Why are bank stocks underperforming?

Bank stocks fall, Nifty Bank index, Banking stocks, Bank stocks, Banks

NEW DELHI: Fortunes of bank stock are said to be intertwined with the economy, growing in tandem and falling in sync. However, recent trends seem confusing. Bank stocks have fallen despite the Indian economy showing some recovery signs.

The Nifty Bank index, comprising 12 bank stocks, has fallen over 8 per cent in the last one month. It has delivered a negative 1.5 per cent in three months and is up just 1.5 per cent in the last six months. In comparison, the Nifty has fallen 3 per cent in one month, 1 per cent in three months and is up nearly 10 per cent in the last six months. In the long-term, the NSE bank index has underperformed the Nifty50 by 19% since February 2020, before the pandemic began.

Punters on Dalal Street have highlighted various “technical” reasons for the underperformance, including extant overweight positions of institutional investors and selling by foreign portfolio investors (FPIs). In fact, bank stocks constitute the largest holding for FPIs and recently they have been selling loads of it.

But some analysts say there is not much substance behind the underperformance but just a narrative that may not have much correlation with facts. “The underperformance of banks reflects the global narrative of incumbent banks being ill-prepared in the emerging environment versus fintechs and big techs,” says Sanjeev Prasad of Kotak Securities. “The market has extrapolated the success of fintechs in payment to lending too. There are two issues with this narrative in the Indian context; one, standalone payment business is not very remunerative, and two, the lending space is already quite crowded where fintechs have no real advantage in lending.”

The emergence of new-age fintech firms have made many nervous, especially after these institutions also ventured into lending. Investors and businessmen say that they may disrupt the lending business, like how buying and paying for groceries and clothes have changed.

The point to be noted is payment companies in developed markets have largely focused on payment with a limited foray into lending with buy-now-pay-later schemes. The Indian payment industry does not appear to be very profitable given a large number of payment options, reluctance of consumers to pay for transactions alone, very low switching costs for consumers and high costs for merchants.

On the other hand, lending is a different ballgame that incumbents will defend more vigorously, unlike payments. “Lending fintechs have largely focused on subprime borrowers (personal unsecured loans) given the plethora of options for prime and super-prime borrowers. This strategy entails its own risks for fintechs with limited datasets on borrowers and riskier profile of borrowers; a Covid-19-type situation would result in a spike in credit costs,” says Prasad.

So, in short, banks are not going out of business.

Add to it the improving health of traditional lenders. Analysts expect a sharp increase in profits and return ratios for banks as provisions lag growth in net interest income and pre-provisioning operating profits.

Thus, they have bullish targets for banks. The median 12-month potential upside for largecap banks is as high as 44 per cent. IndusInd Bank, Axis Bank, HDFC Bank, SBI and ICICI Bank are among the top picks from the sector.

“Bank stocks are waiting to re-rate and the moment you see FII selling coming down, one fine day, you might just see some of the large banks also moving up by like 5-7 per cent in a day. I am quite bullish on the banks,” says Mahesh Nandurkar of Jefferies in an interview with ET Now.

VK Vijayakumar, Chief Investment Strategist at Geojit Financial Services also says the underperformance of banking stocks is bound to change since asset quality concerns have receded and credit growth is picking up. “So, investors can utilise this correction to buy high quality banking stocks,” he adds.

News Related

OTHER NEWS

‘You pack of wet lettuces': Tyson Fury hits out heavyweight rival ‘cowards' and demands fight

© Tyson Fury / Twitter Tyson Fury has hit out at his heavyweight rivals – Tyson Fury / Twitter Tyson Fury has branded rivals Anthony Joshua, Dillian Whyte and Oleksandr ... Read more »

John Legend and Chrissy Teigen list their stunning $18million New York penthouses – see inside

John Legend and Chrissy Teigen have an eye for real estate, and have renovated and sold several properties for profit in recent years. RELATED: Chrissy Teigen reveals former New York ... Read more »

Edinburgh's 14 best whisky bars and pubs, according to Google reviews

© The best whisky bars in Edinburgh (Photo: The Scotch Malt Whisky Society/ Getty Images for Canva Pro… If you’re looking for a wee dram or two, you can’t go ... Read more »

Daryl Dike sends message to West Brom fans after receiving injury diagnosis

© Provided by Football League World DAryl Dike He’s only been at the club for a few weeks, but Daryl Dike’s West Bromwich Albion career has already gotten off to ... Read more »

Irish citizens advised to avoid non-essential travel to Ukraine

Irish citizens are being advised to avoid non-essential travel to Ukraine, it was announced. Irish premier Micheál Martin said on Tuesday the advice comes in light of ongoing tensions at ... Read more »

Paris Hilton and Jimmy Fallon talking about their NFTs might be the most awkward thing you see today

