Why Brett James Caire ‘brutally attacked' man from Grindr with brother

A South Australian father who helped his brother torture an elderly man he met on a dating app agreed to assault him to avoid having his sibling call him “a goodie two shoes”, a court has heard.

Brett James Caire, 37, was charged with a string of offences after his younger brother Charlie Michael Edward Caire used the dating app Grindr to lure the man to his brother’s Murray Bridge home before the siblings tortured him for four hours in February 2020.

During the four hours the elderly man was held captive, he was threatened with a needle — said to have contained AIDS — and was injected with it, tasered, had his hand cut with a carving knife and was victim to other assaults involving a gaslighter and secateurs.

Caire had initially pleaded not guilty to false imprisonment, aggravated blackmail, two counts of aggravated causing harm with intent, aggravated assault to cause harm and theft but later backflipped on his decision and pleaded guilty.

Why Brett James Caire ‘brutally attacked’ man from Grindr with brother

Camera IconThe court heard the victim was lured to Caire’s Murray Bridge home in February 2020 after the defendant’s brother was in communication with him through Grindr. Suppled Credit: Supplied

The court previously heard Charlie Caire and the elderly victim were communicating through the social media app — designed for gay, bisexual and transgender people — when he agreed to meet the victim on Adelaide Road.

Charlie then took the man to his brother's home where the victim consented to being blindfolded, handcuffed, and having his clothes removed.

But, his brother was woken by noises and found the two men in a small room in the back of his house where Charlie had taped the victim’s wrists, knees and ankles and was on a bed.

Judge Liesl Chapman told the court on Thursday Charlie had told his brother the man was a paedophile and offered to pay his sibling to help bash him.

The judge made no comment as to whether Charlie’s allegation about the man was true, telling the court it was irrelevant.

“You thought it was easy money to be made and thought the victim was a filthy, horrible person from what you had been told by your brother,” Judge Chapman said.

“You were also worried if you said no to your brother, he would call you a ‘goodie two shoes’.”

The brothers demanded $5000 from the victim, threatening consequences if he didn‘t, and went on to kick and punch him in his stomach, torso and legs after the brothers were told he didn’t have the money.

The victim then suggested picking up his bank card from his home and taking the siblings to an ATM, which they agreed.

When they arrived at the home, the victim’s friend was inside and offered to take money out from his bank, leading the brothers to a nearby ATM while the elderly man contacted police.

When the brothers returned, they saw police at the premises and drove away in the victim’s car.

Why Brett James Caire ‘brutally attacked’ man from Grindr with brother

Camera IconCaire was sentenced to sentenced to five years and two months imprisonment with a non parole period of two years and seven months in the Adelaide District Court. NCA NewsWire / Dean Martin Credit: News Corp Australia

Judge Chapman said the victim described the experience as the “most sustained, intense physical pain and fear” and “was scared he was going to die”.

The judge said he was also in “constant fear” Caire was going to return and assault him again.

She said the defendant would be sentenced on the fact his younger brother was “in command” and directed him.

The court heard Caire suffered PTSD, had borderline personality disorder and used drugs and alcohol to cope with his mental health issues which made him more easily influenced by others.

She said Caire’s offending was not premeditated but understood he was torturing the victim with the expectation he would profit from it.

Caire, who was high on methamphetamine at the time of the offence, was told by the judge his drug use was “no excuse for what you did” and must “answer for what you did while under the influence”.

“It was a brutal attack on a victim who was particularly vulnerable because of his age … He was terrified,” Judge Chapman said.

Appearing in the Adelaide District Court on Thursday, Caire was sentenced to five years and two months imprisonment with a non parole period of two years and seven months for his involvement in the crime, including a five per cent discount for his late guilty plea.

Judge Chapman said there were no special circumstances to suspend Caire’s sentence like she did with his 21-year-old brother.

She described Charlie Caire’s motivation as “vigilante justice” which she said needed to be condemned as it undermined the criminal justice system.

He was sentenced to five years and six months in prison with a non-parole period of two years and 10 months, but had it suspended for a three-year good behaviour bond.

