novel and the subsequent movie thrust Israel into the lives of millions, and with it initiated a new sympathy for the young country.” [Jill Hamilton: God, Guns and Israel]

“[Exodus is] an antidote to the public silence of American Jews… Something fundamental changed among American Jews as a result of the book.” [Mathew Silver]

“[The effect of Exodus] is so extraordinary that I wanted to go and fight for Israel, even die, if need be, for Israel. Israel spoke to the need I had as a young black man for a place where I could be free of being an object of hatred. I did not wish I were Jewish, but was glad that Jews had a land of their own, even if blacks didn’t.” [Julius Lester]

However, which literary work immediately strikes our memory when Partition is mentioned? Until recently, it was the Nehru dynasty-cupbearer, Khushwant Singh’s eminent apologia titled Train to Pakistan. This pamphlet, disguised as literature, stood unchallenged for decades as the unquestionable Quran of the Nehruvian literary establishment. Then there is Qurratulain Hyder’s voluminous Urdu novel, Aag ka Dariya (River of Fire), ambitious in scope but expectedly ‘secular’ in its tenor and outcome. The fact that the author chooses the fall of the Nanda dynasty to begin her epic mound of apologetics is quite revelatory.



Next, we have another Nehruvian court laureate, Yashpal’s Hindi novel, Jhoota Sach (False Truth), which is a communist comrade’s telling of Partition through the tainted spectacles of class warfare. The less said about Bhisham Sahni’s Tamas, the better. But the most recent granddaddy of all Partition “literature” emerging from India is Salman Rushdie’s Midnight’s Children, which does have some flashes of honesty but is clearly tailored to the former colonial master’s sensibilities. The Booker Prize it received is the best proof of this.

The near-unanimous theme, the inescapable conclusion of all these books is this: no one person or one community is to blame for the Partition. This is a convenient fraud of blaming the invisible “system” for the crimes committed by the actors helming the system and absolving them of their guilt. Taking the line propagated by all such litterateurs, it appears that all of humanity in India spontaneously decided to voluntarily plunge into murderous insanity thanks to the actions or provocations of this amorphous “system”.

Aesthetics and Nehruvian politics

In purely aesthetic terms, a work of literature should not have a “conclusion” because life, the fount of literature, is a continuum, not a conclusion.

This sort of “literature,” as Uris correctly noted, makes us sick. It distorts because it prevaricates. But lest I be accused of partiality or bias, there is a handy test to determine the true mettle of creative literature on the Partition of India that appeared after independence: verify the kind of awards the authors received and the general tenor of reviews of such books. An overwhelming majority of these authors — as noted above — swore allegiance to the Nehruvian establishment.

While I am no fan of prescriptive literature, it must be said that when the author chooses a contemporary theme, honesty, and not audience, must drive the work. Creative liberty is not an excuse for falsehood. Interpretation cannot become a woolen blanket to conceal evasiveness.

As a historical event, the Partition of Bharatavarsha was the savage triumph of virulent Islamic fanaticism which had lost its imperial power but never stopped its grisly quest for reclaiming that power which is needed to sustain this fanaticism. RC Majumdar who wrote the most authentic history of the Indian freedom struggle minces no words to describe the phenomenon: “Jinnah put up a brave fight. It was, however, a fight not for the freedom of India…but for the freedom of the Muslims from the tyrannical yoke of the Hindus, as he put it. He won the fight; the cult of violence decided the issue…there is no doubt that the creation of Pakistan was the triumph of violence… Whatever Hindus might think of Jinnah, he has secured a high place in the history of the Muslim nation, a term at which we can hardly cavil after the foundation of Pakistan. He carried to its logical consummation the work that was begun by Sir Syed Ahmad.”

Clearly, Islamic fanaticism fractionally reclaimed its former power in the form of Pakistan, a usurped geography named after a religion, and after reclaiming it, set about permanently erasing the historical and sacred markers of this geography.

