Why Microsoft avoided antitrust scrutiny that plagued other tech giants in 2021

Asia's Tech News Daily

The Big Tech reckoning gained momentum in 2021, as U.S. regulators accused behemoths like Google and Facebook of abusing their market power to gain an illegal edge over competitors.

But one major name in tech avoided not only the ire of the public but also the reach of antitrust regulators in 2021: Microsoft (MSFT), Yahoo Finance’s Company of the Year and the second-largest company in the U.S. by market capitalization after Apple (AAPL).

Microsoft is indisputably a giant even among its massive peers. It has the world’s dominant desktop operating system in Windows and is second in cloud market share behind Amazon (AMZN); it also owns the planet’s biggest professional network, LinkedIn, and Slack rival Microsoft Teams.

So, why haven’t antitrust regulators pursued Microsoft recently? To be an illegal monopolist, a company has to have a dominant market share and engage in anti-competitive practices. And several antitrust experts say they just haven’t seen signs that Microsoft has violated antitrust law. Perhaps Microsoft learned its lesson from an epic antitrust lawsuit the Justice Department filed nearly 25 years ago. Since then, Microsoft has gotten bigger — but it appears to be playing by the rules.

“Size does not make any difference. We don’t go after firms because of their large size,” Herbert Hovenkamp, one of the world’s leading antitrust scholars, told Yahoo Finance. “For example, Walmart is bigger than Amazon, but nobody is talking about major public antitrust litigation against Walmart.”

Later, Hovenkamp added, “You have got to identify some product where there is both dominance and an exclusionary practice and it’s kind of hard to find one [with Microsoft]. That’s, I think, the bottom line.”

The antitrust war against the rest of Big Tech

The same cannot be said of other tech giants, if antitrust claims against them are true.

Google (GOOG, GOOGL) has the biggest target on its back: The search and advertising giant faces three pending antitrust lawsuits from state attorneys general and one from a coalition of AGs and the Justice Department. The latest government lawsuit, filed in July, targets Google’s app store, Google Play. The others focus on Google’s massive search and search advertising business: When the Justice Department filed its suit in October of last year, then-Attorney General Bill Barr called the company “the gatekeeper of the internet.”

Google CEO Sundar Pichai testifies during a remote video hearing in Washington, U.S., March 25, 2021. U.S. House of Representatives Energy and Commerce Committee/Handout via Reuters

Meanwhile, Facebook parent Meta Platforms (FB) is still defending itself against claims from the Federal Trade Commission that it scoops up rivals like Instagram and WhatsApp to destroy its competition.

For its part, Amazon got hit with an antitrust suit from the Washington, D.C. attorney general in May, while the FTC is considering whether to block its $8.45 billion acquisition of movie studio MGM. Even Apple, which is less maligned than other tech giants, reportedly faces an imminent antitrust lawsuit from the Justice Department over its control of the iPhone.

In antitrust cases such as these, the government may begin an investigation because competitors or customers sound the alarm over allegedly anti-competitive behavior. For example, “Fortnite” maker Epic Games sued both Apple and Google over their app store fees; meanwhile, Yelp waged a years-long campaign to get antitrust regulators to go after Google.

“The victims of anti-competitive behavior are not lying on the ground outside of a building. It’s not like street crime. They have to come into the enforcement agencies and complain or else the enforcement agencies don’t really know about it,” said Harry First, co-director of the Competition, Innovation, and Information Law Program at NYU Law.

Microsoft’s CEO Satya Nadella speaks at the Viva Tech start-up and technology summit in Paris, France, May 24, 2018. REUTERS/Charles Platiau TPX IMAGES OF THE DAY

In the case of Microsoft, experts said they haven’t seen evidence that competitors have complained of antitrust violations. One exception is Slack, which filed an antitrust complaint in the EU claiming Microsoft unfairly bundled Microsoft Teams into its “market dominant” Office productivity suite. Still, that case appears to be an outlier.

“Microsoft simply may be maintaining its market share by being a good competitor,” says John Lopatka, an antitrust expert and professor at Penn State Law.

