Whether It is 1990 or 2021, Pandits Remain the Soft Targets in Kashmir

Asia's Tech News Daily

Whether It is 1990 or 2021, Pandits Remain the Soft Targets in Kashmir
© Provided by News18 Whether It is 1990 or 2021, Pandits Remain the Soft Targets in Kashmir

“Kashmir remains unsafe for the Hindus even after three decades of our exodus. We can’t trust the people there, whatever be the assurances. You were telling me that we should rebuild our ancestral house in Kashmir or build a new house somewhere in Srinagar. Wake up and smell the coffee,” said my mother after hearing about the targeted killings of the minorities by Islamist terrorists in Kashmir.

“They forced us to leave our watan and they will never want us to come back,” added my octogenarian maternal grandmother while reminiscing about towns of Anantnag and Bijbehara in South Kashmir. I didn’t have anything to say this time. Otherwise, I would fill them with hope about our beloved homeland. Both of them haven’t been to Kashmir since the forced exodus of Kashmiri Pandits in 1990.

In his recent article, “In Valley, no return to ’90s”, Amitabh Mattoo, former Cabinet-level advisor to Jammu and Kashmir chief minister Mufti Mohammad Sayeed and professor at Jawaharlal Nehru University, argues that the recent targeted killings of the minorities in Kashmir may open up a new window of reconciliation between the majority Muslims and the minority Pandits. Nothing could be further from the truth.

The recent killings not only remind Pandits of their selective targeting by terrorists in 1989-90 but also renew the sense of betrayal. Instead of reconciliation, such incidents have yet again widened the trust deficit between Pandits and Muslims. Notably, it reinforces the fact that the cause of Tehreek-e-Azadi is above everything else.

READ | Opinion: Recent Killings Show Kashmiriyat Distorted by Islamism; It Needs Reform

We cannot delink “deep angst within the Kashmiri Muslims over government policies” with “real reconciliation between two communities”. That will be disingenuous. What is the deep angst about which Mattoo avers? Isn’t it about the Modi government’s policies that attempt to fix the imbalances in J&K? Such corrective measures are not just for the Pandit community but also for other communities of J&K who have received unfair treatment in the last 70 years. However, like always, a Pandit is made the villain and scapegoat in the Kashmir saga. Whatever steps New Delhi takes in the matters pertaining to J&K, Pandits face the wrath on the ground, particularly in Kashmir, as they are regarded as symbols of India.

We have often heard Muslims proclaiming that Pandits are welcome back in their homeland. However, such proclamations fall flat when the same Muslims show resentment against policies if they look even slightly favourable to Pandits. Giving rights to a dispossessed community should not be a problem — that’s just basic. But even the basics — the right to live in one’s home with a sense of security, dignity and liberty — are opposed in Kashmir.

The much-revered Shankaracharya temple in Srinagar is often cited to show the façade of Hindu existence in Kashmir. What is not mentioned are the temples that have been desecrated and encroached — many of them non-existent now. Even the gods and goddesses had to leave their abodes in 1990 when the madness of jihad took over. Very recently, the Bhargshikha Devi temple in Mattan, Anantnag, was desecrated by the Islamists who didn’t come from Pakistan.

The year 1990 in Kashmir wasn’t an aberration. It was the goriest manifestation of a foreign ideology in post-Partition India under the modern democratic setup. The earliest display of the same ideology was the destruction of the Martand Sun Temple in Anantnag in the 15th century. That the temple remains majestic even in ruins after 600 years bears testimony of the resilience of aboriginal Hindu Pandits of Kashmir.

Given Mattoo’s emphasis on “talking, talking and more talking”, what should the Pandits talk about when their existence is mocked through relentless propaganda? Anti-Pandit bigotry displayed by many people from the majority community is not uncommon on social media platforms like Facebook, Twitter and Clubhouse. To even suggest that there is space for Kashmiri Pandits to come back to Kashmir would be turning a blind eye to the ground reality. They get labelled as ‘collaborator’, ‘informer’, ‘RSS stooge’, and ‘Hindutva agent’ and then are easily killed. Whether it’s 1990 or 2021, Pandits remain the soft targets in Kashmir.