Where partition literature should begin

Thus, as a theme for a profound literary exploration of Partition, the story should actually begin from the alien Islamic invasions of India, and not the clever-by-half falsehood of Aag ka Dariya which begins with the downfall of the Nanda dynasty. Or, if the author is untalented or lacks this sort of sweeping erudition, the story can begin with the death of Aurangzeb because the modern roots of the Partition, most visibly, were planted during that period. One branch of that poisonous tree birthed and sustained by those roots is now known as Pakistan. And over the last decade, we notice other trunks of the same tree on our TV “debates” where assorted Mullahs and Imams unapologetically declare that Mahmud of Ghazni and Aurangzeb are the true heroes of Islam in India.

In many ways, these 75 years after the Partition of Bharatavarsha provide a fertile ground for not only a dispassionate literary exploration of the epochal tragedy but a virgin field for truth-tellers, especially those who are genuinely disgusted with phoney passages masquerading as profound literature. Here is a sample. “The Indo-Muslim lifestyle is made up of the Persian-Turki-Mughal and regional Rajput Hindu cultures. So, what is this Indian-ness which the Muslim League has started questioning? Could there be an alternate India? [Aag ka Darya]

In the Sanatana tradition, poets and litterateurs are seated on the same high pedestal as the rishis. Partition is both an overwhelming invitation to and a far-reaching challenge for present-day creative writers to test for themselves, excavate their conscience and see how best they can elevate themselves to this high, rishi-pedestal.

As recently as 2007, Bhyrappa pioneered this conscientious path with Aavarana. Even if a tenth of that summit is reached, it would be nothing short of path-breaking in the present era of aridity in the field of creative fiction. A decade and a half has elapsed since that masterpiece was published. The Partition of India awaits a similarly gifted pen to reveal itself.

The author is founder and chief editor, ‘The Dharma Dispatch’. Views expressed are personal.

News Related


This is America: It's not just Asian American and Pacific Islander Heritage Month anymore

Asian American and Pacific Islander Heritage Month was already a lot to take in. There are so many distinct cultures and disparate experiences within these two massive identity groups, so ... Read more »

Red-hot inflation is probably costing you an extra $311 per month

Financial squeeze stems from the rising cost for a number of everyday goods Read more »

How Kurtwood Smith Approached His Character In Firestarter - Exclusive

Blumhouse/Universal Stephen King’s 1980 novel, “Firestarter,” was the celebrated horror author’s first full-fledged foray into science fiction, after incorporating elements of the genre into his two previous books, “The Stand” ... Read more »

The Devastating Death Of Tremors Star Fred Ward

Kevin Winter/Getty The entertainment world is reeling today at the news that character actor extraordinaire Fred Ward has died at the age of 79. No cause of death has been ... Read more »

Formula shortage reveals GOP's compassion for American babies, anger over nourished immigrant ones

Cearly these Republicans are addressing the baby-formula shortage through the scriptural philosophy of: “All lives are precious, expect these little immigrant whiners over here. They can pound sand.” Read more »

Self-driving truck company looks to fix supply chain issues for the long haul

Embark Trucks successfully completes autonomous driving tests in winter conditions Read more »

A timeline of billionaire Elon Musk's bid to control Twitter

Elon Musk announced on Friday that his plan to buy Twitter in a proposed $44 billion deal is “ temporarily on hold ” as he tries to pinpoint the exact ... Read more »

Protesters demand arrest of former Sri Lankan PM over attack

The Associated PressSri Lankans protest demanding president Gotabaya Rajakasa resign and decrying the appointment of Prime Minister Ranil Wickeremesinghe in Colombo, Sri Lanka, Friday, May 13, 2022. Five-time former Sri ... Read more »

Law & Order: SVU Fans Are Outraged With Olivia Benson After Season 23, Episode 21