‘Emboldened by success and wealth’

The Justice Department accused Microsoft of being a bad competitor back in 1998. That’s when the U.S. sued the company for allegedly engaging in a “broad pattern of anticompetitive conduct.” The case focused largely on Microsoft’s Internet Explorer browser, which it bundled into Windows for free — arguably at the expense of competing browsers like now-defunct Netscape.

Then-Microsoft CEO Bill Gates didn’t appear to help the case with an evasive deposition where he reportedly declined to answer many of the government’s questions. Stephen D. Houck, then a federal prosecutor in New York, compared Gates and other executives to arrogant professional athletes, The New York Times reported in 1998.

“Emboldened by success and wealth, Microsoft executives felt they could break the rules with impunity,” he reportedly said.

404302 04: Microsoft Corp. Chairman Bill Gates arrives at U.S. District Court with his wife Melinda April 22, 2002 in Washington, DC. Gates is taking the witness stand to give his first live testimony since the antitrust case was filed against the software giant in 1998. (Photo by Alex Wong/Getty Images)

The dispute dragged on for nearly five years, until 2002, when a judge signed off on most of a settlement between Microsoft and the Justice Department. As part of that deal, Microsoft agreed to make it easier for consumers to use rival software on Windows computers, among other concessions.

Microsoft has, it seems, followed both the letter and spirit of that settlement. For years prior to that settlement, the company had resisted opening up its software to other devices, as my colleague Dan Howley reports. But now it pushes to make its software available on other hardware — and vice versa.

“The Windows Operating System is absolutely open. It’s like a bazaar. … Microsoft doesn’t limit choices the way that Apple does in the App Store,” says Hovenkamp, the antitrust scholar.

Microsoft appears to have learned its lesson after fighting a costly antitrust battle often mentioned in the same breath as Standard Oil or AT&T. The years-long case, tough as it was for the company, was crucial for its development, Microsoft President Brad Smith said in 2008, a decade after the trial.

“When I look back at it from Microsoft’s perspective, it did mean many things, but I also think when I try to prioritize it in my own mind, it meant one thing more than any other,” he said in a speech at Harvard University. “It was a part of the maturing of Microsoft.”

Erin Fuchs is deputy managing editor at Yahoo Finance.

Follow Yahoo Finance on Twitter, Instagram, YouTube, Facebook, Flipboard, and LinkedIn

Internet Explorer Channel Network
Asia's Tech News Daily
News Related


University of Hyderabad, TCS team up for next-gen communication tech innovation

The University of Hyderabad (UoH), has tied up with Tata Consultancy Services (TCS) for collaboration in research and innovation on next-generation communications technologies, semiconductor engineering, and heterogeneous computing architectures.TCS and ... Read more »

China says will probe corrupt behaviour behind internet platform monopolies

China‘s top anti-graft watchdog said it would focus on “new challenges and new situations” in its corruption crackdown, pledging for instance to investigate and punish any corrupt behaviour found behind ... Read more »

What’s the best student laptop? We asked students

© Photo by Amelia Holowaty Krales / The Verge The Dell XPS 13 is one of the best laptops for high school and college students. Shopping for a laptop can ... Read more »

Microsoft's new security chip will not lock devices to Windows 11 as feared

New PCs released this year that ship with Microsoft’s Pluton security chip will still be able to run other operating systems besides Windows 11. While it was initially feared by ... Read more »

How to watch UFC 270: time, card and Ngannou vs Gane live stream details

UFC’s first PPV of the year is set to have an unmissable card in California, with a finely balanced heavyweight title showdown as its headline act. Read on to discover ... Read more »

Bengals vs Titans live stream: how to watch NFL Divisional playoff game online

Derrick Henry’s back, but can he pick up where he left off for the Bengals vs Titans NFL Divisional? Tennessee’s stud running back missed most of the season with a ... Read more »