What should Kashmiri Pandits reconcile to? To the trivialisation of their exodus in 1990 and subsequent exile by the majority community? To the myth, often hurled at them, that Jagmohan, then J&K Governor, was responsible for their exodus? To slurs such as ‘Pandits ran away’ and ‘Pandits are cowards who couldn’t fight back’ because they feared for their lives when the whole of Kashmir was up against the Indian state? To the deaths of their old and young due to scorching heat and snakebites in Jammu? To selling of their ancestral houses and lands at peanuts because they needed their own shelter in Jammu and other parts of the country? To encroachment of their properties after they left Kashmir? To the lonely battles for justice for more than three decades? To fading away of their generations in exile?

What does reconciliation mean if it is not based on truth and acknowledgement of the wrongdoings by the majority community of Kashmir in 1989-90? The foundation of reconciliation between Muslims and Pandits will be built on the bitter truth of 1990 and not on perverted narratives which emanate from Kashmir.

ALSO READ | Why Targeted Killings of Civilians in Kashmir are Not Similar to the 1990 Episode

As far as confidence-building is concerned, the onus squarely lies on the majority Muslims, and not Pandits. Pandits didn’t break the social fabric in Kashmir. Pandits didn’t pick up guns and started killing people in the name of religion. Pandits only minded their business and they paid a heavy price for it. Instead of tacitly supporting azadi and terming those who choose the path of violence as ‘misguided’, the Muslims of Kashmir ought to call out Islamist terrorism and take steps to prevent the radicalisation in their own society. Only that will translate into confidence among Pandits. Otherwise, hollow words and banal assurances will be a merry-go-round from time to time.

There do exist cordial relations between some Muslims and Pandits of Kashmir at an individual level, but this can’t be extrapolated to the entire community. Importantly, cordiality doesn’t disregard the betrayal of 1990. The dynamics of the Hindu-Muslim relationship changes at the larger community level because of the contrasting standpoints (Kashmir’s civilisational connect with the rest of India, accession of J&K to the Union of India in 1947, the mass exodus in 1990, etc.)

Why shouldn’t the Government of India intervene? It is the state’s responsibility to rehabilitate its citizens back in their homes. However, the Indian state has completely failed to reverse the exile of the Pandit community in the last 31 years.

We need to stop veiling the realities of Kashmir just because the phoney secularism has to be shown to the outside world. The reality surfaces time and again, and stares at us even when there are attempts to conceal it. The rehabilitation of Pandits in Kashmir is interlinked with the security situation which is hinged on the issue of jihad. We need to talk about the elephant in the room, i.e., jihad and not gloss over it which has resulted in loss of scores of men and women from both communities. Let’s start calling spade a spade for starters. When we clearly identify the problem, only then will we be able to fix it.

There isn’t light at the end of the tunnel as of now — only dark abyss. There will be light only when Kashmir’s majority community will tread the path of its saints, poets, and scholars — Abhinavagupta, Anandavardhana, Kalhana, Lal Ded, Nund Rishi, Roop Bhawani, Shamas Faqir, Rasul Mir, etc. — and categorically shun the path of violence and destruction proposed by the ideologues of Islamist terrorism such as Maqbool Bhat, Amanullah Khan, Syed Ali Shah Geelani, Shabir Ahmad Shah, Syed Salahuddin, and Asiya Andrabi.

The writer is an author and political commentator. He is the co-editor of a book on Kashmir’s ethnic minority community titled ‘A Long Dream of Home: The Persecution, Exodus and Exile of Kashmiri Pandits’, published by Bloomsbury India. The views expressed in this article are those of the author and do not represent the stand of this publication.