Michael Greenberg/NBC Since the series debuted in 1999, “Law & Order: SVU” fans have rallied behind the exploits of protagonist Captain Olivia Benson (Mariska Hargitay). As the Commanding Officer of ... Read more »

Here's Who's Hosting The Saturday Night Live Season Finale

Amy Sussman/Getty The untold truth of “Saturday Night Live” involves all sorts of behind-the-scenes shenanigans, but when it comes to the show’s guest hosts, few things are left untold. There’s a ... Read more »

Woman arrested in 2002 Missouri hospital patient's death

On Location: May 13, 2022 Catch up on the developing stories making headlines.The Associated Press CHILLICOTHE, Mo. — A former respiratory therapist charged with first-degree murder in the death of ... Read more »

Inflation has eroded 40% of Social Security's purchasing power since 2000

Social Security would need to increase by $539 per month to offset inflation Read more »

Toddler weighing under 10 pounds dies; parents arrested

The Associated PressThis photo provided by Polk County, Florida, Sheriff’s Office shows Arhonda Tillman and Regis Johnson. A 2-year-old girl in Florida weighing less than 10 pounds (4.5 kilograms) died ... Read more »

Jesse Spencer Responds To Those Leaked Chicago Fire Finale Images

Timothy Hiatt/Getty Matthew Casey (Jesse Spencer) has been a fixture on “Chicago Fire” ever since the very first episode. Originally starting off as a lieutenant for the first six seasons, ... Read more »

Multiverse Of Madness Screenwriter Reveals Elizabeth Olsen's Reaction To Scarlet Witch's Violent Scene - Exclusive

Kevin Mazur/Getty Images Spoiler warning: This article includes major plot details from “Doctor Strange in the Multiverse of Madness.” Arguably one of the most dramatic character arcs in the history ... Read more »

Pilots at United will vote on contract after tentative deal

The Associated PressFILE – In this July 2, 2021 file photo, a United Airlines jetliner taxis down a runway for take off from Denver International Airport in Denver. United Airlines ... Read more »

Unionists block new N Ireland govt over Brexit trade rules

The Associated PressFILE – Democratic Unionist Party leader Jeffrey Donaldson pauses as he speaks to the media at Parliament Buildings, Stormont, Belfast, Monday, May 9, 2022. Britain and the European ... Read more »

Five-year-old girl dies after being found unconscious in the sea in Stavanger

The five-year-old girl who was found lifeless in the sea in Stavanger on Thursday night was declared dead at the hospital on Friday. The police do not suspect that the ... Read more »

Mixed Texas ruling allows trans youth parent investigations

AUSTIN, Texas — The Texas Supreme Court on Friday allowed the state to investigate parents of transgender youth for child abuse while also ruling in favor of one family that ... Read more »

Mimi Rogers Cried When She Learned About Her Bosch Character's Fate - Exclusive

Tyler Golden/Amazon Freevee Emmy-nominated actress Mimi Rogers has more than 100 IMDb credits to her name, but dedicated fans of “Bosch” almost certainly know her best from her role as the ... Read more »

Severe storms blamed for 2 deaths in South Dakota, Minnesota

Severe weather hits the Heartland and moves East Chief meteorologist Ginger Zee has the latest forecast after damaging storm reports from Kansas to Minnesota. The Associated Press SIOUX FALLS, S.D. ... Read more »

Jesse Williams addresses leak of Broadway nude scene

The Associated PressMichael Oberholtzer, from left, Jesse Williams and Jesse Tyler Ferguson attend the Tony Awards: Meet The Nominees media day at the Sofitel New York on Thursday, May 12, ... Read more »

House of Representatives to give staff free Peloton memberships, costing taxpayers

The benefit is is being offered to Capitol Police officers and House staff Read more »

Elon Musk pausing Twitter deal because of spam accounts not a ‘legitimate excuse': Market expert

Musk could be putting the Twitter deal on hold to renegotiate the price, says Gregg Smith Read more »