© NBC Paris Hilton surprises Tonight Show audiences by giving out NFTs Paris Hilton joined The Tonight Show With Jimmy Fallon to discuss NFTs, and the result left many people ... Read more »

Modders make Kassandra's outfit from Assassin's Creed Valhalla into a wearable armor set

When she appeared in Assassin’s Creed Valhalla, Kassandra, the protagonist from Assassin’s Creed Odyssey, was wearing a unique version of her iconic armor. Modders have now carefully recreated this armor ... Read more »

Elias Melkersen gets Hibs green light as Norwegian striker's work permit is sorted

© Elias Melkersen finally has his work permit The 19-year-old had been left in limbo as he waited for the green light to play following his move from Norwegian champions ... Read more »

Tottenham make bid for non-league Lewes FC youngster Lewis Tanner

© Tottenham Hotspur FC via Getty Images AntonioConte1201A Tottenham have made a bid for non-League starlet Ollie Tanner of Lewes FC. The 19-year-old winger has been training with Spurs’ development ... Read more »

Nicola Sturgeon: I feel responsibility to be open about the menopause

© Andrew Milligan First Minister Nicola Sturgeon spoke about the menopause and whether she experiences imposter syndrome (Andrew Milligan/PA) Nicola Sturgeon has opened up about the prospect of going through ... Read more »

Liberal MP George Chahal fined $500 for taking Tory election leaflet from front door

OTTAWA — MP George Chahal says he has paid a $500 fine after taking an opponent’s pamphlet from a front door and replacing it with his own during last year’s ... Read more »

Will Always Give My Best Performance for India: Neeraj Chopra after Being Honoured with and Padma Shri

© Provided by News18 Neeraj Chopra Second Most Mentioned Athlete on Facebook During Olympics 2020 Neeraj Chopra took to social media to thanks Indians for ‘their support and blessings’ after he was honoured with ... Read more »

Shehnaaz Gill shares Sidharth Shukla's family's statement: ‘Please reach to us if you want to use his name'

The sudden demise of actor Sidharth Shukla had left his fans and family heartbroken. On Tuesday evening, his family issued a statement where they requested everyone to reach out to ... Read more »

How to Groovy a card in Disney Twisted-Wonderland

© Provided by GamePur If you’ve played gacha games with cards before, you may be familiar with the blooming. Blooming is when you can evolve a card, making it more ... Read more »

Government approves PMC Bank amalgamation plan

The government Tuesday approved the plan for the amalgamation of the Punjab and Maharashtra Co-operative Bank (PMC Bank) with Unity Small Finance Bank (USFBL), a joint venture between Centrum Financial ... Read more »

Philippine lady booters bow to Australians

© AFC.com Philippine lady booters bow to Australians MANILA, Philippines — The Philippines suffered a 4-0 defeat at the hands of heavy favorite Australia last Monday in Mumbai, India but ... Read more »

WithU Yamaha RNF Team Drapes YZR-M1 In New Colors For 2022

© RideApart.com Copyright 2022 WithU Yamaha RNF Team – Duo Darryn Binder and Andrea Dovizioso will ride for the new satellite squad The Petronas Yamaha Sepang Racing Team burst onto ... Read more »

Former Bengal CM Buddhadeb Bhattacharya Refuses Padma Bhushan, Says ‘No One Told Me About It'

© Provided by News18 Former Bengal CM Buddhadeb Bhattacharya Refuses Padma Bhushan, Says ‘No One Told Me About It’ As the list of Padma awardees came out on Tuesday, one ... Read more »

Valve will reportedly combine Americas, EU-CIS, and Oceania-Asia for offline RMR events in 2022

© Provided by Dot Esports Ahead of the upcoming Regional Major Rankings cycle that determines the participants of the 2022 Valve-sponsored CS:GO Majors, Valve is making a handful of changes ... Read more »

Bade Achhe Lagte Hain 2, 25th January 2022, Written Update: Shubham hits Akshay

© Provided by Pinkvilla In today’s episode, Meera tells Sara to take Akshay home. Priya cries and tells Meera that Anjali framed Akshay. Meera tells her that she believes her ... Read more »

Apex Legends Cheaters Have New Hacks to Get Full Armor Instantly

A new Apex Legends hack allows cheaters to armor swap and equip attachments out of death boxes almost instantly. While armor swapping is a hard but useful tactic to master ... Read more »

Guinness World Records recognizes Russian YouTuber as making world's first retractable lightsaber

Alex Burkan’s lightsaber produces a 3-foot plasma blade that’s inspired by ‘Star Wars‘ movies. Guinness World Records Movie magic has been brought to life with the world’s first retractable lightsaber.  YouTuber ... Read more »

My husband's cheated with four other women – but always comes crawling back

DEAR DEIDRE: MY husband tosses me aside like a rag doll when a new woman turns his head. Sadly, it’s a familiar pattern. We are both 52, we’ve been married ... Read more »

Kawasaki Updates Engine Oil To Help Get A Jump On 2022 Maintenance

© RideApart.com Kawasaki Performance Oils Is it time for a change? It’s the end of January, 2022, which means it’s prime riding season in the southern hemisphere, and prime maintenance ... Read more »

Kanye West and Julia Fox make a trendy debut in matching denim at Men's Fashion Week

© Provided by Independent Online (IOL) According to People Magazine, on Sunday, Kanye West and Julia Fox attended the KENZO fashion show as part of Paris Men’s Fashion Week in ... Read more »

Behind Every Successful Man...