Read all the Latest News, Breaking News and Coronavirus News here. Follow us on Facebook, Twitter and Telegram.

Internet Explorer Channel Network
Asia's Tech News Daily
News Related


Tourism chief brushes off impact of tighter entry rules for fully vaxxed travelers

Tourism Sec. Bernadette Romulo-Puyat at Senate hearing Sept. 23, 2021 Tourism Secretary Bernadette Romulo-Puyat brushed off the impact on the tourism industry of the suspension of a resolution allowing the ... Read more »

NBA awards race: Predictions for MVP, Rookie of the Year and others through first quarter of 2021-22 season

Just like that, in the blink of an eye, the first quarter of the 2021-22 NBA season has passed us by. With every team in the league hitting the 20-game mark, ... Read more »

Tom Morello wants shock factor in guitar playing

Tom Morello wants as many “what the f***” factors in his music as possible. © Bang Showbiz Tom Morello wants to innovate The Rage Against The Machine guitarist – who ... Read more »

Forget Neves: Lage must unleash Wolves' "magnificent" rarely-seen 19 y/o tonight - opinion

© Provided by Football FanCast Wolves, Premier League, Bruno Lage, Jeff Shi, Molineux, Ruben Neves, Luke Cundle, Wolverhampton Wanderers’ start to the 2021/22 campaign was far from ideal. Bruno Lage ... Read more »

Tyson Fury's coach shares 'never before seen' image of Gypsy King when he weighed 28 stone

The coach that trained Tyson Fury has shared a first time image of the WBC heavyweight champion at 28 stone. © GiveMeSport p1flqu78pj79mhits7t4eh1c41h.jpg The Gypsy King has been on the ... Read more »

Horoskop: Deine geheime Schicksalszahl verrät dein Zukunft!

© Dzhulbee / iStock Horoskop: Deine Lebenszahl verrät dein Schicksal! Du möchtest mehr über dich selbst herausfinden? Checke jetzt ab, was deine geheime Schicksalszahl über dich, deine Zukunft und dein ... Read more »

EU unveils 300 billion euro answer to China's Belt and Road

By Jan Strupczewski © Reuters/YVES HERMAN EU flags flutter outside the European Commission headquarters in Brussels BRUSSELS (Reuters) -The European Commission unveiled on Wednesday a plan to invest 300 billion ... Read more »

Jude Bellingham makes transfer stance clear amid Man Utd and Liverpool links

Jude Bellingham claims he wants to “develop at Borussia Dortmund and give something back by winning titles” amid talk of a return to England. The midfielder left Birmingham City and ... Read more »

'Huge relief' as Capital Gains Tax hike shelved - but 'very welcome tweak' announced

© Getty capital gains tax Capital Gains Tax was recently reviewed alongside Inheritance Tax by the Office of Tax Simplification (OTS). With the Chancellor of the Exchequer often looking towards ... Read more »

Trotz Johnson-Impfung: Ex-Miss Nadine Vinzens lag zehn Tage mit Corona im Spital

Wie heimtückisch Covid-19 ist, mussten die Bündner Ex-Miss Nadine Vinzens und ihr Freund, Techno-DJ Mark Reeve, am eigenen Leib erleben. Beide mussten im Spital behandelt werden. Seit heute ist sie ... Read more »

Neue Beschränkungen: In Portugal gilt wieder Corona-Notfallzustand

In Portugal gilt seit Mittwoch wegen steigender Corona-Zahlen wieder der Notfallzustand mit neuen Beschränkungen und Testregeln. Alle Besucher, die auf dem Luftweg einreisen, müssen nun einen negativen Test vorweisen – ... Read more »

Wo muss ich jetzt schon Maske tragen? Ab wann und wie lange die neuen Massnahmen gelten

© shutterstock Teaserbild Die Ankündigung neuer Corona-Massnahmen sorgt bei manchen für Verwirrung. Sind nun national bereits neue Massnahmen beschlossen worden oder nicht? Und gibt es Unterschiede bei den einzelnen Kantonen? ... Read more »

