When should kids wear a mask: On school bus, in classroom, outdoors? Here's what experts say

© Provided by The Print

New Delhi: Anyone with a young ward knows how difficult it is to make children mask-compliant. As schools work towards reopening, several questions — such as how long to mask a child and at which point can they be allowed to remove it — have become moot points. Guidance on the issue varies across the world, as does paediatricians’ take on it vis-à-vis what governments advise.

In India, the government has been following the World Health Organization (WHO), which does not recommend masking children who are aged five years or less. But doctors claim that children as young as three years “adjust well” to masks and should be encouraged to use them given the potential risks of contraction and passing it on.

Earlier this month, in a provocatively titled article in The Atlantic, haematologist Vinay Prasad, an associate professor of epidemiology and biostatistics at the University of California San Francisco, argued that it is possible the downsides of masking children far outweigh the potential risks they face when exposed without a face covering.

“The issue here is what is the objective of masking children, in which settings and at what age? said Dr K.S. Reddy, president of the Public Health Foundation of India and adjunct professor of Epidemiology at Harvard.

“Children are likely to be unmasked in several settings at home, or even outside home. They could be unmasked and meet people so the likelihood of infection is still there. That is the issue that comes up — is it possible to completely seal off the risk of infection to others?”

He said masking children aged six and above is “reasonable”.

“They should be masked in school transport and in classrooms but not when they are outdoors. There should be as much ventilation as possible in classrooms. There is also a difference in the percentage of adults vaccinated. When 70 per cent of adults are vaccinated, for example, even when children transmit the virus, the risks of severe illness are much less,” he added.

When cases in the community are reducing, then masking requirements too can be more relaxed, he noted.

However, Dr Reddy’s views are divergent from the government’s recommendation of masking children who are aged five years and above. According to the health ministry: “Masks are not recommended for children aged 5 years and under. Children aged 6-11 years may wear a mask depending on the ability of child to use a mask safely and appropriately under direct supervision of parents/guardians. Children aged 12 years and over should wear a mask under the same conditions as adults. Ensure hands are kept clean with soap and water, or an alcohol-based hand rub, while handling masks.”

Some paediatricians feel that starting masking protocol for five-year-olds is too late given the high viral load children often carry and the circulating Delta variant of the SARS-CoV-2 virus that is more infectious than the wild variant.

“Children carry the same viral load as others… Children transmit the infection as much as adults and currently all children in the country are unvaccinated. Though in children without comorbidities, they have a fairly good protection from the innate immune system of the body (though Delta can override that too), they are reservoirs of infection,” Dr Sanjeev Bagai, chairman, Nephron Clinics, told ThePrint.

“They can transmit the virus to parents and grandparents. We have seen children beyond three years get accustomed to vaccines fairly well, apart from the time that they are outdoors or in case of older kids if they are playing professionally. I would say masking children aged three and above is critical in classroom settings. Countries like Israel, some states in the US had to close schools when initially masks were not mandated,” he said, pointing out the immediate need to make N95 masks in paediatric sizes available in the country.

Also read: No substantial evidence to say kids will be more affected in 3rd Covid wave –– Lancet report

Differing advice on masking kids

There are many different takes on masking children even though the WHO has been fairly consistent in its stance that children younger than five years should be spared. The US Centers for Disease Control (CDC) last month cited the delta variant to push for masking of infants.

“Due to the circulating and highly contagious Delta variant, CDC recommends universal indoor masking by all students (age 2 and older), staff, teachers, and visitors to K-12 schools, regardless of vaccination status,” it said.

The WHO, though, does not push for mandatory masking even in the 6-11 years age group. It says that masking in these kids should be based on factors such as the level of infection in the community, whether the child is capable of adhering to mask protocol and hygiene, if there is adequate adult supervision when wearing or taking off a mask and also the potential impact on learning and psychosocial behaviour. The last was the primary argument in Dr Vinay Prasad’s The Atlantic article.

Public Health England, the UK’s health agency, also does not recommend face coverings for children under the age of 3 “for health and safety reasons”. It also advises a more relaxed masking protocol for children aged less than 11 years.

The Danish Health Authority is even more lenient in its exemption of children wearing masks. “If you are the parent of a child under the age of 12 who cannot wear a face mask, you can instead help your child to have clean hands, and you can keep an eye on whether your child is showing symptoms of COVID-19,” the advisory says.

