What's the value of a confirmatory PCR test?

Asia's Tech News Daily

© Provided by The Guardian Photograph: Stéphane Mahé/Reuters

After a wave of cases in which a positive lateral flow device (LFD) test was followed by a negative PCR test, a private laboratory handling swab tests has been suspended.

But conflicting results are not a new problem. Back in June, when secondary school students with a positive LFD were retested with a PCR check, over one in eight came back negative. And even without laboratory problems, it is unclear why a negative PCR should trump a positive LFD.

Imagine a (rather strange) legal case with the prosecution alleging that you harbour the virus. In court, it is becoming common to quote a “likelihood ratio” provided by forensic evidence — the relative support for the prosecution versus the defence.

First, the positive LFD is presented by the prosecution. If the virus were present, a recent study estimates around an 80% chance of a positive LFD – higher if you were infectious. Alternatively, if the defence is correct, there is a less than one in 1,000 chance of a false positive LFD. The likelihood ratio is therefore at least 800 (0.8/0.001). As a comparison, the curvature of the spine found on the skeleton in a Leicester car park contributed an estimated likelihood ratio of 200 in favour of the remains being those of Richard III.

© Photograph: Stéphane Mahé/Reuters A medical worker holds a test tube after administering a nasal swab to a patient.

The defence retorts with the negative PCR test. If you were infected, the PCR test might miss it around one in 20 times. If there were no virus, then that test is almost certain to be negative. Here, the likelihood ratio is around one in 20.

Combining these two conflicting pieces of evidence gives an overall likelihood ratio of about 40 (800 divided by 20). In a court, that might be reported as “moderate evidence” in favour of you having an infection.

As viral prevalence changes, then the probability of infection following conflicting test results also changes. At the current infection rate in England of one in 60 people, and with labs working well, out of 100 people with a positive LFD followed by a negative PCR, around 40 would actually have the virus and be falsely reassured.

The negative PCR does not outweigh the positive LFD.

• David Spiegelhalter is chair of the Winton Centre for Risk and Evidence Communication at Cambridge. Anthony Masters is statistical ambassador for the Royal Statistical Society

Internet Explorer Channel Network
Asia's Tech News Daily
News Related

OTHER NEWS

Aaron Rodgers still isn't happy with writer Molly Knight over ‘COVID toe' story

The Aaron Rodgers-Molly Knight saga continues. When we last left off, on Thanksgiving Eve, Knight had deleted her tweet sharing a story from the Wall Street Journal about Aaron Rodgers ... Read more »

I'm A Celeb fans all say the same thing about Dec's David Ginola impression after hilarious challenge

I'M A Celebrity…Get Me Out Of Here! fans were left giggling tonight after Declan Donnelly did yet another funny impersonation of David Ginola. Football legend David had just completed a ... Read more »

KBC 13: Contestant Govind Pratap Singh couldn't answer THIS Rs 3.2 lakh question; Check it out

© Provided by Pinkvilla November 30th episode began with Amitabh Bachchan resuming the quiz with roll-over contestant Govind Pratap Singh. Govind could only win Rs 10,000 as he failed to ... Read more »

CNN indefinitely suspends Chris Cuomo after damning AG report

Chris Cuomo has been suspended by CNN. Getty Images for CNN Embattled CNN host Chris Cuomo was suspended “indefinitely” over revelations regarding his secret role in trying to defend his ... Read more »

Megan Thee Stallion cancels her upcoming show in Houston ‘out of respect' for Astroworld victims

© Provided by Pinkvilla   Megan Thee Stallion‘s Houston fans will have to wait a bit longer to see the rapper perform in the city. The 26-year-old rapper said on ... Read more »

Schumer targeting week of Dec. 13 to vote on social spending bill

Senate Majority Leader Chuck Schumer is planning to hold the vote for President Biden’s social spending bill the week of December 13. AP Photo/J. Scott Applewhite Senate Majority Leader Chuck ... Read more »

Lego Technic Test Car Crossing Gaps Is All About Inspired Engineering

Scientific creativity at its finest. So, you think building things with Lego is just kids’ stuff? Actually, we know it’s not just kids’ stuff – Technic kits can be intricately detailed ... Read more »