The Xbox Series S is on sale at Woot for its lowest price ever

© Photo by Vjeran Pavic / The Verge Today only, you can pick up Microsoft’s next-gen console for just $279.99. While nabbing an Xbox Series S isn’t as difficult as ... Read more »

A group of Activision Blizzard workers is unionizing

Call of Duty: Warzone quality assurance workers at Activision Blizzard studio Raven Software have announced plans to unionize with the Communication Workers of America (CWA). They have asked the company ... Read more »

Slime Rancher 2 is adding rainbows, quality of life updates, and plenty of secrets

© Provided by GamesRadar Slime Rancher 2 Slime Rancher 2 is a vision in rainbows. While the first game wasn’t exactly muted in tone, developer Monomi Park is really dialling ... Read more »

The first demonstration of Wi-Fi 7 has left us breathless

© A_stockphoto / Shutterstock The next generation of Wi-Fi promises record speeds. Taiwanese manufacturer MediaTek announced that it has carried out the very first demonstration of Wi-Fi 7 technology. It ... Read more »

How to watch One Piece online from anywhere

Along with Naruto and Bleach, One Piece is often referred to as a member of ‘the Big Three’ or, in other words, it’s a must-watch for any anime fan. Luckily, ... Read more »

These best Oculus Quest 2 accessories are down to their cheapest ever prices

A selection of official Oculus Quest 2 accessories including the Elite Strap, Carrying Case, and Oculus Link Cable are reduced in both the US and UK. The discounts are fairly ... Read more »

French physicists developed a bubble that didn't burst for more than a year

Researchers from the University of Lille said their sphere lasted for 465 days. Read more »


© Provided by TechRadar PDFpenPro Review Listing We classify PDFpenPro under word processing software as opposed to just being a PDF editor. The original company behind the PDF editing software ... Read more »

A kibertérben már támadják Ukrajnát

© Technológia: Index.hu Zsarolóvírust kaptak váltságdíj nélkül Oroszország vagy Fehéroroszország felöl. A Microsoft számítógépes fenyegetéseket kezelő központja, a MSTIC blogbejegyzése szerint január közepén támadás érte több ukrán hivatal számítógépes rendszerét. ... Read more »

How to watch Fight Club online: stream on Netflix and anywhere

Fight Club is just about the definition of ‘cult classic’, and despite a relatively poor box-office showing in 1999 and plenty of controversy surrounding its themes, the adaptation of Chuck ... Read more »

Physicists discover “secret sauce” behind exotic properties of a new quantum material

New work on superconducting kagome metal will aid design of other unusual quantum materials, with many potential applications. Read more »

Employees at Activision studio Raven Software formally organize union

© Image: Activision After five weeks of striking, the QA testers at Raven Software, a subsidiary of Activision Blizzard, have formed one of the first unions in a AAA game ... Read more »

New York’s mayor is getting paid in Bitcoin. But can he pay the bills with it?

© Provided by The Guardian Photograph: Seth Wenig/AP New York’s new mayor gets his first paycheck on Friday – and as part of his bid to keep the city “on ... Read more »

Google denies Facebook collusion claims in new court filing and blog post

© Illustration by Alex Castro Google denies colluding with Facebook in new court filing Google has filed a motion to dismiss the antitrust complaint filed last week, which alleges it ... Read more »

Computing for ocean environments

MIT ocean and mechanical engineers are using advances in scientific computing to address the ocean’s many challenges, and seize its opportunities. Read more »

iRobot's Roomba j7+ is $250 off, plus the rest of the week's best tech deals

A bunch of new tech sales cropped up at the start of the week for things like robot vacuums, game controllers and more, and many of them are still around ... Read more »

God of War on the MacBook Air proves Apple accidently made a gaming laptop

Fancy playing God of War on the MacBook Air? Well, that’s possible, and indeed has been demonstrated by one Air owner, who posted a video of the game running online. ... Read more »

Moment Tory minister is told about man so hungry he has to eat toothpaste

A government minister has said he is “appalled” after being confronted by a report of a man going to bed so hungry he eats toothpaste to stave off the pains. ... Read more »

