Who is responsible for tent cities and homeless encampments in B.C.?

Recent events, including a violent attack, at homeless encampments and tent cities in B.C. have raised questions about who is responsible for them, and what is being done to help people experiencing homelessness in the province.

On Monday, a man was shot at an encampment in Nanaimo, on Vancouver Island, while attempting to retrieve an item allegedly stolen by someone who resided there.

A day later, the city of Prince George voted to create a centralized homeless camp in the Moccasin Flats area, to stop camps from spreading across the city due to public safety concerns.

The incidents raise the complicated questions of what rights are afforded to those experiencing homelessness, and who is responsible for their welfare.

Here are some answers to those questions.

Is it illegal to be homeless in B.C.?

No. There’s nothing in Canada’s Criminal Code that makes it a crime to be unhoused; the Charter of Rights and Freedoms includes protections for people in public spaces.

“The main section of our Charter, which applies in the context of people sheltering outside, is section 7,” said Anna Cooper, staff lawyer at Pivot Legal Society who works with unhoused people.

“[It] basically protects the safety of your person and your possessions.”

who is responsible for tent cities and homeless encampments in b.c.?

Anna Cooper, who works with Pivot Legal Society, says tent city residents have the ability to invoke their Charter rights if they feel they are being forcibly evicted, but that they are often intimidated by the presence of police and bylaw officers. She says bylaws around sleeping outdoors are applied unconstitutionally.

However, people who live in tents or makeshift shelters in cities can be in contravention of municipal bylaws around zoning, outdoor camping or fire safety.

Additionally, Cooper says, police can charge someone sleeping outside with the criminal offence of obstructing a peace officer. Police can also enforce the civil penalty of trespassing on private property.

Why are homeless encampments and tent cities allowed?

While many homeless encampments are in violation of municipal bylaws or trespassing acts, courts have ruled before that cities may not evict them without providing residents appropriate housing.

For instance, B.C. Supreme Court justice Christopher Hinkson ruled in 2021 that the City of Prince George could not dismantle the Moccasin Flats encampment, due to a lack of suitable alternatives for residents.

“We’ve had cases where [unhoused] people win at the first instance, but then the city just keeps pushing through the court system until they get that rubber stamp to evict people, even to nowhere,” Cooper said.

Do cities have a legal obligation to provide housing?

According to Cooper, there are no specific laws that guarantee a right to housing in Canada.

She says Canada’s Charter and federal laws have not yet caught up to international human rights treaties the government has signed on to, which provide for the right to housing and the right to not be forcefully evicted.

who is responsible for tent cities and homeless encampments in b.c.?

Homeless counts across B.C. have demonstrated that Indigenous and marginalized people are disproportionately homeless, with lawyer Anna Cooper saying this may be an argument for governments contravening human rights legislation by not guaranteeing housing.

“That being said, governments do have requirements to not discriminate against people,” she added. “The way that homelessness is manifesting … it is disproportionately impacting marginalized groups protected by those codes.

“There is an argument that governments are discriminating in the way that services such as housing are being provided.”

What are the province and cities doing about it?

Under B.C.’s Local Government Act, cities have a broad range of powers when it comes to housing — from zoning to property taxes — but not the ability to fund and build their own housing.

That is largely a provincial matter, under Crown companies like B.C. Housing.

In response to concerns around the Moccasin Flats encampment, Premier David Eby said B.C. was working with communities around the province to “get them the resources” to open housing and close encampments.

who is responsible for tent cities and homeless encampments in b.c.?

Premier David Eby, who once assumed the housing portfolio in B.C., has previously spoken out against the idea of sanctioned homeless camps in the province.

“Encampments are not a solution to homelessness,” he told Carolina de Ryk on CBC’s Daybreak North. “Getting people inside into dignified housing is priority one.”

Asked whether he would overrule municipal decisions on homelessness, as he did when he ordered a Penticton shelter to remain open in 2021, Eby said he would only do that if there was a “major issue.”

He said B.C. Housing is acquiring buildings to create housing in the city, but labour and supply chain issues were delaying construction.

In a statement, a B.C. Housing spokesperson said more than 40,000 new homes have been built or are underway since 2017. Over 5,000 of those are supportive homes for low-income people, and 2,200 are under construction.

Are centralized homeless camps a solution?

Cooper said the idea of a sanctioned, centralized homeless encampment monitored by police — as is being proposed in Prince George — misses the fact that homeless people are not a monolith.

