Why Adani group companies have little analyst coverage

#Adani Group stocks.

One of the upshots of the recent tumble in shares of Adani group companies was the renewed attention on the poor analyst coverage of the ports-to-energy Indian conglomerate receives.

Analyst reports play an important role in helping investors make informed decisions and a low or nil coverage reflects poorly on the quality of the company. It is often looked upon as a sign of lack of genuine investor interest, which makes brokerages and analysts give the company a miss in terms of tracking it.

Take for example Adani Green Energy. The renewables company has zero coverage, as per data from Trendlyne, a capital market insights firm.

Data from Trendlyne further shows that there are research reports on Adani Enterprises by just two brokerages – ICICI Securities and HDFC Securities. Adani Total Gas is also tracked by just a couple of brokerages – ICICI Securities and Monarch Networth Capital.

The only exception is Adani Ports, which has seen coverage by over two dozen brokerages though the number of broking firms still tracking it has registered a fall.

“An analysis of available Bloomberg data on coverage shows that it is in single-digit for every Adani group company except Adani Ports, which has 26 analysts covering it,” said Gaurav Garg, Head – Research, CapitalVia Global Research.

A Meagre Number

That is a shockingly low number for a group of companies that have a combined market-capitalisation of nearly Rs 8 lakh crore.

Adani Green Energy has a market-capitalisation of Rs 1.74 lakh crore and is the 22nd largest listed company on the Bombay Stock Exchange. Adani Enterprises occupies the 28th position with a market-capitalisation of Rs 1.5 lakh crore and is closely followed by Adani Total Gas, Adani Transmission and Adani Ports & Special Economic Zone.

In a recent interview with CNBC-TV18, Adani Group Chief Financial Officer Jugeshinder Singh said some of the group companies are just a couple of years old and the analyst coverage will increase in future.

“We can get analysts to cover us. We have not chased them … we have not done any equity raise. We are hugely cash flow positive … Strategic investors have come in,” he said, adding that such investors do proper due diligence before putting money in any company.

Is that a plausible reason? There are many Indian companies that have listed only in the last couple of years but still are being tracked by several brokerages.

For example, Polycab India listed in 2019 and is being covered by 10 brokerages. Garden Reach Shipbuilders and  Engineers made its debut on the bourses in 2018 and has reports by at least four brokerages. Varroc Engineering also listed in the same year as Garden Reach and sees coverage by eight broking firms.

Note that these firms are much smaller in size compared with the Adani Group entities.

Let’s look at another example.

Nestle India’s market-capitalisation is only a tad higher than that of Adani Green Energy. Still, the food and beverage company is tracked by brokerages such as Axis Direct, HDFC Securities, ICICI Securities, Motilal Oswal Securities, Geojit BNP Paribas, and Prabhudas Lilladhar, among others.

So, what gives?

One vital reason market participants attribute to the modest analyst coverage is the low free float in most of the Adani companies.

The Free Float Angle

A low free float means that promoters hold a high stake in the company that leaves less shares for public shareholders like foreign portfolio investors (FPIs) or the domestic institutional ones like insurance players or mutual funds.

In the case of Adani Green Energy, promoters’ stake was constant at 74.9% for many quarters before falling to 56.3% in the quarter ended March 31, 2021. Both Adani Enterprises and Adani Transmission, have promoter stake pegged at 74.9% while promoters hold 74.8% and 63.7% stake in Adani Total Gas and Adani Ports, respectively.

“The promoter holding in the group companies is quite high and hence the free float is quite low. There is not much interest from many foreign investors and domestic institutional investors and hence analyst coverage is very low,” said Shriram Subramanian, founder and managing Director, InGovern Research Services, a proxy advisory firm.

The frequent restructuring of companies has also made institutional investors wary of investing in the group. Brokerages do not find value in initiating coverage, according to market players.

The Ahmedabad-based conglomerate hived off its port business being from the flagship Adani Enterprises and listed its transmission business as a separate company, carved out from the power generation vertical.