Celebrities often date and marry their fellow public figures. We suppose that at some level it is just easier to be understood by someone who faces the same pressures of ... Read more »

Taylor Lautner Talks 'Twilight' Resurgence and 'Home Team' (Exclusive)

© Charley Gallay/Getty Images Taylor Lautner is reflecting on how Twilight is finding a new audience. The 29-year-old actor told ET’s Matt Cohen how he feels about the franchise that made him famous experiencing ... Read more »

Chelsea 'are negotiating a deal for Ousmane Dembele'

Chelsea ‘are negotiating a deal for Ousmane Dembele‘ and may have already reached an agreement for the wantaway Barcelona star.  Dembeles relationship with the club has always been fractious but ... Read more »

Jonnny May's participation in Six Nations to hinge on visit to specialist this week

© Andrew Fosker INPHO Jonny May. JONNY MAY’S PARTICIPATION in England’s Guinness Six Nations hinges on a visit to a specialist this week, with the Gloucester wing set to miss ... Read more »

Families to be £435 better off each year if Rishi Sunak reforms property tax, says Tory MP

HOUSEHOLDS would be £435 better off each year on average if Ministers introduced a revamped property levy. Chancellor Rishi Sunak is today urged to rip up the existing levies and ... Read more »

Buffett's Berkshire will hold in-person shareholders meeting in 2022

Berkshire CEO Warren Buffett will hold the meeting in person with the option of attending online. AP Warren Buffett’s company plans to hold its annual shareholders meeting that used to ... Read more »

Alabama Amazon warehouse workers tilting pro-union, labor reps say

Amazon warehouse employees in Bessemer, Ala. are considering whether to sign a union contract. AFP via Getty Images The Amazon warehouse in Alabama where workers voted down a union last ... Read more »

Lancaster student allegedly made to pay for his own replacement door after it was vandalised with racist slur

© Sa’ad Muṣṭafā/TikTok Lancaster student allegedly made to pay for his own replacement door after it was vandalised with racist slur A Lancaster University student was allegedly told he had ... Read more »

Former Bengal CM Buddhadeb Bhattacharya Refuses Padma Bhushan, Says ‘No One Told Me Anything About It'

© Provided by News18 Former Bengal CM Buddhadeb Bhattacharya Refuses Padma Bhushan, Says ‘No One Told Me Anything About It’ As the list of Padma awardees came out on Tuesday, ... Read more »

Fears 'thousands' of bottles, slippers and a wheelbarrow blocking river will flood playgroup

A West London river has been blocked by mountains of dumped rubbish from ‘thousands of bottles’ to a wheelbarrow and even an oil drum. The litter pile also includes a ... Read more »

"Special" 56-goal "fighter" gives West Ham transfer the green light, GSB must now act - opinion

© Provided by Football FanCast Jesse Lingard Premier League – West Ham United v Tottenham Hotspur West Ham United have been handed a huge boost in their bid to bring ... Read more »

"I understand" - Journalist drops fresh Aaronson to Leeds update

© GiveMeSport Leeds United manager Marcelo Bielsa RB Salzburg do not want to sell attacking midfielder Brenden Aaronson this month, but that could change if Leeds United present an irresistible offer, ... Read more »

27,000 Covid patients in home isolation, strictly monitoring their condition: PCMC

© Provided by The Indian Express EVEN AS the industrial city of Pimpri-Chinchwad has over 27,500 Covid-19 patients in home isolation, not a single patient has required any emergency help ... Read more »

Liverpool trio join forces for golf's Dubai Desert Classic Pro-Am during winter break

Liverpool FC stars James Milner, Alex Oxlade-Chamberlain and Andy Robertson were just a few of many big names competing in the Dubai Desert Classic Pro-Am on Tuesday. The Premier League ... Read more »

Report: NUFC 'ready' to make fresh bid for 29-goal star who's evoked Harry Potter comparisons

© Provided by Transfer Tavern Robin Gosens celebrates scoring for Germany Newcastle United are preparing to make a second bid for Atalanta’s Robin Gosens after their first offer was rejected, ... Read more »
On free-english-test.com you will find lots of free English exam practice materials to help you improve your English skills: grammar, listening, reading, writing, ielts, toeic