2022 Porsche Taycan GTS First Drive: Tweaked Tweener

2022 Porsche Taycan GTS Exterior First Drive 2022 Porsche Taycan GTS Exterior First Drive 2022 Porsche Taycan GTS Exterior First Drive 2022 Porsche Taycan GTS Exterior First Drive 2022 Porsche ... Read more »

2022 Opel Astra Sports Tourer Debuts To Add German Touch To Peugeot 308 SW

2022 Opel Astra Sports Tourer 2022 Opel Astra Sports Tourer 2022 Opel Astra Sports Tourer 2022 Opel Astra Sports Tourer 2022 Opel Astra Sports Tourer 2022 Opel Astra Sports Tourer ... Read more »

Children with badly controlled asthma at higher risk of Covid hospital admission

Children with poorly controlled asthma are three to six times more likely to be admitted to hospital with coronavirus than those without the condition, new research suggests. Scientists suggest that ... Read more »

Trial begins of Brooklyn judge accused of ‘cover-up' of corruption at MCU credit union

A Brooklyn judge who received tens of thousands of dollars worth of pricey perks in her role as the chair of a major credit union tried to stymy a federal ... Read more »

‘Completely unacceptable': IGA supermarket under fire for sign racially profiling African customers

A supermarket in Melbourne’s western suburbs has apologised over a sign on its register that told staff to get help when African people entered the store. The ABC reports the ... Read more »

Rihanna Is Officially a National Hero

© by The Cut; Photos: Getty Images by The Cut; Photos: Getty Images Yeah, I said it. On Monday, the 55th anniversary of its independence from Britain, the island of ... Read more »

'Boris Johnson's rule-breaking shows reckless hypocrisy of our Prime Minister'

Party PM’s dangerous Slipshod Boris Johnson’s rule-breaking shows the reckless hypocrisy of a Prime Minister incapable of leading by example. When people want to do the right thing and cry ... Read more »

34 members of Munster's party depart South Africa, 14 to remain in Cape Town for isolation periods

© Gordon Arons INPHO Munster at training in Pretoria last week. MUNSTER HAVE REVEALED that 34 members of their touring party tonight departed Cape Town and are set to land ... Read more »

New Covid variant: UP Govt orders genome sequencing of samples in five centres

© Provided by The Indian Express The Uttar Pradesh government on Tuesday issued instructions for the genome sequencing of the SARS-CoV-2 virus that causes Covid-19 at a time a new ... Read more »

Goa Forward Party to back Congress

© Provided by The Indian Express AFTER MONTHS of speculation, the Congress has joined forces with the Goa Forward Party (GFP) ahead of the Assembly elections slated for February next ... Read more »

Grand jury clears officer who shot Pharrell Williams' cousin

VIRGINIA BEACH, Va. (AP) — A special grand jury found that a Virginia Beach police officer was justified in fatally shooting a Black man armed with a gun during a ... Read more »

There were 155 efforts to censor books in US schools and libraries, group says

The American Library Association says it has provided legal guidance and support to a number of libraries impacted by the “dramatic uptick” of attempts to remove books concerning LGBTQ issues ... Read more »

Transition to Surrey Police Service to see municipal officers training under RCMP

SURREY, B.C. — Residents in Surrey, B.C., may notice police officers patrolling in two different uniforms as the city begins what the RCMP says is the largest police transition in ... Read more »

Detective: Brothers detailed how Jussie Smollett staged hoax

CHICAGO (AP) — Two brothers arrested for an alleged attack on Jussie Smollett recounted for Chicago police how the ex-“Empire” actor orchestrated the hoax, telling them via text message to ... Read more »

Police searching for missing Kokomo man

Nov. 30—The Kokomo Police Department is asking the public for help in locating a Howard County man that has been missing since late October. According to a KPD media release, ... Read more »

As Alec Baldwin faces a lawsuit, all eyes are on the gun that killed Halyna Hutchins

On Thursday, Oct. 21, Day 12 of a 21-day shoot for a modest-budget Western called “Rust,” the call sheet laid out the hours ahead for catering, crew, producers, actors, horse ... Read more »

Northern Powergrid denies Tory MP's claim it refused offer of military aid

Northern Powergrid has denied claims by Conservative MP Richard Holden North West Durham that it declined an offer of military assistance as thousands remain without power due to Storm Arwen. ... Read more »