“I’m extremely concerned about cities using single-managed encampment spaces as a way to remove unhoused folks from all public space,” she said.

The federal housing advocate, Marie-Josee Houle, also expressed concern about the plan, saying it would violate Indigenous rights.

In response, Eby said he took the advocate’s point, but that it was “far more constructive” for the federal government to come to the table and be part of housing funding discussions.

“This is an area where the federal government has been absent for a while.”

News Related


Suspect wanted in firearm incident surrenders to Windsor police

David ‘Ivan’ Trombley, 24, of Windsor, in an image shared by police. A Windsor man known to police and being sought on firearms charges has turned himself in. Windsor police ... Read more »

Saskatoon high school student who fled Afghanistan wins $100,000 scholarship

Banin Arjmand never shies away from a challenge. The 20-year-old refugee made a treacherous journey out of Afghanistan with her parents and classmates after the Taliban seized control in August 2021. ... Read more »

Sentence reduced for Victoria mom who sexually assaulted teen boy

The Supreme Court of B.C. in Vancouver. The Supreme Court of B.C. has reduced a five-and-a-half-year jail sentence handed to a Victoria woman who lured and sexually assaulted a 15-year-old ... Read more »

Ravens owner admits major Lamar Jackson problem

Lamar Jackson Ever since the Cleveland Browns gave star quarterback Deshaun Watson a massive fully-guaranteed contract ahead of the 2022 NFL season, it seems to have affected the contract negotiations ... Read more »

‘John Wick 4’ Pays Tribute To Late Lance Reddick In Credits

‘John Wick: Chapter 4’ Lance Reddick Lance Reddick is getting a posthumous sendoff in “John Wick: Chapter 4”. The actor — who died at age 60 last week, prior to ... Read more »

Lions Reportedly Signing Veteran Free Agent On Wednesday

(Photo by Ezra Shaw/Getty Images) The Detroit Lions are bringing back a familiar face. Jalen Reeves-Maybin will return to Detroit, where he spent the first five years of his career, ... Read more »

Feds kick in $43 million to supply clean drinking water for Oneida Nation of the Thames

Oneida Nation of the Thames, an Indigenous community near London, Ont., that has been on a boil water advisory since 2019, has secured $43 million in federal funding to connect to ... Read more »

Mothers in Syrian detention camps given 'cruel' choice to keep children or send them to Canada: advocates

More than two dozen women and children held in northeastern Syrian detention camps are due to arrive on Canadian soil any day, but the fate of 10 of those children ... Read more »

Opinion: Is net-zero putting Canadians’ pensions in jeopardy?

One investment that calls into question the wisdom of rushing into net-zero is CPP Investments’ significant bankrolling of U.K. energy retailer Octopus Energy. In the rush to support Ottawa’s commitment ... Read more »

Nova Scotia teen accused in school stabbing opts to remain in jail

Charles P. Allen High School in Bedford, N.S., was placed in a hold and secure on Monday morning following a weapons call. The teenager accused of stabbing two staff members at ... Read more »

Does Tom Izzo have a son? Meet Michigan State's Steven Izzo playing for dad in March Madness

Does Tom Izzo have a son? Meet Michigan State’s Steven Izzo playing for dad in March Madness For many, sports are like family. For Michigan State head coach Tom Izzo, ... Read more »

Edmonton Oilers superstar Connor McDavid takes aim at lack of best-on-best hockey tournament, Russia and Belarus suspended from IIHF tournaments in 2023-24, and more

Edmonton Oilers superstar Connor McDavid takes aim at lack of best-on-best hockey tournament, Russia and Belarus suspended from IIHF tournaments in 2023-24, and more If there’s one player who has ... Read more »

Launch of 3D-printed rocket successful, but craft fails to reach orbit

Relativity Space’s 3D-printed rocket, Terran, is shown lifting off on March 22. CAPE CANAVERAL, Fla. — A rocket made almost entirely of 3D-printed parts made its launch debut Wednesday night, ... Read more »

How Much Do You Need to Invest to Give Up Work and Live Only Off Dividend Income?

analyze data Look, I get it: nobody actually likes working. After all, imagine what you could do if you had a reliable source of passive income enough to cover your ... Read more »

Crumbl Cookies expands to Canada with first location in Edmonton to open this month

Crumbl Cookies expands to Canada with first location in Edmonton to open this month EDMONTON — Crumbl Cookies says it plans to open its first Canadian store later this month. ... Read more »