News Related


AFL names umpires for the 2021 grand final

Matt Stevic, the umpire at the centre of Toby Greene’s latest suspension, will officiate his ninth AFL grand final in the past 10 years and eighth straight decider after a ... Read more »

Gold-digger killer Charles Bisucci's cold words before murder-suicide

A Victorian coroner has recommended police changes after a gold-digger boyfriend killed his partner and robbed three children of their beloved mother. On August 21, 2017, Charles Bisucci shot his ... Read more »

Man allegedly recorded raping woman in Melbourne's west: cops

A man has allegedly been recorded raping a woman in Melbourne’s west. Sexual crime squad detectives recently arrested two men as part of an extensive probe into multiple sexual assaults ... Read more »

AFL Grand Final: Former Melbourne skipper Nathan Jones has no regrets about leaving Perth ahead of Saturday's decider

Former Melbourne captain Nathan Jones has had the best and worst weeks of his life at the same time but has no regrets about leaving his team in Perth ahead ... Read more »

Scott Morrison unable to secure Macron meeting as relations sour

Scott Morrison has downplayed claims Australia gave France the cold shoulder as the severing of a major submarine contract sours relations between the two nations. The Prime Minister touched down ... Read more »

Sawtell stabbing caught on camera after teens brawl at beach gathering

Disturbing footage has captured the moment a teenager was allegedly stabbed multiple times during a wild brawl at an illegal beach party on the NSW north coast. Witnesses used smartphones ... Read more »

Truck company Connect Logistics hit with new charges over crash that killed four police officers

The trucking company involved in the Eastern Freeway crash that killed four police officers has been hit with fresh charges over the tragic incident. Senior Constables Lynette Taylor, Kevin King ... Read more »

Fresh probe into Macquarie Fields house fire that killed teen Tahma Teara-Jones

Police have launched a fresh appeal for information into a house fire which killed a teenage boy. Emergency services were called to a home in Macquarie Fields, in Sydney’s southwest, ... Read more »

Man allegedly tried to rob, kidnap 34yo woman on early morning Gold Coast walk: cops

A man has been charged with the attempted robbery and kidnap of a 34-year-old woman who was attacked with a knife while taking a morning walk on the Gold Coast ... Read more »

Plastic-eating enzymes trialled in Australian first to create infinitely recyclable plastic

Australia will soon welcome its first commercial recycling plant that uses enzymes to “eat” plastic and break it down into its core molecules so they can be reused. Recycling start-up ... Read more »

How Melbourne forward Tom McDonald went from AFL reject to grand-finalist

Twelve months ago, with doors slammed in his face by AFL clubs after an unfavourable exit interview from Melbourne, Tom McDonald concedes he thought he was done. But this weekend ... Read more »

Residents in three Victorian regions spend first day of what they hope is their last lockdown

Three Victorian regions have spent their first day back in lockdown after enjoying a brief reprieve from some coronavirus restrictions. Residents of the City of Greater Geelong, the Surf Coast ... Read more »

Teen found not guilty of murder after judge found he was acting in self defence

A teenager who fired a shotgun blast into his drug-affected neighbour’s chest at point blank range during a fatal altercation over a barking dog has been found not guilty of ... Read more »

Australia Post in need for almost 5000 employees for Christmas

Australia Post is on the hunt for truck drivers, posties and forklift operators among 5000 vacant jobs it needs to fill to help with a surge in parcel deliveries in ... Read more »

Babysitter charged with 194 child sex offences after advertising services online

A babysitter is facing almost 200 child sex charges that allegedly involve 12 complainants, including one who is just eight months old. Jareth Thomas Harries-Markham, 23, was first charged in ... Read more »

Victorian government to announce two-week lockdown of construction industry after protests

Construction figures are bracing for a snap industry-wide shutdown in response to violent protests in Melbourne. Most work sites are expected to be closed for at least two weeks. The ... Read more »

Tradie protest ‘hijacked' by ‘extreme organisations': CFMEU boss

Construction union boss John Setka has blamed “extremists” for manipulating CFMEU members during a violent protest in Melbourne. A chaotic brawl erupted on Monday after hundreds of people descended on ... Read more »

Body modifier claimed drug overdose killed woman who received snowflake procedure

Former colleagues of a NSW body modifier have told a court he claimed a woman who died after he implanted a plastic snowflake under her skin actually succumbed to a ... Read more »

Victorians to ‘return to winter' in Grand Final week with icy storms forecast

Victorians have been told to brace themselves for a return to winter weather, with umbrellas recommended for any picnic-goers on the AFL Grand Final long weekend. A cold front that ... Read more »

‘There is no reconciling': Family of disability neglect victim Annie Smith break silence

The family of an Adelaide woman killed by her disability support worker who failed to care for her have spoken publicly for the first time. Annie Smith, 54, died of ... Read more »