(Edited by Manasa Mohan)

Also read: Kids, Covid and Delta variant: What we know and what we don’t

Internet Explorer Channel Network
News Related


Trumpelmann, Smit help Namibia keep dream World Cup run going

Namibia 115 for 6 (Smit 32*, Williams 23, Leask 2-12) beat Scotland 109 for 8 (Leask 44, Greaves 25, Trumpelmann 3-17, Frylinck 2-10) by four wickets After countless clashes played ... Read more »

Watch: Imad Wasim's 'special message' for New Zealand cricket team as he mentions the cancelled tour

© Provided by WION After Pakistan’s five-wicket win over New Zealand on Tuesday (October 26) in the ongoing T20 World Cup, all-rounder Imad Wasim shared a special message for the ... Read more »

More an urban sport, but growing love for cue sport in remote corners of the country: Pankaj Advani

© Provided by The Indian Express Ace cueist Pankaj Advani has enjoyed a good run since tournaments resumed after the coronavirus-induced break. The lockdowns left the 36-year old ‘hungrier’ and ... Read more »

COP26: Prime Minister Modi to address leaders' summit on Monday and launch global solar grid initiative the next day

© Provided by The Times of India NEW DELHI: Prime Minister Narendra Modi will address the leaders’ summit at UN climate change conference (COP26) in Glasgow on Monday and along ... Read more »

‘Clear dues towards Air India immediately': Centre directs ministries, departments

The Union ministry of finance on Wednesday directed all ministries and departments to immediately clear all their dues towards Air India, explaining that the debt-laden national carrier, the bid for ... Read more »

Miranda Cosgrove Reveals That A Bus Crash Left A 'Mystery' Hole In Her Leg

© Tommaso Boddi – Getty Images Miranda Cosgrove, 28, on the terrifying post-op issue that left her with a hole in her leg. It was five inches above her ankle ... Read more »

President Ram Nath Kovind to visit Gujarat for 3 days on Oct 28

President Ram Nath Kovind is scheduled to visit Gujarat from October 28 to 30. The President will arrive in Gandhinagar on October 28 and have reserved time at Raj Bhavan ... Read more »

IndusInd Bank Q2FY22 Results: Profit jumps 73% to Rs 1146 cr YoY, asset quality improves – check details here

© Provided by Zee Business Private sector lender IndusInd Bank reported robust second-quarter earnings for the financial year 2021-22 (Q2FY22) on a year-on-year (YoY) basis in both profit and net ... Read more »

Rahul Gandhi questions party membership rule, asks 'how many people in this room drink alcohol?'

© Provided by Zee News Even as the Congress party is going to start a membership drive from November 1, Congress leader Rahul Gandhi questioned how relevant are the rules ... Read more »

Kanhai T-point to be turned into a roundabout for smoother flow

© Provided by Hindustan Times Officials said that the T-junction of sectors 44, 45 and 52, known as the Kanhai T-point, will be made into a roundabout, for smoother traffic ... Read more »

Some Americans may get 4th vaccine shot; Merck makes antiviral accessible to low-income countries: COVID-19 updates

Adults with pre-existing medical conditions who have already received the Moderna or Pfizer double vaccinations and a third shot will be able to get a fourth one, federal health officials ... Read more »

Bluesemi gets USD 69 mn commitment from Luxembourg's GEM

© Provided by Zee Business Healthtech startup Bluesemi on Wednesday announced a USD 69 million (about Rs 515 crore) funding commitment from Luxembourg-based GEM Global Yield, which will help it ... Read more »

Higher officials in government should be open to consultations, not let ego come in the way: Gadkari

© Provided by The Times of India NEW DELHI: Pointing out ego as the biggest drawback of senior functionaries in the government, Union road transport and highways minister Nitin Gadkari ... Read more »

WhatsApp chats and Section 65 of Evidence Act: How it can impact Aryan Khan's case

Indian law lays out detailed processes and procedures to be followed in the course of a criminal trial, including the issue of what can be used as “valid evidence” in ... Read more »

Two accidents slows traffic on Noida-Greater Noida Expressway

© Provided by Hindustan Times Vehicles moved at a snail’s pace due to the accidents on the expressway. (Representative photo/HT Archive) Traffic moved slowly on the Noida-Greater Noida expressway due ... Read more »

Anti-corruption team raids police station, thrashed by cop they tried to arrest

© Provided by Hindustan Times Senior Jharkhand police officers rushed from Garhwa district headquarters to help resolve the matter after some local police officers attacked an ACB team that went ... Read more »

BetterPlace acquires OLX People, Waah Jobs

© Provided by Zee Business BetterPlace on Wednesday said it has acquired OLX People and Waah Jobs to strengthen its portfolio of workforce management solutions and become one of the ... Read more »

Rediscovered Bhupen Khakhar work fetches Rs 12.7 crore

© Provided by The Indian Express In 1972, at an auction organised to raise funds for Bangladeshi refugees in Ahmedabad, American-Indian architect and urban planner Christopher Benninger acquired a 1972 ... Read more »

Nayara Energy sees 15-20 new petrochemical plants in India in next decade

© Provided by Zee Business Indian private refiner Nayara Energy expects 15-20 new integrated petrochemical plants will start operating in the country in the next decade to meet rising demand ... Read more »

7 booked, 4 arrested for celebrating Pakistan's win over India during T20 World Cup in UPÂ