The shocking death of Lance Reddick was felt on John Wick 4’s red carpet

The stars of John Wick 4 joined together at the film’s Los Angeles premiere to pay tribute to fellow actor Lance Reddick, who died last Friday at the age of ... Read more »

French home of Edward VIII and Wallis Simpson to become a museum

The French villa where the former British King, Edward VIII, lived with his American wife Wallis Simpson will open to the public for the first time. The run-down Villa Windsor ... Read more »

Gallagher’s Canadiens Career Comes to Close 1 of 5 Ways

Gallagher’s Canadiens Career Comes to Close 1 of 5 Ways The Montreal Canadiens celebrated the returns of Brendan Gallagher and Kirby Dach from injury with a 3-2 upset over the ... Read more »

Uninspired Jets scrape out two points against lowly Coyotes

Arizona Coyotes’ Connor Mackey (12) and Winnipeg Jets’ Morgan Barron (36) fight during the second period in Winnipeg on Tuesday. It was neither a convincing nor momentum-building victory, the kind ... Read more »

Antetokounmpo, Bucks to host Jones and the Spurs

San Antonio Spurs (19-53, 14th in the Western Conference) vs. Milwaukee Bucks (51-20, first in the Eastern Conference) Milwaukee; Wednesday, 8 p.m. EDT FANDUEL SPORTSBOOK NBA LINE: Bucks -17.5 BOTTOM ... Read more »

Golden Knights down Canucks 4-3, grab top spot in Western Conference

Golden Knights down Canucks 4-3, grab top spot in Western Conference VANCOUVER — Rick Tocchet is still in teaching mode two months into his tenure with the Vancouver Canucks. And ... Read more »

How to save Twitter videos: Step-by-step guide to download viral videos for offline viewing

Twitter doesn’t provide a built-in save button to download videos on its platform. While that’s a bummer, it’s not entirely impossible to download videos from Twitter. Sometimes the most interesting ... Read more »

NCT DREAM Talk U.S. Tour, New Music & Why ‘Everything Comes With Timing’ for ‘7DREAM’

NCT DREAM Talk U.S. Tour, New Music & Why ‘Everything Comes With Timing’ for ‘7DREAM’ When NCT DREAM made their live Stateside return last August as one of KCON’s most anticipated performers, a ... Read more »

Your Daily Astrology: March 22 for 03/22/23

Magi Helena (TNS) WEDNESDAY, MARCH 22, 2023 BIRTHDAY STAR: Actor Matthew Modine was born in Loma Linda, California, on this date in 1959. This birthday star earned a 1994 Emmy ... Read more »

Amazon Shoppers Are Calling This Just-Launched Blouse the “Cutest Top Ever,” and It’s Just $26

A reviewer confirmed it’s “lightweight, but not sheer.” Amazon/ InStyle When it comes to spring fashion, one of the hardest things to shop for is a cute, high-quality blouse. You ... Read more »

South Korean capital announces plans for ‘floating’ swimming pool and art pier

Just two weeks after announcing plans to build the world’s largest spokeless Ferris wheel, Seoul’s city government has shared its intention to construct urban ‘floating’ swimming zones along the South ... Read more »

Peter Werner Dies: Prolific TV Director & Oscar Winner Was 76

Peter Werner Dies: Prolific TV Director & Oscar Winner Was 76 Peter Werner, Emmy-nominated TV director who won a Best Short Film Oscar in 1977, died suddenly this morning in ... Read more »

Your Health Insurance Plan Could Make This Fitness Expense Cheaper

Two smiling middle age adults outdoors with yoga mats. If you’re an American paying a high premium for health insurance coverage, you’re not alone. Thankfully, your health insurance plan may ... Read more »

How Xi and Putin’s new friendship could test the US

As two autocrats traded tributes over a feast of quail, venison, Siberian white salmon and pomegranate sorbet, China and Russia seemed to conjure the anti-Western compact the US has long ... Read more »

YouTube Music contractors say their office is promoting anti-union messages on TVs ahead of the union election

YouTube Music workers at Cognizant’s Austin, TX office are surrounded by screens that cycle through anti-union messaging. Sam Regan Contracting firm Cognizant is pushing back as contractors for YouTube Music ... Read more »
Kênh kiến thức kỹ năng, phát triển bản thân, hướng nghiệp, blog nhân sự