While the intent of the restructuring was to enhance the valuation of the various business verticals by listing them as separate entities, the move seems to have made the analyst community wary of initiating coverage on the firms despite the significant surge in the valuations.

Garg said may be that’s the reason the group moved nearly 600% in the current rally while Nifty has given a return of 110% from the low of 7,500. But he said analysts are possibly staying away from covering the group stocks because prices are trading above 100x PE multiple and the group has a high debt of around ₹1.50 trillion. “The valuation is very high.”

The widely-held perception that the group is highly politically connected also acts as a catalyst for the reluctance of analysts, according to market participants.

“Investors and analysts are aware that it is a politically connected group. There have been regular spin-offs in terms of demerging certain businesses, making institutional investors wary of investing in the companies,” said Subramanian.

The Other Side

A section of market participants isn’t too concerned by the low free float. That is just the group’s way of doing business and does not necessarily reflect the quality of the listed firms, they say.

Arun Kejriwal of Kejriwal Research and Investment Services said Adani’s business approach is to have high group ownership and this is witnessed in almost all their companies. “Secondly, they believe in doing their work and not necessarily keeping the investing world aware on a day-to-day basis. While some people consider this as good and some as bad, this is their style,” he said.

Kejriwal said the largest float in an Adani company is in Adani Ports where being a part of futures (derivatives segment) there is substantial activity in the share and the nature of business makes it well covered by research reports. “While this makes investors happy, this is also the reason why they are unhappy with other group companies on information.”

News Related

OTHER NEWS

Exchange Fund posts US$6.6 billion second-quarter gain, giving Hong Kong more firepower to defend city's currency

Hong Kong’s Exchange Fund, the war chest used to defend the local currency from attacks by short sellers, earned HK$51.4 billion (US$6.6 billion) from its investments in the second quarter ... Read more »

Canara Bank takes one-time settlement route to tackle stress in small-value loans

Syndicate Bank was merged into Canara Bank in April 2020 (File image) Bengaluru-headquartered Canara Bank said on 27 July that it has taken the one-time settlement (OTS) route to recover ... Read more »

Simply Save | What is swing pricing and how can it impact debt mutual funds?

In the last few years, investing in debt mutual funds has been difficult, especially in funds taking credit risks. The liquidity crunch that hit debt markets after Covid-19 pandemic led ... Read more »

Idlis, Dosas, Parota's global footprint: ID Fresh Food expands in Gulf, eyes to open US plant

Idli (Pixabay) Idli-Dosa batter maker iD fresh food said on July 27 that it will be expanding to countries such as Saudi Arabia, Bahrain, Kuwait and Qatar in the next ... Read more »

Skoda to expand presence to100 cities in India by next month

Czech automaker Skoda is planning to enhance its presence across 100 cities in India by next month as it looks to cater to more customers with the launch of its ... Read more »

Tata Communications unveils IZO financial cloud platform in India

Tata Communications | Representative Image. (PC-PTI) Tata Communications on Tuesday announced the launch of IZO financial cloud platform in India, that aims to enhance performance and security of organisations in ... Read more »

Axis Bank buys 5.55% stake in financial technology firm IBBIC

Axis Bank on Tuesday said it has bought 5.55 percent stake in financial technology firm IBBIC. The bank has subscribed to 50,000 equity shares of face value of Rs 10 ... Read more »

Maruti Suzuki India partners with Savitribai Phule Pune University to train youth in auto retail

Representative Image The country’s leading car maker Maruti Suzuki India on Tuesday said it has partnered with Savitribai Phule Pune University, Maharashtra, to train the youth in automobile retail. A ... Read more »

Moneycontrol Pro Panorama | Economic recovery remains anything but smooth

Dear Reader, The Panorama newsletter is sent to Moneycontrol Pro subscribers on market days. It offers easy access to stories published on Moneycontrol Pro and gives a little extra by ... Read more »

Torrent Gas plans Rs 10,000 crore capex in 5 years; sets up 25 CNG stations in Chennai