Jacob Rees-Mogg and Scottish Tory leader Douglas Ross face standards probe

Commons Leader Jacob Rees-Mogg and Scottish Conservative leader Douglas Ross have become the latest MPs to face a standards probe. On Wednesday, both were added to the list of MPs ... Read more »

Viel Lärm um wenig Ralliart - Mitsubishi Triton und Pajero Sport Ralliart (2022)

Mitsubishi bringt die Motorsport-Marke Ralliart zurück. In Thailand wurden nun die ersten Modelle Triton und Pajero Sport vorgestellt. Sportlich ist da allerdings wenig. © Mitsubishi / Patrick Lang Auf der ... Read more »

Scots should adopt informal version of vaccine passport scheme for Christmas dinner, expert says

Scotland – Peter Summers/Getty Images Scottish families should adopt an informal version of the SNP Government's vaccine passport scheme to decide who can attend Christmas dinner, the country's national clinical ... Read more »

Jacob Rees-Mogg faces Commons inquiry over undeclared £6m loans

Photograph: Anadolu Agency/Getty Images Standards commissioner launches investigation after complaint from Labour against Tory frontbencher The parliamentary commissioner for standards has begun a formal investigation into Jacob Rees-Mogg after a ... Read more »

Royal Family: The unexpected reason why the Queen has given up her favourite drink - and what she's having instead

Having a glass of your favourite tipple at the end of a long day can be a refreshing way to unwind. When you’re a royal, enjoying an alcoholic beverage before ... Read more »

Matt Edmondson and wife Bryony are expecting their second child

© Provided by Daily Mail MailOnline logo Matt Edmondson has revealed he and his wife Bryony are expecting their second child. The presenter, 35, said the couple, who are already ... Read more »

Voices: So now we know – one in five employers wouldn't hire a disabled person

‘People with known disabilities have long been aware that they have to be streets ahead of the competition just to get in front of an interview panel’ (Getty/iStock) We are ... Read more »

Oil prices have tanked so hard traders are assuming planes won't fly for 3 months: Goldman Sachs

Oil prices have come down way too fast on Omicron variant concerns, says Goldman Sachs oil strategist Damien Courvalin. In fact, the price correction is borderline comical, per Courvalin's calculations. ... Read more »

EU urges daily travel reviews, booster shots over Omicron

© Reuters/STEPHANE MAHE FILE PHOTO: Coronavirus disease (COVID-19) vaccination in La Baule BRUSSELS (Reuters) – The European Union needs daily reviews of its travel restrictions and rapid deployment of vaccine ... Read more »

Singapore tests out 'smart bandage' to monitor wounds via app

Researchers in Singapore have developed a smart bandage to enable patients to have chronic wounds monitored remotely via an app on a mobile device, potentially saving them visits to the ... Read more »

KL City juara Piala Malaysia, Wilayah Persekutuan cuti Jumaat

© Provided by Free Malaysia Today KL City FC menamatkan 32 tahun kemarau kejuaraan Piala Malaysia selepas menewaskan JDT 2-0 pada perlawanan di Stadium Nasional Bukit Jalil. (Gambar Facebook) PETALING ... Read more »

Scottish international rugby star Siobhan Cattigan dies suddenly aged 26 as tributes paid

SCOTLAND international rugby star Siobhan Cattigan has died suddenly aged 26, it was confirmed last night. The back row, who won 19 caps for her country, died on Friday, with ... Read more »

You've been using your heating all wrong – four myths to avoid and save HUNDREDS of pounds

THERE'S lots of advice available on how households can reduce their energy bills, but some well-known tips won't actually help you cut costs. Some popular guidance won't save you an ... Read more »

I'm obese & my wife's a size 8 – people say it's a billion to one chance I've found someone who's into ‘fat blokes'

THEY say love comes in all shapes and sizes – after all, what matters is what's inside and how your special someone makes you feel. These TikTok lovebirds, Sienna Keera ... Read more »

Full list of countries with new test and vaccine rules for tourists including France, Spain and Germany

AS new cases of the Omicron Covid strain are being reported across Europe, many countries are reintroducing testing restrictions and vaccine rules. Here are the latest travel updates for popular ... Read more »

Gardener who called neighbour's lover ‘fat cow' and punched her in face in pot plant row vows ‘she won't get a penny!'

