Why Did Putin Change His Mind On China’s Ukraine Peace Plan?

why did putin change his mind on china’s ukraine peace plan?

Why Did Putin Change His Mind On China’s Ukraine Peace Plan?

After initially rejecting China’s 12-point peace plan to bring the war in Ukraine to an end, Russian President Vladimir Putin welcomed the proposal during a joint press conference with Chinese President Xi Jinping on Tuesday. The Russian leader said that “many of the provisions” put forward in the plan are “consonant with Russian approaches” and could be used as the “basis for a peaceful settlement” when Kyiv and the West are “ready” for it.

The Russian president also reiterated his claim that the West isn’t prepared for peace, however.

“So far, we see no such readiness from their side,” Putin said.

While Putin didn’t endorse the plan in its entirety, his comments were substantially different from those offered by Kremlin spokesman Dmitry Peskov in February. While Peskov said Russia would give the plan the “attention” it deserves, he also said that the Kremlin does not “see any of the conditions that are needed to bring this whole story towards peace.”

MORE: ‘Final Nail In The Coffin’ – Donald Trump Is In Serious Legal Hot Water

MORE: Joe Biden Might Have Just Destroyed America’s Banks

MORE: Donald Trump ‘Hush Money’ Case Takes A Crazy Turn

MORE: Gavin Newson Destroyed California

MORE: Lauren Boebert And Marjorie Taylor Greene Have No Clue

For Russia, the only acceptable peace plan is Ukraine’s surrender and the absorption of at least four major regions of Ukraine into Russia.

The Chinese plan for peace was roundly criticized not just by Russia, but also by Western analysts, for its vagueness. The plan also looks to be part of a wider effort to encourage Western nations to accept China’s claims of territorial control over Taiwan. Writing for the Carnegie Endowment for International Peace, Alexander Gabuev noted that the plan was “not aimed at actually ending the war” but at “impressing the developing world and rebutting accusations that Beijing has become a silent accomplice to Moscow.”

The first two points of China’s 12-point peace plan make it quite clear that this isn’t just about Ukraine. In the first point, titled “Respecting the sovereignty of all countries,” the Chinese government proposes that “universally recognized international law” must be “strictly observed,” adding that the “sovereignty, independence and territorial integrity of all countries must be upheld.”

It adds that “all countries, big or small, strong or weak, rich or poor, are equal members of the international community.” Had this very same measure been proposed by the United States, few domestic analysts would have raised an eyebrow. It would likely have been praised as a common-sense proposal necessary for the prevention of war. China, however, would no doubt have objected – and for the simple reason that China and the United States, and the East and the West more generally, have different ideas about what “territorial integrity” means.

For China, territorial integrity means the strict adherence to the One China policy, and the reclaiming of territories that the Chinese Communist Party believes to be inextricable parts of China. This would include both Taiwan and Hong Kong. For Russia, territorial integrity means reclaiming Ukraine and rebuilding the Russian Empire.

The second point in China’s peace plan encourages world leaders to abandon the “Cold War mentality.” This is by no means a new talking point for the Chinese, and while at face value it seems just as unobjectionable as the first point, the implications of simply abandoning that mentality without first securing meaningful change and security guarantees are significant. China’s proposal is predicated on the falsehood that neither China nor Russia pose a threat to humanity, the environment, or global security. The Cold War mentality arose as a result of the aggressive growth of communism, the risk it posed to the people of those countries suffering through it, and the real possibility of an anti-human ideology spreading further West. Today, Russia is unhappy with the West’s constant eastward expansion, and while some might argue that the West provoked this war by purposely expanding NATO’s borders closer and closer to Russia, without agreements from Russia and China to abandon their blatant human rights violations it’s hard to imagine any Western leader blindly agreeing to China’s proposal.

Cold War mentality cannot simply be abandoned when Eastern superpowers continue to enslave and torture ethnic minorities, and President Xi seeks to grow his own country’s power by absorbing territories it claims are already part of China.

China knows that, but the war in Ukraine – and the fact that both Russia and Ukraine want the conflict to come to an end as soon as possible – may be just the catalyst President Xi is looking for. It’s a long shot, sure, but China may just see Ukraine as an opportunity to prove its anti-war credentials. And, in exchange for a peace agreement, the West could theoretically look the other way when the Chinese president orders his military to invade Taiwan. If that happens – and it probably won’t – then risking angering President Vladimir Putin with the peace deal would be worth it. And, as it turns out, Putin is now on board with the plan anyway.

