Why are BMW and Daimler being sued over climate change?

ngo, daimler, bmw, carbon emission target, Deutsche Umwelthilfe

German activists have filed a lawsuit against automakers

BMW

and Daimler for refusing to tighten carbon emissions goals, the first time German citizens have sued private companies for exacerbating climate change.

The lawsuit from the heads of Deutsche Umwelthilfe (DUH), a non-governmental organisation (NGO), is similar to one being lined up for Volkswagen by the heads of Greenpeace’s Germany division in collaboration with Fridays for Future activist Clara Mayer and an unidentified landowner. However, this group has given Volkswagen until Oct. 29 to respond.

DUH also challenged energy firm Wintershall to restrict its emissions targets, but no suit has been filed against the company as of yet.

Here’s what the cases mean, and why they matter.

WHERE HAS THIS COME FROM?

In May last year, Germany’s top court ruled the country’s climate law was not doing enough to protect future generations. It set carbon emissions budgets for major economic sectors, increased the percentage by which emissions must be reduced from 1990 levels by 2030 to 65% from 55%, and stated that Germany as a country must be carbon-neutral by 2045.

While meeting these demands implies some restrictions to current generations’ lifestyles, not meeting them would force future generations to make significantly more drastic sacrifices in order to both survive in a warmer world, and prevent the problem from getting worse, the court argued at the time.

In the same month, environmental groups in the Netherlands won a case against oil company Shell for not doing enough to mitigate its impact on the climate – the first private firm to be ordered by a court to reduce its emissions.

On the back of those two rulings, the German activists are making their case.

WHY DOES IT MATTER?

This case is important on two levels.

Firstly, because of the legal precedent it could set – namely, that companies are directly responsible for the effect on people’s lives of the emissions their products create.

If the defendants win, citizens could be emboldened to sue other companies – from airlines to retailers to energy firms – for not doing enough to mitigate their impact on the planet.

Secondly, because companies will be forced to prove in court that their emissions targets are as watertight as they say they are – stress-testing their claims that they are taking climate change seriously.

WHY THESE COMPANIES?

Daimler and BMW have set a number of climate-related targets.

Daimler aims to produce purely electric vehicles (EVs) by 2030, and provide an electric alternative for all models by 2025. BMW wants at least half of global sales to be EVs by 2030, and reduce CO2 emissions per vehicle by 40% in the same timeframe. Volkswagen has said it will stop producing fossil fuel-emitting cars by 2035.

All three firms have stated that their targets are in line with the international Paris Agreement on tackling global warming.

But the defendants argue that the companies’ goals aren’t enough to adhere to the German climate ruling and carbon emissions budgets set by the Intergovernmental Panel for Climate Change (IPCC).

By prolonging carbon-emitting activities, the companies are directly responsible for the constraints on individual rights that will have to endured in future if carbon budgets aren’t stuck to, the case argues.

These are by no means the only firms to which such an argument could apply – and if DUH wins, more lawsuits could follow.

WHAT DO THEY WANT?

DUH wants both autos firms to legally commit to ending production of fossil fuel-emitting cars by 2030, and to ensure the CO2 emitted by their activities before those deadlines does not go beyond their fair share.

What do they mean by their fair share? It’s a complex calculation – but put simply, the NGO has calculated a personal ‘carbon budget’ for each company, based on a figure put together by the IPCC of how much carbon we can still emit globally without warming the Earth beyond 1.7 degrees Celsius, and how much carbon the companies emitted in 2019.

According to its calculations, the companies’ current climate goals aren’t enough to keep them within their allocated budget – meaning that even if everyone else sticks to their budgets, these companies’ activities would push emissions over the limit.

WHAT HAVE THE COMPANIES SAID?

Daimler said on Monday it did not see any grounds for the case. “We have long provided a clear statement for the path to climate neutrality: it is our aim to be fully electric by the end of the decade – wherever market conditions allow,” it said in a statement.

BMW said its climate targets were already at the forefront of the industry, and its goals were in line with the ambition of keeping global warming under 1.5 degrees.

Volkswagen said it would consider the case, but that it “does not view suing individual firms as a suitable method to tackle societal challenges.”

WHAT HAPPENS NEXT?

It’s now up to Germany’s district court to decide whether the case should be taken forward. If it thinks so, the companies will be asked to present evidence to defend themselves against the charges, and a written debate between the two sides will ensue.

A ruling could be years away. But the longer it takes, the higher the risk to the companies if they lose – as they could be left with very little time left to meet any court demands by 2030.