Representative image Torrent Gas, part of the USD 3 billion Torrent Group, has drawn up a Rs 10,000 crore capital expenditure plan spread over the next five years including Rs ... Read more »

Adani Ports raises $750 million from global markets

The amount to be disbursed by NHAI would provide a liquidity breather for the projects. Adani Ports and Special Economic Zone Ltd (APSEZ) has raised USD 750 million (around Rs ... Read more »

Yondr Group, Everstone announce tie-up to develop and operate data centres in India

Representative image Yondr Group, the US-based global data centre major, has entered into a strategic tie-up with Singapore-based private equity firm Everstone Group to develop and operate data centres in ... Read more »

Retailers start expansion as COVID-19 second wave ebbs; focus on high-street locations, smaller towns

Representative image Retailers across segments in India are on an expansion spree as the second wave of the COVID-19 pandemic subsides. While some retailers are implementing plans that had to ... Read more »

Cairn arbitration: Govt confirms French court order against Indian assets

(File image: Cairn Energy) The government on Tuesday confirmed that a French court has ordered the freezing of certain Indian assets in Paris on a petition by Britain’s Cairn Energy, ... Read more »

ABB to divest Mechanical Power Transmission division to RBC Bearings for $2.9 billion

Representative image Swiss engineering major ABB on Tuesday said it has signed a pact to divest Mechanical Power Transmission division (Dodge) to RBC Bearings for USD 2.9 billion. The transaction ... Read more »

19 drug cocktails approved pre-1988 come under fresh review

Medicines (Representative image) Nineteen fixed dose combinations (FDC) drugs that were exempted from government ban in 2016 as they were approved prior 1988, will be coming come under fresh review ... Read more »

FMCG revenue growth likely to double in FY22 to 10-12%: CRISIL Ratings

The FMCG sector is set to double its revenue growth in the financial year (FY) 2022 to 10-12 percent as compared to 5-6 percent in FY21, estimates CRISIL Ratings. According ... Read more »

Can a bankrupt Vijay Mallya still live as a baron?

Vijay Mallya Vijay Mallya, the former promoter of grounded Kingfisher Airlines, was declared bankrupt by the London High Court on July 26. As a result, some questions have arisen. Can ... Read more »

Tata Motors rolls out 10,000th unit of new Safari

Source: Tata Motors Cars Homegrown auto major Tata Motors on Tuesday said it has rolled out the 10,000th unit of the new version of its SUV Safari. After the roll ... Read more »

Tata Power distribution arm in Odisha ties up with CSCs to facilitate online bill payments in rural areas

The collaboration will help rural consumers of the joint venture company between Tata Power and the Odisha government pay their power bills to CSCs and Village Level Entrepreneurs (VLEs), he ... Read more »

DLF's Q1 sales bookings jump nearly 7-fold to Rs 1,014 crore despite second wave of COVID-19

Realty major DLF Ltd’s sales bookings jumped nearly 7-fold year-on-year to Rs 1,014 crore during the April-June quarter of this fiscal, on strong demand for its independent floors and luxury ... Read more »

Amazon eyes potential stake in Indian film, media businesses; Inox denies report

In the four-page letter, a so-called ‘show cause notice’, the CCI asked Amazon why it should not take action and penalise the company for providing false information. (File Image) Amazon.com ... Read more »

Analysis | NPA woes continue for banks, NBFCs in Q1; will the next quarter be better?

The last date for submitting an Expression of Interest for the bid is May 17, 2021. The second coronavirus wave was to leave the Indian banking sector unscathed when compared ... Read more »

Devesh Sachdev succeeds Manoj Kumar Nambiar as chairperson of microfinance industry association MFIN

Microcredit industry association and self-regulatory organisation Microfinance Institutions Network (MFIN), on 27 July, announced the election of Devesh Sachdev, Founder and CEO, Fusion Microfinance, as its Chairperson. Sachdev succeeded Manoj ... Read more »