A GARDENER who called her neighbour's lover a “fat cow” and punched her in the face during a row over her pot plants has vowed she “won't get a penny” ... Read more »

TOWIE's Ella Wise makes explosive return to filming after axe to record show's Christmas special

AFTER being axed during the mass cull of stars earlier this year, it's been confirmed Ella Wise will make an explosive return for the show's Christmas special. Ella, 20, was ... Read more »

8 of the best garden football goalposts 2021: from rebounders to locking models

KICKING a ball around the garden is great fun for kids of all ages – whether they fancy themselves as the next Harry Kane or just want to have a ... Read more »

Call of Duty new Warzone map first look reveals everything you need to know about Caldera

CALL of Duty players have gotten their first look at the upcoming Warzone Pacific Caldera map. The new Warzone map releases next week and replaces the existing map that we're ... Read more »

Most shocking Dancing On Ice injuries – from Jennifer Ellison's sliced scalp to headbanger concussion & slashed face

DANCING On Ice's latest contestants are beginning to comprehend the agony they face on TV's most dangerous show. It's been a disastrous week for professional skater Vanessa Bauer and her ... Read more »

John Bishop is unrecognisable after dramatic transformation for BBC's Doctor Who

DOCTOR Who’s John Bishop looked unrecognisable after showing off his incredible transformation on set of the BBC sci-fi series. John returned to our screens earlier this month as part of ... Read more »

The richest soccer club in the world still hasn't won a game this season, and is on course for an embarrassing relegation

© Getty/Serena Taylor Newcastle still hasn’t won a match this season. Getty/Serena Taylor Newcastle United, the richest soccer club in the world, still hasn’t won a game this season. Eddie ... Read more »

New York's AG is trying to force Amazon to re-hire a worker it fired after he led a protest over COVID-19 safety conditions

© Provided by Business Insider Chris Smalls was fired from his job at Amazon’s JFK8 warehouse in Staten Island in March 2020. Craig Ruttle/AP Photo New York’s AG filed for ... Read more »

France donates 1.6 million AstraZeneca COVID-19 vaccine doses to Philippines

© Luisito Santos/dzBB France donates 1.6 million AstraZeneca COVID-19 vaccine doses to the Philippines A total of 1,632,900 doses of the AstraZeneca COVID-19 vaccine donated by the French government arrived ... Read more »

Oslo is the world's 11th most expensive city, according to the Economist Intelligence Unit

Tel Aviv is in first place on the Economist Intelligence Unit’s list of the world’s most expensive cities. Oslo is just outside the top ten. Inflation and pandemic-related delivery issues ... Read more »

Premium Bond winners for December announced - with two new millionaires this Christmas

Premium Bond winners for December have been announced – and there are two new millionaires in time for Christmas. The first big winner is from West Sussex who is now ... Read more »

EU global investment plan a "true alternative" to China's - EU exec

© Reuters/POOL College of Commissioners meeting at the European Commission in Brussels BRUSSELS (Reuters) – The European Union’s plan to invest 300 billion euros globally in infrastructure is a true ... Read more »

Rishi Sunak urges voters to trust him on tax cut promise

© Provided by Daily Mail MailOnline logo Rishi Sunak has urged voters to trust that he will deliver on his pledge to cut taxes before the next general election.   The ... Read more »
On free-english-test.com you will find lots of free English exam practice materials to help you improve your English skills: grammar, listening, reading, writing, ielts, toeic