Internet Explorer Channel Network
News Related

OTHER NEWS

Unemployment down again in last month of massive corona support

Unemployment as a share of the labor force has fallen to 3.1 percent as a result. That is the same percentage as in July. In August, Statistics Netherlands noted a ... Read more »

Over 103 crore COVID-19 vaccine doses provided to States, UTs: Centre

The government has provided more than 103.5 crore COVID-19 vaccine doses to States and union territories (UTs), said the Union Health Ministry on Thursday. A total of 1,03,53,51,045 vaccine doses ... Read more »

Gauri Lankesh murder: SC sets aside HC order quashing charge sheet against accused for KCOCA offences

The Supreme Court on Thursday set aside the Karnataka High Court order quashing the charge sheet against an accused in the murder of journalist Gauri Lankesh for purported offences under ... Read more »

Shah Rukh Khan meets Aryan Khan at Arthur Road jail

Actor Shah Rukh Khan paid a visit to his son Aryan who is lodged in Mumbai’s Arthur Road jail in a drugs haul case, on October 21. The the 23-year-old was arrested after ... Read more »

100 crore vaccination milestone: 61% Indian citizens willing to take third dose, finds survey

Source: AP As India achieved the 100 crore COVID-19 vaccine doses milestone, at least 61 percent of citizens have expressed willingness to take the third dose of COVID-19 vaccine, if ... Read more »

Scott Technology returns to the black, signs $20m US contract

Freshly streamlined automation and robotics company Scott Technology has returned to profit. The company reported a net profit $9.5m for the year to August after restructuring costs took the company ... Read more »

Havells slumps 7% on disappointing Q2 results

NEW DELHI: Shares of Havells India slumped more than 7 per cent in early trading Mumbai on Thursday as the consumer electrical goods maker posted a 7.34 per cent fall ... Read more »

Why Indian Doctors Are Taking Booster Shots Of COVID-19 Vaccine

Ever since the pandemic first struck, doctors and healthcare workers have emerged as our first line of defence against infection. Their contributions have been widely reported and lauded. Some of ... Read more »

Unacademy ropes in Zomato's Deepinder Goyal as board member

Zomato’s Deepinder Goyal has joined Unacademy as a board member. Temasek-backed ed-tech firm Unacademy has roped in existing angel investor and Zomato’s founder Deepinder Goyal on its board. Goyal invested ... Read more »

CBS: unemployment down in September

Unemployment fell in September. According to Statistics Netherlands (CBS), thousands of people managed to get back to work in the last month of the massive corona support for businesses. As ... Read more »

MG Motor India sells out first batch of SUV Astor within 20 minutes of opening bookings

MG Motor India – the British brand owned by China’s SAIC – has sold out the first batch of SUV Astor within 20 mins of opening booking Thursday. Deliveries for ... Read more »

Ahead of T20 World Cup, Twitter brings Communities to India and rolls out live cricket scorecards

Twitter has extended its Communities feature to India with the launch of a Cricket-focused community called Cricket Twitter-India that will enable users to talk all things cricket in multiple Indian ... Read more »

Uttarakhand flash floods and landslides: Death toll mounts to 54, five missing

Flash floods and landslides caused by heavy rains in Uttarakhand have claimed the lives of 54 people in the last few days. A total of 19 people have sustained injuries ... Read more »

Achieved 100 crore COVID-19 vaccinations through collective effort, says Bhupender Yadav

Union Minister for Environment, Forest and Climate Change Bhupender Yadav on Thursday said the landmark of 100 crore COVID-19 vaccinations has been achieved through collective effort. “Today we’ve achieved 100 ... Read more »

Strong Randstad recovery from corona crisis with profit doubling

“The company is in very good condition,” said departing CEO Jacques van den Broek during the presentation of the quarterly figures. “Not only in this quarter, but we came out ... Read more »

The hydra-headed monster that wants to gatecrash your retirement party

Fixed deposits or FDs, the play-safe savings investment bet for many Indians, now fetch a negative return due to high inflation. That is, the interest you earn on your FD ... Read more »

L&T Finance Holdings sheds almost 5% after dip in Q2 profit

NEW DELHI: Shares of L&T Finance Holdings dropped almost 5 per cent in early Mumbai trading Thursday as the non-banking financial company reported a fall of 10 per cent in ... Read more »

Thodi si to lift kara de: How to prepare your best elevator pitch

Note to readers: This is the first installment of a new series of articles designed to give our readers an edge on matters of competitiveness, upskilling/reskilling and knowledge gathering. Essayed ... Read more »

Cruise drugs case: Bombay HC to hear Aryan Khan's bail plea on October 26

The Bombay High Court on Thursday said it would hear on October 26 the bail plea filed by Aryan Khan, son of superstar Shah Rukh Khan, in connection with a ... Read more »

Asia stocks slip as Evergrande jitters return

SINGAPORE (Reuters) – Asian stocks slipped on Thursday (Oct 21) as the upbeat mood that carried the Dow Jones and Bitcoin to records a day earlier ran out of steam, ... Read more »