Newly released police report reveals 'Rust' director Joel Souza's first account of fatal shooting

Santa Fe County Sheriff Adan Mendoza speaks during a press conference at the Santa Fe County Public Safety Building to update members of the media on the shooting accident on ... Read more »

Strategy meeting in poll run-up, BJP to hold 6 yatras

© Provided by The Indian Express Ahead of the Assembly elections in Uttar Pradesh, the ruling BJP on Tuesday decided to take out six yatras in the state to reach ... Read more »

Jharkhand floats tender to develop Soren house as ‘heritage building'

© Provided by The Indian Express The Jharkhand government will spend Rs 4.59 crore to convert former chief minister and Jharkhand Mukti Morcha (JMM) supremo Shibu Soren’s government residence into ... Read more »

Tamil writer Perumal Murugan's photo appears in BJP's slum outreach campaign posters

Tamil writer Perumal Murugan’s photo appears in BJP’s slum outreach campaign posters The Delhi BJP used the image of Tamil writer Perumal Murugan on a poster for the party’s slum ... Read more »

Govt revokes clearance granted to Old Goa bungalow

© Provided by The Indian Express As the fast by protesters demanding demolition of an allegedly illegal bungalow constructed in Old Goa heritage precinct entered its seventh day, Goa Deputy ... Read more »

BioNTech boss says 'don't freak out' about Omicron as Pfizer jab likely to protect against severe COVID

The Pfizer vaccine is likely to offer strong protection against any severe disease from the new Omicron COVID variant, according to the head of BioNTech who urged people not to ... Read more »

Rust Investigators Finally Reveal Who Let Live Ammo Onto The Set

Fred Hayes/Getty Images The entertainment world is still reeling from the tragedy that took place in New Mexico on October 21, 2021. On that date, actor Alec Baldwin fired a ... Read more »

A Fan-Favorite Character Is Returning To The Flash

The CW/YouTube A heavy storm is coming to “The Flash,” but at least it’s one that fans are familiar with. For over seven seasons, the CW superhero drama has presented viewers with ... Read more »

Three students killed as 15-year-old opens fire at his school in Michigan

Three students have been killed and eight people wounded after a 15-year-old opened fire at his Michigan high school. © Reuters Ambulances were lined up outside the school in Michigan ... Read more »

The Boys Showrunner Gives Fans A Tease Of What To Expect In Season 3

Amazon Studios Over two acclaimed seasons, “The Boys,” Amazon Prime’s dark satire of the omnipresent superhero genre, has dazzled fans with its blend of hyperviolent action and politically resonant storytelling. ... Read more »

Omicron threat in Scotland may 'diminish rather than increase', says Nicola Sturgeon

Nicola Sturgeon has predicted the threat from the omicron variant may “diminish rather than increase” after disclosing all the cases discovered in Scotland are linked to one event. © Jeff ... Read more »

I'm a Celebrity airs beef between Naughty Boy and Kadeena Cox

© ITV I’m a Celebrity airs beef between Naughty Boy and Kadeena Cox. I’m a Celebrity… Get Me Out Of Here! contestant Naughty Boy was at it again after snapping ... Read more »

EU reports mild Omicron symptoms; South Africa registers 4,373 new cases

South Africa registered 4,373 new Covid-19 cases, bringing the cumulative total to 2,968,052. A further 21 Covid-19-related deaths were reported, taking total official deaths to 89,843. A total of 25,619,891 ... Read more »

Land claimants still in the dark about date of return to District Six

The land restitution process for District Six claimants was taking too long, MPs acknowledged In a parliamentary meeting on Tuesday. © Copyright (c) Daily Maverick , All Rights Reserved There ... Read more »

Digital Vibes: Health DG Sandile Buthelezi CLEARED in R150m probe

© Provided by The South African The Health Ministry has confirmed that its Director-General Dr Sandile Buthelezi is back at work, after his suspension in relation to the Digital Vibes ... Read more »

TikTok video shows Oxford High School students fleeing shooter

A school shooting at Michigan’s Oxford High School left three dead and at least eight wounded. AP Terrified students apparently hunkered down in a classroom during Tuesday’s deadly school shooting ... Read more »
On free-english-test.com you will find lots of free English exam practice materials to help you improve your English skills: grammar, listening, reading, writing, ielts, toeic