ShareChat raises $145 million from Temasek, others at $3 billion valuation

ShareChat was launched by three IIT Kanpur alumni- Sachdeva, Farid Ahsan and Bhanu Singh in 2015 Content-sharing platform ShareChat has raised $145 million in fresh funding from Singapore’s Temasek Holdings ... Read more »

Brazil scraps Covaxin's EUA application after Bharat Biotech terminates pact with partners

Bharat Biotech’s Covaxin was granted restricted emergency use approval in ‘clinical trial mode’ on January 2. After suspending the proposed clinical trials of Bharat Bioetchs COVID-19 vaccine Covaxin, Brazil has ... Read more »

MyGlamm raises Rs 355 crore in funding from Accel, others

Direct-to-consumer beauty brand MyGlamm on Tuesday said it has raised Rs 355 crore in fresh funding from Accel, along with participation from existing investors, taking the total funds raised in ... Read more »

Tata Motors expects govt to be consistent with support for local production of EVs

Tata Motors | Representative image Tata Motors on Monday said it expects the government to consistently follow the policy of promoting local manufacturing of electric vehicles (EVs) under the FAME ... Read more »

IPO Buzz | Carwale owner CarTrade Tech gets SEBI approval for Rs 2,000 crore public listing

Representative image Online auto classifieds platform CarTrade Tech has received the regulatory approval from Securities and Exchange Board of India (SEBI) to float Rs 2,000 crore via the initial public ... Read more »

Biocon Biologics, Adagio Therapeutics sign pact for potential antibody treatment against COVID-19

“We expect results from the phase 4 study on itolizumab by the end of this quarter. This would be real-world data from around 300 patients,” said Arun Chandavarkar, Managing Director ... Read more »

SBI announces major reshuffle in HR, technology divisions

State bank of India State bank of India (SBI) on July 26 announced key reshuffling in the bank’s HR and technology departments. Om Prakash Mishra who was elevated to the post ... Read more »

NTPC REL bags 325 MW solar projects at Shajapur Solar Park in Madhya Pradesh

General view of one of the world’s largest floating solar panel farms in Singapore, July 13, 2021, in this still image taken from video. (Image: Reuters) State-run power giant NTPC ... Read more »

RBI imposes monetary penalty on Balasore Cooperative Urban Bank

The Reserve Bank of India (RBI) on July 23 imposed a monetary penalty of Rs 1 lakh on the Balasore Cooperative Urban Bank Limited, Balasore, Odisha for violating the directions issued by the RBI ... Read more »

Govt to sell up to 8% stake in HUDCO via OFS, fixes floor price at Rs 45 per share

President Ram Nath Kovind, acting through the Ministry of Housing and Urban Affairs, Government of India, gave the nod for the share sale in HUDCO via the OFS route. The ... Read more »

ITC's cigarette business clocks recovery, albeit on a low base

A man talks on his mobile phone as he walks past an ITC office building in Kolkata (File image: Reuters/Rupak De Chowdhuri) Better-than-expected cigarette sales lit up ITC’s first-quarter earnings ... Read more »

Alembic Pharmaceuticals net profit drops 45% in Q1FY22 due to pricing pressure in US market

India business helped by COVID-19 and lower base of last year rose 57 percent to Rs 481 crore. Alembic Pharmaceuticals net profit dropped 45 percent year-on-year (YoY) to Rs 165 ... Read more »

Sony Pictures Networks India rejigs top-level positions under vision 3.0

Under its vision 3.0, Sony Pictures Networks India has revamped its organisational structure and made leadership changes. Rohit Gupta who was Chief Revenue Officer – Ad Sales and International Business has now taken on ... Read more »

SBI Life Insurance Q1 net profit down 42.9% at Rs 223.16 crore

SBI_Life Private life insurer SBI Life Insurance posted a 42.9 percent year-on-year (YoY) drop in its June quarter (Q1) net profit at Rs 223.16 crore due to additional reserving for ... Read more »

Quick commerce segment to be a $5 billion market by 2025, says report

Quick commerce, defined as the delivery of consumables under 45 minutes, is slated to see rapid rise in the years ahead, showed the findings of a report by consulting firm ... Read more »