Companies intensifying industry-academia partnerships to foster talent

Jeon Kyung-hoon, left, the president of Samsung Electronics, poses with Chung Jin-taek, the president of Korea University, during a ceremony to mark their agreement to foster talent in the telecommunications ... Read more »

You can now reserve the Samsung Galaxy S22 and get $50 store credit

The next Samsung Galaxy smartphone – almost certainly the Galaxy S22 – is now available for reservation via the official Samsung site. Not only that, but you’ll get a neat ... Read more »

The Legend of Vox Machina review

There was a time when Dungeons & Dragons (D&D) was deemed uncool and nerdy. But, thanks to hit shows like Stranger Things, and the rise of D&D-centric YouTube and Twitch ... Read more »

WhatsApp gives us a glimpse at Android-to-iOS chat migration

WhatsApp is not only one of the most popular chat apps on the market, it is also one of the fastest evolving. It’s long been known that WhatsApp’s beta program ... Read more »

How sweeping E.U. rules would curb tech companies

The 27-nation bloc has gained a reputation as a trendsetter in the growing global push to rein in big tech companies. Read more »

Biden's cybersecurity policies praised despite persistence of ransomware

From Russian cyberespionage to attacks on crucial supply chains, the Biden administration has had no shortage of cybersecurity challenges to face. Read more »

Hack exposes data on 515,000 vulnerable people, Red Cross says

The agency said the breach targeted an external contractor in Switzerland that stores data, and there was no indication the information had been publicly shared or leaked. Read more »

Microsoft upgraded Windows Media Player—but you might still prefer one of these apps

© Windows / Unsplash Find the perfect program for loading up your movies and music. Microsoft never fully killed off the classic Windows Media Player, but in recent years it ... Read more »

Astronauts are losing 3 million red blood cells every second in space

© NASA Astronaut Tim Peake (right) completes a blood draw in space. The sample was taken as part of the MARROW experiment. Scientists have long known that life in space ... Read more »

Korea's tech trade logs second-highest tally of $29 bil. in 2020

gettyimagesbank Korea’s technology trade reached its second-highest tally ever at $29.9 billion in 2020, down 5.5 percent from the previous year, government data showed Friday.Technology trade refers to the country’s ... Read more »

Hyundai Samho's IPO plan angers investors in parent firm

Hyundai Samho Heavy Industries’ shipyard in Yeongam, South Jeolla Province. Courtesy of Hyundai Samho Heavy Industries Irregular worker’s death jeopardizes shipbuilder’s ESG rating By Park Jae-hyuk Minority shareholders of Korea ... Read more »

'Hyundai Motor shows no signs of rebound in China'

Hyundai Motor plans to sell its first plant in Beijing, after suspending its operation in 2019, as demand for its cars in China has been falling since 2017. Korea Times ... Read more »

Kakao names Namkoong Whon as new CEO

Namkoong Whon, new CEO of Kakao / Courtesy of Kakao Kakao, the operator of Korea’s top mobile messenger KakaoTalk, said Thursday it has named Namkoong Whon as its new CEO, ... Read more »

Korea aims to become world's 5th biggest metaverse market by 2026

gettyimagesbank The government unveiled a long-term road map to foster its metaverse industry Thursday, with the aim of becoming the world’s fifth-largest market over the next five years.Under the plan, ... Read more »

Hyundai, US firm join hands for battery development

gettyimagesbank Hyundai Motor said Thursday it has partnered with U.S. quantum computer firm IonQ for battery development. The partnership will allow Hyundai Motor to use IonQ’s quantum computers to develop ... Read more »

Netflix loses $125B in market value as herky-jerky member growth is set to screech slower

© Provided by CNET Angela Lang/CNET Netflix’s saw its market value plunge by $125 billion Friday, a day after the company predicted it will add far fewer subscribers  than expected ... Read more »
On free-english-test.com you will find lots of free English exam practice materials to help you improve your English skills: grammar, listening, reading, writing, ielts, toeic