Heartbreaking moment mother confronted her daughter's murderer

A grieving mother has confronted the Muay Thai expert who brutally bashed her daughter to death during a drug-addled rage, telling a court of the heartbreak that had rippled through ... Read more »

Social worker concerned about ‘pay-offs' for alleged victims of Malka Leifer

A social worker was worried an alleged victim of Malka Leifer wanted a “possible pay-off” and feared she could be sued if she made a statement to police, a court ... Read more »

WA hard border could complicate Premier Mark McGowan's defamation case against billionaire Clive Palmer

Western Australia’s border closure with NSW could make it difficult for Premier Mark McGowan to attend his defamation trial against billionaire Clive Palmer without being forced to quarantine upon his ... Read more »

Victorian mum pleads guilty to trying to drown her toddler in bath

A young Victorian mum’s attempt to drown her toddler was “five seconds of parental failure”, a court has been told. The 23-year-old woman pleaded guilty to one count of reckless ... Read more »

Peter Keogh's horror past outlined in Maria James inquest

The brother of a woman killed by her monster ex-partner has shared why he thinks the man could have killed a different woman seven years earlier. Phil Cleary’s sister Vicki ... Read more »

Court hears of DNA match in cars used during alleged plot to murder Ibrahem Hamze

Police allege the DNA of a man with suspected links to the Alameddine network was found inside two vehicles connected to an aborted hit on a rival last month, a ... Read more »

‘We can't tolerate that': Dorm room parties during lockdown leave uni students out in the cold

A handful of students from a top university have been expelled from their accommodation after they hosted dorm room parties during lockdown. The students have been removed from Campus East ... Read more »

Two boys, man found clinging to capsized boat 80km south of Perth

Two boys and a man have been rescued from waters roughly 80km south of Perth after their boat capsized. The 5m fibreglass boat started taking on water after being swamped ... Read more »

90-year-old Geelong aged care resident sexually assaulted in bed

A 90-year-old aged care resident woke to a man sexually assaulting her in a sickening attack at a Victorian nursing home on Sunday morning. The woman woke to find the ... Read more »

Queensland records zero new local Covid-19 cases as state recovers from latest cluster

Queensland has recorded no new locally acquired Covid-19 cases on Sunday as the state continues to recover from the Indooroopilly cluster. Premier Annastacia Palaszczuk said it was an “absolutely perfect ... Read more »

Woman allegedly held captive in western Sydney and beaten in two-day ordeal

A woman was allegedly held captive and beaten with a pole and frying pan in Sydney’s west for two days before she was able to escape. The 29-year-old woman was ... Read more »

Parents found dead in Oberon home identified as son is charged with murder

The parents of a man arrested in Penrith on Friday have been identified as the victims of the “tragic” alleged double homicide in the quiet NSW town of Oberon. Glenn, ... Read more »

Dog walker finds suspected human bone washed up on City Beach, Perth

What is suspected to be a human bone has been found washed up on a popular Perth beach, sparking a police investigation. WA Police were called to City Beach at ... Read more »

Cop's sleazy texts to girl before threesome with another police officer

As police officers James Delinicolis and Angelo Dellosa patrolled the train lines of southwestern Sydney, they had an ulterior motive – scouring for women. It led them to room 226 ... Read more »

Western Sydney residents ‘struggling to survive' with harsh stay-at-home orders

An angry local mayor has compared the covid-ravaged western suburbs, which is currently in lockdown to “Zimbabwe or Kazakhstan”. Cumberland Shire Council mayor Steve Christou said the “vibrant, hardworking community” ... Read more »

‘Reckless conduct': Runaway Bourke Street Mall driver Bryce O'Donnell ordered to perform community work

A Ballarat man who drove his car down the same section of Bourke St where James Gargasoulas mowed down six people will be released from jail on a community corrections ... Read more »

Former Mudgee Race Club head Colleen Walker takes NSW Racing to court

The former head of a prestigious race club has launched a court challenge after being stood down. Colleen Walker has taken NSW Racing to court after she was stood down ... Read more »

‘Not that f***ing stupid': How ‘threats' ruined Roberts-Smith's friendship with private investigator

Court documents have claimed a veteran private eye cut ties with Victoria-Cross recipient Ben Roberts-Smith over “threatening letters”. It comes as the Federal Court hears the high profile investigator will ... Read more »

Sex work to be decriminalised in Victoria

An outdated law that has made sex work “burdensome” and “unworkable” has been overhauled in Victoria, with the state announcing on Friday it will decriminalise the industry. As part of ... Read more »