Here's Why Moon Knight Could Suddenly Fly In The Final Episode

Disney+/Marvel Studios Marvel’s “Moon Knight” wraps up its six-episode run with an epic battle between Marc Spector/Steven Grant (Oscar Isaac) and the powerful zealot Arthur Harrow (Ethan Hawke). It’s a ... Read more »

The Fed raising interest rates will ‘create a recession,' Dick Bove warns

The Fed ‘can’t avoid’ a recession, the chief financial strategist stresses Read more »

German police investigate possible terrorism in knife attack

VIENNA — Police have arrested an Iraqi-born man and are investigating a possible Islamic extremist motive after five passengers received knife wounds on a regional train in western Germany, authorities ... Read more »

German police investigate possible Islamic extremist motive after 5 wounded in knife attack on train

BERLIN — German police investigate possible Islamic extremist motive after 5 wounded in knife attack on train. Read more »

Doctor Strange 2 Star Benedict Wong Recalls His Longtime Friendship With Benedict Cumberbatch - Exclusive

Noam Galai/Getty Images Thanks to the sprawling narrative of the MCU, many of the film saga’s actors have had the opportunity to work together again. That’s a good thing when ... Read more »

Queen attends horse show in first public appearance in weeks

The Associated PressBritain’s Queen Elizabeth II is joined by Prince Edward and Sophie, right, the Earl and Countess of Wessex as they sit in the Royal Box at the Royal ... Read more »

UN humanitarian official urges attention to drought in Kenya

The Associated PressVillagers gather during a visit by United Nations Under-Secretary-General for Humanitarian Affairs Martin Griffiths, in the village of Lomoputh in northern Kenya Thursday, May 12, 2022. Griffiths visited ... Read more »

Film Review: ‘Firestarter' remake fails to ignite

The Associated PressThis image released by Universal Pictures shows Ryan Kiera Armstrong as Charlie in a scene from “Firestarter.” (Ken Woroner/Universal Pictures via AP) For a movie about a girl ... Read more »

Report: Austria sees record number of antisemitic incidents

VIENNA — Antisemitic incidents reached a record high in Austria last year, according to a report published Friday. The statistics, compiled by the Jewish Community of Vienna, recorded 965 incidents ... Read more »

Germany: Over 300 far-right extremists at security agencies

VIENNA — The German government said Friday that it has identified more than 300 employees of national and state military, police and security agencies with links to far-right extremists or ... Read more »

38 rescued, 11 dead as US searches waters near Puerto Rico

SAN JUAN, Puerto Rico — At least 38 people have been rescued and 11 bodies found as the U.S. Coast Guard scoured the open waters northwest of Puerto Rico on ... Read more »

Becki Newton On The Joy Of Working With Neve Campbell On The Lincoln Lawyer And Her Dream Co-Star - Exclusive

Lara Solanki/Netflix Throughout her career, Becki Newton has worked with a string of talented actors, including Judith Light and Vanessa Williams on “Ugly Betty,” Neil Patrick Harris and Cobie Smulders ... Read more »

As the United States grapples with abortion law, what is the situation here in Norway?

The recent leaking of a draft decision, by the United States Supreme Court, to overturn more than 5 decades of the legal protection of a woman’s right to seek an ... Read more »

Nasdaq's nosedive nears pandemic crash of 2020

The 10-year yield hit 3.203% Monday – a 3.5 year high Read more »

Croatia passes law paving way for euro currency introduction

ZAGREB, Croatia — Croatian lawmakers on Friday approved a law that paves the way for the introduction of the euro currency next year. Croatia is due to replace the Croatian ... Read more »

Report: Missile attack kills 10 Syrian soldiers in the north

BEIRUT — A missile struck a Syrian military bus in the country’s north early on Friday, killing 10 soldiers, Syria’s state-run media and an opposition monitor said. It wasn’t immediately ... Read more »