Putin’s sudden U-turn comes after the two world leaders met in Moscow and signed two agreements affirming new “strategic cooperation” between the countries. Following “successful and constructive talks” at the Kremlin, the Chinese president promised that China and Russia would enter a “new era” of trade and economic cooperation together. For Putin, struggling under the weight of Western sanctions, an improved relationship with a country that boasts far greater economic and military strength is a blessing. Accepting China’s peace agreement, even if it doesn’t explicitly accept Russia’s claim to the Donbas and other parts of Ukraine, is the price he must pay.

Perhaps, then, the Chinese president used their recent Moscow meeting to convince Putin that the vague terminology found within the plan can mean anything he wants it to.

Jack Buckby is 19FortyFive’s Breaking News Editor. He is a British author, counter-extremism researcher, and journalist based in New York. Reporting on the U.K., Europe, and the U.S., he works to analyze and understand left-wing and right-wing radicalization, and reports on Western governments’ approaches to the pressing issues of today. His books and research papers explore these themes and propose pragmatic solutions to our increasingly polarized society.

News Related


If You Invested $1,000 In General Motors Stock When Mary Barra Became CEO, Here's How Much You'd Have Today

If You Invested $1,000 In General Motors Stock When Mary Barra Became CEO, Here’s How Much You’d Have Today Automotive giant General Motors Co (NYSE: GM) emerged from bankruptcy in 2009 ... Read more »

Ukrainian Armed Forces have yet to strike the deciding blow, believes Estonian intelligence

Ukrainian defenders fire on the front line near Bakhmut Combat is currently ongoing around Bakhmut, he added, but the intensity of combat operations has increased sharply in Zaporizhzhya Oblast, which ... Read more »

National Parks Service Hilarious Guideline For Tourist Wildlife Safety

National Parks Service Hilarious Guideline For Tourist Wildlife Safety Staying a safe distance away from wildlife should be common sense. National parks and state parks provide plenty of signage instructing ... Read more »

Blue Jays pitcher who apologized for sharing Christian video removed from roster

Blue Jays pitcher who apologized for sharing Christian video removed from roster Toronto Blue Jays pitcher Anthony Bass has been removed from the team’s roster following an apology he gave ... Read more »

Utah Teen Stripped of Pageant Title Days After Win Over 'Clerical Error': 'It's Unfair'

Amanda Giraldi, 17, won the Miss Lehi Teen crown, but said she learned three days later she was too old to have competed KUTV2 Amanda Giraldi A Utah teen says ... Read more »

Dalvin Cook's Release Sends Losing Message to Vikings Fans

I get it. Nobody wants to pay big money to running backs anymore. But when you already have one of the NFL’s best, and you’re coming off a 13-win season ... Read more »

J&Js Covid Vaccine — Taken by 19 Million Americans — Pulled by FDA Over Rare Blood Clot Concerns

The Food and Drug Administration (FDA) has taken a significant step by revoking its authorization for the Johnson & Johnson Covid vaccine, a move initiated after the pharmaceutical company itself ... Read more »

Texas man at center of attorney general Paxton's impeachment faces federal charges

FILE PHOTO: FBI arrests Texas man at center of suspended attorney general Paxton’s impeachment By Brad Brooks (Reuters) – Federal prosecutors on Friday leveled charges of making false statements to ... Read more »

Scientist emerges half-inch shorter after living 100 days undersea. Here's what he learned.

A Florida professor emerged Friday from spending 100 days living underwater, shattering the previous record of 73 days. Joseph Dituri rose slowly from his temporary home in an ocean lagoon ... Read more »

June 2023: The Market Today And Where It's Headed

Summary The stock market in 2023 seems to be primarily influenced by higher interest rates, artificial intelligence, and a renewed focus on balance sheets and cash flow statements. This has ... Read more »

Weekend Severe Weather Could Bring Damaging Winds, Hail

Sign up for the Morning Brief email newsletter to get weekday updates from The Weather Channel and our meteorologists. S​evere weather this weekend will threaten a broad area from Texas ... Read more »

The Mk-19 Automatic 40mm Grenade Launcher Is a Beast

MK 19 Grenade Launcher We at 19FortyFive have recently published our fair share of articles about grenade launchers, from the venerable M203 40mm grenade launcher to the ‘203’s intended replacement ... Read more »

Jerry Seinfeld, Jim Gaffigan coming to Chicago this fall as part of 4-city arena tour

Two of comedy’s biggest names will be taking the stage at the United Center this fall as part of a brief, four-city arena tour. Jerry Seinfeld and Jim Gaffigan will ... Read more »

Viral TikTok apology, air quality, a salmonella outbreak and more: Look back at week's top headlines