Energy boss demands price cap reform as firms face '£5bn bill' for market mess

Scottish Power's chief executive argues that the current market is unsustainable and could force a return to the days of only a 'big six' group of suppliers without urgent action. Read more »

Jhunjhunwalas hike stake in Titan for first time since Dec 2019

NEW DELHI: The jhunjhunwala duo, Rakesh and his better half Rekha, bought Titan Company shares in September quarter on a net basis for the first time since December quarter of ... Read more »

India's vaccination drive outpaces most countries as it breaches 100 crore inoculation mark

With an uptick in the world’s largest vaccination drive against COVID-19, India on Thursday crossed inoculation of 100 crore vaccine doses, according to the Ministry of Health and Family Welfare. ... Read more »

Online abuse: Banning anonymous social media accounts is not the answer

In the wake of the tragic death of the member of parliament for Southend West, David Amess, fellow MPs have been talking about how to best protect both politicians and ... Read more »

China: Crunch time for Evergrande as unit sale collapses

The collapse of China Evergrande’s planned $2.5 billion sale of a property services unit has left the troubled company closer than ever to its end, ramping up fears it will ... Read more »

Tata Motors share price gains 2% after Jefferies raises target to Rs 625, maintains 'buy'

Tata Motors share price rose over 2 percent in the early trade on October 21 after foreign research house Jefferies raised target price to Rs 625 from Rs 565, maintaining ... Read more »

Railway Board is not keen on merging CRIS with IRCTC. Here's why

A month after the Finance Ministry asked Indian Railways to merge the Centre for Railway Information and Systems (CRIS) and RailTel with Indian Railway Catering and Tourism Corporation (IRCTC), the ... Read more »

Hainan's January-September tourism revenues grew 136.9% year-on-year

The province’s total revenue amounted to $16.7 billion Read more »

Facebook may change its name to rebrand itself while also focusing on metaverse

Photo by: Gerd Altmann/Pixabay Facebook is reportedly planning to change its name to something related to metaverse and rebrand itself. It was reported this week that as it is heavily ... Read more »

COVID-19 Vaccine Tracker: India achieves 100-crore-vaccinations milestone on October 21

Representative image. India has achieved the milestone of 100 crore (one billion) vaccinations on October 21. India accounts for about 15 percent of the total vaccine doses administered worldwide as ... Read more »

House of Commons showdown looms over bid to end 'fire and rehire' practice

A campaign in support of the bill, bankrolled by trade unions, is reaching a crescendo ahead of the bill's second reading on Friday, when ministers are expected to be accused of breaking promises to act. Read more »

'India scripts history,' PM Modi says, as nation reaches 100-crore COVID jab milestone

Prime Minister Narendra Modi. As India reached an extraordinary milestone of giving away 100 crore COVID-19 vaccine doses on October 21, Prime Minister Narendra Modi congratulated the nation and expressed gratitude to ... Read more »

India sees over 18,000 new COVID-19 cases, 160 deaths

A single-day rise of 18,454 fresh cases pushed India’s COVID-19 tally to 3,41,27,450, while the number of active infections rose to 1,78,831, according to the Union Health Ministry data updated ... Read more »

Union Health Minister Mansukh Mandaviya congratulates nation as COVID-19 vaccinations cross 100 cr mark

Union Health Minister Mansukh Mandaviya on Thursday congratulated the citizens of India on crossing 100 crore COVID-19 vaccination coverage and attributed the achievement to Prime Minister Narendra Modi. “Congratulations India! ... Read more »

Dolly Khanna buys this media stock amidst speculations over takeover by Adani Group

New Delhi: Amid speculations in the market that the Adani Group is eyeing NDTV, seasoned investor Dolly Khanna has bought a fresh stake in the media stock. As per the ... Read more »

Media: Hainan National Park to be an important link in a new model of green development

According to the Hainan Daily newspaper, the protected rainforest area will be an important strategic factor which will considerably raise tourism standards Read more »

Congratulations pour in as India races past 100-crore-jab milestone

File image of PM Modi getting first dose of Covaxin on March 1, 2021. (Image: Twitter-@narendramodi) Praise has poured in for India reaching the 100-crore-vaccination milestone from all quarters, from ... Read more »

China Evergrande secures extension on defaulted $260 mln bond -REDD

China Evergrande Group has secured an extension on a defaulted bond, financial provider REDD reported on Thursday, offering rare respite to the developer a day after a deal to sell ... Read more »

Havells India share price declines 9% post Q2 results announcement

Havells India share price slipped 9 percent intraday on October 21, a day after the consumer electrical goods maker announced its September quarter results. Havells India on Wednesday reported a ... Read more »
On free-english-test.com you will find lots of free English exam practice materials to help you improve your English skills: grammar, listening, reading, writing, ielts, toeic