© Provided by Zee News New Delhi: The Uttar Pradesh Police by Wednesday (October 27) has registered cases against seven people from across five districts for celebrating Pakistan’s victory over ... Read more »

Highlights, Scotland Vs Namibia, T20 World Cup 2021, Full cricket score: JJ Smit, bowlers set up Namibia's big win

© Provided by Firstpost Highlights, Scotland Vs Namibia, T20 World Cup 2021, Full cricket score: JJ Smit, bowlers set up Namibia’s big win Toggle between tabs to view scorecard and ... Read more »

Hardik Pandya goes through fitness drills, bowls at nets

© Provided by The Indian Express Hardik Pandya went through fitness drills focusing on strength and conditioning and bowled at the India nets on Wednesday. In India’s World T20 opener ... Read more »

T20 World Cup: Ruben Trumpelmann heroics help Namibia outwit Scotland in low-scoring thriller

Debutants Namibia made history on Wednesday by registering their first-ever win in the ICC T20 World Cup main draw after beating Scotland by 4 wickets in a low-scoring Super 12 ... Read more »

IND vs NZ, T20 World Cup: Hardik Pandya Bowls in Nets Ahead of Crucial Clash Against New Zealand

© Provided by News18 IND vs NZ, T20 World Cup: Hardik Pandya Bowls in Nets Ahead of Crucial Clash Against New Zealand Flamboyant India all-rounder Hardik Pandya rolled his arms ... Read more »

Roja, 27th October 2021, Written Update: Will Anu discover Pooja's presence in the house?

© Provided by Pinkvilla In today’s episode, everyone rejoices as Shenbagam recalls Roja’s childhood. Shenbagam checks Roja’s hand for the mark she received while burning crackers. Kalpana claims that the ... Read more »

Balika Vadhu 2, 27 October 2021, Written Update: Premji locks Anandi in a room

© Provided by Pinkvilla In today’s episode, Dhingri tells Khimji that Anandi was absent from school today. Everyone gets shocked and worried after this. Anandi urges Premji that she wants ... Read more »

Anya Taylor Joy reveals HILARIOUS acting skill she uses to mess with her friends

© Provided by Pinkvilla Queen’s Gambit star Anya Taylor-Joy recently shared a very special secret talent and how she makes use of it! While making an appearance on The Late ... Read more »

SHOCKING! Esha Gupta REVEALS two horrible casting-couch experiences with a director and producer; was almost replaced after she stood her ground

© Provided by BollywoodLife.com It’s been 9 years since model-turned-actress Esha Gupta made successful Bollywood debut opposite Emraan Hashmi in their 2021 film Jannat 2. And with time, the actress ... Read more »

Bill Murray CONFIRMS MCU debut, hints at joining Paul Rudd, Michael Douglas & more in Ant Man 3

© Provided by Pinkvilla Actor Bill Murray may finally be joining Marvel’s cinematic universe! While chatting with Variety in a new interview, the 71-year-old actor couldn’t stop himself from dropping ... Read more »

Chef Kunal's Gharwali Ginger-Garlic Paste Recipe Makes Us Wonder, Are We Doing It Wrong?

© Provided by iDiva One of the most widely used ingredients in almost every vegetarian and non-vegetarian Indian dish—like curries, dal and marinades—is the aromatic blend of ginger and garlic ... Read more »

Fall In Love All Over Again With Peppery Hot Hakka Noodles!

Wondering how to prepare Hakka noodles at home instead of flinging for the same at an eatery? Then, you’ve landed on the right page! With a zing of soya sauce, ... Read more »

I got Botox for the first time. Here are 7 things that surprised me about the procedure.

© Marisel Salazar Botox helped with my jaw pain and swelling. Marisel Salazar Aside from minimizing the appearance of wrinkles, Botox can be used to treat sore, swollen jaws. I ... Read more »

Prince William ‘deeply frustrated' over The Crown's recreation of Princess Diana's infamous interview

© Provided by Pinkvilla The Telegraph recently reported how upset and “deeply frustrated” Prince William is by Netflix for recreating his late mother–Princess Diana’s controversial interview with Martin Bashir for ... Read more »

LATEST: Vicky Kaushal & Katrina Kaif to tie the knot at THIS place in December?

© Provided by Pinkvilla Rumors mills are buzzing with the reports about the alleged wedding of Vicky Kaushal and Katrina Kaif. ETimes has it that the exciting Bollywood couple will ... Read more »

Angelina Jolie deliberately DODGES question about her rumoured 'friendship' with The Weeknd

© Provided by Pinkvilla Angelina Jolie has recently been asked about her rumoured friendship with singer The Weeknd and the Eternals actress knew how to respond! During her interview with ... Read more »
On free-english-test.com you will find lots of free English exam practice materials to help you improve your English skills: grammar, listening, reading, writing, ielts, toeic