Here's a look at some of the top headlines from this week Read more »

Judge grants Florida woman who fatally shot neighbor $154,000 bond

Susan Louise Lorincz, 58, of Ocala returned to court in Marion County a day after she pleaded not guilty to a first-degree felony charge of manslaughter with a firearm, as well as counts of culpable negligence, battery and assault Read more »

Some Delivery Workers Biked 50 Miles in the Thick of the NYC Wildfire Smog: ‘It's an Ominous Feeling'

On Wednesday, the streets were emptier in midtown Manhattan with many employees working from home due to the dangerous air quality brought on by Canada’s wildfires. But some like Josh ... Read more »

What Tesla Charging Partnerships With Ford and GM Mean for the EV Industry

Ford Motor, General Motors and Tesla appear to have shifted the tide on electric vehicle charging infrastructure in North America. Tesla struck agreements with GM and Ford to grant their ... Read more »

See photos of the boxes of classified documents at the heart of Donald Trump's 2nd indictment

Former President Donald Trump is facing 37 felony counts related to the mishandling of classified documents, according to an indictment unsealed Friday Trump is accused of sharing classified details related ... Read more »

California investigators suspect Florida Gov. Ron DeSantis planned the flight carrying 16 migrants who were 'dumped' outside Sacramento church

Democratic Gov. Gavin Newsom of California criticized the policies of Republican Gov. Ron DeSantis of Florida, in an interview with Insider. Justin Sullivan/Getty Images and Wilfredo Lee/AP Photo Sixteen migrants ... Read more »

‘10 dollars an hour is crazy’: Viewers defend teenage Pizza Hut worker who makes $10 per hour

woman preparing pizza at pizza hut Working as a teenager can be liberating. Earning your own money, building skills that many don’t obtain until their mid-20s, and gaining a measure ... Read more »

'Stop Cop City' activists pack Atlanta City Hall ahead of crucial vote

Protesters gather outside Atlanta City Hall ahead of a council vote over whether to approve public funding for the construction of a proposed police and firefighter training center, Monday, June ... Read more »

New York Yankees Could Lose Aaron Judge to Injured List Again With New Ailment

A fantastic play has come with consequences. New York Yankees superstar Aaron Judge is dealing with a right big toe injury that could potentially land him back on the injured ... Read more »

Jake Tapper Creeped Out by Brianna Keilar’s Analogy for Crowded GOP Race: ‘I Do Not Thank You for That’

Jake Tapper did not care for Brianna Keilar’s analogy for the growing 2024 Republican primary field on Monday’s edition of CNN News Central. This week, a handful of candidates are ... Read more »

You Can Download the iOS 17 Developer Beta on Your iPhone Right Now

iOS 17 was announced Monday at WWDC 2023. Tharon Green/CNET Not wanting to lose any time, Apple has just released the first developer beta for iOS 17, shortly after announcing ... Read more »

Why 22.8 Million Americans Might Have Just Gotten a Big Credit Score Boost

A person typing on a laptop while sitting comfortably on a couch. There are different factors that go into calculating a credit score. These include length of credit history, new ... Read more »

Bannon Goes to War With House Republicans, Wants Primary Opponents for MTG, Jim Jordan, and Others Over Debt Vote

Bannon Goes to War With House Republicans, Wants Primary Opponents for MTG, Jim Jordan, and Others Over Debt Vote Former Trump campaign manager Steve Bannon declared Monday that he wants ... Read more »

Florida officials mum as second migrant flight arrives in Sacramento

“[Ron DeSantis] you small, pathetic man,” California Gov. Gavin Newsom wrote in a tweet Monday. TALLAHASSEE, Fla. — A second plane full of migrants from the Texas border landed in ... Read more »

Texas sheriff calls for charges after DeSantis migrant flights

Texas sheriff calls for charges after DeSantis migrant flights The sheriff’s office in Bexar County, Texas, has filed a criminal case with the county’s district attorney over a 2022 incident ... Read more »

‘They are way more dangerous than anybody knows’: Mom almost loses child to water bead toy. She says Target marked it on sale and restocked the shelves

Woman Holding Baby. Target Retail Store A mother claimed that after her infant child nearly died from accidentally ingesting a singular water bead, the company sent their condolences and Target ... Read more »

AI should be licensed like medicines or nuclear power, Labour suggests

Photograph: Yuichiro Chino/Getty Images The UK should bar technology developers from working on advanced artificial intelligence tools unless they have a licence to do so, Labour has said. Ministers should ... Read more »
Kênh kiến thức kỹ năng, phát triển bản thân, hướng nghiệp, blog nhân sự